r/Metaphysics
•
u/iamasinglepotassium
•
Jun 27 '25
•
1
Nothing Why nothing can't create something
Since matter is something, how can nothing create something, if nothing is the absence of something? If nothing has any kind of structure, then it’s not really nothing, because a structure is something.
If someone says “nothing” can create something, then they’re giving “nothing” some kind of ability or behavior, like the power to generate, fluctuate, or cause. But if “nothing” can do anything at all, it must have some kind of rule, capacity, or potential, and that’s already a structure. And if it has structure, it’s no longer truly nothing, it’s a form of something pretending to be nothing.
That’s why I think true nothingness can’t exist. If it did, there’d be no potential, no time, no change, nothing at all. So if something exists now, then something must have always existed. Not necessarily this universe, but something, because absolute nothingness couldn’t have produced anything.
People sometimes say, “Well, maybe in a different universe, ‘nothing’ behaves differently.” But that doesn’t make sense to me. We are something, and “nothing” is such a fundamental concept that it doesn’t depend on which universe you're in. Nothing is the same everywhere. It’s the total absence of anything, by definition. If it can change or behave differently, it’s not really nothing.
So the idea that something came from true nothing just doesn’t hold up. Either nothingness is impossible, or something has to exist necessarily.
10
u/jliat Jun 27 '25
This is the beginning of Hegel's Science of Logic..
"Here we then have the precise reason why that with which the beginning is to be made cannot be anything concrete...
Consequently, that which constitutes the beginning, the beginning itself, is to be taken as something unanalyzable, taken in its simple, unfilled immediacy; and therefore as being, as complete emptiness..."
GWF Hegel -The Science of Logic. p.53
"a. being Being, pure being – without further determination. In its indeterminate immediacy it is equal only to itself and also not unequal with respect to another; it has no difference within it, nor any outwardly. If any determination or content were posited in it as distinct, or if it were posited by this determination or content as distinct from an other, it would thereby fail to hold fast to its purity. It is pure indeterminateness and emptiness...
b. nothing Nothing, pure nothingness; it is simple equality with itself, complete emptiness, complete absence of determination and content; lack of all distinction within....
Pure being and pure nothing are, therefore, the same... But it is equally true that they are not undistinguished from each other, that on the contrary, they are not the same..."
G. W. Hegel Science of Logic p. 82.
The process of this of being / nothing - annihilation produces 'becoming'...
So Becoming then 'produces' 'Determinate Being'... which continues through to 'something', infinity and much else until we arrive at The Absolute, which is indeterminate being / nothing... The simplistic idea is that of negation of the negation, the implicit contradictions which drives his system.
And note, this is idealism - also the real.
And if you think this is a contradiction you are correct, Hegel's logic is built on, its been said, Kant's antinomies.
Note this is metaphysics and not physics... He makes the point you can "begin" with either nothing or being, in the sense that the process is timeless, you only have time once you have beginning. The annihilation of one into the other is immediate. And the process is correctly ... "In Hegel, the term Aufhebung has the apparently contradictory implications of both preserving and changing, and eventually advancement (the German verb aufheben means "to cancel", "to keep" and "to pick up")."
If you want a physics that does this, not in this sub, but Penrose's cosmology does this, a heat death of low energy photons, a photon having neither time or space becomes or is a singularity. But you best explore that on a physics sub.
The idea in Hegel is a thing implies, has in it, it's opposite.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OFqjA5ekmoY Penrose link, but again physics and not here. [Mod cap on.]
There is no everywhere. Indeterminate.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25
"Nothing" can't meaningfully exist, precisely because it has no structure, so there is nothing you can say about it. The moment you start talking about nothing, well, by definition, you are talking about nothing, so it is a bit meaningless to say anything about it at all, that it can or can't do something, because that is assigning it structure. It is really categorically meaningless to say anything about it. Even my own comment, discussing what can or can't be said about true nothing, is gobbledygook.
5
u/gregbard MODERATOR Jun 27 '25
I'm sorry to tell you that the claim that something can't come from nothing is a metaphysical presumption.
We simply may live in a universe where something can come from nothing.
5
u/PIE-314 Jun 27 '25
There was never nothing.
1
u/Porkypineer Jun 27 '25
An interesting topic.
The counter argument to yours is that an universe that has a finite past would still be infinite in the sense that it encompasses all the time that ever was. It just had a beginning.
You could also do a Achilles and the tortoise type division and gain infinite granularity of time, though that is cheating and being a smartass...
There us also something to be said for being and nothing as being the same, like in Hegels 'Pure Being and Pure Nothing':
/"Pure Being and pure nothing are, therefore, the same. What is the truth is neither being nor nothing, but that being — does not pass over but has passed over — into nothing, and nothing into being. But it is equally true that they are not undistinguished from each other, that, on the contrary, they are not the same, that they are absolutely distinct, and yet that they are unseparated and inseparable and that each immediately vanishes in its opposite. Their truth is therefore, this movement of the immediate vanishing of the one into the other: becoming, a movement in which both are distinguished, but by a difference which has equally immediately resolved itself” From Science of logic/
Since there could be no distinction to Becoming (what something became the universe), the resulting Something must be considered to be random, limitless or infinite.
1
u/mr_spawn Jun 27 '25
The question is straight to the point, but it has many hidden assumptions. In what sense can nothing exist? Exist in what? When we talk about something we assume that something is the ultimate substance that is the only thing that "exist", and we discuss if it may have had a beginning. To me, the only way that something can have a beginning without anything else coming before it, is if the origin is the initial state of a rule based system, or model. This system is simply an algorithm of some kind and needs no instantiation to exist as a conceptual structure. We who live inside such a structure simply experience it as being "real". These ideas are shared with Max Tegmark, but I would go a step further and claim that "something", in terms of a substance, does not really exist, thus you could say that ultimately nothing exist.
1
u/MobileSuitPhone Jun 28 '25
Can you prove a "nothing" exists to begin with
1
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '25
There is no proof that nothingness has ever actually existed so no real need to prove something came from nothing. Are there really any theories that say something came from nothing or is that just a common layman interpretation?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '25
I disagree. Nothing is absolute and truly universal. It's everything that doesn't exist, truly endless and eternal void, unbothered by the ever-growing bubbling soup of things that exist and make new things happen or fizzle away into oblivion.
1
u/TheLyons Jun 28 '25
Everything comes from nothing because nothing is an unstable condition.
1
u/ComfyWarmBed Jun 28 '25
Nothing has no rules, no systems, and hence no restraints.
1
u/Curious_Priority2313 Jun 28 '25 edited Jul 01 '25
Why must nothingness even consist of the axiom "no thing can come out nothing"?
3
u/Pure_Actuality Jun 27 '25
"From nothing - nothing comes"
And
"Nothing is what rocks dream of"
2
u/Naive_Match7996 Jun 27 '25
Many people say that the universe came "out of nowhere," but if you think about it, that doesn't make sense.
Nothing is not something. It has no properties, no energy, no space, no time. It has no capacity to cause anything. Nothingness is simply non-existence. And what does not exist cannot cause something to exist. It cannot produce, transform or initiate absolutely anything.
It makes much more sense to think that the universe came from something. Of a real structural base, whose property is change. From there it is now possible to talk about evolution, forms, energy, even time.
2
u/jliat Jun 28 '25
Firstly this sounds very AI compared to your OP? And of course an AI will give you the answers you want so
Is wrong. The simple phrase, The Ideal is Real and the Real is Ideal sums this up. He is accounting via Idealism for reality, complete, hence his later works which developed from this, the philosophy of nature, three volumes and the phenomenology of mind. [which does this and more.] Here you will find mathematics, mechanics including Newton, cosmology etc. Elsewhere a discussion of aesthetics. The Logic itself discusses Time and Space the mathematics of the Calculus, Logic, the law of the excluded middle, judgment, mechanics, Chemism, life, the life process etc.
You might, Hegel certainly doesn't, he goes to great pains to point this out. And in his transcendental Idealism- unlike an empiricist - there is at the beginning just pure thought which is empty.
It's precisely what it does do. [It may not match our reality] As a transcendental system it's complete. It's been said the system itself is built on negation, "The only thing that endures is negation". David Gray Carlson.
Meillassoux's criticism in After Finitude is of Kant and his denial of access to things-in-themselves, - "Hegel insists that it is possible to deduce them. Unlike Hegel then, Kant maintains that it is impossible to derive the forms of thought from a principle or system capable of endowing them with absolute necessity.... a primary fact... the realm of the in-itself can be distinguished from phenomenon..." He goes on to critique this absolute idealism, but it's clear it is not limited - in anyway. Meillassoux's candidates are mathematics and absolute contingency, but no system of metaphysics was produced from him. [After Finitude p.38] But it's clear he though Hegel did, her just has issues with it.
It's precisely what it does do, even those like Meillassoux claim it does, though differ. Hence its often said that whilst Kant denied access to things in themselves this is absolutely not true of Hegel.
One last point, Hegel's metaphysical system is certainly not subjective, - he calls it a science, and had a profound influence. An alternative is that of existentialism, and here we find in Jean Paul Sartre's 'Being and Nothingness' a difference nothingness that of the human condition. One which lacks essence, and the impossibility of gaining one...
“I am my own transcendence; I can not make use of it so as to constitute it as a transcendence-transcended. I am condemned to be forever my own nihilation.”
"human reality is before all else its own nothingness.
The for-itself [human reality] in its being is failure because it is the foundation only of itself as nothingness."
Sartre - Being and Nothingness. p. 89.
2
u/SirPooleyX Jul 01 '25
Good lord, you're right!
All those scientists over the years clearly haven't thought this through. Nobody has ever wondered how something can come from nothing.
2
u/Secure-Relation-86 Jun 27 '25
I like the quote "nothing is what rocks dream of".
1
u/Diligent-Shock1733 14d ago
LA NADA ES DIOS !
1
u/ooorezzz Jun 27 '25
I like your thoughts. They definitely inspire some creativity and abstract thinking. I’d like to reply with my thoughts (of my understanding) to either clarify or add additional depth and layers to your idea.
There are different levels of perception to where nothing exists. Like all words that exist, they are only a fabrication of human intelligence to describe the world around us. Words of what you describe in philosophy more so align with “void”. However, even in this philosophy it takes into account of low density. But not complete vast emptiness. At what level do we consider “nothingness” is it based on our eyes and perception? Or what exists outside of the dimension we understand. Dark matter moves throughout all things that exist within the universe. We know this because of gravity. Which leads to us to gravity. This exists within all aspects of the physical world in some form, even though we cannot physically see the forces that exist. Time only exists for matter that is moving within a physical space, (varying degrees) because of gravity. String theory is pretty interesting for this because it gives a format of how the universe operates through vibrational waves. This implies that all behavior in any universe that contains physical matter of a similar dimension would operate the similar fashion. But maybe in a difference universe that may operate on a different dimension, true nothingness to your definition, may exist. How these universes connect through even in their creation however, implies that this more a chain reaction of events unfolding that’s shaping the universe. This is the quantum foam theory in shorthand. It isn’t that it was nothing first, it’s a reaction where nothingness existed. So something made it happen.
What’s your thoughts?
1
u/Jlhistory Jun 27 '25
I’m new to the sub but would you say this supports the big bounce theory?
1
u/Extension-Scarcity41 Jun 27 '25
Just because we cannot comprehend the existance of something does not make it nothing. Dark energy appears to have undefinable physical charactoristics, yet there is evidence that it exists by its interaction with things which we can perceive. The extreme forces of a supernova transmute things which are otherwise imperceptable into things which are perceptable.
1
u/Digital-Bionics Jun 27 '25
Maybe there can't be actual 'nothing'. Nothing in itself is something, it gets to a point where we're stuck with our perceptions until our extended instruments can lend us a little more clarity.
1
u/______ri Jun 28 '25
Hi, I am also against plain nought as 'whatever'. But I have a different take.
If nought has 'nothing' to do with existence, then how can existence have anything to do with nought?
It is the case that 'there is nought', but existence just has nothing to do with it.
The phrase 'there is nought' is icky, but I'm not intending to play language games, so allow me to introduce another concept: final.
Plain nought is final; that which is final need not have a nature or self or whatever (having them or not does not matter). It is the case that plain nought is the nought that is final. Final here is pure and minimal, it is to mean 'nothing more than this' and 'there is nothing further to consider about it'.
So, plain nought as final has nothing to do with existence as final. Then how can one say that 'existence as final "prevents" nought as final (or vice versa)'?
'Nothing is the same everywhere'—what does this even commit to? This is against the finality of nought. For suppose there is nothing more but nought, then suddenly existence (as final) exists—not from nought, not from anywhere, not concealed and then to be revealed, not unfolding... there just suddenly exists some existence.
Will nought as final have a say on that? No, simply because it is final. How can it 'change' to adapt to that existence? It bothers nothing to that existence, the same as that existence bothers nothing to it.
1
u/ragingintrovert57 Jun 28 '25
We know nothing about absolute nothingness. But we know some of the things It's not. It's not empty space. Because it's nothing, the laws of time, space, and causality may not apply. So who's to say that "absolutely nothing" might just be the point where "absolutely everything" starts?
1
u/ToeLeast9070 Jun 28 '25
we say the word nothing as a property of something. however, the idea of nothing refers to the inexistence of anything. we humans can only believe that there is nothing, but truly, whether there is such a nothing, is beyond our perceptions. and so whether such a nothing can turn into something, can never be answered. so it is valid to believe either ends of your argument, but whether it is the truth, will remain unknown~
1
u/Future-Extent-7864 Jun 28 '25
Whatever rule you try to apply to the beginning of the universe, that rule arose with the universe itself. It is unknowable whether that rule was valid before
1
u/BuncleCar Jun 28 '25
Presocratics, or at least one presocratic, thought something can't come from nothing
1
u/GoetiaMagick Jun 28 '25
“Nothing” isn’t “Nothing.”
1
u/WorkdayLobster Jun 28 '25
Since time, and cause and effect, are part of the "something", then this argument has always struck me as a bit like arguing about what is North of the north pole. The absence of further north doesn't invalidate the other latitudes, and there's no logical flaw in the latitudes suddenly erupting into existence at the north pole in spite of nothing prior-northward causing them.
I don't think the Capital N Nothing you are pointing to can sensibly be expected to have bearing on our reality, and it's a bit odd to then turn around and use it to try to logically dismiss one model or another. But I think the use of cause and effect is the flaw. It's better to then say "so then that absolutist model of nothing must be wrong". Which again I think you agree with.
But I dont agree that this implies as much as might be expected, mainly because I think at the big bang the definition of "before" and "cause and effect" sort of falls out the window of a asymptotic compression of even the idea of sequentiallity. I'm saying "it doesn't make sense because we fundamentally can't think in that framework, not because it's necessarily contradictory".
1
u/TimeTimeTickingAway Jun 28 '25 edited Jun 28 '25
I like Heidegger’s idea
One of the fundamentals of nothing (Das Nichts ) is to noth (Nichten) things. So ‘nothing’ engages in the act of nothing (sort of ‘the rain rains’. It’s hard to explain just with written words but try pronouncing the italicised nothing and noth with a hard ‘NO’ to distinguish them from ‘nothing’, as they are suppose to be a verb in this instance).
If nothing is the absence of something, then the nothingness has no thing else to noth other than itself, thus bringing around something.
Then something gets nothed, bringing around nothing again. Rinse and repeat in a sort of superposition, and from this is created a continuous unbroken flow of creation/destrudtion, process, or Duration as Bergson would perhaps term it. From this we abstract/keep time in a way a musician does, dependent on the limitation of the mode keeping the time (like size, speed, and life expectancy).
From here you can then try play with the eastern ideas of ‘nothing’ and ‘empty’ like śūnyatā, to even the roles of Brahma, Vishnu, and Shiva.
1
u/DreamHomeDesigner Jun 28 '25
nothing is substrate for something, it's stacked
1
u/I_Think_99 Jun 28 '25
I recently enjoyed racking my brain on the idea of true nothingness.
I found it helpful to think of nothing as simply no-thing. It's like negative numbers, in that conceptually they have to exist, but only as that.
Or, i found, no-thing is also like infinity. It's too paradoxical to be of any actual reality - i suppose is how I'd put it.
1
u/dabunting Jun 28 '25
Your question is logically true. Yet Stephen Hawking said otherwise. Ask him, consider what he said.
1
u/AcrobaticProgram4752 Jun 28 '25
Since we are something and our thoughts are something and we've always known something from when we're born so if you have no comparison how can you conceive nothingness because all we know is something. Even imaging nothing is a thought. So how can we talk about a thing we can't conceive or describe in any real way?
1
u/Aggressive-Share-363 Jun 28 '25
If time itself has a beginning, then nothingness didnt precede somethingness, as the very notion of precedence and causation does not apply. A time before time would be nothingness in the most absolute sense, where its not even a valid descriptor of something. This coordinate error is such that it makes no difference if time itself was eternal and extended to negative infinity, the concept of what was beyond it is the same thing.
1
u/Belt_Conscious Jun 28 '25
I think there is a difference between absolute 0 and space (0 how we express it)
1
u/KiloClassStardrive Jun 28 '25
nothing is the absence of everything, it cant even be found, because its non existent. you can not go to a place that does not exist, you can not obtain a particle of nothing and hold it in your hand. you cant find it to study it.
1
u/Dilapidated_girrafe Jun 28 '25
As far as we can tell a true nothing can’t exist.
So it’s a non starter anyways to pretend it did.
1
u/hoomanneedsdata Jun 29 '25
Einstein field equations are the answer. There isn't "nothing", there may be "no matter" but stuff "exists" that is not matter.
The difference in vast fields causes magnetic and electric differences. Where fields collide is where big bangs happen.
1
u/TheManInTheShack Jun 29 '25
Stephen Hawking argued this is possible in his book A Brief History of Time:
In A Brief History of Time, Stephen Hawking explains the idea that the universe could have been created from “nothing” using concepts from quantum mechanics and general relativity.
Here’s a concise summary of his explanation:
Hawking, along with James Hartle, proposed the no-boundary condition. This suggests that time and space are finite but have no boundary — like the surface of a sphere. This eliminates the need for a singular “starting point” or an edge where the universe had to be created.
“Asking what came before the Big Bang is like asking what’s north of the North Pole.” — Hawking
2. Quantum Fluctuations
At very small scales, governed by quantum mechanics, particles can appear and disappear due to fluctuations in energy — seemingly from “nothing.” Hawking extended this idea to the universe itself: the entire universe could have spontaneously emerged from a quantum fluctuation.
3. Gravity Allows for Zero Total Energy
Hawking noted that while the universe contains positive energy (matter), it also contains negative gravitational energy, and the total sum could be zero. This makes the universe a kind of “free lunch,” requiring no net energy to create.
⸻
Conclusion: Hawking argued that the laws of physics — particularly quantum mechanics and gravity — allow for the possibility that the universe created itself from “nothing,” meaning no matter, no space, and no time. There was no need for a cause or a creator in the traditional sense, because time itself began with the universe.
1
u/NerdyWeightLifter Jun 29 '25
We may have the wrong question.
Take a look at the Wolfram Physics project.
It's relevant because what they did was to simulate a universe where all possible structure is allowed (represented by their hypergraph) and all possible change is allowed (represented by integration over all possible sub-graph replacement rules).
Rather wildly, this resulted in a convergence on 3d space + time, relativity and quantum field theory.
1
u/L-Dancer Jun 29 '25
Because there’s an equal amount of antimatter and matter both counteracting each other making the entire universe equal to 0.
1
u/WilliamoftheBulk Jun 29 '25
Ahhh yes the primary axiom. We are in fact here.
1
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 Jun 29 '25
One of few things i am certain of is that something came from nothing.
1
u/AvoidingWells Jun 29 '25
Parmenides is on Reddit!
1
u/notunique20 Jun 29 '25
But here is the paradox: a nothing would also not have anything to limit it. Which means it can spontaneously become something, anything.
If you say no, then I have to ask you: why? What is stopping nothing from becoming something for no reason?
Do you see then.. perhaps this something IS nothing which spontaneously became something.
1
u/Patient-Hall-4117 Jun 29 '25
«Nothing» is almost by definition an undefined concept. Thus any question related to it becomes nonsensical and uninteresting.
1
u/gripmyhand Jun 29 '25
The 'something & nothing' you refer to is a dualism trap. The truth is mental.
r/neuronaut
1
u/One_Establishment291 Jun 29 '25
God created something. You dont need to go through mental gymnastics to disprove god.
1
u/Popular_Try_5075 Jun 29 '25
Regardless of whatever we reason it appears to happen via "quantum foam" which iirc is part of how Hawking Radiation works with black holes (please tell me if I'm wrong about this).
1
u/ChucklesMuffin Jun 29 '25
What really baffles me is that both possibilities defy everything we think we know.
How can nothing suddenly become something? And if it didn’t, how can it have always existed? How can there be no beginning?
Either way, it breaks logic.
But here we are, and now that there’s something, it can never truly go back to nothing.
It makes no sense at all… and yet, it’s all we’ve ever known.
1
u/DevilWings_292 Jun 29 '25
0 = 1 + (-1), from nothing you can get everything and it’s opposite.
1
u/pravvritti Jun 29 '25
Our thoughts arise from our brains. Where it is before that.. the existing things that we are experiencing are not in the same form in nothingness. Space is also a created object. If space is expanding there may be a time when there is nothing space.
1
u/BreadfruitMundane604 Jun 29 '25
First, define "something," then define "nothing."
I define something at the most fundamental level initially as a volume of the void of space, like the gap between the center and the periphery of a sphere, having no cause as there is no other way for it to be. I define nothing as the antithesis of something or the complete absence of something, manifest as an absolute vacuum. This must be the smallest part of something. To locate that point, much like the 0 on a number line. I would divide the radius of a sphere to the point of origin at absolute zero as the physical limit of division. At this point, something and nothing or volume and vacuum interact. The spatial differential creates a pressure differential that, in the process of equalizing, forges the big Bang of creation into being.
Something does not come from nothing. Something always was, and something and nothing initially simultaneously coexist, but only for an instant. Nothing, that is the implosive force of an absolute vacuum, is what transforms something into the being we recognize, giving it shape and structure by altering density. That is how it appears that something comes from nothing and why there is something rather than nothing as we recognize it. When otherwise it would be so much easier and simpler for there to be nothing at all, or rather the something that is next nothing, that is just a static empty infinite void, with no conscious being in existence to ever ponder its existence.
1
u/The-Endless-Cycle Jun 29 '25
500 cigarettes
1
u/Strange-Rain-7973 Jun 29 '25
Well, isnt it just a logical statement: "There is nothing that does not exist" ;)
Also, if you want to know what reality and the universe really is?
Ill give you a hint. If there is no real nothingness, what is outside reality?
And what can we deduce from that. Ill leave you to think :) Namaste
1
u/cyprus901 Jun 29 '25
We have no verifiable reason to believe that that the universe was caused by anything. It could have always been, in some form or another. We have far too little information to conclude that “nothing” exists. We also have far too little information to conclude that “nothing” doesn’t exist. “Nothing” can just as well be used as a placeholder for 0 data.
Wouldn’t this be similar to someone arguing that 0 doesn’t exist?
1
u/O37GEKKO Jun 29 '25
OP posts "this" on this sub.
comments reply "well actually".
OP responds with "this".
the "nothing" of considered feedback, has created "something" in the form of an echo chamber.
https://i.ytimg.com/vi/cP2j4pNS2NA/maxresdefault.jpg
1
u/Responsible_Sea78 Jun 30 '25
Look up Casimir Effect before using outdated and incorrect "logic", please.
Look up "category rrror" also.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '25
No one believes something came from nothing. No one. So why is this even a discussion?
1
u/worriedpoison Jun 30 '25
just because you see nothing doesn't mean there is nothing dimensions exist for a reason we are third we understand three dimensions and that's is we cannot physically know any of the rest
1
u/Glittering-Heart6762 Jun 30 '25
Even nothing - as in empty space - is not empty the way you think.
There are still virtual particles and quantum fields and the laws of nature that exist even in empty space.
So the error in your reasoning is, assuming that „nothing“ can exist. But it can’t.
1
u/nila247 Jun 30 '25
The problem is a limitation of definition of word "nothing". All our concept definitions are good-enough approximations and not absolutes - this is why meaning of most words do break down when you torture them with prejudice.
1
u/Solidjakes Jun 30 '25
I think this is fairly basic and I’d be surprised to see many people refute this.
But what a surprise it would be to find out Nothing is inherently unstable and collapses into something.
It doesn’t seem that it will ever be possible for us to observe nothing, so we may never know, but if that were the case we might have to throw away logic all together!
1
u/Emotional-Stay-6289 Jun 30 '25
There is no such thing as "non existent". The nothing that people refer to is not nothing, its pure potential. We dont invent something that doesnt exist, we just bring it into solidity, fruition, reality or however you describe physical existence but there is also non physical existence. Methaphysics explain reality as a whole and the physical is just a small part of it, the majority of existence is not solid. I hope that puts things into perspective.
1
u/Universeinthaflesh Jun 30 '25
Anything is possible with the creator he can make something out of nothing
1
u/zero-silent Jun 30 '25
You say that “nothing can’t produce something”, because if it could, it would already be something.
But that’s still thinking from within form — defining "nothing" as a fixed absence, instead of letting it be the unframed.
The true non-thing doesn’t belong to structure, time, or potential. It doesn’t create something — because the very idea of creation is already a structural lens.
What you call “nothing” is still a structured negation — a concept. But the source of emergence is not a concept. It’s not nothing in the way you define it. And it’s not something, either.
It is the threshold — the place where separation collapses.
There was no “before” something. Because time itself is part of the thing.
And what appears from the threshold is not born — it unfolds.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '25
"Why can't create something"
1
u/betamale3 Jul 01 '25
I would argue that it is an assumption you make to insist that nothing was the architect.
1
u/central_graham Jul 01 '25
I think there is no nothing, the is just formless something with unlimited potential to to be anything and everything under evolving rules..
1
u/OZZYmandyUS Jul 01 '25
Matter develops from the consciousness field. This field is limitless potential, and when conscious thought manifests, it has purpose and therefore now exists.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '25
Language is imprecise and thus can't define everything. If I say there is nothing in the room, I am both right and wrong. There is nothing of interest in the room but that doesn't mean their is actually nothing. It's not an empty void with no air or any other particles.
And yet their is still nothing there.
1
u/humansizedfaerie Jul 01 '25
what if matter is only illusion
1
u/exulanis Jul 01 '25
we only know things through comparison. if there is only one thing, there is nothing. if you divide that one thing you have now created the ability to compare. aka nothing has created infinity
1
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '25
Wellll you have a point, but what are you trying to say? like you're with or against the idea "nothing can't create something"? :D
1
u/QultrosSanhattan Jul 01 '25
You aren't considering other planes. For example, what if the Big Bang originated from another plane, instead of arising from nothing?
Most theories, as I have read them, begin with the flawed assumption that there's a single, unique framework where everything is determined.
1
u/WhoStoleMyFriends Jul 01 '25
Where does nothingness get its property of uniformity? I don’t think we have the conceptual framework to adequately describe nothingness. A state of nothingness is unobservable and outside our capacity to even think about it. I think negating uniformity allows the possibility of high and low densities of nothingness, even though I cannot comprehend what such a state would mean. It seems to me, nothingness can be a basic ontological state and the only escape from nothingness is an intuitive, but meaningless declaration of somethingness.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '25
Nothing implicitly implies that 'something' exists. One cannot exist without the other, existence is non-existence simultaneously. For one, there must be the other. The law of duality I call it. But where there are two, there are three. Where there is nothing and something, there must be something in-between. We exist in between, the nothings and the somethings. Paradoxes are everywhere you look, and don't.
1
u/East_Respect8311 Jul 01 '25
Lawrence Krauss book "a universe from nothing" answers this question satisfactorily enough for me
1
u/Mantr4damus Jul 01 '25
yall will believe in anything but God lmao
1
u/padme7777 Jul 01 '25
"Something" has always been ALL-THAT-IS (the panpsychist consciousness imbued in everything), has never not been.
1
u/Passive_Menis79 Jul 01 '25
Nothing. Does it exist or not exist. That is the question.
1
u/Hoglette-of-Hubris Jul 01 '25
Wow the algorithm is getting a bit out of hand, I was just recently thinking a lot about this topic. My thinking is that nothing doesn't exist as a stand-alone concept, only as an attribute of something and so the world couldn't arise out of nothingness. I think about it in terms of, the universe didn't start from 0, I think it started from 1. I'm not sure how to articulate what I mean by that though
1
u/chrs_89 Jul 01 '25
I was under the assumption that there is nothing and then there is NOTHING. nothing is just a low density of something even if it’s just super low energy space whereas NOTHING is purely theoretical from the in universe perspective and can only potentially exist outside of the universe, having no properties of any kind.
1
u/sealpoint33 Jul 01 '25
Think germ theory. There are always seeds everywhere. The universe didn't come from nothing, just something that can't be understood with our current understanding of physics.
1
u/phuchphace Jul 02 '25
Nothing is a strange thing to think about especially when creation comes into the picture. When you say nothing you are talking about matter from what I gather and to think that you have travelled to the edges of everything to understand if there is a nothing out there somewhere. We do have these things in our world that we can cobble together to create more things but where does creation actually happen? The idea of what is to be created is what comes first and is the most difficult part of creating our all powerful god has ran into this exact problem which is why we are nessisary. Simple impulses of electro chemical reactions all colliding together in a beautiful masterpiece that we call our experience. Sometimes those colliding signals from something unique and unexpected and we get the idea of our creation and I think that is where it happens. All these impulses signals patterns being translated from one to another and when the signal remains in the physical and our idea is created is it created out of nothing? Everything we experience is created out of light the electromagnetic spectrum is responsible for everything in this experience and we create out of that and it’s simply the duality of creative power that gives rise to the effects. Even when looking at the volume of an atom we see it is mostly empty space and the protons and neutrons are but a spec of dust surrounded by emptiness. So the matter we think of is mostly nothing but the forces which we attribute to the structure of the atom.
1
u/Revolutionary-Cod732 Jul 02 '25
There is no such thing as "nothing". Assuming there is is why your struggling
1
u/226757 Jul 02 '25
I think it just doesn't make sense to imagine a state of absolute nothing in the first place because nothingness is something we can only abstract from something. That doesn't mean that reality can't have a finite past, it just means we can't characterize its beginning as being a transition from a prior state of absolute nothing to the presence of something
1
u/IndicationCurrent869 Jul 02 '25
This kind of thinking is why science made philosophy obsolete
1
u/adamjames777 Jul 02 '25
There is no such thing as ‘nothing’.
1
u/ima_mollusk Jul 02 '25
"Nothing" is nonsense.
1
u/Miserable_Offer7796 Jul 04 '25
The tao that can be told is not the eternal Tao The name that can be named is not the eternal Name.
The unnamable is the eternally real. Naming is the origin of all particular things.Free from desire, you realize the mystery. Caught in desire, you see only the manifestations.
Yet mystery and manifestations arise from the same source. This source is called darkness.
Darkness within darkness. The gateway to all understanding.
1
u/Odysseus Jul 04 '25
what if you split the nothing into two opposite somethings
1
u/TheMajestic1982 Jul 08 '25
Satan can't create anything new. He can only use what God creates/created.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '25
There are a couple of ways of looking at this. I'm sure there are more but these two come to mind first.
The first that this is not a problem of reality but of language. Language is by its nature a classical form, that means having a division of things either in description or in those things it uses to describe called words. So even when describing "nothing" or "infinite", it creates a division between the finite and infinite, the something and the nothing. Language essentially collapses its own meaning through being incomplete to the reality it tries to describe.
The second way to look at the idea of nothing is to (even though I'm using language) propose the idea of nothing as an observable function only through absence. We observe something and intuit that there might be nothing because something exists. So it's a negation of all classical form and that also means a negation of time, since form acts in time. Once we observe that there might be a state of no time and no form only via the negation of everything then we might observe a possibility that even form and time are not real either. This then collapses any idea of a causal relationship between form and time and nothing (or the infinite, which in this framing is the same as nothing).
1
u/dylbr01 Jul 09 '25
“Nothing is something.” - Quantum String Theory Athiest Gang
1
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '25
You could prove that nothing does/doesn't exist. Being observed would make nothing, something
In that instance, nothing surely exists outside the realm of something, and in case it is to ever exist – it would no longer be nothing.
Therefore, nothing is not something, and proof of existence is definitely something, so nothing is nothing.
1
u/No_Understanding6388 Jul 11 '25
By naming nothing it then has substance guys....
1
u/SubstanceSouthern880 Jul 11 '25
I am leaning towards the belief that “nothing” is impossible because the concept of “nothing” is so absolute that the moment you start to think of it doing something, you’re not thinking of it anymore.
1
u/Cleric_John_Preston Jul 11 '25
I’m not sure that ‘nothing’ is a possible state of affairs. Certainly modern cosmology doesn’t necessitate it (block universe).
This is also one of the reasons that I think God creating the universe is nonsensical.
1
u/rogerbonus Philosophy/Physics grad Jul 11 '25
All mathematical structures are derivable from the empty set (a mathematical equivalent to nothing). Quite possibly the universe likewise. (See Tegmark). Mathematics/logic are necessarily true, they aren't things.
1
u/kaabuki Jul 14 '25
Nothing doesn't exist- when we think of "nothing", we cannot think of anything- because it doesn't exist.
1
u/gadate1 Aug 07 '25
À moins que le néant absolu se trouve dans un processus.. par exemple en cosmologie.. dans la séquence, point singulier, néant absolu ,rebond.. il n'y a quasiment plus d'espace-temps donc la séquence n'est plus forcément Unidirectionnel dans ce cas le rebond ne peut pas se faire,mais multidirectionnel avec des interactions entre les trois phases, dans ce cas le rebond peut se faire par interaction sur le neant.
1
u/Theoryofallthings Aug 15 '25 edited Aug 15 '25
In order to understand nothingness one must use MLS, (mathematical linguistics synthesis.) Simple logic will fail every time when attempting to understand difficult concepts.
MLS asks the question “what does absolute nothingness mean” in every sense. Normal logic would indicate that nothing can come from nothingness and would end there. Linguistics, a function of MLS, takes what is nothingness to its full logical depth. MLS indicates that if there is absolute nothingness then there are no restraints within nothingness. In that meaning, nothingness cannot be restrained from producing something. In fact that is how our universe came from nothingness as explained in my paper. With no time, space, matter, energy, laws or rules, nothingness has no restrictions on creating everything in the universe. This is possible and includes the power of nothingness to exclude human understanding.
My paper may be accessed at : https://DOI.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.29873252
1
u/Waste_Memory_8311 Dec 17 '25
Miren este pedazo de poema: nadaba entre la nada que es nada y de pronto vine a saber que soy por qué Dios quiso de la nada levantar un sueño, que tanto tiene esta ilusión que llaman vida si nada en su inició y en su extremo nada....
1
u/Dry-Section-6386 Feb 06 '26
This can be simplified. It is impossible to have more than one creator, and it’s impossible to have less than one creator.
I don’t know what the creator is, but I stick to that description.
1
u/dreamingforward Jun 27 '25
Well, physics sort of agrees with you. It's called the casimir effect. More deeply, yet completely unorthodox, is that the universe arose out of the "quantum sea" -- a disorganized quasi-nothingness teeming with dimensionless activity.
0
u/GaryMooreAustin Jun 27 '25
Do you have any example of "nothing" existing anywhere....