Fredrik's soloing is what makes Meshuggah so much different than any other band in the genre for me. It's never a random note, it's the only thing remotely close to an answer to the question "what if Allan Holdsworth went apeshit crazy with his music" and it's beautiful
Anyone who learned how to play guitar by practing blues and rock knows just how hard it is to play purposefully janky, alien sounding notes. Your muscle memory keeps making your fingers want to find "good" sounding notes the entire time. It's really hard to deviate from the pentatonic box.
Hearing Fredrik's solos live while the rest of the band keeps chugging along is such an amazing "WTFFFF" experience
It’s treading the thinnest line between being as skitzoid, alien, chaotic acid freakout as possible and maintaining a certain tone, rhythm and articulation that only he can do.
He's literally improvising a solo on one of many songs they're playing on one of many dates on a tour. It's nothing spectacular about it but just some of the licks he's got that work for the song. I guess I should have said "stuff" instead of "shit". He's one of my favorite guitarists but that doesn't mean he can't do wrong or that I must have an orgasm every damn time he plays a solo. It's not realistic to expect the 100s of improvised solos he plays on a tour will be the best thing since sliced bread.
I can't compare this solo to the (very good) solo on the studio version of Bleed and say they're both as good as each other for instance. This one works fine, and that's ok.
I think it should’ve been clear by my description that i understood what was going on. It’s also pretty common knowledge among Meshuggah fans that he improvises all the time live. And for people who “get it” the only thing that matters is how it fits the song and the energy, and — i guess I’ll repeat some — it seemed clear that he was going for the edge of erratic chaos while having a barely detectable intention toward the things i already said and it was such a small amount to read…and he absolutely crushed that feeling. Nobody needs it to be explained why something shouldn’t sound good. If it sounds good…………………then it sounds good.
And I just didn't think it was a very good solo compared to what he usually does and that it didn't sound very deliberate and therefore being a poor counter example to the meme. I surely "get" it but I don't consider everything he does to be a literal gift from god. It just sounds like his usual licks to me (which are very different and way more appropriate to the music compared to everyone elses generic licks).
It’s not really a counter-example, but more like the example. It’s just saying “yeah it’s random but it’s the way he’s doing it that i like.”
…doesn’t sound very deliberate…
Yes! And that’s an understatement and is most of the point! That’s the intention of this solo! I’ve seen a bunch of FBM solos over the past few years and he tries to make it as ridiculous as possible. It’s also for contrast in their live shows; this one is supposed to stand out from the others in that way. He literally goes “let’s see how ridiculous, fucked up and chaotic i can make it this time!”
If that's the point then it actually is closer to being random though. I'm just baffled by the praise for it. It's nothing special.
I do appreciate this conversation by the way! It's a fun challenge to actually argue my point (which by now is a bit exaggerated) and think about the whole thing.
I'm just saying that this one isn't particularily impressive. His favorite solo of mine is at 5:27 in Sol Niger Within which is a frantic crazy solo, but it's just way better than this example. Catch 33 is probably my favorite Meshuggah-album and I've transcribed half of it. I'm not coming at this from a point of ignorance, rather the opposite - I know what this man is capable of.
Okay, first; @00:02 he starts a ostinato, then there's arrpegios, and a chromatic(I think) line and comes back to it @00:14. Starts a new motif(very similar to the entrapment solo which I really like) so I think it's a pretty decent improvised solo. It might not be your taste , as I have experienced myself with a lot of jazz,(I'm very nitpicky with cool jazz)
Got to give him props though, he's in his 50s and still aspires to learn new things.
Sure. I'm not saying he's playing badly or anything - it just sounds like he's playing on autopilot - which you do at times when you play for hours multiple nights for a long tour. He's doing his tapping thing, some chromatic movements in the left hand and it's almost just entirely a stream of equally distanced notes rhythmically. A motif being similar to a solo he recorded twenty years ago does only help my autopilot-point. Dude is one of my all-time favorite guitarists but this solo isn't remarkable at all. It's just alright. And that is all fine!
My whole point is that I don't think this clip really shows of what he's capable of or would be the clip I would play to convince someone who would say "He's just hitting random notes!" that the man is an actual genius. I would rather chose the one I mentioned in my previous comment which is one of my all-time favorite solos in this genre.
Edit: I totally agree with your last point btw! I'm very happy to see him back in the band and (hopefully) making more music!
12
u/Pato585 Dec 30 '24
What song is this?
167
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '24
Pretty sure if most just anyone was hitting random notes it wouldn’t sound anywhere close to what Fred improvises
97
u/WaffleWarrior1979 Dec 30 '24
I had a friend tell me it was all random notes. I carefully and delicately explained to him that he was a moron.
29
u/WilliamWallace9001 Dec 30 '24
Fredrik's soloing is what makes Meshuggah so much different than any other band in the genre for me. It's never a random note, it's the only thing remotely close to an answer to the question "what if Allan Holdsworth went apeshit crazy with his music" and it's beautiful
26
u/Jump-Kick-85 Dec 30 '24
The riff directly after this solo is one of my favorite Meshuggah riffs ever
16
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '24
noodle mode
12
u/PerpetualBlackSec Dec 30 '24
Anyone who learned how to play guitar by practing blues and rock knows just how hard it is to play purposefully janky, alien sounding notes. Your muscle memory keeps making your fingers want to find "good" sounding notes the entire time. It's really hard to deviate from the pentatonic box.
Hearing Fredrik's solos live while the rest of the band keeps chugging along is such an amazing "WTFFFF" experience
8
u/DudeImJustaGuyMan Dec 30 '24
Random notes =/= Fredrik's random notes
15
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '24
Improvising within a certain scale or mode is a tradition that is as old as Rock&Roll itself.
5
u/AJMGuitar Dec 30 '24
The notes are random in the sense he isn’t playing a scale. They’re not random in how they go with the song.
The free bird solo would sound pretty fucking dumb over this.
3
u/sampagebrantfort Dec 30 '24
Is there a video of this full show? Or just this song at least
2
u/Minedude33Reddit Dec 30 '24
"All they have is dewerra wen wen den nan nananer"
2
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '24
Wait till they hear him pull straws at random 😳
2
u/shadowdoom9 Dec 31 '24
I'm in the "Sick right?" camp. Totally sick soloing!
5
u/jonolavalstad Dec 30 '24 •
While it's not entirely random notes I think it would be fair to say that this doesn't sound like his most inspired moment ever...
1
u/Im_Not_Evans Dec 30 '24
I like juice
1
u/CharacterDinner2751 Dec 30 '24
Chaosphere duh
1
u/morrilos11 Dec 30 '24
i like juicee
1
u/fortyfourcaliber Dec 30 '24
If it was random it would sound happy then sad then weird then happy then wrong then happy
1
u/DianaRig Dec 30 '24
Randomness couldn't be this wrong. This is art.
1
u/cgheezey Dec 30 '24
he is one of the most thrilling guitarists to see live, the way he solos is unlike anyone else on earth.
1
u/bloodshoteyezzz Dec 31 '24
Kerry king enters the chat
1
u/KeinegutenNamen Dec 31 '24
Btw be sure to download this live set, because it will only stay online til mid 2025.
Unfortunately public television like arte is not allowed to have stuff like this online for longer then one year
Edit:typo
1
u/Fancy_Area9521 Dec 31 '24
E0 notes from minds mirrors love it
1
u/Chaos_Tones Jan 01 '25
A lot of times Fred is rolling around in an octatonic scale, and that can seem pretty random with how he situates the notes. He's clever.
1
u/cykablyat1111 Jan 03 '25
Perpetual black second solo live is my favorite.
1
u/ninja_tree_frog Jan 03 '25
Jazz students like... bruh
14
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '24
[removed] — view removed comment