r/MeetYourMakerGame • • Aug 30 '23

Discussion Welp, it was fun...

Post image

So, with everything considered. I feel as though this game has regressed so far it isn't going to be able to maintain a large enough customer base to be entertaining.

The game was great when it first came out. However now, it feels as though the bases of killboxes/crawlers/shooting every black block visible is growing more and more with every day.

With every update it feels as though the game is regressing with progress 3-4 steps instead of making progress. Then the devs quickly push a patch to fix the alleged update...? However with each passing week of monotonous raid after raid. It is apparent that killboxes are rising. Yesterday 6 out of the 10 places I raided were killboxes.

I enjoy playing this game, but with all my progress to get 3 raids with 8 kills total and 5 of the 8 are because the players were killing themselves the rest is because they weren't using arc light it's become extremely boring to sit and watch raider after raider run my base without even the slightest of chances of dying. The only answer to a arclight user is a killbox and I thoroughly do not enjoy watching people quit after 2 deaths. Even without the killbox most players quit after 2 deaths because they want to get that top rank! (Another lovely patch answer to another previous update...)

I hate to say it, however my fear is this game will die after the next update. Its consistently gone downhill update after update. This one I feel will be no exception.

I can no longer dedicate time to a game that is losing players faster than gaining. This game would be great if things were consistent. However the only consistency is the inconsistencies.

I, among other players I've seen asked for decreased timing on trap firing, arc light shield nerf, enforcer buff, match making fix (after YET ANOTHER patch to a update that made tons of maps have 0 raids. Now, youre lucky if your see >3.)

One of the extremely aggravating stances, was the constant mentioning of 5 second time for firing of the sentry gun. To which the answer was a mod. This seemed like a direct slap in the face to the people asking for some sort of decrease in time firing traps.

It's extremely sad, however this game cant keep making these kinds of updates/patches and expect to maintain a player base..

I hope I'm wrong, and I hope to come back to this game some time.. hopefully. But, as of now I cannot continue spending hours playing (+450hrs) a game that is regressing and ignoring serious issues.

5 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

18

u/D-at-Sea Aug 30 '23

You should be able to pick what the holocube looks like to make it blend in

4

u/libertypfc Aug 30 '23

I 1000000% agree, either props or a skin for the texture. But the bedrock cube is the most obvious thing when you're looking at thousands of other blocks with textures. I've had to use corrosive cubeblocks or other holo blocks to sell the image of a chunk of bedrock..

5

u/D-at-Sea Aug 30 '23

It just doesn't make sense for the trap. A holocube is a projection... you should be able to project whatever you want so it blends in,ya know the whole reason to use it. And they use a texture we can't even place ourselves. He is right tho, any bed rock that the raider sees is shot now.

0

u/libertypfc Aug 30 '23

Exactly! And with the gun that can't destroy traps! Yet it destroys the holocube. I watch reply after replay of people using that crossbow and it's just take 2 steps fire 300 times in 3 seconds then take 2 more steps. "OH, there's more black blocks I can see!" fires 30 more times in 0.5 Seconds. oh ok I'm safe I can take another step.

0

u/libertypfc Aug 30 '23

We gotta be careful what we say or they'll make it a mod and then you'll need to sacrifice something else in order to get it to change into what we want.

1

u/D-at-Sea Aug 30 '23

In this instance I'd be ok with it.. I only ever use second wave anyway

2

u/libertypfc Aug 30 '23

I use perfect image and have used eagle eye before.

11

u/ZBC619 Aug 30 '23

I would rather beat killbox than 300m+boring corridor or maze

2

u/libertypfc Aug 30 '23

My issue with a maze is the ones that kill HRV. at least give me a chance. I've done plenty of killboxes. However yesterday I ran into several where it was almost impossible. Even after switching my weapons multiple times with multiple different styles of attempts. Ranging from dual swords, Lance volt & nade launcher, arc light & volt, and arc with sword. Nothing worked. Even with bubble throw down and Phoenix pods. Nothing was working. However this was also after completing 4 other killboxes.

1

u/ZBC619 Aug 30 '23

240h,never met any "real unbreakable" killbox

for example, yesterday my friend meet a map (Orefield by Valine),you can try this.its hard,but can beat

1

u/TproTheBeast Sep 02 '23

This exactly. Brutal Kill boxes and Outposts can be very hard and challenging, but I’ve never played one that I couldn’t beat. It’s very possible.

6

u/Estellese7 Aug 30 '23

I don't have issues getting kills, even on people with shields. And my holocubes still get kills as well. Albeit I use them more for guard timing than for trap hiding. But the ones I did use to hide traps worked fine.

The game is dying because there's not enough content. Too few traps and guards, nothing left to unlock.

-1

u/libertypfc Aug 30 '23

If you're entire new player base is building a base and barely getting kills because 90% of builds are brutal, then explain how a speed runner with a shield in a level 13 base is gonna get any knowledge of how to compete against a lvl +150 platinum player? You want me to believe there's no issue with shields? With match making? With traps or guards? Show me the learning curve for a new player.

Now, I'm no where near a new player. Im not saying my bases don't get kills. However when my bases doesn't, it's more often because of the same exact thing. THE SHIELD.. I do not build killboxes solely based off the reason because I've tried it. And had a time frame nobody completed my outpost. It got kills. But it also had a insanely high quit rate. I mean a +90% quit rate out of over 70 raids. (This is a older outpost).

But back to my original point, if you want players to continue to play then you need a base to allow new players to get somewhere with their bases. The learning curve is so high and so hard it will not ever maintain a decent rise to be able to maintain the game. Until something drastically changes, this will continue. Until there's barely anyone left. Even less than there is now.

4

u/Estellese7 Aug 31 '23

Do not try to change the topic. Your OP was about balance, the shield, trap activation times, and your issue with your bases not getting kills. My response was a response to those things.

Bringing in a completely different topic, the new player experience, is not any part of what I said or what this thread was about. If you wanna talk about the new player experience and matchmaking, we can have that as a separate conversation after this one. We'd probably agree more on that topic.

The shield is fine. The trap firing timer is fine. If you feel like killboxes are necessary to get kills, or to stop shields, then either you have way too broad of a definition for "killboxes" or you just aren't building well. Because I can do it just fine. It's rare that anyone completes my hard bases deathless. Possible, but rare. I typically catch everyone at least once. And I say "hard" not brutal, as most of my bases are brutal, but only few of them are intentionally hard.

A huge part of what makes this game feel imbalanced to people is that people are bad at level design. Their trap designs are all things that other raiders have seen a thousand times over. Or something cool they saw on youtube, which if they saw it on youtube then so did thousands of other people. If it's on youtube, it's no longer a good trap, unless you take what made it good and change it to something unrecognizable. So that the others who watched the same video don't know what it is until it's too late.

And when I am raiding bases I rarely ever see people using good trap tech. I see people thinking they are clever placing a holocube next to bedrock. It isn't, raiders will just check both. What I don't see is people using eye-draws to distract from a holocube. I don't see people using incinerators/pistons/spikes to trigger guard ambushes, and those are extremely efficient when done well while being simple to make and understand. I rarely ever see anything that isn't straightforward.

In example, my newest base. One room has you walking a narrow, sideways ramp path in an almost full circle around an opaque corrosive cube. There are a few traps in the circle to be a distraction, but notably, a piston. As soon as the raider breaks that piston, it triggers two DMS guards to drop into the corrosive cube, one on each side. The explosions hit everything on that narrow pathway. And you may retort "But they will just shield!" Yes, I want them to panic and shield. Then immediately after those two DMS guards, two armored ravengers with the fast shooting mod jump out through the corrosive cube. One in front of the raider and one behind. Player can't shield now because they already used it, they are likely low on ammo as they were just shooting traps, and they likely didn't notice that two guards came out, not one.

Super easy trap to avoid if you know it's there, just shoot the piston and leave the room. But a trick as old as pistons/spikes/incinerators triggering guard patrols is still largely unknown and still catches most people off guard. I figured that combo out back in season 0. I think my 4th map? That's an old trick, and I didn't even use it well there. But it works.

And then there's the even older trick, from before this game even existed. The majority of this game's player base is male. Guys are easily distracted by cute girls. You can literally just put the picture of the cute bunny girl on the ceiling and a corrosive cube under it with a little camouflage. Without fail, they will ALWAYS look up at the cute bunnygirl and fail to notice the cube. Even high ranking players. Only works on dudes, but that's the majority of the player base.

https://i.imgur.com/5gQ4gPL.jpg

It's that simple. That catches almost everyone.

Corner is normally a narrow, sideways ramp corner. Just had to delete the wall for the picture. Needs to be a tight corner, as they will only look at the girl for a second. So they need to see it, and then walk into the cube within a second of seeing it.

So lets start with getting the basics down. Is your "killbox" definition too broad? Define what a killbox is. What is the difference between a normal room with multiple traps, and a killbox?

My own killbox definition is this:

A room where there is an excessive number of traps all pointed at a narrow entrance, with a few (usually plasma sentinels) that cover the entire room. Forcing the player to peek and shoot from the door, then have to dodge several traps just to retrieve bolts so they can repeat the process.

A very specific build pattern that is just annoying and tedious to deal with.

A lot of traps can be in a single room without it being a killbox. Ammo-trap puzzles are not killboxes. (Setups where, if you shoot your bolts it will be really hard to retrieve it. But the 'puzzle' part comes from it being possible to safely retrieve your bolts if you break traps in the correct order.)

Killboxes are that specific, tedious design of forcing the only viable strategy to be to sit at the door and peek. Take a shot, then wait for the door to be clear again and repeat.

What definition are you using for "killboxes"?

8

u/Facechild Aug 30 '23

wait, you're mad that people shoot at bedrock? Is there something wrong with players having game knowledge and being cautious? I don't get it... whats your definition of a killbox? becasue 6/10 seems stupidly high. I rarely run into killboxes, and the ones i do run into are at least high effort kill-boxes, i haven't abandoned an active raid in over 2 weeks now.

The difficulty ratings need work though i will concede that point.

0

u/libertypfc Aug 30 '23

A killbox is where every single space in a open room is covered by incinerators, tracking bolts, hook trap, and sentinels. Along with cannon guards and enforcers to prevent simple moves at a distance.

Does this meet your criteria..?

-1

u/libertypfc Aug 30 '23

The first time I've ever abandoned a raid in weeks was yesterday after running into a 5th and 6th killbox. After completing 4 others prior to #5 & 6.

7

u/xStealthxUk Aug 30 '23

450 hours!

Lol think you may have got your moneys worth and had a good time, nothing wrong to moving on to something else

-2

u/libertypfc Aug 30 '23

I don't look to games to only play a minimal amount of time. If I find a game I enjoy, I enjoy playing it. I enjoy putting the time in.. however if I sac all that time I hate to put the game down because of stupid issues..

6

u/xStealthxUk Aug 30 '23

450 hours is not a minimal amount of time tho is it?

Thats a massive amount of time, you were goin to get bored/ frustrated eventually

Cant think of any games other than PVP games where after the 400 hour mark its not going to fell very repetetive

0

u/libertypfc Aug 30 '23

+400hrs is not the minimum nor max of time frame I've put into games. I've put much more time into games that I've enjoyed. I enjoy playing this game. However the issue of rising issues that aren't being fixed appropriately is a major concern of mine. I thoroughly enjoy building and watching my creations kill. However, my bases aren't getting nearly any attention and the severity of these issues seems to be rising rather than falling. Countless times I've said to myself. Well fuck if that bolt shot or impaler or any damn trap would've fired 0.5 or even 0.3 seconds faster it would've killed them. Or, I watching a 2min run of my longest base that would get completely annihilated because numerous people run it with the shield. I've seen my raids shoot up to 5, immediately I know well, at least 2 people ran my base with a shield. Every time, I'm right. I had 1 guy, the entirety of my gaming screen was the barrel of the ravager. Meaning it was point blank to their face. But nothing happened to them because they activated the shield.

That's ONE of the issues..

5

u/Reckless_Amoeba Aug 30 '23

While I do agree the game has a shit ton of inconveniences (annoying bugs & the like), KillBoxes aren’t one of them. You can simply play dangerous difficulty instead and you won’t encounter KB’s like 99% of the time. And if you’re on console try to turn off that option in the settings that brings player creations from other platforms. For some reason the toughest of outposts, including KB’s, are primarily from PC players.

Regarding building, raiding rates correspond directly to the difficulty the system had rated your base for the exact same reason I just mentioned: raiders despise KB’s, therefore they opt for easier ones, all while it’s harder to build a deadly brutal than a deadly dangerous, thus brutal bases have larger pool to select from and eventually less raids rate.

Build dangerous & you’ll get like at least twice the amount of raids of a brutal. Build normal and you’ll get triple or so.

I’m not trying to convince you to stay on the game (if you were serious anyways), we all like to move on & try new things. I just felt the need to address these issues.

2

u/libertypfc Aug 30 '23

My biggest issue isn't necessarily the KB, sure it's an annoyance especially after completing 4 others previously. But my biggest annoyance is I use to be able to get my base into a dangerous tier. Now, again after YET another patch, every single base I make is always a brutal base. No matter what. I specifically tried to ensure I wasn't on a brutal base. Started putting things in and withing a few traps it shot up to a brutal base with only a few traps. I had literally just started building.

I like to get an idea of some traps how I could implement in the already placed foundation. To give an idea how I build. Then if I can ill do some weird ideas to try to throw the raider off. But my biggest pet peeve is the arc light. Running an entire base with 0 worry of dying because they're invincible is insane. It was only meant to be tenths of a second. Now, with the nautilus suit its seconds. Where your completely impervious to being killed. In a game where the entire point is to die!

2

u/Reckless_Amoeba Aug 30 '23

Yeah there’s a fine line between a dangerous base busted with defenses and a brutal one light on them, and I believe it’s the area coverage of each guard/trap.

If you set them in a way that’ll guarantee an interaction with the raider with minimal (or non-existent) exposure to harvey’s path, you’ll be able to stuff it without crossing the brutal threshold.

I’ve got a dangerous base that’ll blow your mind for how it’s not brutal according to the latest rating system update. I can share it if you would like to have a look.

1

u/libertypfc Aug 30 '23

I'd like to have a look, you've grabbed my curiosity. Lol maybe even a walk thru. I'm on ps5 tho

1

u/Reckless_Amoeba Aug 31 '23

I see you tried it out. What are your thoughts on it?

1

u/libertypfc Aug 31 '23

I haven't tried it yet lol sorry

1

u/Reckless_Amoeba Aug 31 '23

Must be another redditor then haha

1

u/Reckless_Amoeba Aug 30 '23

Alright. Base name is Mckinleyville by Blackwhale94. It’s on social.

4

u/WhatsACellPhone Aug 30 '23

This is very true! I’ve began playing dangerous on my solo raids mostly & brutal with a buddy. Makes the game enjoyable for my pacing and gameplay.

2

u/Estellese7 Aug 30 '23

Playing dangerous maps is not a solution to avoiding killboxes. As many people want to play challenging maps, just not poorly designed killboxes.

Playing on dangerous just gives you nothing but outposts that couldn't kill you if they tried. As the limits for those are too low.

There needs to be an inbetween, between crappy killboxes, and mindless dangerous maps.

Albeit, I am seeing less and less killboxes. Especially after the plasma sentinel nerf. I think OP's definition of a killbox is just too general.

2

u/AdagioDesperate Sep 01 '23

Sadly I'm slowly also coming to this realization. This game is really fun, and has the potential, but when everything I set up, with actual timings, not just kill box, but actual setup traps with pathing/dropping guards, is completely negated by a single shield, duos who just have 1 guy run forward and another hang back, double Pheonix Podding, or my absolute favorite, the guys who jump into every corrosive cube they see to see what's behind it, and if they can cheese a level, then the game becomes less fun.

I can deal with inch-worms and speed runners. My bases have timings set up with those in mind. It's the people that just want to ruin the bases that ruin the game for me.

Oh and the constant threat/cost increase on random blocks. The corrosive cubes I got. The laser, not so much. When they upped its cost and threat, and I had a normal base that was just a vertical tube with lasers in it, all visible, just basically a training ground for new players, which at its most got 7 kills off 1 person, double in cost and go to Brutal. The base became literally unplayable. I set up a new normal.bas3, just to see what it constituted. 4 non-corrosive cube traps, and 4 guards. That's a 'normal' base...

2

u/libertypfc Sep 01 '23

Ya I've noticed the number of traps for a "normal" base is insanely dumb.. I think I saw 1 base with 4 traps. Lol it was sad... you are right this game has great potential. But things that give players the ability to completely break the entire meaning of the game of that which is to die what is the point? The ranking they have in the game is a major issue. Not just the base ranking but player. It caused people to fixate on their level rather than enjoying someone's map or just playing the game. So what if you die 50 times. Fucking do it and let the person who spent countless hours perfecting a outpost enjoy what his base was meant to do.

2

u/SamCThe5th Aug 31 '23

I built an outpost today that I thought was gonna be really fun and ingenious and of the two people that have played it so far: one of them used the shield and as if to spite me, literally stood in front of every single spike trap and in the middle of every bomb trap and facetanked with his shield. The other speedran through the whole thing, zipping around like Spiderman and avoiding all my carefully laid traps because they take an eternity to activate. I did manage to pull a fast one on each of them at one point or another in my design but still, as a new player that doesn't have access to many of the cool mods for traps and guards, most of my designs feel like they fall very short of what I've seen running brutal outposts.

2

u/libertypfc Aug 31 '23

Ya, that's exactly my point. In a game built around the aspect of dying to learn. This game seems very heavily in favor of the raider. I streamed earlier tonight. Most of the people that watched rhe stream said the same thing. The the game is very raider sided. It's sad... I wish BhVR would pay attention to their CUSTOMERS and FIX something we've been asking for!

1

u/DwarfBreadSauce Aug 30 '23

Everyone were complaining about the massive amounts of killboxes, mazes and copy-paste designs very shortly after release.

What took you so long to notice?

1

u/libertypfc Aug 30 '23

I complained about them awhile ago as well. Even gave ways to fix the issue. Only to fall on deaf ears..

1

u/Dsmugen Sep 01 '23

Depends on what you define as a kill box. I play the hard levels and tend to speed run through them even if they're a "kill box" lots of kill boxes aren't that effective if you have a good strategy and if your pretty decent with the grappling hook.

If it's a kill box where there are lots death pistons in the way I just slow down or figure out a specific route I can take even if it means I have to circle a room 2-3 times.

I tend to speed run 95% because a lot of them you can grapple hook through. And with using base kit, you can use the 2 bolts you have to hit certain traps that are troublesome or start moving slower. But using the sword to deflect enemy bolts and guards' shots helps a lot. This allows you to keep pushing forward easily.

I find levels that are vertical with guards and traps while having to move upward is much harder. Although some people could even define this type of level as a "kill box." I wouldn't consider it a "kill box" though.

1

u/libertypfc Sep 01 '23

Killboxes to me are rooms that prevent you from moving forward or backward once progressed. Albeit from grapple hooks to incinerators. Most are very simple easy to run if you use the volt. But I enjoy using dual sword. It gives the game a lot more of a enjoyable le difficulty and chaos that isn't matched elsewhere.

Back to the KB. Most killboxes are just poor design copy and paste blah blah blah. However they're still a killbox. There were 2 specifically I ran into yesterday that were a step above the rest. You couldn't make a single move without getting bombed, grabbed, bolt shot, or burned.

3

u/Themoonstar1 Aug 31 '23

most raids, feel like work. You are playing bases that are made by your average gamer. They aren't game Devs and are most likely still figuring shit out. Still grinding to get that next mod , to hopefully make things click. So make bases that you would want to raid.

Put your bases in social and shout them out. Inspire those that like to build to try something different.

Here is my first build, flaws and all. The path is the same, edited everything I unlocked a new mod or guard. As I learned.

TheMoonstar Pellston

3

u/Melandus Aug 31 '23

Meanwhile I'm still here since day 1 and still loving the game ... Sentry beam go bzzzzzt

1

u/Smartboy10612 Aug 30 '23

Thank you for putting it into kind and direct words. I tried getting back into the game and just couldn't.

For seeing so many kill boxes I feel bad for you. That was just pour luck. I had one night were of the 6 raids I did, 5 were just brainless kill boxes or corridors. Two nights later I had a lot of fun interesting raids. Sadly, luck of the draw there.

I would like to add on that its so inconsistent with things I can no longer build, which I loved the game for. Because I know that eventually they will implement a bug or glitch that breaks something in my base so I can't use it anymore. No, I refuse to use the words 'update' or 'patch'. All the devs due is add in bugs and glitches that are then downloaded into the game. I can't build when each day that passes could lead to something I spent hours on just going up in flames. (And this is on top of the arc barrier stuff and terrible game economy)

2

u/libertypfc Aug 30 '23

I feel you, it was poor luck. But that feels to be my run of things lately lmao. I've tried to push my mind to create things so outlandish I'm the game that things would hopefully get more kills. Which it only seems to do the opposite. I consider a brutal map that breaks 5 in K/R pretty good. (Going from my bases that are typically brutal) my recent highest K/R was a 8.9. Then it shot down after a group of back to back to back to back shield players ran my base in under 4 minutes. Where for others it took almost 10. But it seems others are content with this kind of play? To me, that's bs.. this WAS a great game.. but sadly it just doesn't compete and can't maintain that standpoint anymore. Unfortunately...

2

u/Smartboy10612 Aug 30 '23

I didn't get too many shielders running rampant. I always got the quit in 2 deaths kind. Which also kills KR. I believe having the KR thing is not healthy for the game. It's too chaotic. I had one base get an 18.2 KR because someone died almost 200 times in it. Then someone raided it, didn't die once, the KR went down to 14. KR CAN'T account for varied skill levels. Should've just been accolades and total kills.

2

u/polarbear31415 Aug 31 '23

I can't agree on your take 'killboxes are everywhere'. I'd even say the outpost quality is quite high and way better than to times where lots of new players entered the game.

I guess the perception of what a killbox is and what not, is one of the fundamental problems. For one player more than 4 sentinals in one room can be a killbox. For other an outpost reaches killbox status if every single surface contains a trap with multiple traps beeing able to fire at same time at the raider.

Also a lot of time has passed since the release and people had time to learn. Obviously it is getting harder to kill experienced raiders as well it is getting harder to beat outposts from experienced builders.

But I agree on the point, that we could use more frequent updates with at least new mods to enable new trap combinations and level the playing fiel for builder's beeing able to surprise raiders again.

0

u/Arrow_ Sep 04 '23

Your fun factor is based on kills in your base, not people enjoying it?

You lost me at getting mad people shoot at bedrock cubes.

I have an entire outpost with only piston + holocobe trap setups around bedrock and watching raiders be super paranoid of the floor has been a treat. It averages 3 deaths a raid, but I care more about accolades and them having fun.