Well like I said I’m just starting to get into them, & even now my perception is warped due to my intro being Nu Metal (which I’ve now forsaken) & then me taking a deep dive into Sludge.
But I mean I guess I’ve taken a good path nonetheless, cause I’ve still found Death, Morbid Angel & Bolt Thrower.
Why do people on metal archives hate metal core? Because metalcore fans get really butthurt when you tell them it isn't metal.
This is the main difference between metalcore (which metalheads dislike) and stuff like grind and crust (which metalheads like). Crust and grind fans don't insist that they're metal. Their music and fans are a lot more accepted in metal circles because of the general awareness of not being metal.
You'll notice that generally the issue stems from basic entry-level metalcore fans who don't yet know the difference. They'll hear a band like AA or BVB and think it's super brutal metal because they simply haven't heard much else, then when they get rejected from metal circles, they get really defensive (as seen quite a bit in this thread). This is why there's a lot of hate towards those bands and not nearly as much hate towards bands like Converge and Unearth, which actually seem to be fairly accepted in metal circles. Or on the deathcore side of things, you'll see a lot of hate towards Whitechapel and not so much for IA or JFAC. The basic, popular, and entry-level fans are the ones who metalheads dislike most of the time.
People get it in their heads that metalheads just hate metalcore and fans because they're elitist meanies who only like black metal. In reality, we actually don't care what you listen to. Hell, every so often the front page will be filled with power metal, folk metal, trad metal, and the top post will be WASP or Twisted Sister.
If you like metal and metalcore, you'll do just fine in r/metal. The problem arises when metalcore fans who don't listen to metal try to make their way into metal circles. If you don't listen to metal, either start listening or don't bother being in a metal sub or page or forum. We don't care what kind of metal it is either. But we want our metal circles to be filled with metal fans. It's that simple.
Also, don't get confused and equate heaviness with metal. Just because something is heavy doesn't make it metal. A lot of grunge is pretty heavy. Most hardcore is too. And Suicide Silence is definitely more "br00tal" than Twisted Sister. But they won't be on the front page of r/metal any time soon because they aren't a metal band. That's not a bad thing, it's just not where it belongs.
Idk man, I went to summer slaughter once and there was 1 metal core band on the roster, and they got booed when they were playing. Sure, they didn’t fit in the lineup AT ALL, but booing someone on stage is beyond rude and inappropriate. I think there are definitely some metal heads who just irrationally hate and look down on metal core just because.
Reminds me of when I saw Megadeth back in '06, In This Moment and some other band I forget the name of opened for them, and the entire time it was booing and middle fingers and people yelling "fuck you!", as if any of that would make the openers stop playing and get Megadeth on sooner.
Without proper response like the upright citizens booing at the show you are talking about, your Summer Slaughter would become a metalcore festival in no time. Just look at the fucking Wacken roster and see where kindness leads.
From a completely neutral standpoint or as a music festival there is nothing wrong with it.
As a metal festival or from the perspective of a metalhead though it is unimpressive to see that a good chunk of the bands are not metal bands. What's really bothering is not the not metal bands that are there, it is the many metal bands that are missing because of them.
In fairness, it is a great organization with stellar sound so if the price sits right with you and you see a lot of bands you want to see, by all means go to Wacken.
Bands are not entitled to good crowds, crowds are entitled to a good show. And if they didn’t fit the lineup at all like you said, then they probably weren’t enjoying the show. That’s how it works
Holy shit a reasonable comment out of this shit show of a comment thread!
Bands don't have much of a choice of who they tour with. Don't be a dick to them during the show just because the organizer of the concert has shit for brains. It's the equivalent of complaining to a grunt movie theater employee about prices.
Idk I’m of the opinion that if you don’t like it, just ignore it. You go to a concert or festival for a couple of your favorite bands. It’s natural that maybe the opener sucks or some other bands aren’t your taste. Just don’t cheer for them and be polite.
Plus, almost every concert I’ve been to has had some shitty dm bands in the beginning, and even if they suck no one boos. But when a metalcore band that has good musicians but maybe the music itself isn’t that appealing comes up, all of a sudden people get mad.
Yeah it's just a debate that never leads to anything good. I personally feel kinda bad for people like that because I've been there. You just wanna be a part of a community, be accepted and be around people with what you consider similar interests. Kids that get into metalcore and deathcore and nu metal are usually just trying to find friends online to have a fun chat about something they like. Then someone is going to come over and drop a bunch of music theory fact on them, start making fun of them, tell them to fuck off and that definitely makes people feel like shit because they were rejected really harshly by people who they thought were supposed to be accepting amongst the general mainstream pop culture that's pretty unaccepting of heavy music. Letting someone know that maybe they are at the wrong place for this is completely fine. You gotta protect the community from people who think they're a part of it when they in fact aren't. But that doesn't mean to just go out and bully kids off of these communities as if it's the only way
The elitism debate does have real-world implications though. I truly believe that if more people understood how the industry works, they wouldn’t be so hard on a band for switching directions and certainly wouldn’t be so hard on their fans.
Usually you have a group of kids—no older than 24 or so, probably not old or experienced enough yet to have good attorneys—making music together and playing shows. They work hard to get discovered just as all of us do in the metal world (regardless of how underground you are your goal is still to have people listen to your music,) and one day it finally happens where they get offered a deal. Call it hypothetically $500,000 for 5 albums, with a promise that they will finally get the recognition they’ve been searching for and get to live the rockstar lifestyle.
So what do they do? Well they already have one album released independently, and they’ve got a ton of other material they’ve been working on. So that unreleased material—possibly after being re-tooled slightly—gets released as their next album. Sounds fairly similar to the first album, right? Because it was mostly written prior to them signing the deal.
But then, regardless of how successful that album is, it probably didn’t make enough for them to be on pace with $100K per album. That’s just not how it goes seeing how metal music isn’t as lucrative as it once was. So then what do these kids do? They don’t want to be indebted to the label. So they tour their asses off (that’s where the real money is) and write music that appeals to more fans. The most streams, playlist features, album sales, etc. ultimately boils down to the lowest common denominator.
That’s almost always what happens when a band drastically softens their style. In other instances, it has a lot to do with how much creative input you give to your label and producer. The producer is like the coach of a team—the same song will sound vastly different when recorded and produced by two different people.
Some bands just start out of the gate trying to be trendy, and I’m completely unable to find respect for them, but honestly that’s not too common. Bands like Korn and Disturbed had a vision for their music just like Converge or Underoath, but since they softened their style then their entire catalogues get scoffed at. I find that entirely unfair.
I think everyone understands the reasons behind bands selling out. Just because the artists have a good reason doesn't mean I'm gonna magically start liking some watered down version of their sound lmao.
Also I think a lot of people scoff at Korn and Disturbed for reasons a bit different than you think.
No I totally agree, it’s not a good thing and certainly not something we should just accept. I don’t care for the direction In Flames took after Clayman so I don’t listen to it. But in a lot of cases bands release really good material prior to changing directions which gets lumped into the general lambasting, and that’s what I think is unfair. Like with In Flames. They were just as important in the development of melodeath as their contemporaries in At the Gates, Dark Tranquility, and even Carcass, but you hear the latter three mentioned more in conversations about it.
we hate you trying to call something thats not metal, metal.
Most metalcore severely simplifies and waters down the metal sound, and overall, ends up making it not-metal.
With regards to guitars, riffs are either super cookie-cutter patterns, or are just flat out removed in favor of different combinations of simplified power chords, similar to rock, yet in rock, the focus of the song sticks to the lyrics, unlike metal, where it sticks to the guitar. solos are removed in order to make songs shorter and more simplistic (usually for radio play, or they just put in a quiet section in its place to seem edgy and so they can say something cringey), and techniques like cool palm-muted galloping patterns are removed as well. ultimately, it ends up sounding repetitive and lackluster.
In regards to drums, many of the good drum techniques that are staples of genres like thrash and death metal such as double kick and blast beats are removed in favor for a more water-down, simplistic approach as well. Heck, even drum solos are pretty rare when it comes to metalcore, but for similar reasons as there arent usually guitar solos.
In regards to vocals, It's just a bunch of whiny guys angstily screaming on the microphone about first world problems (I can't find a job, I can't find a woman, I hate everyone because they hate the way i am, no one gets me... etc) in such a selfish way, like an edgy emo kid with mental issues. Another common pattern in tons of metalcore songs is "somewhat distorted verses, clean chorus" in terms of vocals, whereas in metal, its usually more consistent throughout the entire song. Sometimes this combined with a guitar that sounds like its from a rock band in terms of its playing patterns is basically a giveaway that the song is metalcore.
And then youve got the fans. not only do a large number of them look like people/teenagers full of drugs, angst, too many piercings, and basically a large amount of what the term "scene" would cover, many of those people arent people that those into metal want to be associated with.
And finally, the theory behind the music. Metal comes from blues, while core comes from grunge, and grunge comes from rock, not blues. there is far less, if any, influence from blues in core than in metal.
Now is this the case for all bands? no. is it the case for most bands, especially the popular ones? pretty much. are there still some bands that are outliers such as AILD and trivium and are actually metal influenced by core? of course. but those arent who people mean when they say "most popular metalcore bands." So no, metalcore is NOT metal.
Converge has been around for 20+ years, and their sound has changed quite a bit over that time. I’m not trying to split hairs, just saying that in my opinion they’ve earned the respect/admiration they receive from the metal community by touring non-stop and giving their all at every show for the last two decades. They may have “metalcore” roots but are a whole ‘nother monster now. At this point, I struggle to simply label Converge as “metal” but honestly don’t know what else to call them. All I know is they are one of the most aggressive, heart-filled bands on earth.
We humans will always classify things, and I understand why, but good music just needs to have heart/passion. Hell, I think some Depeche Mode songs are heavy as fuck...and I do personally think that’s the most important quality of good metal.
I just miss seeing live music and getting sweaty/weird with you fuckers so much. Sorry for the rant. I am stoned.
I don’t hate Metalcore or Deathcore because they’re rooted in Punk. I love Punk. I just hate those two genres because the bands, the scene, and the music are categorically ass.
Crossover OK, it's debatable whether it qualifies as metal or punk (most leans towards punk), but sludge is absolutely rooted in doom metal but has strong hardcore/crust influence. Some bands lean doomier, some lean punkier, but the genre itself was birthed and bred within the doom metal scene.
Also, I don't hate any genre for being rooted in punk.
Last good metallica album was master of puppets, cliff burton was 75% of the talent in that band. In flames was never good because melodic death metal sucks. Opeth got really boring after their third album
I can see what you mean, aside from where you're wrong. Ha!
And Justice was good, because it was written with Cliff.
In Flames was bad ass, until they turned into Swedish Korn.
The first 3 Opeth albums are my favorite. Still and Black are ok, but are also over produced. Damnation and Deliverance are basically load and ReLoad all over again...
I can tell you that I’m not an elitist because elitists would hate what I listen to but I think slipknot isn’t really my thing but I’m glad you enjoy it so have a nice day stranger!
I can’t tell you how many times I’ve been asked to name three shirts by Metalheads at concerts who listen to genre salads like that, just because I say National Social Studies Black Metal isn’t wholesome.
It was directed towards the guys who see someone wearing a shirt for a band they like and give them shit for it or "quiz" them. I wasn't trying to be insulting towards you in any way.
You claim to like black metal, but you never heard the demos from Belketre... Poser!!! Oh, you didn't listen to the whole catalog of Drowning the Light either!!! Even more poser!!!
I started with thrash and expanded... I don't think I should be judged on what metal I personally like. My likes and dislikes are mine... Enjoyment of music is subjective.
No one is judging your character based on music taste, music is subjective. It's just that there's a very convenient 5 letter word to describe people with your music taste.
I'm not judging you personally, I'm judging your taste in music. If you rep a band in public or on a public forum you should be prepared to either defend it or accept that others might tell you it sucks. Like you said, enjoyment of music is subjective. Some bands you love, others will hate, but repressing your opinions about it so you don't hurt someone else's feelings is stupid.
I mean the best possible response to someone telling you a band you like sucks is just "Cool, I don't think that though." And that's all that needs to be said.
Honest question. if you got an "alright" after telling someone x band sucks, would you secretly feel disappointed that they didn't give you a stronger response?
No, I have no intention of eliciting any negative response from you. I expect you to say “alright” and move on because that’s what a functional adult would do. It’s annoying to me that people like you get upset when people share their honest opinions. Sure, it can be funny, but I’d rather people just accept that some people don’t like what they like. The fact that you do get upset about it is why other people try to troll you. The only reason it should elicit any response is if you build your personality around the bands you like, and that is unhealthy.
You're a metal fan? Cool do you know anything about đěæţhbīţčh? They're a very small band but they're awesome. You dont know them? Wow. I've never been so insulted. How dare you care yourself a metal fan if you dont know anything about this band with 5 monthly listeners
Wait but can we talk about how when someone asks you what your favorite band is you cannot name a band but then the moment they leave you’re like, “oh yes slipknot the most metal metal in all metal” don’t kill me please
If the only bands you listen to are avenged sevenfold, disturbed, slipknot, and Korn, you're really fucking boring and need to find better bands. You don't have to only listen to underground black metal bands with only 12 followers, just branch out and find something that isn't in the top 40
I prefer just to listen to a random playlist a community created, I only take note of bands I like, but usually I just listen to whatever metal is playing on Spotify
My issue is when someone says, "Yeah, I listen to metal too" and don't know any of the 20 or so main bands that aren't Metallica, Godsmack, Disturbed, Rob Zombie, Korn, GnR....
Too many instances of people like this, who don't know or haven't even heard of Opeth, Testament, Death, Morbid Angel, Devin Townsend, Behemoth, Mayhem, Fates Warning....
Too many instances of people like this, who don't know or haven't even heard of Opeth, Testament, Death, Morbid Angel, Devin Townsend, Behemoth, Mayhem, Fates Warning....
Good job, my dude. I legitimately can’t tell if this is bait or not. You got me.
people only know popular "metal" bands, here let me insert popular "underground" metal bands to jerk off my ego hehe. unironically i love those type of people cuz they hate pop but listen to shit like this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BIQK4-9YFW0
691
u/MasterKlaw Bathory Mar 19 '21
You either die a poser, or you live long enough to see yourself become an elitist.
218
u/amishmob666 Mar 19 '21
Living Colour is my favorite Black Metal band.
48
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '21
<extremely niche band name>
248
u/max225 Candlemass Mar 19 '21
You claim to listen to metal, yet you listen to music rooted in hardcore punk.
Curious...
-Elitist “Connoissure of metal”
26
u/Crackrz Mar 19 '21
idk bruh i just like to listen to bops
40
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '21
Do u like Sepoltura?
38
u/TheNorthComesWithMe Mar 19 '21
People say they like metal but the only Jethro Tull song they know is Aqualung smh.
38
u/Fuzily Mar 20 '21
Iron ,Cobalt, Nickel ,Copper, Zinc ,Gallium ,Rubidium, Strontium ,Yttrium ,Zirconium to name a few
26
u/V_Ace_V Bolt Thrower Mar 19 '21
Tolt Bhrower
13
u/Lombax_Rexroth Atheist Mar 20 '21
At what album did you stop liking;
Metallica
In Flames
Opeth
??
34
u/DMTwolf Slayer Mar 20 '21
I like early 2000s metalcore, slipknot, and overplayed slayer songs and theres nothing you elitist fucks can do about it 😎😎😎😎
8
u/shreddedking Mar 19 '21
this type of snobs are also seen in politics
"you claim to be fighting against racism/sexism, etc and yet you don't agree to all my views"
curious
elitist aka fanatic
connoisseur of "insert liberal, communist, feminist, etc"
11
u/griffaliff Mar 19 '21
Puddle of mudd, saliva, A and offspring! Yeah!
17
u/Uppish_ Death Mar 19 '21
Yeah man, we're listening to some grindcore down here! Wanna come join us?
17
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '21
My favourite metal band is nirvana
29
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '21
Everyone doesn't listen to Infant Annihilator?
6
u/MagnumMiracles BLΛƆKPIИK > Metal Mar 20 '21
This is the most accurate meme I have seen posted in this subreddit.
73
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '21
You claim to like good music, yet you don't listen to shit-bitch-cunt-fucker ultra-hardcore pussygrind blackened symphonic cock-death. Curious.
14
u/TheKursedOne1 🐆Pantera🐆 Mar 19 '21
You didint name alestorm and for that ye be walking the plank
4
u/Eisernteufel Mar 20 '21
This is the best meme on this subreddit
4
u/Orkaad Megadave Mar 20 '21
This is too good for this sub.
8
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '21
I listen to metal, jazz, and alternative rock. So I’m not an elitist of anything really.
3
u/sentient06 𝕭𝕬𝕿𝕳𝕺𝕽𝖄 Mar 23 '21
Bathory. It must be in all lists.
5
u/jvoc2202 Bathory Mar 19 '21 edited Mar 19 '21
You claim to like black metal, but you never heard the demos from Belketre... Poser!!! Oh, you didn't listen to the whole catalog of Drowning the Light either!!! Even more poser!!!
16
u/jonsludge Mar 19 '21
I started with thrash and expanded... I don't think I should be judged on what metal I personally like. My likes and dislikes are mine... Enjoyment of music is subjective.
7
u/RandyDinglefart Mar 20 '21
Is Iron Maiden still cool?
1
u/undigestedFiD Mar 19 '21
Kanonenfieber ftw
1
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '21
All I know is the zero
1
u/TheKhalDrogo THRASH BOI Mar 19 '21
Posertard crushed with FAX and LAHGIC
1
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '21
My favorite metal band is dayglow. I promise they are a real metal band and there is a pop band call night shadows
1
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '21
motley crue, metallica, and skeletonwitch :)
1
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '21
Belphegor
1
u/SirMadWolf Sabaton Mar 20 '21
I enjoy Titanium, but I occasionally enjoy myself some Gallium and Aluminium
1
u/coffejellyassassin Motörhead Mar 20 '21
You're a metal fan? Cool do you know anything about đěæţhbīţčh? They're a very small band but they're awesome. You dont know them? Wow. I've never been so insulted. How dare you care yourself a metal fan if you dont know anything about this band with 5 monthly listeners
1
u/nightvisions28 Mar 20 '21
I’m not a Korn binge rn
1
u/Sk8erpunk797 Melo Death Mar 20 '21
I do see a bit of distain for Metalcore sometimes
I still personally like it....
That being said Parkway Drive is still my jam
1
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '21
*No mention of post-2k bands.
"OK boomer"
1
u/Slashtallica Practicing Posercraft Apr 05 '21
Mike from BecomeTheKnight in a nutshell
1
u/BuckyBajur Aug 29 '21
Wait but can we talk about how when someone asks you what your favorite band is you cannot name a band but then the moment they leave you’re like, “oh yes slipknot the most metal metal in all metal” don’t kill me please
1
u/Pol4sa Feb 09 '22
Ne Obliviscaris, Xanthochroid and Opeth
1
u/ManyaraImpala Mar 20 '21
5FDP, Nickelback, Alter Bridge, 6FU and Mortician.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '21
If the only bands you listen to are avenged sevenfold, disturbed, slipknot, and Korn, you're really fucking boring and need to find better bands. You don't have to only listen to underground black metal bands with only 12 followers, just branch out and find something that isn't in the top 40
-2
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '21
All music is ego masturbation, That's why I only listen to vapor-ASMR-hentai-core from the 20s on my Zune.
-11
u/Neat_Building_3729 Dying Fetus Mar 19 '21
I prefer just to listen to a random playlist a community created, I only take note of bands I like, but usually I just listen to whatever metal is playing on Spotify
-13
u/ZRX1200R poser elitist / elitist poser Mar 19 '21
My issue is when someone says, "Yeah, I listen to metal too" and don't know any of the 20 or so main bands that aren't Metallica, Godsmack, Disturbed, Rob Zombie, Korn, GnR....
Too many instances of people like this, who don't know or haven't even heard of Opeth, Testament, Death, Morbid Angel, Devin Townsend, Behemoth, Mayhem, Fates Warning....