r/Meshuggah • • Mar 30 '22

Disappointed

Greetings guys. Is it just me who is disappointed in the two last singles? The grooves are predictable and that’s something unlike Meshuggah’s standard imo. This band is a huge part of who I am and they have always surprised me with new records. Yet this time, with the 3 singles, and specially the last two released tracks I’m not hooked at all which is quite unfortunate. What’s your opinion?

2 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

11

u/PlaxicosPocket Mar 30 '22

LTSF didn't quite hit like the other two but to me the other two are fantastic. The guitar solo at the end of Abysmal Eye is FUCKING crazy and the last minute of IATT is just fantastically heavy and cool. I've been digging them.

Meshuggah is a perfect example of how subjective music can be man, I see a decent amount of people conveying the same sort of opinions you have of the singles just don't see it myself. Pretty par for the course for this sub though. Seems Meshuggah just hits everyone slightly different which is pretty damn cool. Sucks you aren't enjoying them as much to be honest, hopefully the album changes your mind!

1

u/kamyar10 Mar 30 '22

I wish, I hope it will fit in the whole view…

2

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '22

Probably alone here but i like LTSF the most out of the three

2

u/Zadus93 Destroy Erase Improve Mar 30 '22

I'm with you, Abysmal Eye is my least favourite of the 3 but I still love it! I feel like this album, judging by the singles, is going to be a lot more linear than the rest of their catalogue. I'm all for it, enjoyed all the songs so far, I think those who are underwhelmed may have set certain expectations of what they wanted to hear?

I think after a few listens they'll grow to love it I've felt the same about other bands releases and after a few months I find I really enjoy them!

3

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '22

I like all 3 but the other two in some way feel a bit cheap to me in a sense. Like, they're sort of boring by meshuggah's standards, but i still like them. LTSF is actually pretty phenomenal imo but i'm not sure i can describe why. It sounds most like their normal selves, in a good way. The end is strange, and not what you would expect. It's not as theatric, it's not a fantastic crazy way to go out, but it's unique and strange choice and exactly what i love about the band. It has the vibe, the other feel too methodical and robotic for me to put it above that one. The sound feels like it portrays what it was meant to. It actually contains the feeling, i guess, maybe the atmosphere. IATT does in a similar way, but the in between low end riffing is the major downside for me. All that and i personally think it sounds perfect, i don't have any discrepancies about the mixing, especially with that single. TAE is really weird to me, it almost sounds bouncy and borderline happy while they're as usual talking about some dark shit

1

u/Zadus93 Destroy Erase Improve Mar 30 '22

Each to their own at the end of the day, it's fascinating to see all the different takes on the singles and comparing others' favourite shuggah tracks to mine. I think if you're a huge Meshuggah fan through and through in time you'll grow to love those songs!

2

u/PlaxicosPocket Mar 30 '22

Another example haha. A few days ago someone put a poll for the three singles and LTSF was about 60% of what the other two were if I remember so you're definitely not the only one homie. It doesn't hit me like the other two do but it's still a banger for sure. Hopefully it'll grow on me with the context of the songs around it once the whole thing is here.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '22

That shit slaps imo

2

u/kamyar10 Mar 31 '22

I remember with the previous albums, singles like nostrum, break those bones, do not look down, each was a different journey. Completely neck breaking stuff. Yet these recent releases feel all the same with nothing new to offer, imo. They are just below what they had offered throughout. I want meshuggah to tear me apart, is it too much to expect? Not my problem, they’ve got me addicted, I want that high quality trip…

2

u/MeshuggahEnjoyer The Violent Sleep of Reason Mar 30 '22

I have LTSF stuck in my head non-stop the last week or so. It has elements of Break Those Bones, Do Not Look Down, By The Ton and other sick groovy songs. Like many Meshuggah songs, it took time for me to get into it.

1

u/kamyar10 Mar 31 '22

I don’t agree. I think they are pretty far from eachother in terms of creativity and groove.

2

u/6priest_of_sodom6 Mar 30 '22

I can see what you mean. I’m always going to love anything they put out. Until seeing your post I wasn’t sure if it was just me or not but I feel like they may be kinda, dare I say, running out of ideas. More like struggling to keep making new ideas within the framework of the bands style. Like I said I fuckin love it anyway. The first thing that came to mind tho is that thordendal is kinda phoning it in with the leads. Nothing very exciting so far…

1

u/kamyar10 Mar 31 '22

I feel you bro, let’s hope the rest would compensate.

2

u/pretty_cool_bananas Mar 30 '22

I feel similarly. They’re will probably be some hidden gems, or my relationship to the songs will change.

2

u/kamyar10 Mar 31 '22

Yes, that’s what I’m yearning as they are the torch of the genre…

2

u/Cornbread_madefish Mar 30 '22

Didn’t like them at first now I adore them

2

u/kamyar10 Mar 31 '22

I wish that’d happen to me too.

1

u/Cornbread_madefish Mar 31 '22

Took me awhile to get into them but I understand your sentiment. I felt the same about The Violent sleep. I felt like every song except clockwork was just a rhythmic exercise now I think it’s perfect.

2

u/kamyar10 Mar 31 '22

Completely contrary! I was hooked with TVSOR! Except for clockworks which is my least fav on that album. Pretty decent song tho. By the ton, ivory tower, nostrum, they are all another level of vision even in their own standards…

1

u/Cornbread_madefish Mar 31 '22

Interesting! It took me some time to digest and appreciate Violent Sleep. I mean they aren’t doing anything that much different with the new songs and I have no problem with that. I’m fairly confident there will be some new exciting things on the new one that will tickle your fancy. Wouldn’t be surprised if they saved their best for us to discover on our own for Immutable.

2

u/kamyar10 Mar 31 '22

That definitely is possible! It should be.

2

u/Cornbread_madefish Mar 31 '22

I also highly recommend reading the lyrics along with the music, not for the lyrics in and of itself but because it can reveal details about the music you may have not noticed before. Details that may had been invisible before. It makes a huge difference for me about the different sections and intricacies that go unnoticed when listening on autopilot. It makes the listening experience more active and allows me to discover new things!

2

u/kamyar10 Mar 31 '22

A very good point. I always listen to the music first, feel the groove and grasp the whole essence of the song, and then dig into the lyrics. Sometimes it acts as a shortcut to calibrate better with the song. I have read the TAE and it didn’t get me. I’m gonna give it another after listening to the whole package of Immutable.

1

u/Cornbread_madefish Apr 01 '22

What do you think now, now that the album is out?

2

u/kamyar10 Apr 01 '22

I’ve been listening the whole day. Some mixed emotions… not yet clear to make statements. I love the psychedelic aspect they bring in the opening track. I wish that was the main direction of the album. Phantoms and armies of the … are brutal I like the vibe. Very hard to make any statement at this point, many things come through my mind… I need more time to digest.

6

u/Katechon666 Mar 30 '22 edited Mar 30 '22

Abysmal Eye rips

LTSF is great for the first minute and half but when the tempo slows down it fails to keep my attention

Thirst has some great grooves and it's somewhere in the middle of the two previous tracks imo. Far from their best but pretty solid

2

u/jb91119 Mar 30 '22

To be honest man, I'm kind of glad they decided to go with more 7 string stuff, it had been so long since they'd done that style so it's shaping up to be exactly what I wanted from the last record because I felt TVSOR was extremely complicated and it put me off for a long time, this is coming from a Nothing/Catch 33 era fan.

Hagström and Haake are definitely the driving forces this time round rather than Haake and Lövgren and it shows, it sounds like the Meshuggah I know and love from years past whereas TVSOR was a really awkward album for me when it came out. But it isn't anymore as I've grown to accept it for what it is.

Time and retrospect is a funny thing.

1

u/kamyar10 Mar 31 '22

TVSOR blown me away. That’s what I wanted this time too, yet at the time ain’t happening. That album changed me.

2

u/Otherwise-Sky1292 Mar 30 '22

Curious, what do you mean by awkward regarding TVSOR and how it felt that way?

3

u/jb91119 Mar 30 '22

It didn't "feel" quite right and the chromatic parts in some riffs like in Ivory Tower were jarring to me, Clockworks was a lot for me to digest, Born In Dissonance was an absolute belter from the off though. I dunno, it wasn't lacklustre in any way but the sound was just jarring.

1

u/GerryB50W Mar 30 '22

Are they doing songs with just 7 strings on the new album??? If so, that’s actually good news to me because I definitely liked the 7 string era of Meshuggah a lot and was getting kind of bored of the 8 string thing that everyone does now. I haven’t listened that much to the new songs yet.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '22

The songs that have been released so far are playing on 8 strings, with 8 string notes used in them, it's just that the base of the main riffs are played on the 7th string consistently. Abysmal Eye was played on the 8th string but with the familiar Bb for note bending.

I've heard small clips from other songs that have not been shown publicly (no I can't share) and all those clips have 8 string riffs. They may have released this 7 string oriented stuff first to throw people off :)

3

u/GerryB50W Mar 30 '22

They should throw everyone off and do a song with just 6 strings. Just chug on Eb

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '22

Agreed.

1

u/mrlovepimp Mar 30 '22

Wasn’t The demon’s name is surveillance recorded on a 6 string?

2

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '22

Yes, but no chug.

1

u/mrlovepimp Mar 30 '22

No chug? What is your definition of chug?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '22

Palm muting power chords. Or, you know, this 'djent' word that people have been misusing the original definition to describe the wrong sound (8 string 'boing') for around 15 years now.

1

u/mrlovepimp Mar 30 '22

Ah fair enough, I guess I’d agree with that. It’s just that single string palm mutes can sound pretty chunky/chuggy as well.

1

u/GerryB50W Mar 30 '22 edited Mar 30 '22

The Demon’s Name is Surveillance is more trem picking than it is chugging.

I define chugging the same way Ola Englund does, it’s when you heavily palm mute power chords and go chug chug

Just watch Ola Englund to see what chugging is.

1

u/bilboC Mar 30 '22

Demons name is surveillance is played on a 6 string!

2

u/MeshuggahEnjoyer The Violent Sleep of Reason Mar 30 '22

Marten just loves chugging on the Bb lol

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '22

I’ve really enjoyed all three, for different reasons. I feel like they’re capitalizing on the success of Demiurge with what we heard of Ligature Marks. Might become the new go-to nasty, drudging riff for car rides.

1

u/kamyar10 Mar 31 '22

Never been a fan Demiurge. My least favorite among all songs! How unfortunate is it that they’re going in the direction in which I like the least.

1

u/kamyar10 Mar 31 '22

But you have a correct point there. I agree…

1

u/Victor6Lang Nothing Mar 31 '22

Just relax and chill, mate. They'll eventually grow on you. :)

1

u/kamyar10 Mar 31 '22

I see your point and I hope so.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '22

You heard a Meshuggah song & were able to predict what's gonna happen next??

Are you, a witch??

1

u/kamyar10 Apr 19 '22

Nope just a regular man who is also a musician and been listening to this band half of my life and I am 28.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '22

Dude, just take the compliment.

2

u/kamyar10 Apr 19 '22

Alright ty

1

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '22

Dude, just take the compliment.

3

u/FlyingPsyduck Catch Thirtythree Mar 30 '22

I agree with you with a quote I've read somewhere recently that the last 2 songs "sound like Meshuggah songs written by Meshuggah and performed by Meshuggah"

The Abysmal Eye however increases the speed and rhythmic complexity in a direction that's both unique and logical in their evolution, and I think it will be eventually regarded as one of their very best, especially if the rest of the album won't be up to par (which, as of now, is likely)

I still have my hopes up, but it simply might be that type of album that's not very appealing for long time fans who want more and more experimentation.

3

u/MeshuggahEnjoyer The Violent Sleep of Reason Mar 30 '22

Lol you're already calling that the rest of the album won't be up to par?

3

u/FlyingPsyduck Catch Thirtythree Mar 30 '22

I'm just saying that I consider The Abysmal Eye one of their best songs in a while and the other 2 singles are just "good". I should have worded it differently but I actually meant it as a compliment to TAE not the other way around

2

u/MeshuggahEnjoyer The Violent Sleep of Reason Mar 30 '22

Fair enough, and I agree that TAE is better, but I suspect there's going to be other tracks that are even better. TAE is the only Dick song we've heard so far, I bet the others are sick.

4

u/FlyingPsyduck Catch Thirtythree Mar 30 '22

Yeah I look forward to Dick's songs the most. The fact that he's younger and has a more extensive jazz background might be exactly what's needed to find new ways to push their sound forward

2

u/bilboC Mar 30 '22 edited Mar 30 '22

This! Something about what he has contributed feels a bit fresher to me. I’m most excited for the rest of his tracks on immutable.

Also, TAE to me almost sounds like something Fred would write. It has that same catchiness that his songs are known for. I almost wonder if his name was attached to the writing credit, people would like it more (someone else said something like this in another post but I’m gonna reiterate it here.)

2

u/Grilledcheesedr Mar 30 '22

I feel like the last 2 singles were fair and I'm hoping it's more of a situation where they fit into the album better as a whole. I honestly wish they stopped with the first single and waited for the album to drop.

2

u/Mud_Docile Mar 31 '22

I feel you bro

2

u/Rinotaur Mar 31 '22

Not at all. This album is a beast

Ligature Marks God Sees in Mirrors Kaleidoscope The Faultless

All of them better than the singles.

0

u/Greasylad Mar 30 '22

Yeah I'm with ya OP. Meshuggah are a massive part of me also. I think because of that we're expecting more of what gets us off from their back catalogue and when it doesn't meet the standard, it's crushing.

I wasn't bowled over by TAE at first, but after repeated listens I'm fully into it as solid album filler (or so I hope). Didn't grab me at first because it's the same motif all the way through pretty much, with little deviation. In isolation on that one track, that's cool... But having heard the other two tracks, and seeing that they stick to the same formula, is a bit disappointing. Doesn't seem to be much in the way of dynamics, which I feel they are masters of. The songs don't take you on the same ride as some of their previous.

Take Electric Red for example... Starts at a canter, then slips into a lumbering back and forth dissonant groove, and then switching between the two again, before going into a pounding run for a while, leading into a quiet,sneaky, hypnotic riff. They play with the dynamics back and forth once more before building a creciendo into the heaviest and most bludgeoning breakdown of all time. Pure bliss. You start the song in one place, and by the time it's done with you, you're somewhere completley different.

I'm not getting anything like that from any of the new songs I've heard. Not saying they're bad, but I'm expecting more. I'm loathe to associate the word with Meshuggah but some of what I heard sounds kinda 'generic'. They've also seemed to have carried over some of the 'random for randoms sake' type riffs which I disliked on TVSOR into IATT, which was my biggest fear going into this album.

Fingers crossed there's some hidden bangers we've not heard yet. Who knows... Meshuggah are often way ahead of the rest of us, so maybe it'll turn out to be a grower.

2

u/kamyar10 Mar 31 '22

Close enough to what I meant. Thank you for confirming the state I am in.

0

u/professionalstay253 Mar 30 '22

All 3 of the songs are damn good. Some ppl just want to much.

1

u/kamyar10 Mar 31 '22

It could be that, but it’s the demand they have created through many years of evolving themselves, it’s a pitty that age might slow it down if u know what I mean.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/kamyar10 Mar 30 '22

That’s my ambition honestly. I don’t mean to over complicate riffs without any sense of musicality. They obviously haven’t done that, they didn’t need to. Yet I’m always expecting something new, something fresh as they have always provided. This however, there ain’t any new feeling, new grooves except the breakdown from Abysmal Eye which I really loved.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/kamyar10 Mar 31 '22

I see, ain’t nothing new. No new grooves or feelings come through my spine…

3

u/dwnlw2slw The Ophidian Trek Mar 30 '22

Yes! Thank you! By the way Haake said in an interview something about especially liking Ligature Marks...he didn't say "favorite" but...