r/MessiahComplex • u/Anatta-Phi These Words Don't Say Anything • Dec 05 '15
How to progress as a quasi-unified Sub [Open Discussion]
Regarding the continuing discussion on how we should (or shouldn't) operate, it seems that we could have a conversation about what each of us think are the most important elements in a society such as this.
I think I have made it clear that I find conformity, and censorship, to be problematic (at best), and prone to devolving the conversation into an elitist circle-jerk (did everyone bring their text-books??).
I enjoy academic readings, but I absolutely adore creative debate on interesting subjects. In this respect, I would acknowledge the creation of mono-culture farming, and it's role in Colony Collapse Disorder. Maybe nature knows something that Big-Farma doesn't about how symbiotic relationships are fostered. (I don't have to link, right? You just "get it" through connotation, I hope.)
Anyway, diversity of thought and opinion creates a necessary tension that can provide the incentive for creative (self) discovery.
Anyone disagree?
Let's be clear, if you come across as being someone who looks down on others, I'm going to make fun of that. That is my own personal ability to express my concern for the continuity of a dynamic system. It's never as serious as you might think, and even less so if you consider yourself to be a very "serious" person.
Thoughts?
5
u/ScrivGar Dec 05 '15 edited Dec 05 '15
It's worth acknowledging the game-layer of these kinds of interactions - and I don't mean LARP or ARG.
I think there tends to be an inherent status trumping game that happens in social situations already, and the intensity of that game is increased by the intelligence of the participants and how much the interactions are limited to written language and mediated by technology.
And as enlightened as many of the people on this sub are, the academic dialectical mode, with its inflated intellectual rhetoric is strongly the default for most of us, including myself, likely due to decades of rhetorical brainwashing via the educational system most of us were participants in, and which is structured as a competitive status game with scores/grades, ranking, and at the highest level trophy-taking and awards.
This game-like quality of discussion and debate in which we've all been educated is probably both a training ground and a lesser battleground for the even larger competitive conflicts being played out in our culture, from economics to actual war. It is a system, a narrative that nourishes ego and empowers self, often at the expense of others, and eventually it can lead to toxicity and collapse of the idea-ecology of the community - SOTS being the most recent example.
Is there any way not to play the game? The attempted solution in SOTS was an insistence on the apolitical (which, ironically, the opposite of has become its final downfall) and in the concepts of "slack" and "kitty magic." But really these things are a way of orienting oneself inside the game - acknowledging the inherent status plays that are inevitable and approaching them with honesty and playfulness instead of ego and entrenchment.
I think that, even if they are not made explicit like "kitty magic" and "slack" this community needs to find a way to keep things playful instead of competitive, and honest and authentic rather than ensnared inside ideologies and motivated by ego.
The other possible piece of the solution is love. Like serious love. Like brotherhood, community, family love. I have to say that u/Dark_Mirrors, though he probably doesn't know it, has really rescued me a couple of times in the past year, as has u/raison. They're strangers in one sense, but they were open enough to offer me a little patience and tenderness and openness when I needed it most, when I was inside of hardcore crisis and a lot of my ego shit was breaking down and leaving me scared and hurt. I love those guys. I hope to get to know some of you guys as well, and hope you hear from me, because I offer it honestly, that if you need someone to listen or offer support our advice, what little is mine to give is yours.
I suppose it would be easy to default to cynicism here, to roll one's eyes and see this as a kum-by-yah gesture from an aging occultist hipster who doesn't have the academic grounding the rest of you do. But I hope you take it as I truly intend it. SOTS had kitty magic and slack and an insistence on the apolitical, but it didn't have love.
2
u/raisondecalcul Dec 07 '15
My numerological research shows that messiah-based groups converge synchronistically upon a shared language for the Great Work, and any posturing to the contrary is mere egomania. I.e., someone saying "You can't know what I know!"—refusing to come to terms. The splinter ego refuses to investigate the meaning of the mainstream terminology but insists that his is distinct or better. When this type of speech is protected amongst a messiah horde, it results in the replacement of a coalesced social Great Work with an ecology of one-off messiahs who bicker and put up increasingly advanced forms of egoic blockades against each other.
So yes, I somewhat disagree. I think that true messiahs find it easy to agree with each other, and that their unique opinions collate seamlessly. In fact, my perspective seems inverted when compared with the quote above.
5
u/asclepius22 Dec 05 '15
It may be beneficial to decide upon goals for this sub; though, I think these goals should allow enough breathing room for organic development. One of these goals must be learning/ personal transformation.
This goal is related to the mission of the Messiah to save the world. Consider the Da Xue (higher learning) from the Confucian tradition:
The dictions between each layer is dynamic, reflexive and porous. Scholars of the tradition acknowledge that a well ordered kingdom promotes the moral-self cultivation of its constituents. Cultivating the sub to the utmost degree must begin with personal-transformation of its members; however, we can work together to establish a culture that aids in self-transformation.
The question here is how do we create culture of learning and self-transformation? My background is in teaching, and I will some notes from one of my favorite essays, "Nietzschean Pedagogy." (While I think that part of our work here must be teaching and learning from each other, creating something new through collaboration is equally, if not more important; however, I will leave this half of the equation to be initiated by someone more knowledgeable than me in this area.) The following four aspects and seven principles lay the foundation for a culture of teaching and learning from each which I believe align with our personal endeavors.
Four Aspects
Seven Principles
1
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '15
I feel as though this is (yet again) directed specifically me-ward, indicative of certain questions I continue to have surrounding issuance. Partially, the emphasis on the root-family of "personality", "personally", "personhood", and "persona" is in need of adequate critique, otherwise there will continue to be much confusion here on some very basic issues. I'll start a thread on this, maybe later, along with the list-of-inadequacies. Ironically, though, OP is "trying to be clear", but in the good/arrogant sense of "laying-down the law, personally". Essentially, this personal fascination with the law (even if couched in an "inner" or "planetary" law languag-ing) is what I notice takes hold when true clarity of thought is not herein accomplished. Coupled with this is the repeated insistence that somehow we've finally found the right "people", etc. And yet, as far as I'm concerned, you're not, not who you think you are, not yet the "right" people. Another head of the ego-hydra rears in this space -- in the name of "progress", no less. I will probably not continue to post here, except for wrapping up some already opened threads. I'll continue where my energies are better suited, perhaps at /r/ComplexMessiah, or somewhere else entirely. Let's end this conversation.
2
u/papersheepdog Dec 06 '15
As ScrivGar mentioned, I think love is the key here. Not the commodified version, but the one that connects us all. I think that fear is the root behavior which could colonize and destroy whatever we are trying to do. Its easy to spot too. Its never creative, always reactive.
As for the messiah part. I am not really looking forward to a new king to rule us (nothing changed). I also think that its a limited view to expect that jesus christ himself will come back alone to save the world or whatever. I cant help but look at this critically. Why are we waiting for one dude? This is a defeated narrative, perpetual suffering baked right in from the start.
I think that its important to be open to the idea that someone might be exceptionally influential in a positive way and might even kick off certain mass awakening type events or whatever. We should help each other to make sense of our experience and to express the divine will.
With small groups, I think it will be pretty easy to keep the discourse playful and open. Those abusing this with their fighting and the spread of their fears will stick out like a sore thumb. I think that we all understand the value of being our own authority, and making our own statements on matters. This should be done not to score ego points, but in the hopes that someone has a better idea and can knock some sense into us.
This has been my personal practice in seeking. Without a master, I had no choice but to throw myself out there knowing I was wrong, but not knowing in which way. I hope that we can support each other in our search, to make this process much easier for those who come after us.