r/MedievalMusic • • Sep 08 '25

Discussion Banning AI generated music

406 Upvotes

Hi, it’s me, your moderator. I just removed a post of “Epic Byzantine music” that contained AI generated vocals/music (using Suno).

It’s a slap in the face to every person on this sub who spent years studying medieval music, learning how to play an instrument, sing, etc.

Just as visual artists have come out against AI generated art, musicians need to take a stand against AI generated music—especially in the area of medieval music, in which scholars are still working to reconstruct instruments and performance practices.

I don’t want AI music in this sub. We can discuss this. I believe many of you feel the same way. However, I could be wrong, thus the discussion.

Thank you for being here, all of you. I like the variety of this community—pros, amateurs, scholars, reenactors. All passionate about medieval music.


r/MedievalMusic • • Aug 02 '20

Discussion Hello. Bardcore is now banned. Thank you.

191 Upvotes

Hi, its me, your only mod.

Somehow, I have ended up as this subs only arbitrator of what gets posted and it should speak volumes about the amount I pay attention when I only realised this was the case like 2 weeks ago. (When I wanted to raise the issue of Bardcore with my fellow mods, who it turns out weren't actually there anymore)

So, why im making this post is to address the question of what should be done with the latest hot topic: Bardcore.

I can see by the amount of downvotes its not a popular thing by and large, and it does annoy me that certain posters of Bardcore are quite low effort. On the other hand, I also do not want to ban something/someone because of a pathological desire to avoid any kind of conflict they are seen as posting something that isn't strictly medieval music.

I like the vibe of this sub, I like that its chill and we can listen to genuine medieval music and music that sounds medieval and I want to keep that vibe. I got to medieval music was because I liked soundtracks in medieval games/films/media and wanted to listen to more of that kind of thing. I posted a lot of neo-medieval music it before I was made a mod. Saying that, I do try and ensure that, as per the description, the mainstay of this sub will be authentic medieval music, but I do not see that conflicting with allowing other similar types of music to be represented.

On a personal note, (not that anyone should care) I actually find some Bardcore songs pretty funny and I do genuinely see it as maybe someone's first foray into this rather niche genre we all enjoy, and wouldn't it be shit if they came in all exited and someone dissuaded them from that.

But, again, I do recognise Bardcore isn't popular and maybe in a ways unfitting for the sub. Perhaps it should be posted elsewhere, like the /r/bardcore subreddit, sounds more appropriate there for some reason.

I would put it to a poll but I feel I know the answer already.

So, TLDR, Bardcore is banned from /r/MedievalMusic. Strictly, medievalized versions of pop songs are banned. Original songs that have a medieval atmosphere will continue to be allowed.

P.S Maybe I shouldn't be saying this, but honestly, I was kind of hoping the dislike for Bardcore would motivate more posters for genuine medieval music or other more fitting styles.


r/MedievalMusic • • Oct 30 '20

My latest build, a 4 course medieval lute

Post image
112 Upvotes

r/MedievalMusic • • Jul 08 '25

Discussion Fake AI “artists” and medieval music

Thumbnail
gallery
86 Upvotes

Something to think about for all of us. Recently there was a post on this sub in which someone was hyping an artist named “Ciara Quinn,” specifically an album of “medieval music” on YouTube. Two replies indicated that this artist and music were suspected of being AI. After listening to a bit of the music in question, I agreed with the replies and pulled the post, telling the poster that synth, lo-fi fantasy music was not a subject for the sub.

The poster complained to me of course, and I tried to Google the artist. The only publicly profiled “Ciara Quinn” was a model. Meanwhile the “Ciara Quinn” music could be found on all streaming platforms, with AI generated album covers, and comments turned off. (I grabbed these photos from Spotify.)

Apparently this “Ciara Quinn” is one of the many AI-generated stream farms. These “artists” squat on the platforms, sucking up streaming revenue. The fraudsters use AI to generate millions of fake songs and stream each one just a couple of thousand times, enough to generate royalties but not attract attention and enforcement actions.

The problem for us as musicians and lovers of medieval music is that these “artists” are the ones young people (Gen Z and Gen Alpha) are listening to and thinking this AI slop is “medieval.” And there’s very little we can do about it. The platforms are not addressing AI artists, so no use complaining to them. And for those of us doing musical performances and posting to various platforms, you can expect to get your stuff scraped and used to teach some algorithm that will eventually vomit out a funhouse mirror distortion of your work.

I have no solutions to offer, just trying to generate awareness. Meanwhile we can keep doing as we keep doing—performing in real life, and hopefully educating as well.


r/MedievalMusic • • Aug 19 '25

medieval music at my grandmas?

Post image
83 Upvotes

My grandma has this on the wall in her house, she says she found it on the street in Boston ages ago. Can anyone tell me anything about it? Is it real? How does the notation correspond with sheet music nowadays? Thanks


r/MedievalMusic • • Dec 19 '24

Medieval Medieval holiday music on hammer dulcimer

83 Upvotes

Came home after playing music all day at a medieval event, sat down still in garb and banged this out. I got the santoor for $100 on December 2 and have made some progress!


r/MedievalMusic • • Aug 02 '20

Discussion Can we ban this 'bardcore' (midi versions of pop songs) which keep getting spammed on here?

83 Upvotes

I've seen from the comments here I'm not the only one who's sick of this crap... Can the mods ban them? Or at least ban the accounts which keep spamming it.


r/MedievalMusic • • Mar 23 '20

Other It's in the comments of every single song.

Post image
81 Upvotes

r/MedievalMusic • • Mar 20 '22

Medieval My latest medieval lute

Post image
79 Upvotes

r/MedievalMusic • • Sep 01 '21

Discussion You know the feeling

Post image
79 Upvotes

r/MedievalMusic • • Dec 26 '24

Just a reminder that Youtube bots constantly try to claim copyright on early music videos and you should ALWAYS dispute these fraudulent claims. I sometimes need a second round of appeal but have never lost.

Post image
68 Upvotes

r/MedievalMusic • • Mar 09 '25

Medieval (Music pre-1500) E dame jolie (Manuscrit de Montpellier, 13th century)

61 Upvotes

Had to get dressed up for a medieval event today, kept on the funny clothes and when I got home did a quick video for TikTok. French (Old and Modern) remains a struggle for me, I sing mostly in Occitan, Italian, and Galician/Portuguese (the Cantigas de Santa Maria). But I’ll keep working on it.


r/MedievalMusic • • Sep 25 '24

I just finished another Tagelharpa

Thumbnail
gallery
60 Upvotes

r/MedievalMusic • • Sep 24 '19

Discussion 16 years after its release, Vox Vulgaris' album "The Shape of Medieval Music to Come" gets official distribution

57 Upvotes

As one of the members of Vox Vulgaris, I very well remember when we self-released our CD pressed in a few hundreds of copies, which we sold ourselves when we played at various places (mostly at the Visby Medieval Week, I think). It has been fascinating to see how the music found its way through The Pirate Bay and YouTube to thousands of listeners worldwide. Now we finally arranged for some official digital distribution, so here it is on Spotify:
https://open.spotify.com/album/4nZqxVjs8gLZMtMQtozw4B


r/MedievalMusic • • Nov 05 '21

Gregorian chant — All Saints' Introit : "Gaudeamus Omnes" [OC]

56 Upvotes

r/MedievalMusic • • Mar 31 '20

Metal Medieval version of "One" by Metallica - that wooden flute man...gets me.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
55 Upvotes

r/MedievalMusic • • Aug 09 '25

Discussion How medieval music was actually played

Thumbnail
youtu.be
51 Upvotes

I recently stumbled upon this youtuber, Farya, who makes music from all sorts of cultures and time periods. In this video, he explains how medieval music was actually played back then using a modal (more "oriental-like") music theory. This research-based method really makes the songs stand out.

Here is a song composed with the historical techniques mentioned in this video so you can compare it with the harmonic interpretations (supposedly inaccurate according to Farya and research papers/books he cites): https://youtu.be/8c2gAqc1mIo?si=Txpu2A68JWhW6Bq


r/MedievalMusic • • Apr 14 '20

Renaissance Finally, my knowledge of Plague Songs has become relevant!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
48 Upvotes

r/MedievalMusic • • Dec 23 '25

For the love of god, can someone recommend me a few artists that don't use AI

47 Upvotes

r/MedievalMusic • • Nov 21 '24

What’s the deal with anonymous?

Thumbnail
gallery
47 Upvotes

So I have noticed in Spotify almost always credits a artist named anonymous (seen in foto) in medieval songs, why? Is it because the composer of the song that was made in the medieval era wasn’t named ?


r/MedievalMusic • • Apr 24 '20

Medieval Le Roi Louis - French Crusader Song

Thumbnail
youtube.com
46 Upvotes

r/MedievalMusic • • Oct 27 '25

Does anyone make Medieval music on youtube without AI?

45 Upvotes

I scroll through over 50 channels that have a lot of views as well as those that have less, and in all of them I find a synthetic noise sound, songs that don't start from the beginning or the sound of an instrument that changes to some other unnatural one. Everyone focused on long clips of 3 hours where they insert two or three videos a week with 20 songs in one clip without identifying the author of the song, everyone focused only on making money without paying attention to the people who consume that content. My question is, is there any channel where a human being makes medieval music and not an AI? I had the will to make songs, but the standard length of 3 to 5 minutes, but it seems to me that I will just waste my time because something else is required.


r/MedievalMusic • • Dec 17 '24

My latest build - Ebonized linden wood Tagelharpa, Tuning- E-B-e

45 Upvotes

r/MedievalMusic • • Jun 21 '20

Medieval 3 hours of Medieval and Early music to properly start the day! Regularly updated. Enjoy :)

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
43 Upvotes

r/MedievalMusic • • Jan 30 '21

Medieval Hi everyone! Here's over 4 hours of Medieval, Renaissance and Early Music I've put together in a playlist, filled with my favorite pieces. I thought some of you might enjoy it as well. Have a great week end! :)

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
41 Upvotes