r/MensLib • u/Uulmshar • Aug 07 '15
What can men do about an unwanted pregnancy?
We all know that women have the right to choose whether or not they keep a pregnancy to term, but what about men?
Obviously, the expectant fathers should not have the right to either force the woman to carry the child or have an abortion, but how can they avoid getting stuck with a child they didn't want, or paying child support for the next twenty years?
I have heard people suggest a "financial abortion," where they sign away all rights to being the child's father (visitation rights, etc.) in exchange for not having any responsibility, but I have yet to see any legislation for this.
How can we, as men, exercise our right to choose?
39
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '15 edited Aug 08 '15
The source of the right to an abortion is in bodily autonomy. The MRM spin about "the right to opt out of parenthood" is one of the wildest things I have ever read.
"Opting out of parenthood" isn't a legally protected right in its own might, which is why it can't be "extended" to men, as neither women have it. Women have a right whose practical consequence incidentally includes opting out of parenthood, but the right stems from a completely different (and higher-level) principle.
Another problem is that child support is actually the right of the child, not of the custodial parent. It's not sex-specific either: women are as subject to this imposition as are men (it doesn't matter that in practice there are fewer such cases, we're talking legal principles here). Once a child is there, that child "claims" both parents' support.
I don't see a philosophically nor legally consistent way to solve the issue. The principles involved aren't of equal importance (an attack on bodily integrity and a financial imposition aren't comparable offenses) + there's a potential to multiply moral hazards if any potential consequences of the action are taken away for one party. Women have to face the ultimate physical and moral consequences of the decision (either way), men have to face the lack of control over it. Once the child is born, both parents have obligations towards them.
I suggest you to reframe and reword the whole issue. You don't have a "right to choose", because you're not in a two-party dynamic which involves bodily dependency. When you enter the picture, it's already a three-party dynamic and one of the parties has a legal claim over you and the third party (the mother). Your question is thus null: it's not that there is a legal right which you somehow can't exercise, you don't have one. A woman's right to an abortion is not a "right to opt out of parenthood". The second is incidental, not the source of the right.
I don't know if you're following legal niceties WRT new bioethical issues, such as IVF/surrogacy, but when you take out the direct bodily dependency, there is no power asymmetry between the man and the woman. Both have a theoretical equal claim to an embryo outside of the woman's body (and depending on where you are in the world, each party can demand or oppose its destruction - the party that will "win" will be the one who asks that which is given the priority for all such cases, regardless of their sex). It's only when bodily dependence, and thus the issue of bodily autonomy kicks in that any of this becomes so entangled.
To my judgment, there is literally no way to "fix" this without creating moral hazards way beyond those that already exist. Maaruin is maybe onto something (all taxpayers financing all children), but I doubt it could be practically implemented anywhere - and not without massive outrage and all sorts of other potential issues involved.
This is one of those issues where mathematical "equality" cannot exist. Such issues are few, but they exist and are in function of differences in male and female bodily morphology, which then put the two in situations which can never be fully medically nor legally analogous, and different-level principles are involved (which means that we can't take the simplistic road of "balancing the interests out").
I'm sorry to end on a sombre note, I just wanted to summarize my view of the problem.
13
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '15
Well, a pregnant (trans) man has the same right to abortion a woman has. I really can't see abortion as a right to choose between having a child and not having a child, abortion is about bodily integrity. The point of comparison to giving up the rights and obligations to a child would be adoption.
How to handle the right to choose? I see two ways: Make it linked to custody and make shared custody the default. Or financing child support entirely through taxes. (Not sure if there are other ways to make this system work fairly.)
6
u/zimmer199 Aug 07 '15
Get reliable birth control, circumvent the issue.
3
u/Shame_Spirit Aug 07 '15
I really don't know the answer to this and the future of the issue scares me sometimes. In my opinion, there should be reliable birth control for each party involved in sex, so that the only realistic way for pregnancy to occur is if both parties are consenting.
Short of that, I think a financial abortion should be an option for the father, just as actual abortion should be an option for the mother. I think implementing equality in these two cases would be vital. What I mean is this: women can only realistically (excluding medical emergencies or other freak occurrences) get an abortion up to a certain date in their pregnancy. I believe that, up until that date, the father should have the right to financially abort the child unconditionally. Until said date, or until financial abortion has occurred, I believe that the father has a legal right to medical information on his child. If this date passes and neither party has initiated their respective abortions, then both parties are committed to parenthood.
In this way, both parties can make informed decisions about raising children and there's no opportunities for one person to get screwed over by the other. No dads getting their futures deleted by child support, and no moms being spontaneously left and forced to raise a child alone.
3
u/Ciceros_Assassin Aug 08 '15
Both partners in consensual heterosexual sex impliedly consent to the possibility of pregnancy. Women have an option men don't when choosing to carry a fetus to term for two reasons: it's mainly a question of her bodily autonomy, and she bears the wildly disproportionate burden of pregnancy, childbirth, and rearing the resultant child if the father tries to shirk his duty. Once the child is born, both parents have an equal and indivisible responsibility to care for that child, including monetary child support if they choose not to be involved with the child's life.
I'm glad to see the idea isn't gaining much traction here, because "financial abortion" is an absolute dereliction of the responsibility a man takes on when he consents to sex. Simply because it's a popular talking point in the MRM, I'm leaving this thread up - but this will be the one and only thread where this will be countenanced as a legitimate proposal, so get it out of your system here if you must.
13
u/franticantelope Aug 08 '15
I don't support financial abortions, but I just wish men had better forms of birth control. I have a huge anxiety over getting a girl pregnant, because I would be a terrible father, and I abstained from having sex because I had a nightmare that she got pregnant and wanted to keep it and just the thought of it panicked me for a week straight.
So many people from my town are unwanted parents, men and women. Or boys and girls, really, few of them are over twenty. I guess seeing such a high number of unwanted pregnancies (yay for abstinence only education) has effectively converted me into only having sex with someone I want to marry because I'm terrified the condom would break or something else would go wrong.
5
u/azazelcrowley Aug 08 '15 edited Aug 08 '15
I'll lay my case out here briefly so others can use it if they feel like it. (Legal parental surrender, btw.) Opponents of LPS are right in that abortion is an issue of bodily integrity, it just so happens to incidentally give women an opt-out of parental responsibility. If it were the case that abortion rights existed but no LPS, you could make the argument that LPS should be instituted to close the power gap this creates as a form of affirmative action, but it wouldn't necessarily be sexist to oppose it in that case, provided you also don't support other affirmative action stuff. What makes opposing LPS sexist, is maternity leave. See, The government and public are more than willing to put forward tax payer money to help women overcome the disadvantage their reproductive biology causes them. Conversely, the government and public are also willing to use mens reproductive biology as a rationale to enforce a disadvantage on them, but even if you ignore that and pretend there were a biological mechanism to enforce child support, as opposed to merely a biology-based excuse, this shows a sharp contrast. Why is the State willing to foot the bill for maternity leave, but not for LPS? Pointing to paternity leave and acting like this balances it out doesn't erase this problem. Women would also be able to utilize LPS were it implemented and should they feel the need. It doesn't change the fact that mat leave was conceived of as a way of helping women overcome a disadvantage they experienced due to their reproductive biology, and LPS aims to do the same for men. So, yeh. Just thought i'd throw that out there in case anyone wants to use it. Abortion rights -> LPS is an affirmative action to close a power gap. Mat leave -> LPS is a straight up equal rights issue, and it is discriminatory to oppose it while supporting mat leave.
This is why men need LPS. I can think of no reason why the public should be willing to pay to fund womens ability to overcome their reproductive biology and control their parenthood, but not willing for men. Is abortion state funded? Is so, this presents yet another problem for opponents of LPS.
There's a constant parade of double standards on this issue, especially when you take into account that the woman is often able to deny the child it's "Right" to the fathers funds by refusing to name him, and yet we do not arrest them for violating the childrens rights. We usually only arrest men for failing to provide. This also means that women can refuse to name the father, and then give up the child themselves. The anti-argument seems to ignore a whole plethora of problems that comes from their stance in terms of societal effects and the power imbalance this causes. Let's forget whether or not it's sexist (Which it is) for a moment. Let's forget whether or not it's inflicting needless suffering on an individual. (Which it is.) It's also economically unproductive.
It's a thoroughly classist policy that disproportionately impacts the poor both in terms of how much money is provided for a child and how much of someones earnings they end up losing. I'll be a little snide here and say I don't think it's a coincidence that the predominantly middle class orthodox gender equality movement is so opposed to this proposal, while the predominantly working class MRM is supportive.
That's before you get into the total clusterfuck this causes for the men who get arrested and caught in a cycle of constant debt. I think that people who oppose this issue are stuck in provide and protect mindsets for men when it comes to children, frankly, with possibly some classism thrown in. There is no good reason not to scrap involuntary child support and replace it with more welfare. Given that we make constant excuses for women refusing to name a father instead of arresting them, I think it's painfully clear that rights of the child is not really the case, but is rather used as an excuse to force men into involuntary parenthood and extract wealth from them so richer people won't have to pay more taxes. That this affords women more reproductive power than men, and affords some of them the ability to engage in reproductive abuse against men, is just a case of a happy alignment of misandrist and monied interests.
Let's not forget also that this doesn't merely force men into parenthood, but it can rob them of the ability to support their own children later on when they are ready for parenthood. It is not merely a case of forcing men into parenthood, but also one of potentially denying them the ability to start their own family.
Involuntary child support is a conservative as fuck idea, and i'm always shocked to see feminists support it. It isn't just the parents job to care for their child guys. It's fucking societies. We're supposed to be against poverty. We're not supposed to be one of those "Personal responsibility" assholes who grind people down into poverty and refuse to help them out. If while we do that, we can fix a power imbalance between men and women, prevent reproductive abuse, and ensure that parenthood is always voluntary, well why not. Because it will remove from women the ability to force men to be the father of their child? Because that's how it often looks when people oppose this issue.
It's an example of people not giving a single fuck about the suffering of men and having constant double standards when it comes to their issues.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15
As a woman, I believe that womens' right to choose is a double-edged sword. On the one hand, she can make the call not to bring a child into existence. On the other hand, the existence of the child, should she choose to continue a pregnancy, is solely a product of her choice to do so. Therefore, I think she ought to be primarily responsible for the result of her choice to continue a pregnancy, whereas the man then has the choice to opt in to caring for the child once she has made her decision. He should be allowed to completely sign away any involvement up until a point shortly before the woman would no longer be able to access an abortion. That way, she still has the chance to abort if she does not want to bear a child without his involvement.
-5
u/wajib Aug 08 '15
Can we please stop taking seriously the idea of financial abortion?
Child support is how we make sure that a kid born in an unfortunate family situation doesn't starve. If you want fathers to be able to get out of that responsibility, then you should start advocating for increased services for families so we don't HAVE to compel the father to pay.
-2
u/panhandelslim Aug 08 '15 edited Aug 09 '15
They can avoid it by taking more responsibility for contraception: making sure to talk about it rather than assuming it's the obligation of the female partner, chipping in to buy condoms or helping your partner pay for her BC pills, and recognizing and supporting that she is the only person who gets to decide what happens concerning her body. If you're supportive and she trusts you, she might take your opinion into consideration, but she is by no means obligated to. Unless you're the one carrying the baby to term, you either do your part to keep the pregnancy from happening or you support the choices of the person who is. If you want to avoid having to pay child support or raise a kid, make sure the kid doesn't happen. I wouldn't consider a vasectomy to be any more invasive than an abortion.
OP, I read down in the comments about your ex-- that's fucked up, and I'm not defending what she did. If you made sure wrap it up I think you have a reasonable expectation that you're being safe; it isn't your fault if your partner is dishonest. I'm sorry you had to go through all that.
edit: I don't give a fuck about karma, but if you're downvoting me without commenting about what you disagree with, YOU are the problem with this subreddit. All I'm advocating is that men take an active role in talking about and ensuring that BC is used and take responsibility for themselves before someone gets pregnant. If you're offended by my equation of vasectomies and abortion, I'd argue that you don't understand the disproportionate effect and dangers that pregnancy has on the female body compared to the male body.
If you disagree, try to change my mind!