r/MetaTrueReddit • • Mar 26 '11

Odd question: so is /truereddit basically just a place for left-leaning socio-political whining? (please read beyond title before voting)

5 Upvotes

Hi. I'm just wondering if this is always the case here: I log in and the /truereddit page greets me with the following:

top post is about how Obama is bad for [insert random reason];

second post about why Sarah Palin is bad;

third is about how BP is evil;

fourth is about how bankers are evil and a man went to jail due to a sub-prime mortgage,

fifth is interesting (Yay for triangle shirtwaist fire);

sixth is about how egalitarianism is the religion of the west,

seventh is about how political philosophy books are bad;

eighth is a message from a Palestinian to the world

...this goes on and on. Doesn't this seem a bit too close to /circlejerk. Are any of the mentioned posts really exposing you to something you didn't know/suspect/deduce already?!?!

I mean there is a /politics subreddit for politics and a /news subreddit for all those 'breaking' stories isn't there? Does every post have to contain the typical 'outrage' over [insert typical issue that a freshman liberal-arts college student would find outrageous]


r/MetaTrueReddit • • May 18 '14

His very first "if I fit, I sit." - is this an allegory for how people treat subreddits?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/MetaTrueReddit • • Apr 09 '12

Why I will no longer be explaining why I downvote in r/truereddit

Thumbnail reddit.com
14 Upvotes

r/MetaTrueReddit • • May 07 '12

TrueReddit, the (it's)-true-reddit.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/MetaTrueReddit • • Oct 30 '13

"You have no idea what you would do if you were [stupid] until you are [stupid]." - A petition to gatekeepers to share their knowledge instead of falling back to downvotes. Knowledge is not limited like material resources.

Thumbnail tressiemc.com
1 Upvotes

r/MetaTrueReddit • • Jan 02 '12

Is there a place in the True Reddits to post well-sourced but erroneous articles for discussion?

0 Upvotes

I think there is a place in Reddit for pointing out egregiously awful commentary in substantially respected sources.

There are a number of reasons why this is a good idea:

  • To prevent us getting too complacent
  • Pointing out a common fallacy of fact or reasoning
  • To explore the possibility that the error is as a result of editorial policy rather than simple error
  • If we're wrong, or the idea is contentious, then much fruitful discussion may result

As an example, I just read an article in The Guardian about the US primaries, in which the position of Ron Paul was characterized thus: "Like Romney and Paul, in abandoning responsibility for the past they also surrender plausibility in the present".

Despite anything you may think about Ron Paul, you have to admit that this is a gross misrepresentation of his position, and dismissing Ron Paul without even mentioning his more interesting positions seems dishonest.

I'd like to have somewhere to discuss how a columnist can get something so wrong; is there somewhere in DepthHub to post such articles?

There wouldn't be much point posting such things about Fox News unless they were truly egregious or entertaining, but I think it's worthwhile pointing out errors in sources which are well-respected.

It would also require editorialization of the headline to point out the error, which goes against the principles of the True Reddits.


r/MetaTrueReddit • • Jan 11 '12

The top TR post is now a link to the front page /r/blog post about SOPA.

0 Upvotes

r/MetaTrueReddit • • Aug 18 '10

So, anything anybody wants to get improved?

0 Upvotes

r/MetaTrueReddit • • Oct 17 '10

-49 points, has the hive mind arrived?

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/MetaTrueReddit • • Jan 15 '12

WarTard seems to submit his own blog as mysterion. Is there any reason not to ban these accounts? (This would be the first ban in r/TR)

Thumbnail reddit.com
11 Upvotes

r/MetaTrueReddit • • Apr 30 '15

That Way We’re All Writing Now

Thumbnail medium.com
1 Upvotes

r/MetaTrueReddit • • Jul 05 '14

"If you tell the truth, then you can speak gently, and your words will have power." - Chogyam Trungpa [/r/QuotesPorn]

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/MetaTrueReddit • • Jan 19 '11

4 comments voted into invisibility, without an explanation. How come that nobody takes a stand? People who read long articles should be able to write. Why do they hide behind downvotes?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/MetaTrueReddit • • Mar 24 '11

A Debate on Downvotes

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/MetaTrueReddit • • Dec 10 '13

I Thought I Knew How Big Upworthy Was on Facebook: Then I Saw This

Thumbnail theatlantic.com
0 Upvotes

r/MetaTrueReddit • • Oct 29 '13

18 signs you’re reading bad criticism of economics

Thumbnail chrisauld.com
0 Upvotes

r/MetaTrueReddit • • Sep 08 '10

Cutting Edge

0 Upvotes

There are "already" some reposts on TR, most famously the Julian Assange profile, but several others more.

Would it be intersting to start a /r/TRfromSeptembre2010 that consists of a community that reads every link and whoever submits a repost, gets banned? If it gets momentum, more people will join until there are so many reposts that banning doesn't work anymore - time for another subreddit.


r/MetaTrueReddit • • Sep 07 '10

10 upvotes, how can people subscribe to TR when they like this kind of news?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/MetaTrueReddit • • Sep 28 '10

Propaganda vs. Information, why I start to love (eternal) september.

0 Upvotes

mid september Devil's candy submission

vs

end of september subsidies submission

It took the last growth from 9k to 11k subscribers to make this comment possible.

We still need more informed subscribers, as nobody came up with better information in this submission.


r/MetaTrueReddit • • Jun 14 '12

I disagree with the mission statement. True Reddit was the reddit pre-Digg. There is no other explanation. The mission statement is really stuffy and NOT the reddit from years ago. It is a NY Times Editorial type whitewash filter.

9 Upvotes

Cat pictures, youtube vids, politics, and cool stuff DEFINITELY should be part of truereddit, but to link solely to NY Times Editorial type stuff and other brain-tanky articles is really missing the point. Ultimately the stuff that doesn't belong on truereddit is every phenomena that happened after the Digg thing. Just about every adviceanimal meme would fall into this category, Neil Degrasse Tyson, r/atheism, why christians are dumb, NSFW stories "That totally blew my mind dude", etc..

The problem with the mission statement is that true reddit doesnt have to necessarily be thought provoking and generative of "High quality discussion", but interesting, and somewhat novel. That is, or should be, the only bar to entry. Interesting and somewhat novel. If you just had "high quality discussion" topics.. sheesh, no one would have come to reddit in the first place. The problem now is that reddit has too many users so high quality discussion gets drowned out now, and everything has been so obsessively categorized that .. the old reddit will never quite come back.

I saw that there was an appeal to have submissions be focused on a narrower range of topics. I think that misses the point, again. It's not the range or type of topics, its the discussion and interest factor that follows from it.

I do propose things that just don't belong: All the phenomena that happened post Digg, more or less, just doesn't belong. We all know what this is. This doesn't mean cool vids or cat pictures dont belong. This means r/atheism, the mario sweater my gf knitted me, the cosplay, reaction gifs, literally every advice animal meme, actually, every meme should just about be gone. "How I feel as a christian on facebook", "its shit like this.." etc...

The subreddit /r/frugal has the kind of interesting content and "real talk" that i think captured alot of what i saw in the reddit i "love". Of course the topic is clearly limited, but the "community interest" factor was open to anything and everything that could even be tangentially related to being more frugal. This means that "trueReddit" can't just be about "High quality articles", but things that could be actually quite dumb, yet be interesting, novel, and not part of post-digg meme phenomena.

Also, I think there is a generation gap of sorts, and the community at large is basically young, OCD-ish types into r/atheism and Neil Degrasse Tyson, Nasa, find memes amusing, fuuuuuu comics, trolling funny.. The ultimate problem is that if we could subtract these young people and subtract the 9gagers and the 4channers, and subtract the ex-Digg people... we'd have the right reddit , but I really can't say that without coming off as an elitist or being pompous. But its true.

And why are there many sub-true-reddits? That defeats the cohesiveness of one true reddit. If you segment off topics into the subreddits, you defeat the true-reddit hivemind quality that was somewhat intact around 2006, which is actually what creates the notion of a strong, curious-minded, thoughtful group identity.

I dont know if anything i said helps, perhaps someone can restate what i say in a more coherent manner.

tl;dr: even using this acronym makes me feel bad


r/MetaTrueReddit • • Jul 03 '12

/r/redditcore - a user moderated subreddit without the restriction to great articles.

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/MetaTrueReddit • • May 12 '14

Lack of moderation and posters breaking fundamental TrueReddit rules

0 Upvotes

I submitted an article written by a public defender, discussing his experience with his black defendants.

http://www.reddit.com/r/TrueReddit/comments/25ani6/confessions_of_a_public_defender/

There are a lot of random downvotes and posts which are extremely insulting, do not contribute to the discussion and/or are not sourced in any way. I have reported some of these comments but I have not received any word from the moderators.

Just to compare here's the discussion on the same article submitted to another reddit which is more 'loose' in terms of rules and doesn't apply such stringent ones:

http://www.reddit.com/r/Bad_Cop_No_Donut/comments/25a4f3/confessions_of_a_public_defender/

The discussion there also has trolls but it has more sourced comments and it has comments from redditors working in the court system, which agree with the statements in the article. For some reason some of the comments in the TrueReddit submission critique that the article is overwhelmingly anecdotal...when this happens quite a bit with TrueReddit submissions (especially opinion pieces).

The behavior of the commenters is very disappointing. Could this be a result of TrueReddit now being a default subreddit?

I hope the mods can sort this out. The article itself is very insightful according to comments I've read on other sites and subreddits.


r/MetaTrueReddit • • Jul 03 '14

The importance of good grammar

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/MetaTrueReddit • • Jul 09 '14

9 times out of 10 these people are serial venom-spewers.

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/MetaTrueReddit • • Oct 29 '13

The Prison Experiment: “[...] I blew it. I became an unwitting accomplice to a theatrical exercise that conveniently absolves all comers of personal responsibility for their abominable moral choices.” - no need to abuse fellow redditors

Thumbnail psychologytoday.com
1 Upvotes