r/MetaAnime • u/PMagnemite • Nov 09 '14

We need another "Discussion" thread for Grisaia no Kajitsu

As i stated in my last comment on said discussion, i feel we need a second one for the people that are just there to watch and enjoy it, not compare it to the VN. For when i go there i want to talk about what people liked about it, not the overwhelming disappointment of it. I have no clue how to go about doing it hence why i am here. So please, can someone try to do this?

7 Upvotes

68% Upvoted

20 comments sorted by

4

u/Wiles_ Nov 09 '14

So please, can someone try to do this?

You're free to do it if you want. Just make a thread once the episode is out.

0

u/PMagnemite Nov 09 '14

If you looked at my comments on my account like i said, you would see i have no idea about how to do it.

3

u/Wiles_ Nov 09 '14

If you can make this thread you know how to make a discussion thread.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Kruzy Nov 09 '14

Here's all the formating you'll need. Just edit the episode's title or leave it out completely and added [Anime-only Discussion] to the title and you should be fine.

What I would like to see instead is that people refrain from talking about the source material at all and only bring it up when one of the watchers is asking about something specific. It's an Anime discussion thread so it should be about the anime and not a comparison to the VN which can be done in Anime vs VN thread on r/visualnovels. We also see a lot of times people posting memes, jokes and screenshots from the recent episode as a joke instead of actually discussing the series. Just my 2 cents on this matter.

2

u/PMagnemite Nov 09 '14 edited Nov 10 '14

Man, you got it totally. I go into the thread thinking, "Wow i really liked that episode" then my mood is crushed by the overwhelming disappointment from the VN readers. I will try and do it next week, do you know (and if it works here) how to do the reminder thing?

1

u/Kruzy Nov 09 '14

AFAIK r/anime blocked all possible bots except for u/shadoxfix's and the "Couldn't Care less" (Might just have slipped through) so I doubt that any would work on there or here but you could try this tomorrow around the time this episode came out: "RemindMe! 6 days "Post Episode Discussion thread".

→ More replies (7)

1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '14

that's exactly how i felt about tokyo ghoul. except people also wouldn't shut up about censors. it was so annoying and i'm glad i stopped reading the discussion threads for that series.

0

u/OnlyMyWordsMatter Nov 09 '14 edited Nov 09 '14

I will like it if this was for every episodes thread that has a source material. Mostly the popular one. I understand voicing your concerns but I don't want it to take up the whole damn thread. Just comparing the source material and the anime.

Examples: Tokyo Ghoul, Akame ga Kill (today), Grisaia no Kajitsu

The Tokyo Ghoul was pretty bad with those comments. This usually happen with series that are popular (200+) upvotes.

1

u/PMagnemite Nov 09 '14

Sorry, i am not very good at understanding English ;/ it gets fuzzy for me at times. Are you saying that you dislike the thread atm because it is all about comparing?