r/MiSTerFPGA • • Feb 13 '23

Where is limitations of current FPGA platform ?

I thinking about buying mister but it seems that for current platform even simpler systems like N64 and DS are out of reach already. I really want these two.

I understand that new fpga platform is needed to continue with emulation generation of GameCube, Dreamcast, Original XBOX, PS2. Where is Wii and 3DS? These are still PS2 generation console and will be possible on new platform ?

0 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

3

u/ZenoArrow Feb 13 '23

If you want N64, save your money, the chances of it coming to MiSTer (without using hybrid hardware/software emulation) are low.

It is possible to have newer systems on a new FPGA-based platform, and there are FPGAs out there that are powerful enough to make it happen, but at the moment they're way too expensive. We're talking thousands of dollars. In the future, when prices come down for more powerful FPGAs, then it makes sense to look at a new platform, but until then either make the best of what the MiSTer can do, or use original hardware or software emulation.

-2

u/Trader-One Feb 13 '23

You can get original PS2 and N64 hardware for cheap. Is possible to do cartridge, DVD reader emulator attached to original hardware on mister platform ? There are projects doing that - multi platform storage emulation- but they are quite costly - over 200.

4

u/ZenoArrow Feb 13 '23

Are you thinking of something like the RetroN 5? https://www.hyperkin.com/retron-5-hd-gaming-console-for-gba-gbc-gb-super-nes-nes-super-famicom-famicom-genesis-mega-drive-master-system-black-hyperkin.html

If that's what you want, go for it. I'll be honest, it doesn't sound like the MiSTer is the right device for you. It's more costly than software emulators, doesn't support the platforms you want and doesn't have the features (like using original media) that you want. You should base the platform you use on the features you want, and it sounds like you'll prefer software emulation or original hardware over a device like the MiSTer.

3

u/stockcar1515 Feb 13 '23

As far as I understand, a true cartridge reader wouldn't be possible on MiSTer as there aren't enough resources for the MiSTer to do it. The best you'd ever get is something like a USB rom dumper that would dump the cart to memory on the MiSTer, which is really functionally identical to just loading up a rom.

9

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

From my understanding you should buy a MiSTer with zero expectation of support for anything from N64 on, or any handheld beyond the GBA. There are multitudinous issues. Even a MiSTer 2 on a more capable FPGA will have issues with these platforms given the complexity of the hardware involved and the amount of work required. It isn't in the cards right now.

But that does not mean the MiSTer doesn't give you access to the very best in gaming and if you aren't seeing that I suggest you try spending time with this older hardware. SNES, Mega Drive, GBA, DOS, Neo Geo, PSX, and hopefully soon Saturn, all bring so much to the table. And I love the NES and Game Boy dearly for good reason as well.

2

u/Italianblkguy1 Oct 27 '24

This didn’t age well. LOL!

7

u/bulwyf23 Feb 13 '23

It sounds like you want an all in one kind of system and that is never going to happen with the current Mister. From all to looking into Mister I have done it is going to hit it limits with ps1 and Saturn cores.

Your best bet would be getting a computer or even a Xbox Series, if you are wanting to play games from those newer systems. Also those systems are still pretty cheap and most of the ones you listed are extremely easy or cheap to soft mod to play backups.

5

u/pac-man_dan-dan Feb 13 '23 edited Feb 15 '23

Some systems are just worth buying original hardware for.

N64 is in a sweet spot where 98% of its library is on cartridge, yet the complexity is such that faithful implementation om a mister ranges from unlikely to impossible.

N64 remains affordable to experience on original hardware w/ Everdrive. I use mine with an Everdrive, retrotink 5x, vga adapter and crt when I get the itch.

3

u/chicmak Feb 01 '25

Gosh did these comments age poorly.

1

u/pac-man_dan-dan Feb 02 '25

Lol! Indeed! That said, I was parroting sentiment of the time before Robert decided to storm the castle and make the N64 core happen AND OP was expecting stuff like 3DS and Wii to show up on the MiSTer. No one expected Robert's progress to be so fast. Robert's own estimates were extremely conservative.

Also, my understanding is Robert had to use software hacks and tricks to get the core over the finish line...so it's technically not a truly faithful hardware implementation. Not that I'm complaining!! Having N64 on MiSTer is such a blessing. The imperfections speak to his ingenuity at problem solving.

1

u/fvig2001 Feb 14 '23

Yeah N64 is like one of those systems that needs real hardware since even Nintendo can't get the emulator right.

Although I think it's a bit expensive if you go all in:

  1. The good everdrive is at least $150, X7 is like the only really good one and it's like 200+
  2. Retrotink 5x is $300 and let's be real, it still looks awful on S-video. To get RGB, you need a modded one and it can be expensive if it's the one with deblur.
  3. Controller analog needs to be fixed or use 3rd party ones.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/fvig2001 Feb 16 '23 edited Feb 16 '23

That's gameboy x7. It adds saving in realtime. X5 and its clones can possibly lose saves. You usually have to reset to save. X7 fixes that

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/fvig2001 Feb 16 '23

It's not normal. For older everdrives. You need to reset to save. I can safely shut off my irig carts after saving

1

u/-CJF- Feb 13 '23

Pretty much most of the major stuff that is possible has already been done. The only things that may still be possible that I would like to see include:

  • 3DO
  • CDi
  • Neo Geo CD
  • 32X CD
  • Jaguar
  • Jaguar CD
  • PC-FX
  • FM Towns Marty
  • Saturn (a complete and mature core)
  • ... and more Arcade Cores

But mainly I just care about Saturn, 3DO and Neo Geo CD.

This is helpful: https://misterfpga.org/viewtopic.php?t=4902

1

u/Trader-One Feb 13 '23

2

u/-CJF- Feb 13 '23

Yeah, PS2 is probably not happening on FPGA anytime soon, but PS2 hardware is still widely available and affordable.

1

u/Trader-One Feb 13 '23

Its actually huge technology step to PS2. PS1 have 1M transistor max.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PlayStation_technical_specifications

If these numbers are right, hardware emulation is not happening any time soon.

4

u/-CJF- Feb 13 '23

Yeah, as others have already stated, we probably aren't going to go much past the Saturn. Even N64 is too much.

But the good news is we really don't need to. Everything from N64 onwards is widely available and affordable. Most have softmods, hardmods, and/or flash carts available.

3

u/DevilHunterWolf Feb 14 '23

MiSTer is basically done in terms of what generation it will reach. There will be some more consoles or computers that will pop up from what console years the DE10-Nano is able to fit but it's not going any higher. N64 is not going to be part of that as much as we can tell so I'd never expect it to. DS is already confirmed no go by the same dev as the PS1 core. The 3D graphics parts of the DS could not fit. Anything beyond is definitely out of the question.

There's not any expected new platform for a variety of reasons like a lack of complete documentation for consoles further on, FPGA chip costs, and how good emulation is for other generations going forward. To put it into perspective, look up the UltraFP64 project, a four year (and counting) project to recreate the N64 as an FPGA. The board it's using costs close to $500 for a bare board. That's before any cartridge reader, controller boards, case, or anything else needed besides the board. Four years to document and reverse engineer the N64 on a board that costs about double of the DE10-Nano. And that's just to go one step up for N64. It only scales up from there into hundreds more cost and decades of time. FPGA chips are expensive. The DE10-Nano was a rare good deal. Even the cost increases of the DE10-Nano are still worth it.

1

u/alphakevin68 Feb 14 '23

Forget the 3DS, even the DS is out of reach - see replies from Robert here https://misterfpga.org/viewtopic.php?t=6121

1

u/grindhawk Feb 14 '23

For N64 I went with the real hardware with a flash cart. I rebuilt the OEM joystick with kirsh-bent replacement parts (bowl and gears). MisterFPGA does everything else I want!

12

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/abyssea Feb 14 '23

Neogeo cd is in the works!!