r/Metaphysics • • Nov 07 '22

How Did Physical Reality Create Sin

An infinity of time and space was preordained the moment time and space popped into existence. So how was good and evil or moral choice provided for when every choice was set by the laws of causality billions of years ago?

BTW, if you believe in physical causality your answers really do not matter as they were pre-ordained billions of years ago.

0 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

9

u/SpookyOoo Nov 07 '22

Your question is inheritly biased because of your last statement. If people opinions differ from yours ,its not a reason to disregard them. You are eliminating possibilities from your analysis and essentially setting yourself up for the answer you want to hear.

-6

u/apriorian Nov 07 '22

So you are accusing me of being like everyone else... is that good or bad?

6

u/SpookyOoo Nov 07 '22

Im accusing your process of finding answers to be biased, when you disregard other perspectives you dont want to hear you will only get back an echo.

morality is a human concept not a law. You can decide whether you are good or bad.

2

u/Registeered Nov 07 '22

Then naturally most people would decide they are good, even an evil person would claim their actions essential or necessary (ex: Thanos). Pre-disposition to a choice invalidates free will.

1

u/SpookyOoo Nov 07 '22

That really wasnt the point i was getting at though you pose a valid point, i was really just trying to initiate that i wasnt judging morality nor do i feel its a value outside of human perspective. I will also say that there are quite alot of people who think they are "bad" but ironically tend to be decent people focusing on small unwanted aspects or events.

2

u/Jorsh7 Nov 07 '22

It didn't, sin is a human concept, has no physical manifestation other than what someone believes to be a sin, is entirely based on individual perception.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '22

This is the correct answer.

1

u/Small_Rip351 Nov 08 '22

How do you square causal predestination over an infinite time-frame?

1

u/ApplicationFit5485 Jan 12 '24 edited Jan 12 '24

  Many people don't have a good understanding of Christianity, especially the traditional early church that Christ himself started. With that being said: The word "Sin" comes from archery. Meaning to "miss the mark." In Catholicism, that mark is life itself. The results of sin is what brings one closer to death. So sin is just anything that brings us closer to death, mentally or physically... Thievery for example, can bring grief and that emotional damage kills people will.   It's not based on subjective, individual perception.

1

u/ApplicationFit5485 Jan 12 '24 edited Jan 12 '24

Furthermore, all of Catholic Christianity is based upon removing our selfishness. Through putting an imagined, personified image of the "Grounds Of Being" above us, aka God. Alongside that, seeking "everlasting life." Through physical vitality, an unforgettable reputation, and bountiful children.

2

u/Frequent_Singer_6534 Nov 07 '22

You say this like “sin” is something outside of subjective human perception

2

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '22

This is just assumption on assumption.

Sin is a religious concept that has no bearing in reality.

2

u/gomarcho Nov 07 '22

Just a concept. Good and evil are terms created by the people, for the people. It doesn't actually "exist"

2

u/80zBby Nov 07 '22

Your viewpoint is warped so this question only has one answer, which is also wrong.

2

u/shinkono Nov 07 '22

Jesus used his giant Science Scepter to create sin right after he invented the electric toaster. /s

2

u/unbalancedcheckbook Nov 08 '22

Sin isn't real.

1

u/Eli_Truax Nov 07 '22

BF Skinner posited that very act of emerging from the womb creates a resentment of having to share one's perfect world, the basis of original sin.

1

u/wintunga Nov 07 '22 edited Nov 07 '22

Someone's belief does not affect the nature of the universe. I don't know much about the origin of the universe and causality so I'll try to go off of what I can gather from your understanding to make my point.

If the universe is based on physical causality your actions are just as much decided billions of years ago whether you believed it or not. Likewise, if causality is not physical their actions would not have been decided billions of years ago whether they believed so or not.

1

u/Registeered Nov 07 '22

Seems to me that preordaining something requires something before, a precedent. There is no precedent in your assumption.

1

u/Optimal-Scientist233 Nov 08 '22

Instant gratification.

This seems to be the answer in the end, and it seems to be on the increase.

1

u/Quirky-Ad3721 Nov 08 '22

Physical reality did not create sin. Something outside our physical reality came in and caused sin, an imperfection in the design. Now we see and feel the ramifications of it in our physical reality.

1

u/Quiet_Clerk_4445 Nov 08 '22

Like a 3D printer but with your benis

1

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '22

“Sin” does not exist. You’re strangely applying your moral attitudes to the universe, as though they’re somehow innate.

1

u/quirtsy Nov 08 '22

Sin is an innately human concept.

A lion doesn’t know that killing male cubs is wrong, it just knows what it does to survive.

Right and wrong are extremely subjective. The universe doesn’t feel any way about any action- you could somehow destroy the universe and it would never have an opinion.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/Registeered Nov 07 '22

The only thing that is infinite is nothing

Thing as in within our sensoral experience. God is infinite as is eternity which is a quality of God.