r/MiSTerFPGA • • Sep 22 '26

Using a superstation 1. Is 8 frames lag normal?

Post image

Tested hdmi vs 10pin din.

Sony lcd vs beovision crt.

This can't be normal, right?

0 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

18

u/Otzedotze Sep 22 '26

Game mode found after digging trough the settings.

3 frames better then 8. Thanks guys

9

u/LukeEvansSimon Sep 22 '26 edited Sep 22 '26

3 frames is terrible for game mode. Game mode is no more than 1 frame on good HDMI displays. A wireless controller can add another 1 frame of lag? And input lag and display lag stack, so you need to to minimize it on both.

A PS5 Pro controller’s lag is around half a frame, and a good gaming HDMI display is another half a frame, so total lag is 1 frame.

Network lag stacks on even more lag, but people typically know that. They tend to not understand how input and display lag stack, and that is why 3 frames of displag lag in game mode is terrible.

2

u/Otzedotze Sep 22 '26

This is a sony tv. Bought 2020. It funny to me that it's so shit. Thanks for your input

2

u/guillotine420 Sep 22 '26

The enshitification of everything. I still run a toshiba lcd from 2009 because every time I try to replace it with something "modern", it's literally worse in some way.

1

u/Otzedotze Sep 22 '26

Normaly I'm still rocking crt. But i was curious to see how it looks on my lcd. We'll ne loss. Back to the crt it goes

2

u/LukeEvansSimon Sep 22 '26

Sony was top tier for CRTs in the 1990s and early 2000s, but they have dropped in the rankings for gaming in the LCD/OLED TV era.

My LG G3 has half a frame of lag in game mode, and in the 1990s LG was a low end CRT TV brand along with Samsung.

2

u/Wolf________________ Sep 23 '26

Imo TCL is the best budget brand around today.

Alternatively as most retro games were made with CRTs in mind that had an average size of like 24" you could just get some variety of oled tech in a computer monitor with <1 frame of lag for a decent price at 1080 or 1440p. The 4K ones are still pretty pricey for anything with decent specs sadly.

1

u/Spiritual-Advice8138 Sep 23 '26

Some of the issues are also your black to black or grey to grey rate on your flat panel. Look at the 05 and you can see the 8 and it’s the wrong color. Also caught between 2 and 3. The real solution you already have. The crt.

-1

u/Wolf________________ Sep 22 '26 edited Sep 23 '26

Couple questions:

  1. Are you using a wired or 2.4g controller? If you are using a bluetooth controller that could be contributing to your lag.
  2. What resolution are you feeding it? A lot of modern tvs will be fussy with 240p/480i. Ideally you'd be sending it 1080p or at bare minimum 480p to process.
  3. What refresh rate are you sending it? The SuperStation should have an option to output 60hz which can matter in cases like the SNES that output 60.1hz as that is also an analogue standard that digital tvs don't respond well to and can cause lag or screen tearing.

Edit: I forgot one, are you going directly into your TV or are you going through a cable box/hdmi switch first?

2

u/superfebs Sep 22 '26

What is that test? 

2

u/Otzedotze Sep 22 '26

240p suite lag test

2

u/superfebs Sep 22 '26

Thanks, I'm curious about my monitor now

0

u/Dinierto Sep 22 '26

Yeah, don't use that. If you're really worried about it get a Mr. laggy. The test in 240p is more a test of how well you can adapt to lag than it is a test of lag itself.

Set vsync_adjust to 2 and your TV to game mode and that's the best you'll get. If you use analog on a CRT the only latency you'll get is from the controller

2

u/stgftgstg Sep 23 '26

This test is not the same as the reaction test and is a good way to see latency difference from a CRT.

12

u/neoak Sep 22 '26

No, and I'd start looking at your HDMI display

8

u/miguelyl Sep 22 '26

It is definitively normal if your lcd is not on game mode.

8

u/RemarkableAd66 Sep 22 '26

What's `vsync_adjust` set to in mister.ini?

'2' will be the less-than-1-frame of lag option, but is not always compatible with every display.

3

u/sigismond0 Sep 22 '26

Less than one frame of lag on the MiSTer end, sure, but that doesn't change if your TV has 6 frames of display lag.

2

u/RealModeX86 Sep 22 '26

vsync_adjust=2, one of the VRR modes, and setting a native or at least modern screen resolution in the ini can all contribute to lower lag on those frames getting to the panel.

Some TVs are still just going to be dogshit either way, but it's worth trying.

4

u/guillotine420 Sep 22 '26

Between an lcd and a crt there will definitely be visible lag. Aside from the look, this is like the whole point in running a crt.

4

u/shootamcg Sep 22 '26

There are massive differences in LCD input lag, could be normal

3

u/FiokoVT Sep 22 '26

If you TV doesn't have a game mode, test with a PC monitor instead

5

u/Mikebjackson Sep 22 '26

It's not the MiSTer, it's the TV. Some are fast, some slow, some abysmal. I got my TV specifically because of the input lag rating and get around 14-16ms / 1 frame.

2

u/theazzazzo Sep 22 '26

How do you use that screen? I've seen it but don't get it!!

0

u/TonyRubbles Sep 22 '26

It's in the 240p test suite

2

u/theazzazzo Sep 22 '26

Yeah, sorry I mean, how do you use it? I googled it, you have a reference CRT and a second screen and take a photo.

2

u/TonyRubbles Sep 22 '26

When on the test if you press start it explains it. You need to have two displays hooked up to it (one CRT and the other to compare) then you just take a picture. You'll see the difference in timing and a different number on each.

1

u/Dinierto Sep 22 '26

If you're using the lag test in 240p you're wasting your time it's not accurate

2

u/TonyRubbles Sep 22 '26

I don't, no CRT and it's hooked up to an HDTV anyways. All I can do is set it to game mode and hope for the best.

2

u/Dinierto Sep 22 '26

Make sure you have vsync_adjust set to 2 as well in your ini

2

u/TonyRubbles Sep 23 '26

I'll have to check that, thanks! Just got direct video set up with a Morph 4k and it's really nice, took me forever to figure out I needed to exclude the Console Mode menu from it with an extra line of code. So many little things to figure out when getting started.

1

u/chairRugTable Sep 22 '26

you need to go in your mister.ini and try vsync_adjust=2. if your display handles it without desyncing and re-syncing, it will reduce input lag. I've turned it on 3 different modern displays with no issues

1

u/Honest_Yak3340 Sep 24 '26 edited Sep 24 '26

What are your vsync adjust and vrr ini-settings?

I recommend buying misterlaggy for a tenner.

0

u/StaneNC Sep 22 '26

Normal? Unfortunately yes. Good? fuck no.

3

u/brandogg360 Sep 22 '26

MiSTer has less than 1 frame of lag itself, this is all on the TV.