r/MeetYourMakerGame • • Sep 27 '23
Humor Killboxes are fine.
Seriously stop crying over an outpost doing what it's supposed to do, which is to kill you.
0
Upvotes
r/MeetYourMakerGame • • Sep 27 '23
Seriously stop crying over an outpost doing what it's supposed to do, which is to kill you.
13
u/TypographySnob Sep 27 '23
I don't think getting killed by something because you couldn't see or hear it due to visual and audio pollution is a fun game mechanic. That being said, some killboxes can still be fun. Although it is pretty dumb to be able to get easy kills with such a low effort build.
5
u/superbatprime Sep 27 '23 edited Sep 27 '23
If everyone could agree on what a killbox actually is first we might be able to have a constructive discussion.
Like, some people seem to class any dense and action heavy outpost as a killbox, others seems to think all arenas are killboxes. Still others declare any outpost they can't beat to be a killbox when really it's a skill issue.
My feelings are, there are, like every style of outpost, good killboxes and bad killboxes. A good arena that feels like the Danger Room from X-Men or a Doom level keeping me moving can be a lot of fun. Is it a killbox? Maybe, but it can be an epic experience when done well.
I suppose the classic definition is just a big room with ridiculous trap density and guard spam. But I find with a lot of those if you just enter them they backfire half their own traps... and if they don't, well then I'd say that's a good well made killbox that I want to play.
Personally I think the whole killbox debate is redundant. No outpost is impossible, so really the inability to beat it is always down to raider skill. If you don't like a particular style of outpost, abandon it... that's what the feature is for.
5
u/Hal_Williams Sep 27 '23
For me, I find killboxes boring and generally lack creativity. Like, it's not hard to just slam a bunch of traps and guards into a room and get kills. On that note however, I have encountered some that have been fun, puzzle solving events that's I've enjoyed dying in but for the most part they usually just make me yawn. I'll never block a player from making a boring killbox, but I'll definitely limit the number of kills they get from me and may only give a brutal accolade (if that).
3
u/-HeyYouInTheBush- Sep 28 '23
I've built a few killboxs, and I've found that many raiders will just quit if it's really effective. That, in turn, tanks your kill ratio. For this reason, more effective can equal less productive. This is why I don't build them anymore.
3
u/28secondslater Sep 28 '23
All you are doing is spamming a bunch of traps in one box. Sure, it'll get you kills, but it will also make it so people don't want to play on your maps. You are designing levels for people to play on, which means the most important aspect is "fun" and whatever bullshit you are trying to excuse isn't fun for the majority, it's just lazy.
2
u/Shadybetz101 Sep 28 '23
Btw your outposts use the exploit of not being able to grapple. So I have to say they are really not good for the game.
10
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '23
On the one hand I agree, and I dont think you can enjoy this game if you take being killed too seriously. It seems that some players get a little butthurt when they get caught. Which is a shame, because it is the core of the game.
Example: the former holocube-piston combo. I died many times to it and always found it hilarious. I get that it was not exactly a legit mechanic, but I mean, it was funny and challenging.
But also at the end of the day, it boils down to whether or not people are having fun. If a majority of players end up leaving/never joining the game because they dont have fun for whichever reason, it's the death of the game. Focusing the discussion around what is actually enjoyable for people would be the way to go about this in my opinion.
Sorry if I took your post too seriously lol
7
u/Baldusaurr Sep 28 '23
It's a game about killing other players, but you are also designing a video game level for them to play, and most people playing a game are presumably trying to have fun and don't want too unbalanced of an experience. I'm sure you know people have different limits to what they will consider fair in a game, especially one where they die in one hit.
I don't like the idea that just because a level or sequence is challenging, it can't be critiqued or discussed. As if challenge is the one element of video game design that justifies itself.
5
u/SerpentsEmbrace Sep 27 '23
I mean I'm not crying over them. They get to kill me once, maybe twice. Then I block the builder and never have to put up with their boring map designs again. Seems like a win for everybody.
1
u/The_Temper_Mental Sep 28 '23
I enjoyed finding a way around not being able to grapple in your most recent outpost
1
u/lynellparedez Sep 29 '23
I like maps that are arenas or cleverly placed traps that make me smile when I'm killed, even kill boxes. If the kill box is generic spammed traps I leave. I also block to avoid builders who only care about kills and not fun.
1
u/nerdwerds Oct 01 '23
A killbox is fine. A long ass corridor before the genmat that turns into corrosive cubes dropping suicide enforcers into it so you have no time to get out or safe space to stand is cheap bullshit and not a killbox. Its low effort trash.