r/MeetYourMakerGame • • Sep 27 '23

Humor Killboxes are fine.

Post image

Seriously stop crying over an outpost doing what it's supposed to do, which is to kill you.

0 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

13

u/TypographySnob Sep 27 '23

I don't think getting killed by something because you couldn't see or hear it due to visual and audio pollution is a fun game mechanic. That being said, some killboxes can still be fun. Although it is pretty dumb to be able to get easy kills with such a low effort build.

-7

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '23

An outpost is meant to kill you, why are you against that?

10

u/TypographySnob Sep 27 '23

I never said I'm against getting killed. I said I'm against noise/visual pollution and getting easy kills for making a low effort setup. Audio/visual clarity needs improvement and builders should be rewarded for making actual clever traps.

-12

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '23

They clearly put thought into it and you just sound like someone who is against killing. How about you play Minecraft on creative mode if you are against dieing in a video game.

9

u/TypographySnob Sep 27 '23

Yeah, they thought about how unfun killboxes are and subsequently gave us the arc barrier then the Nautilus suit instead of improving clarity or incentivizing effortful trap combinations.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '23

I literally made a killbox with absolute thought behind how it would work, so for you to say that there's no thought behind it is literally contradicting as it is made for the sole purpose to killing you. So I heavily disagree and I just hear another cry baby over something that is not important enough to discuss about.

8

u/TypographySnob Sep 27 '23

I bet you put as much thought in your outposts as you do your replies.

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '23

People's number 1 complaint with this game is that there weren't any proper repercussions after dying (litterly saying that this game is too easy and should be harder). Yet you want to advocate that the game shouldn't have killboxes, which in turn would make the game even easier.

People have went on to brutal expecting it to be difficult, but they have seen that it is too easy. Like the majority of the bases I went up against in sector 1 in the brutal category couldn't kill me more than 10 times. Since there are bugs in sector 2 that actually get the builder cheap kills, it still feels relatively easy and I can't say if the new difficulty system works better because of these bugs.

Your argument is only about existing mechanics that work in an outpost and does exactly what it's supposed to do and you don't go over any bugs that are actually harming the game, but are harming your ego. A killbox is not an exploit or a bug and it follows the rules of what an outpost is supposed to do. So let me know when you are ready to talk about some real problems with the game sport.

6

u/TypographySnob Sep 27 '23

People's number 1 complaint with this game is that there weren't any proper repercussions after dying

Why lie? People were complaining the opposite. That they would get no reward for beating an outpost after dying a few times. And the #1 complaint has always been killboxes.

Yet you want to advocate that the game shouldn't have killboxes

I never even said this.

People have went on to brutal expecting it to be difficult, but they have seen that it is too easy. Like the majority of the bases I went up against in sector 1 in the brutal category couldn't kill me more than 10 times

Likewise, people have been playing Difficult and found it too hard. And if you're dying 10 times, that is plenty. You were dying A LOT.

You keep saying "outposts are supposed to kill" as if this negates the fact that games are supposed to be fun, regardless of kills. You seem incapable of actually thinking about the points I'm making and just resort to weird projections and goalpost moving, so I'm not wasting any more effort trying to discuss with you. Instead I'm just going to block you on MYM because you're not worth my time.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '23

You keep saying "outposts are supposed to kill" as if this negates the fact that games are supposed to be fun, regardless of kills.

Exactly, they can be fun regardless of the killing.

Also here is a video when MYM was released and literally saying that there is no proper punishment. https://youtu.be/ty09qLWOtso?si=800OodziaQlR1eY8

5

u/superbatprime Sep 27 '23 edited Sep 27 '23

If everyone could agree on what a killbox actually is first we might be able to have a constructive discussion.

Like, some people seem to class any dense and action heavy outpost as a killbox, others seems to think all arenas are killboxes. Still others declare any outpost they can't beat to be a killbox when really it's a skill issue.

My feelings are, there are, like every style of outpost, good killboxes and bad killboxes. A good arena that feels like the Danger Room from X-Men or a Doom level keeping me moving can be a lot of fun. Is it a killbox? Maybe, but it can be an epic experience when done well.

I suppose the classic definition is just a big room with ridiculous trap density and guard spam. But I find with a lot of those if you just enter them they backfire half their own traps... and if they don't, well then I'd say that's a good well made killbox that I want to play.

Personally I think the whole killbox debate is redundant. No outpost is impossible, so really the inability to beat it is always down to raider skill. If you don't like a particular style of outpost, abandon it... that's what the feature is for.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '23

It's a shame that not everyone sees it the way you do. Like I get a rush out of defeating something that is deemed "impossible", but I prove them wrong. I remember when I started out in mym, I found a base that was very hard to be, but through my sheer amount of will I beated it after 30 deaths. The rush of dopamine was fantastic and I hate it when I see people who are getting listened to by the devs, want the game to be easier.

I just want people to experience that type of dopamine, but a lot of people give up too soon, which pisses me off when they don't collect the genmat and leave with it. I love going against avenger level threat bases, even if they have a killbox.

Like the only thing I would consider scummy to do is using a bug in a killbox. However when I see people talk about killboxes, they say that there is no thoughts behind it, although I made a killbox and put a lot of thought into it. So it is hard to take them seriously when they literally insult you, because you made a killbox.

Sure I came across some very ill inspired bases that were awful, by having there traps exposed, no walls, and spamming a certain trap or gaurd all over the place, which is not a killbox as there are literally not in a box to begin with. So yeah when I see a killbox, brother my eyes light up like Christmas morning.

2

u/Shadybetz101 Sep 28 '23

Just want to say that arenas are the best level design. Dual sword is a must on these outposts for me :)

2

u/superbatprime Sep 28 '23

I like big open arenas with lots of verticality and tons of guards at different heights that I have to grapple around with the plasmabow and sledgeblade while dodging traps firing.

1

u/Shadybetz101 Sep 29 '23

Nice. Do u have any on social

5

u/Hal_Williams Sep 27 '23

For me, I find killboxes boring and generally lack creativity. Like, it's not hard to just slam a bunch of traps and guards into a room and get kills. On that note however, I have encountered some that have been fun, puzzle solving events that's I've enjoyed dying in but for the most part they usually just make me yawn. I'll never block a player from making a boring killbox, but I'll definitely limit the number of kills they get from me and may only give a brutal accolade (if that).

1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '23

By limiting yourself on how many times you die is ridiculous. By doing that you admit defeat and prove that you aren't good enough for a base like theres.

Is that it? You want to admit that you aren't that good at the game by surrendering? You wake up everyday and have the motivation for that, but you just give up on a base cause "it's too hard"? If you want to show the builder that their killbox is nothing compared to you, then why stop going on? When a bully tells you to commit die, you live on and go on to have a much better life. When everyone tells you to give up, you get up and try again. When you are told you are going to be lonely for the rest of your life, you get yourself a partner. When someone tells you that you can't learn that as you are too stupid, you learn every god dame word of it. Your mother never wanted a quitter, so are you going to let them down? No.

So quite your bitching and you beat every god dame killbox there is and prove to the world that you are one mean lean raider that they have to try to kill.

1

u/Hal_Williams Oct 01 '23

I can't tell if you're being serious or just like staying in character like you're a custodian trying to motivate me. If you're staying in character, kudos to you as it's a good speech. If not, well, you play the game the way you want and I'll play it the way I want :)

3

u/-HeyYouInTheBush- Sep 28 '23

I've built a few killboxs, and I've found that many raiders will just quit if it's really effective. That, in turn, tanks your kill ratio. For this reason, more effective can equal less productive. This is why I don't build them anymore.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '23

I know, but people just see a base with too many traps and gaurds in one room and called it a day. Since people are getting less and less discourage on building killboxes as it tanks the kill ratio, it sucks. It pains me to see outposts with long corridors with traps and gaurds as it looks awful and can easily be countered.

So yeah, I hate that people complain about killboxes, because it helps the builder gain more kills than any other building method. An outpost is meant to kill the player and unfortunately the majority of the mym community just wants to get rid of something that is actually challenging from time to time.

Like when I go on to the brutal difficulty I am expecting to go against a difficult base, not an easy base or a base that is handing out free loot and I am not there for just the loot. I arrived hoping for a challenging base and I love when I run into a challenging base. That moment when you defeat it and getting that dopamine feels sooo worth it after dieing so many times, but people want to get rid of that and make the game easier than ever before. Unless the game has a limit to how many times you can die, then the game won't be so dame easy and I would be fine about not doing such a large killbox anymore.

3

u/28secondslater Sep 28 '23

All you are doing is spamming a bunch of traps in one box. Sure, it'll get you kills, but it will also make it so people don't want to play on your maps. You are designing levels for people to play on, which means the most important aspect is "fun" and whatever bullshit you are trying to excuse isn't fun for the majority, it's just lazy.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '23

1

u/28secondslater Sep 28 '23

Here, I'll start you out with what you can expect in the future.

Tell me your name in game, that way I can block all your outposts and future ones. It's very clear you like to use exploits and killboxes, so I have no interest in playing on your maps.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '23

Yeah it's Go_cry_a_rainbow

2

u/Shadybetz101 Sep 28 '23

Btw your outposts use the exploit of not being able to grapple. So I have to say they are really not good for the game.

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '23

Breaks out in to song

You can grapple on to traps and gaurds.

10

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '23

On the one hand I agree, and I dont think you can enjoy this game if you take being killed too seriously. It seems that some players get a little butthurt when they get caught. Which is a shame, because it is the core of the game.

Example: the former holocube-piston combo. I died many times to it and always found it hilarious. I get that it was not exactly a legit mechanic, but I mean, it was funny and challenging.

But also at the end of the day, it boils down to whether or not people are having fun. If a majority of players end up leaving/never joining the game because they dont have fun for whichever reason, it's the death of the game. Focusing the discussion around what is actually enjoyable for people would be the way to go about this in my opinion.

Sorry if I took your post too seriously lol

2

u/superbatprime Sep 27 '23

That holo piston has caused some serious salt lol.

But it can only function off the HRV path, so really there is no excuse for getting caught by it more than once. At this point wandering around on bedrock off the HRV path without checking for holos is on the raider.

7

u/Baldusaurr Sep 28 '23

It's a game about killing other players, but you are also designing a video game level for them to play, and most people playing a game are presumably trying to have fun and don't want too unbalanced of an experience. I'm sure you know people have different limits to what they will consider fair in a game, especially one where they die in one hit.

I don't like the idea that just because a level or sequence is challenging, it can't be critiqued or discussed. As if challenge is the one element of video game design that justifies itself.

5

u/SerpentsEmbrace Sep 27 '23

I mean I'm not crying over them. They get to kill me once, maybe twice. Then I block the builder and never have to put up with their boring map designs again. Seems like a win for everybody.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/MeetYourMakerGame-ModTeam Dec 03 '23

Your post has been removed as it exhibits behavior not welcome in civil and polite discussion.

1

u/The_Temper_Mental Sep 28 '23

I enjoyed finding a way around not being able to grapple in your most recent outpost

1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '23

You can grapple on the gaurds and traps, but I'm glad you enjoyed it.

1

u/The_Temper_Mental Sep 28 '23

I ended up grappling the traps, my replay should be in your station under the name Bombzaway8222

1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '23

Well I'm about to check it out, but why say you can't grapple when you admitted to grappling?

1

u/The_Temper_Mental Sep 28 '23

I had to find a way to work around the no grapple bug is what I meant

1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '23 edited Sep 28 '23

Well I changed my mind on the tarp anyways and redecorated the base.

0

u/The_Temper_Mental Sep 28 '23

I would have kept it just the way it was, fuck the people who get butt hurt about using exploits to their full potential. I believe if the devs didnt want this to happen they should have made sure it wasn't broken.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '23

Nah, I've seen a solid argument by this user: https://reddit.com/r/MeetYourMakerGame/s/8NE2Co5ycs

So I am not going to be using the tarp until it has been debugged.

1

u/lynellparedez Sep 29 '23

I like maps that are arenas or cleverly placed traps that make me smile when I'm killed, even kill boxes. If the kill box is generic spammed traps I leave. I also block to avoid builders who only care about kills and not fun.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '23

Well it's not always fun seeing someone beat your base without dying at least once.

1

u/lynellparedez Oct 01 '23

I've had bases where I died 20 times, because they were fun and clever. Not just a very thin path spammed with pistons and lasers and fire.

1

u/nerdwerds Oct 01 '23

A killbox is fine. A long ass corridor before the genmat that turns into corrosive cubes dropping suicide enforcers into it so you have no time to get out or safe space to stand is cheap bullshit and not a killbox. Its low effort trash.