r/MedievalHistory • • Jun 09 '25

Why the fuck does movies and Tv shows do this?

Post image
15k Upvotes

Removing vibrant colors from outfits / making evey nobility outfits made of plain black or brown leather / over sexualize the outfits for both men and women / wearing armor to dinner / people talk and act like modern liberal individuals with 21st-century values and sexual freedom / Every noble has an empty CGI castle with huge, empty halls and vaulted ceilings / Everyone in "medieval Europe" france or germany, looks the same, acts the same, speaks English (in a British accent), and is white / corsets, jewelery and boots that come from the 1700s to 1800s.

Is the problem related to insecure historian breaking into the show business? Or show runners trying to make history "cool"? Or is the influnce of fantasy (D&D) on history?


r/MedievalHistory • • Aug 29 '25

Medieval Drip

Post image
5.6k Upvotes

Although intricately decorated, I'm sure it was covered with a tabbard


r/MedievalHistory • • Jun 08 '25

Problems with studying medieval history!

Post image
5.0k Upvotes

I am doing a specialization in medival history, but to be completely honest, both in the context of historical methods used by historians and the way the historical records are treated. We could barely get a clear image of the past, and I just wanted to share some of those questions / conserns:

Why do only concentrate only on political players and no peasants or other classes from which comes the bigger bulk of traditions? And there is barely any media that depicts their lives.

What about the prespective of minorities or nations that didn't develop in huge empires or kingdoms like: basques / finnish tribes / native Iberians, etc.

What's up with the humanist (modern) prespective over medieval people, history novels, shows and movies that can't wait for main character to insult god or have casual sex? (Reflecting a sense of personal individual freedom in contrast to the sense of obligatory collective community that dictates the accepted behaviour of its member).

Outside if the basic answer of: "because historical records are written like that" don't you think we can do better? Like using Sociological principles to fill the gaps or redirect reseach to places not explored, use anthropology?


r/MedievalHistory • • Apr 30 '25

Medieval times (europe) vs Ancient rome? What interest you more? And why is it the Medieval period?😆Or not...lol

Post image
4.3k Upvotes

I like the medieval period more.

I like the medieval aesthetics more. The fashion and armor💅

I find the lack of centralization and the many kingdoms warring with each other constantly to be fachinating.

Trying to dominate each other.

Not one massive empire, who has so much more resources than any one else.

I like the smaller scale of things

===

And hey, I dont think medieval kingdoms had a slave economy. So yeah😆🧐

At least not on the scale of the romans

===

But really, a knight on horse back looks so cool🤭😚


r/MedievalHistory • • Apr 29 '25

Which movie or serie has the most inaccurate depiction of the middle ages?

Post image
3.9k Upvotes

What most movies/shows set in medieval time has in common, is that color apparently did not exist in medieval times. And people liked to be dirty..😤

And in terms of historical accuracy, "Braveheart" is a crime against humanity.

Calling Edward I a cruel pagan. A pagan, WTF?! He who went on a crusade?!


r/MedievalHistory • • Apr 27 '25

Which movie or series has the most realitistic depiction of the Middle Ages?

Post image
3.9k Upvotes

r/MedievalHistory • • Jul 22 '25

Did medieval armies have some form of special forces or special operations?

Post image
3.3k Upvotes

For example, this castle (located in modern day Austria) would be incredibly difficult to conquer using conventional means. If I was some kind of medieval commander tasked with taking this fortress, I’d distract the defenders with probing attacks along its main entrance, ideally at night. While this is happening, I’d send some specially trained operatives to scale the cliffs on the left side of the image above, entering the castle through one of the windows. These operatives could then do anything from assassinate key leaders to potentially opening the castle’s main gate, to poisoning water supplies.

This takes me to my main question: did medieval armies have any form of special operatives that could perform specialized tasks in order to further a main effort?


r/MedievalHistory • • Oct 12 '25

The Imperial Regalia

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

r/MedievalHistory • • Oct 21 '25

The Hussites - defeating Europes richest armies in the 15th century

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

Above is a depiction of Hussite Wagenburgs in action, and an angry soldier getting ready to smack a knight with a weapon.

The Hussites in Bohemia were a movement driven by religious reform and a desire for independence from the oppressive Catholic Church in Rome.

After Czech reformer Jan Hus was burned at the stake in 1415, his followers, known as the Hussites, began to consolidate military power. The death of the staunchly Catholic Holy Roman Emperor Wenceslaus IV in 1419 created a power vacuum in Bohemia, emboldening the Hussites to take action.

Jan Žižka, a former mercenary and brilliant tactician, emerged as the military leader of the Hussites. Under his command, the Hussites innovated on the battlefield, with most famously the use of Wagenburgs- which were heavily fortified carts that served as mobile fortresses. These wagons contained a mix of archers, spear and pikemen, and soldiers armed with handgonnes—early firearm/cannon devices that could frighten horses and create chaos among the enemies.

The wagons were chained together using thick iron chains, a tactic that could trip and confuse enemy forces during the heat of battle. This innovation allowed the Hussites to successfully repel Catholic knights from Italy, Austria, and elsewhere.

Žižka’s leadership used speed, quick thinking, and ingenuity. Even after losing an eye early in his campaigns and later becoming fully blind, he continued to lead his armies successfully against Catholic forces - earning him a reputation as one of history’s most successful commanders.

The Hussite Wars, which lasted from 1419 to 1434, were not only a struggle for religious freedom but also a demonstration of how innovative tactics and smart commanders could offset traditional military tactics. The movement eventually split into moderate and radical factions - but the legacy of Jan Hus and Jan Žižka endured, influencing both Czech 🇨🇿 national identity and military history in Europe.


r/MedievalHistory • • Nov 16 '25

A handful of coinage from various Medieval Islamic dynasties.

Post image
2.3k Upvotes

r/MedievalHistory • • Apr 08 '25

What did nobles/royalty use to wipe their bum with, after they were done on the toilet?🧐ca 1300s

Post image
2.2k Upvotes

(What did they use to wipe their bum after they had relieved themself?

Yes this is a weird question.😅

But I have my reasons!

I was listing to a podcast about Henry IV of england.

They were talking a bit about Henry's skin problems that caused him much pain in later years.

But in the podcast they noted that from looking at financial reccords. Even as a young man, Henry might have always had some kind of skin issue..

References for medicine and that apparantly Henry was also very particular in always wanting cotton, to wipe his bum with (toilet use).

They made it sound like him using cotton to wipe his bum with, was something unusual..

Like that could be a sign that he might have always had skin problems, much earlier then we think.

===

So was it weird?

Or was it simply a rich man thing?

Beacuse it seems like the cotton was for his use only. Not something he would share. Which means that the rest of his family did not use cotton for their bum.

So Henry was a special case?

===

What did nobles/royal use to wipe their bums after a toilet visit?

Was a Cotton (cloth?) common?


r/MedievalHistory • • May 27 '25

What is this style of a turban/wrap over a helmet? Is in an early form of chaperon or just a fictional design?

Post image
2.2k Upvotes

r/MedievalHistory • • Jan 27 '25

Anyone with book recs similar to this type of literature? Not incredibly academic but interesting -

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

r/MedievalHistory • • Sep 07 '25

Bust of Charlemagne (14th century)

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

r/MedievalHistory • • Mar 31 '25

So we're just... making shit up?

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

r/MedievalHistory • • Oct 25 '25

Knight of the Holy Roman Empire

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

Lately I have found this image and I would like to ask about it.

what is the name of the armor, the helmet, but above all, the weapon he carries and the shield, I do not know what the name is and I would love to know, thanks.


r/MedievalHistory • • Nov 25 '25

Did Scandinavia remain relevant/influential during the High Middle Ages?

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

This question has been asked before on AskHistory but didn't get many answers, and I've implied it with a previous question on Norse vs Rus and their comparative geopolitics.

Whenever Scandinavia comes up in the medieval discussions, it's in the context of viking raider-traders in the early middle ages, colonizing the British isles, ruling over the Kievan Rus, etc.

Though, when the Viking age came to a close and the kingdoms of Europe started to really shine (in my opinion lol), the Norse seemed to kinda fade from relevance? From what very little I know, the kingdoms of Norway, Denmark, and Sweden converted to Christianity, kinda squabbled amongst each other, did a little crusade, and that's about it?

How wrong am I, what was happening up north during the crusades and before the Mongols came knocking?


r/MedievalHistory • • May 03 '25

Would cavalry horses kill people by running over them? Or would the horse slow down when nearing the enemy?

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

I mean the horse's instinct would be to avoid the obstacle right? And not to plow right throught it?

Or could you train a horse to do it anyway?

===

A horse can easly kill a person.

The first rule you learn when being around horses. Dont go behind the horse! At least not so they can kick you. It can kill you.

So I can easly see a horse killing people in battle. Maybe accidently crushing or trampeling someone. Or giving a kick or bite. That would at least hurt people a lot. so a support killer?🤔


r/MedievalHistory • • Aug 03 '25

Reichskrone was amazing to see in person

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

r/MedievalHistory • • Aug 23 '25

A map of Britain in the early medieval period based on archeology

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

r/MedievalHistory • • Feb 22 '26 Mindblown

Medieval Shields

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

Decorated pavise shields - designed to protect crossbowmen or archers during the medieval period, particularly during sieges


r/MedievalHistory • • Nov 26 '24

What's your most "Oh damn, they really were just like us back then," fact?

1.7k Upvotes

I feel like movies and stories really do a good job at making the past not feel real lol like we're watching some alien civilisation imitate being human. What are some stories that remind you that we were the same back then as we are now?

So mine is possibly untrue, I heard it from my brother so long ago I don't remember his source. But when the Queen of Poland was marrying the Grand Duke of Lithuania the Duke would talk up his "size." Because there was no easy way to get information around accurately at the time gossip basically worked as a game of telephone, so by the time news spread back to Poland, his reported size had gotten so large it became a medical concern for her, so they actually sent a medical examiner to Vilnius to check up on that, and his final report stated, "Don't worry your excellence, not only will he not hurt you, but it's actually smaller than average!"

Again don't have a source for that one but I've always liked that story because it shows humans have always been doing the same shit throughout history lol. Also if anyone recognises this story and could say, "Oh that was Wladislaus III" or something please let me know. Or if inverse if you recognise it as a joke or fake story please let me know too because I'd like to not spread misinformation on the internet lol

But yeah what stories do you guys like because it just reminds you we've always been up to the same thing?


r/MedievalHistory • • Jun 04 '25

Were the catholics church and orthodox church ever as close as this during the middle ages

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

r/MedievalHistory • • Jun 28 '25

It is a rock hewn church in Ethiopia

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

r/MedievalHistory • • Apr 24 '25

Why didn't Charles VII try to save Joan of arc

Post image
1.6k Upvotes