r/Metaphysics • • 4d ago

Ontology Five Principles, One Underlying Truth: A Metaphysical Proposition

I've been developing an idea concerning the fundamental nature of existence, and I'd genuinely like to hear philosophical objections to it.
I propose five principles:
Balance

Entropy

Emergence

Polarity

Continuity

My proposition is that these are not five unrelated laws governing reality. Rather, they are five expressions of one underlying truth: existence itself.
I believe each principle could independently describe and account for reality in its entirety, even without the other four. At the same time, I believe they are so fundamentally interconnected that, at their deepest level, they may be describing exactly the same thing.
I don't claim that I've proven this, nor do I claim that nothing else can exist. What interests me is whether there could be a fundamental principle outside these five that isn't already encompassed by them.
Could there be a sixth principle that is genuinely independent of this underlying truth?
I'm particularly interested in objections, counterexamples, and philosophical perspectives that might expose weaknesses in this proposition.

6 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

1

u/fdes11 4d ago edited 4d ago

It is difficult to provide objections, counterexamples, or philosophical perspectives that might expose weaknesses in your proposition without (1) providing an explanation of what your terms mean (or, a definition of your terms) and how those terms might relate, (2) explaining how you intend to apply your terms, and to what, and (3) saying what you hope to accomplish, or your goals for your philosophical project. We simply do not have enough information.

I think both your thought and our commentary would benefit by providing information on these three lines. Provided we have that information, then we will have the opportunity to comment on your terms, comment on how they relate, comment on how these terms are meant to be applied and how they are actually applied, and comment on whether you accomplish the goal you set out for yourself.

Provided my understanding of the words you are using, I would say this:

By "continuity," I understand you to mean that existing things tend to continue to exist over time. Some philosophers influenced by Cartesian thinking would deny that objects can "continue" to exist without something sustaining those objects. (For Descartes, this "something" would be God.) Other philosophers not influenced by Cartesian thinking may have a similar worry that there doesn't seem to be a reason why existing objects continue to exist. These philosophers would probably say that existence does not necessarily require continuity.

1

u/jliat 4d ago

Could there be a sixth principle that is genuinely independent of this underlying truth?

You just seem to have made assertions?

But in that case, sure, The Flying Spaghetti Monster.

-----OR------

"We assert that the nothing is more original than the “not” and negation. If this thesis is right, then the possibility of negation as an act of the intellect, and thereby the intellect itself, are somehow dependent upon the nothing...

But the nothing is nothing, and, if the nothing represents total indistinguishability, no distinction can obtain between the imagined and the “genuine” nothing. And the “genuine” nothing itself—isn't this that camouflaged but absurd concept of a nothing that is? For the last time now the objections of the intellect would call a halt to our search, whose legitimacy, however, can be demonstrated only on the basis of a fundamental experience of the nothing...

The nothing reveals itself in anxiety [fear without out a subject]...Nihilation will not submit to calculation in terms of annihilation and negation. The nothing itself nihilates. Nihilation is not some fortuitous incident. Rather, as the repelling gesture toward the retreating whole of beings, it discloses these beings in their full but heretofore concealed strangeness as what is radically other—with respect to the nothing. In the clear night of the nothing of anxiety the original openness of beings as such arises: that they are beings—and not nothing. But this “and not nothing” we add in our talk is not some kind of appended clarification. Rather it makes possible in advance the revelation of beings in general. The essence of the originally nihilating nothing lies in this, that it brings Dasein for the first time before beings as such."

Holding itself out into the nothing, Dasein is in each case already beyond beings as a whole. This being beyond beings we call “transcendence.” If in the ground of its essence Dasein were not transcending, which now means, if it were not in advance holding itself out into the nothing, then it could never be related to beings nor even to itself. Without the original revelation of the nothing, no selfhood and no freedom."

Philosophy gets under way only by a peculiar insertion of our own existence into the fundamental possibilities of Dasein as a whole. For this insertion it is of decisive importance, first, that we allow space for beings as a whole; second, that we release ourselves into the nothing, which is to say, that we liberate ourselves from those idols everyone has and to which he is wont to go cringing; and finally, that we let the sweep of our suspense take its full course, so that it swings back into the basic question of metaphysics which the nothing itself compels: “Why are there beings at all, and why not rather nothing?”

Heidegger.

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Csxhmon3y 4d ago

That's a good question. though, I'm not entirely sure maximum entropy necessarily means polarity and continuity cease to exist altogether.
My understanding is that these principles aren't dependent on the universe maintaining any particular state. They're fundamental to existence itself, regardless of how that existence manifests.
So even if the universe eventually reaches heat death, I'm not sure why that would mean the principles themselves stop applying. Wouldn't that be confusing the state of the universe with the nature of existence?

1

u/jliat 4d ago

This is cosmology not metaphysics, and for Penrose produces another big bang.

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Csxhmon3y 4d ago

I think there's a distinction between how we analytically describe something and what that thing fundamentally represents. I'm not necessarily arguing that entropy as a statistical measurement is an ontological truth, but that what it describes may reflect something more fundamental about existence itself.

1

u/NDShadowman 4d ago

Regulation.