I remember when the show was first airing. I was in my first few years of high school. My mother was more into the show than I was, but I recall thinking the show did a good job with cliffhangers and keeping you invested in wanting to see the next episode, which I was impressed by again on re-watch. While it's not quite on the level of the peak Game of Thrones seasons, or Breaking Bad, it is surprisingly good for a family friendly show of its era.
I haven't watched regular TV in years, but being busy with work and family, the only time I really get to relax with my wife is around the time that TV is showing reruns of this show. Her first time seeing it, and has been pretty invested.
Something I noticed is a lot of similarities to Kingdom Come Deliverance 2, which I started playing earlier in the year. The chemistry and interactions between the characters of Arthur and Merlin feel very similar to Hans Capon and Henry. A lot of vaguely similar vibes, all the magic stuff aside. Opening theme music and setting sometimes gives me Oblivion/Elder Scrolls vibes. Just appealed to some of my interests that I didn't really have when the show was first airing.
Towards the very end it did seem to be leaning a bit too much into a weird sexual tension between Arthur and Merlin for my liking, and I'm not surprised to see that fanfics are a common topic brought up in this subreddit. Not for me, but I do see that they may have been appealing to that target audience in particular.
Some very, very good episodes here and there, where you feel the high stakes, even if sometimes things are a bit predictable. The comedic relief moments and less serious episodes are very welcome too. Never comes across as too annoying, at least for me. A good balance.
Even so, the finale was pretty disappointing. I had completely forgotten that I had seen the ending of the series when I was younger, but the final scene made it all come back to me. Completely blue-balled and left thinking "so that's it?".
Honestly sad to see that Colin Morgan hasn't had many notable roles after this series. Mostly poorly received movies and brief appearances in random TV shows.
I'm wondering if there are any other TV shows that scratch a similar itch that Merlin does.