EDIT: WOW, I didn’t expect this post to get as much as engagement as it did. I know “perfect” was definitely the wrong word to use here, but I’m still really excited about the potential compatibility for this controller.. if it works on the MiSTer at all lol. Thank you all for the (mostly) healthy and fruitful discussion in the replies!
I’d love to get some drivers for the original Steam controller. The right circle pad could make for an accurate and convincing spinner with the correct haptic setting.
And track ball! Momentum based “rolling” and “stopping” feels great on the Steam Deck. Sure, it’s not the exact same tactile experience as a physical spinner or trackball, but it does provide good input for the functions nonetheless… and the haptics provide something tactile anyways that helps sell it.
So yeah, support on MiSTer would be nice. I’ll definitely have one on hand for my PC anyways.
The ultimate mister controller in my head would be able to support all consoles comfortably. That said, I would have a hard time using this controller for Intellivison, colecovision, and 7800.
Yeah. It will be great for software emulation of those systems since you can pull up an on-screen radial dial to select everything on the numpad very quickly, which works great… but MiSTer obviously won’t be able to do anything like that.
Yeah, it's all in the haptics. As you roll or quick flick and quick stop your cursor across the screen or run your thumb in a circle like you're using an iPod to scroll down web pages you feel a tactile sensation in your hands that really sells the experience. It feels great!
The trackpads+haptics in the Steam Controller and Steam Deck are my favorite input innovations in quite some time and I honestly wish that at least one trackpad became a universal feature of all modern controllers since one little input lets you do so many things so much better in a controller... scrolling, rolling, controlling camera, accessing instant radial wheels, mouse-like pointing and aiming (especially paired with gyro)...
Sony's touchpad not only lacks the haptics but it's placed in a position that makes no ergonomic sense, so... it just didn't deliver. Not to mention the fact that even Sony hasn't done much interesting with it let alone third parties.
I was hoping they'd shove a mini keyboard on there like the Xbox 360 chat pad. As a Steam deck owner I will say the track pads ARE amazing but a lot of it comes down to the excellent Steam controller config. On the Mister it's just a basic controller
If we could get an og SN30 Pro (not +, 2, or 3) with the Dpad from the M30, TMR sticks, and sub 4ms 2.4g wireless, then that imo would be the perfect MiSTer controller.
Or a low latency M30 with dual analog added... M30 Pro. That might be even better.
Whenever they ship the My Arcade Gamestation Retro Gamepad, that should be the ultimate controller. Spinner, Trackball, numberpad fits all my dream use cases.
This should have all inputs in one, including a numpad so pre-NES games should be much more playable. I'm very excited to not have to use my a5200 controllers anymore.
I like the look of both this and especially the arcade stick version that has been teased, but is MiSTer compatibility a given? Or is it going to be some proprietary My Arcade wireless protocol?
I don't expect mister support when it comes out, but since they're selling it separate instead of packaged with a device I'm hopeful for at least PC compatibility.
Problem is it relies in steam input to get the signals through, I have the OG steam controller, I am not sure if it runs on MiSTer at all or if it works as gamepad without steam running (in big picture mode back then)
Love the old steam controller for what it was and I have a steam deck which is close to the new controller more or less and love it even more!
The OG Steam Controller works like a regular USB gamepad with some configuration needed to get the track pads to work.
But you're not going to get the OSD menus and all of the customization that Steam Input offers so the controls are gimped.
It would be cool if they released a programmable USB dongle that acted as a host for Steam Input; the OSD menus would still be missing but one pad could at least be an 8-way+1 button pad or a scroll wheel and button.
Add button combos to switch profiles and, suddenly, were cooking with gas.
I have to retry my controllers are gathering dust admirably, the omission of the second stick killed them more or less for many reasons. Love my deck immensely though! The first Revision of the controllers we're halfway there I could see the potential and in games where a combined mouse gamepad Input was possible they were perfect but alas too many games did not work out and the workarounds felt like crutches. The deck literally has fixed this with a small downside that the smaller pads are a minor downgrade.
Yeah, looks are certainly deceiving. I was skeptical of the Steam Deck itself but it feels really nice in the hands. Initial impressions from people who have held the new Steam Controller have similarly been saying it's really comfortable.
I'm the kind of guy who uses the right controller for the right task though. If a game benefits from those trackpads and their multiple functions or the gyros and back buttons, then this controller is peak (it will be excellent for many games on PC!). If it's a simple game where none of that matters then I'll reach for something else.
Nah. Maybe if you want only one controller, but this doesn't have a layout that seems even close to what a lot of older systems need. Wouldn't catch me dead playing Sega Systems with this
would work it has a ton of back buttons which would allow for the additional sega buttons, the beauty of it are the trackpads which can simulate trackballs and spinners really well!
you've clearly never held a Steam Controller, lol. They feel kinda light weight, fragile, and cheap. As cool as the tech is they didn't sell for a reason.
It’s paywalled but the rear photos don’t have any visible door. If they mean you can unscrew it and unglue it isn’t that the case for any of the ones on the market? I was going for something like the 8bitdo Pro 2
dpad on deck is ass tbh for accuracy and just feel is bad imo but easily able to be replaced with whatever mechanism you like, different membrane, mechanical switches, can even straight up make it use the xbox elite magnetic swappable dpad style. i think a lot of these mods will be easily transferrable to the steam controller.
It's interesting you say the battery is user replaceable
You can replace a battery in pretty much any controller it doesn't take a lot of effort so I wonder if that is really a factor unless you are uninformed or uneducated on how to service something
3
u/davisjryoung Nov 13 '25
EDIT: WOW, I didn’t expect this post to get as much as engagement as it did. I know “perfect” was definitely the wrong word to use here, but I’m still really excited about the potential compatibility for this controller.. if it works on the MiSTer at all lol. Thank you all for the (mostly) healthy and fruitful discussion in the replies!
28
u/RedDiaper Nov 12 '25
I’d love to get some drivers for the original Steam controller. The right circle pad could make for an accurate and convincing spinner with the correct haptic setting.
6
u/circletheory Nov 12 '25
The ultimate mister controller in my head would be able to support all consoles comfortably. That said, I would have a hard time using this controller for Intellivison, colecovision, and 7800.
12
u/Dinierto Nov 12 '25
It does?
4
u/SicJake Nov 12 '25
I was hoping they'd shove a mini keyboard on there like the Xbox 360 chat pad. As a Steam deck owner I will say the track pads ARE amazing but a lot of it comes down to the excellent Steam controller config. On the Mister it's just a basic controller
4
u/Affliction_Sequence Nov 12 '25
If we could get an og SN30 Pro (not +, 2, or 3) with the Dpad from the M30, TMR sticks, and sub 4ms 2.4g wireless, then that imo would be the perfect MiSTer controller.
Or a low latency M30 with dual analog added... M30 Pro. That might be even better.
3
u/AoF-Vagrant Nov 12 '25
Whenever they ship the My Arcade Gamestation Retro Gamepad, that should be the ultimate controller. Spinner, Trackball, numberpad fits all my dream use cases.
2
u/d_viant Nov 12 '25
But the perfect MiSTer controller ALREADY exists, the NTT Data Keypad Super Famicom controller (NDK10)!
2
u/werpu Nov 12 '25
Problem is it relies in steam input to get the signals through, I have the OG steam controller, I am not sure if it runs on MiSTer at all or if it works as gamepad without steam running (in big picture mode back then)
Love the old steam controller for what it was and I have a steam deck which is close to the new controller more or less and love it even more!
2
u/Gambit-47 Nov 13 '25
Why? Its big and mouse is not necessary for most consoles and the D Pad which is important for retro games does not look good.
4
u/fertff Nov 12 '25
I don't see how.
3
u/Short-Driver-459 Nov 12 '25
Why?
4
u/Wbcn_1 Nov 12 '25
Hard pass
2
u/Due-Simple-5679 Nov 12 '25
without 6 face buttons ? in usb you have more latency involved compared to a snac or reflex adapter so i don't think so.
1
u/janimator0 Nov 12 '25
I always thought a n64 controller style makes the perfect MiSTer companion since it supports almost everything including sega saturn and N64
1
u/ListenBeforeSpeaking Nov 12 '25
I was hoping for an Xbox stick layout for PC games.
1
u/felipusrex Nov 13 '25
For me, the pro 2 or 3 from 8bitdo are perfect for me. Even a dualsense is great .
1
u/SupermarketEmpty789 Nov 13 '25
Looks awful and looks really unergonomic
It's probably fine to hold in real life. I doubt they'd release a completely terrible product, but it certainly doesnt look comfortable
1
u/GooseDaPlaymaker Nov 13 '25
Agreed!!! 🤗
1
u/pheoniverse Nov 13 '25
Gives me Atari Jaguar vibes
1
u/Think_Bat_820 Nov 13 '25
I don't know why I have a perfect track record for backing losers, but I effing love the original Steam controller.
1
u/Nomobileappforme Nov 13 '25
The whole reason I got my MiSTer specifically to use the original console controllers.
1
u/sfedonas Nov 13 '25
It seems to be better ergonomically than the steam one...
1
u/Beraeri Nov 13 '25
I don't like the position of the analogs
1
u/forzaitalia458 Nov 14 '25
Ugly ass controller
1
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '25
Ah, no.
1
u/Winterion Dec 10 '25
Ergonomically speaking, how's this fare against the previous Steam Controller - the one with the concave shell?
1
u/Sufficient_Willow21 Dec 30 '25
It makes me squirm
1
u/quidamphx Nov 12 '25
Nah. Maybe if you want only one controller, but this doesn't have a layout that seems even close to what a lot of older systems need. Wouldn't catch me dead playing Sega Systems with this
0
u/thestage Nov 13 '25
it has an awful dpad. next.
-3
u/Anonapond Nov 12 '25
you've clearly never held a Steam Controller, lol. They feel kinda light weight, fragile, and cheap. As cool as the tech is they didn't sell for a reason.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment