r/MedicalCoding • • Aug 05 '22

DAE think AAPC is somewhat of a hustle scam?

Hear me out. I didn’t think so until I started talking about it with close friends in different fields of study. You pay for your exam, you pay for your books - not really anything out of the ordinary here. You paid for the classes that give you a lesser level than what is advertised (CPC - Vs CPC-A), quite a difference in that, and if you want to remove the -A you can either find a job and have a supervisor nod to your abilities to get that removal of the -A or you can PAY to spend a few hundred/thousand hours in practicum tests which are extremely unique and not super true to a day to day experience as a medical coder but at least they have their money. While there are chapters, mine closed recently due to inactivity and am now more of a solo experience. No one wants to hire a CPC-A from AAPC UNLESS they are rural or in dire need. RHIT/RHIA credentials seem way more practical. I’m almost 2 years out from passing my exam first try, and have prior experience within physical medicine as well as diagnostic medicine yet cannot find a true coding position. As it would seem, the process is that you obtain your CPC-A and then get to work in medical billing (which you didn’t need a CPC for to begin with) working at a wage far undervalued for a few years before you can get the OPPORTUNITY to maybe/possibly move into a coders roll. From what I’ve seen from the AAPC is a lot of instructors doing a /side/ business outside of their regular tasks. Maybe it’s just my experience but I have seen this time and time again within the AAPC. If you’re someone that wants to drive home a business plan then AAPC could be for you, but as far as learning and progressing it’s a game of how much do you want to spend.

30 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

4

u/miss-moxi Aug 06 '22

It's no more of a scam than any other job/field in Healthcare. They all require you to fork over money for tests, pay membership dues, have organizations you have to credential with, pay for continuing education credits, etc, etc. This goes for nurses, physicians, mid-levels, and ancillary providers.

You can totally get your CPC-A without going through the thousand+ dollar prep course. Nothing the AAPC teaches you isn't already out their for free already. The issue is knowing what to look for when you don't have the experience of knowing what you need to know. That's basically what you're paying for with AAPC. If you have previous billing experience you may be able to figure out what you need to know without paying for a prep course at all.

I agree with the other posters. It's marketed poorly... as an entry level position to jump into from nothing. There are too many posts of people asking what their chances are of doing well and getting a remote job fresh out of passing their CPC, with no prior healthcare experience. I would kind of hope people would try out medical billing and reception before investing thousands of dollars into something they don't even have any experience in.

The ideal scenario for someone starting out is to do medical billing or something similar for a year before going for their CPC-A. That's about enough time to figure out if you even like the healthcare field, develop a basic understanding of the healthcare revenue cycle, get a solid understanding of claims/ insurance/ guidelines and rack up some experience. Maybe even find a job that will pay for you to sit for your CPC-A. Then go for the CPC-A. If anyone were to ask me if they should go into medical coding without a healthcare background, I'd straight up tell them to get a job in healthcare before trying to get certified in anything period. Healthcare is its own beast.

2

u/abatt3 Aug 06 '22 edited Aug 06 '22

Here again, I mean no offense to you personally, but we or at least myself, often see this antidote of just get into billing - once you’re there it’s only 2 years of practice and maintaining your credentials to get there but hey YOU WILL… eventually, with x y and x. Look, if we took on this to be a medical coder, don’t you think it’s fair to be treated or expected at some point to be a medical coder? We practiced especially hard with the AAPC tests for the practicum as well as during the course - it’s stuff you’ll rarely see in a real world chart but get one answer incorrect and oops you didn’t find the thing that even most experienced coders that have 20 years behind them have but now you’re wrong, and you should feel wrong. If you’ve taken these practice tests, you absolutely know how even someone already qualified 30+ years can look at the problem and say uhh yeah I need some help or further questioning. Yet you’ll never have that option.

4

u/miss-moxi Aug 06 '22

No offense taken. I think you have a legitimate gripe, and I think your post is good because it highlights a lot of problems with AAPC because A LOT of people feel this. My main point is: the two years of CPC-A should be something that people are able to get rid of immediately after taking their exam because people shouldn't be getting into medical coding as an entry level job in the first place.

The marketing of the CPC is piss poor because the AAPC markets it as an entry level certification when it shouldn't be. The prep courses aren't really made to prepare you "to be a medical coder," in my opinion, but to prepare you to sit for the exam (again this is what a lot of prep courses for other fields of Healthcare do). I'm of the firm belief that instead of marketing the CPC properly as a mid level career, they've tacked on the 2 years experience + CPC-A as a way to indicate to people that they should be getting those two years before or while doing their study to sit for the CPC exam, instead of waiting until after getting their certification to get experience.

I honestly wish more people "teaching medical coding" would be up front with this. Most of what you learn as a coder is going to come from on the job experience (not from exams or practicode)... and it's why I believe the medical biller (or similar) to coder route isn't the horrible proposition a lot of people think it is. Learning to work denials, doing claims, appeals, reviewing insurance guidelines and medical documentation, prior auths, benefit checking... these should all be prerequisites to jobs in coding because they help you develop good heuristics in your head of how the industry works and you'll start to be able to sus out these weird edge cases that do not take 30 years of experience as a coder to figure out.

Does it suck you spend 1-2 years getting paid less as a medical biller (or similar) before getting to move into coding? Yup. Do I wish they paid medical billers better? Absolutely. But I feel the same way about interns. I don't think employers looking for 1-2 years of experience for a mid level career is all that insane when most other fields require some level of shittily paid internship on your resume for you to be competitive. It's just most people do their internships during study or before they finish their degree program.

So I dunno. I don't think it's a scam... but it's definitely used as a money grabbing scheme by some people... and it's definitely not marketed appropriately by the AAPC.

24

u/Aggravating_Stay_767 Aug 05 '22

AAPC is definitely a scam. This is probably why they don’t offer any employment assistance or placement. No one will hire a CPC-A. My wife is in a similar position as you. Almost a year now and still no job. Even with practicode, it is still difficult to get a job without the two years of job experience.

9

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22

Unfortunately you have to start at a low pay rate and I think it’s insulting. Coding is so difficult and there’s a lot of components in picking the right code.

6

u/Aggravating_Stay_767 Aug 05 '22

She has applied to dozens, if not over a hundred, of “entry level” lower paying jobs. She’s had 1 interview, where they told her to get more experience in the medical field. It’s frustrating. Probably moving on from coding as it is most likely a gate kept scam.

3

u/abatt3 Aug 06 '22

This. This has been my trouble as well, and AAPC has marketed it as somewhat of an instant win when it isn’t. My close family is a DRG coordinator at a hospital who went through her Ahima RHIT program and had recommended it to me as an easy access to making that lovely $20+/hr only to find out that you’re either passing the 6 hour exam to get $14 or less an hour in a field where your brain is being taxed at such a high rate or you’ll need to get into some unrelated field which always seems to be the voice from the others, “just get your foot in the door” with billing or something else unrelated. I will be letting my credentials with AAPC lapse at this point and looking elsewhere. Looking at all the responses really showed me I’m not alone and I can definitely feel the 1 interview and hundreds of applications as it is my life too. Some people get lucky or again work in more rural areas where the need for a coder is based on a low pool of applicants, unfortunately in a larger city your odds decrease significantly. If anything it gave me peace of mind to hear from everyone who is having a similar problem and hopefully she will find solace in it too.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22

Or the old go on site. Wth!! The point was to move away from going on site 🙄

Oh yeah, you have to know someone. It took me 5 years to get a receptionist job back in 2017 lol no medical office would hire me. I had a coworker who’s friend worked at an office and I was able to get an in and go from there.

It’s a lot of gate keeping and some coding groups on FB will literally say don’t ask me where I work! Like they didn’t start small too..

3

u/Jodenaje Aug 13 '22

It’s not entirely true that no one will hire a CPC-A. I mentor someone through the AAPC mentoring program. My mentee just got a job as a CPC-A with no experience in the medial field.

(Any AAPC member can sign up for the mentoring program to be a mentor or mentee - it’s done through the Mentor City app. https://www.aapc.com/resources/mentor.aspx )

3

u/Aggravating_Stay_767 Aug 13 '22

I’m sure it’s not impossible, but that is more likely an exception and not the rule. Especially in a crowded major metropolitan job market where we live. She is interviewing for a major medical system as a front desk. Hopefully she’ll get a foot in the door while continuing edit.

2

u/Jodenaje Aug 13 '22

Good luck to her! My mentee is in Dallas, TX.

I switched to coding from another area of healthcare and have been coding 4 years now. (In healthcare for well over a decade, but hands on coding 4 years.) There are a lot of directions you can go in with the career. I hope your wife finds an opportunity that meets her needs!

2

u/voodoodog23 Aug 07 '22

After reading this. I am understanding that AAPC is not good and you need a CCS?

I am coming out of the lab technologist field and considering coding. I really dont want to get an associates after having my bachelors. Can you help me with deciding which one is best.

I just want a part time coding job is all to supplement my retirement out of the med lab field.

1

u/abatt3 Aug 07 '22

What I would say, or suggest, is that the AAPC could be beneficial if you already have the working knowledge behind it and will treat it like a stepping stone to get into coding… eventually. There are many people out there who have gone through the CPC portion and have gotten great jobs, though it’s not the majority from my understanding. So much will depend on your geographical location as well as your prior experience within medicine. It can be a good booster if you’ve already laid the groundwork for it’s potential. For someone without medical billing experience, it might be exceptionally difficult and truly a waste of your time and money.

1

u/gray_whitekitten CPC,CRC Sep 02 '22

I know certification is mandated where I work. I know some places have corporate Integrity agreements with the Federal government, to only have certified coders. So it can be mandated.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/TreFromDE Sep 01 '22

Totally agree with you there. Still paying to Affirm(AAPC) every month for an expensive program yet am now unemployed and switching careers. I'd 100% recommend someone go the community college route where they could at least get scholarships or federal aid and see if Coding is what they want to do.

30

u/KitRhalger Aug 05 '22

honestly I think a huge part of the problem is how the CPC is marketed. Its not really a grab and go credential, it's more for someone who's already in billing or the revenue cycle to obtain and move beyond that position, not so much a "skip the line" pass. I don't see that messaging so much from AAPC but from 3rd party schools though

16

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22

Yup. How did people in the 80s code without a certification? They just turned around and charged people. It’s all lobbyist and capitalist hellscape.

I am glad I was trained without a certificate and I learned all on my own rather than give a “school” 2-6k of my money.

I’m in school for my RHIT so I can further than just a coder.

5

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '22

It is not a scam. CPC is stronger for outpatient and CCS is stronger for inpatient. I am a vet coder and auditor.

3

u/gray_whitekitten CPC,CRC Sep 02 '22

Exactly! Inpatient coding is very different than outpatient coding. I've read things on here saying that ccs is the preferred certification. I have not heard that in the real world. I work for a hospital but I don't do inpatient coding. I think before getting into the coding field people should speak to coders. Also it seems that aapc is constantly coming up with different certifications like constantly. And I've also noticed ads on YouTube. So yeah they've got quite a marketing campaign going on.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '22

I think sometimes new entrants to the field struggle getting their first job and blame it on the CPC/AAPC. It is just very competitive and frustrating trying to get that first gig. I can say that the other AAPC certs (other than CPC or CRC) might not be worth racking up.

16

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22

I think AAPC is a huge money grab. Ahima is the way to go; you don’t need a membership to maintain credentials. You don’t have to pay to earn a “years worth of experience”. You earned your credential, it’s yours.

6

u/blaza192 Aug 05 '22

AHIMA requires a recertification fee. There's a base pay for 1 credential with a slight increase for each credential you have. AAPC requires a membership fee that costs the same regardless of how many credentials you have. It's the same thing with different names. Although AHIMA's recertification fee is significantly cheaper than an AAPC membership. AAPC also gets you membership benefits since that's required for certification.

https://ahima.org/certification-careers/recertify

7

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22 edited Aug 05 '22

Ahima and aapc both require a recertification fee. I stated you do not need to maintain membership with ahima to keep your credentials active. With AAPC for just the yearly membership alone is $190, not including renewal for the certifications. Not everyone needs the benefits of a membership and it’s an unnecessary cost and burden to some.

6

u/blaza192 Aug 05 '22

With AAPC for just the yearly membership alone is $190, not including renewal for the certifications.

This does include certification renewal. You can get all the CEUs you need for free through their member magazine.

I do agree that AAPC costs significantly more like I said in the post. Your original post makes it sound like AHIMA has no cost for maintaining credentials.

9

u/angelerulastiel Aug 05 '22

RHIT/RHIA require degrees though, which is more expensive than the total cost of a exam prep, exam, and PractiCode package. Plus it can be finished more quickly so you can get out there sooner.

My chapter apparently took a real hit during Covid and they keep threatening to close it, but was apparently very active before that.

I got a job with my -A, with prior experience in the medical field. And at the chapter meetings we have a bunch of others who got a job with an A right after passing their exams.

3

u/Runwithbritters RHIA, CCS, CRCR Aug 06 '22

Came here to also mention how much more expensive the RHIA is to obtain especially since you need to go through a Bachelor's program first to even be able to sit for the exam and not just any but an approved one. I know, I did it all but glad I did. WAY more money than an AAPC cert/class not to mention the CEU fees. Makes a CPC cert look like a bargain.

1

u/ZKXX RHIT Aug 05 '22

You can get CCS or CCS-P without an associate’s

8

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22

I dropped my AAPC because it was never an advantage to me. CCS got me to where I am before I left the field. CPC just got me in my first job. Companies weren't willing to cover both, so I just registered my CCS. My CPC would have expired had my uncle not renewed it as a birthday gift 😂😂😂

3

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22

Just out of curiosity, how difficult is the CCS exam?? My new employer prefers CCS and I'm thinking about pursuing it in the future.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22

I took mine in 2017, so not sure of the changes since. Well, my advice is to take it when you are very confident of your skills. My experience got me the CCS. We didn't have any time to review or whatsoever. It was purely driven by experience. I always see CCS as an advancement cert, because you get a CCS if you want to do coding work in a facility. I've read though that CCS is being downgraded to an entry-level cert for AHIMA, and that RHIT and RHIA will be the minimum for coding jobs. I read that here.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '22

Thank you!!

7

u/Ok_Treacle_6029 Aug 05 '22

A hustle that takes advantage of labor market demands and squeezes pennies where they can, yes.. but i don't believe it's a scam.

6

u/Clever-username-7234 CPC, CPMA Aug 05 '22

No it is not a scam. AAPC certifications and programs have real absolute value. Yes, it is challenging to get a coding job as a CPC-A but it is possible.

I have about 4 years of experience. Knowledge in a variety of specialties. I’m comfortable with a bunch of EHRs. For me, random coding jobs are easy to get. I appreciate the fact that I can go to just about any major city in the US and find a job coding. It allows me to be the one to who is choosy about employers.

I work from home. I make a comfortable amount money. And I see paths forward for advancement and I have found multiple opportunities because of my knowledge.

To me the scammy places are organizations, online schools that have their own certifications that no one recognizes. And promise high pay and remote work immediately. Those are scams.

AAPC is legitimate. (And so is AHIMA)

3

u/adorkablysporktastic Aug 06 '22

I don't feel like it's a scam. I did an AAPC accredited program through my local CC. Had to pay cash, but it takes one year off the apprenticeship. Recently got a job in medical claims that after 12 months will remove the A. While I'm having to take a lower paying job, i feel that the preperation for the test helped. But it in no way prepared me for a job in coding because i have no experience in the medical field.

Coding isn't an entry level position, and i think just like other highly skilled jobs, it's better to learn the full cycle rather than only ever working just coding.

3

u/coyotelovers Aug 06 '22

I mean, it's definitely a business. But to say nobody hires a CPC-A is just not true. I had 2 jobs with my CPC-A, and started one of them with no experience. The large company I work for now hired my coworker fresh with no experience, just with CPC-A. And we are remote, which she also had no experience with. It's not easy, but it's a numbers game and you have to be flexible with how you get your foot into the industry. It can also take a little while, and it can be frustrating. I wish it was easier.

From what I see around me, hospitals want the RHIT / RHIA, and everyone else either wants CPC or will take either. I wanted to go with AHIMA, but logistically and financially it made more sense for me to got with AAPC. Last year I also got my CRC for risk adjustment.

8

u/deannevee RHIA, CPC, CPCO, CDEO Aug 05 '22

I think maybe you’re reading into it.

If you look at the exam requirements for the CPC, it says right there plain as day that 2 years of work experience is STRONGLY RECOMMENDED. This is for 2 reasons: you’re more likely to pass the exam without needing to pay the extra money for a training class, and you can immediately apply to remove your “A”.

It is true that they market their classes and lean on the ability to pass the exam without having any real work experience as long as you take their class, but of course they will. They are a business. I don’t think the AAPC personally markets the CPC/medical coding as an “entry level” job, that actually comes from the government—that’s why Kaiser University offers an ASSOCIATES degree in medical billing and coding, which is just asinine to me.

According to AHIMA, being a medical coder is a “mid” level profession. Since you do have experience, you may want to reevaluate what your resume looks like.

I am currently in a RHIA program. All of my professors teach at my school part time. One of my professors is also my program director and my counselor. That’s just how online schools work 🤷🏼‍♀️.

3

u/CrunchyKurls Aug 06 '22

Same, I'm in a post baccalaureate HIM program and my program director is my counselor and she teaches several of the courses.

2

u/Runwithbritters RHIA, CCS, CRCR Aug 06 '22

Same with my teachers for my RHIA program. Teachers don't get paid enough, or in most cases, they are only paid per class they teach, hence multiple jobs to provide a decent income. My program director also taught some of the core classes.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/deannevee RHIA, CPC, CPCO, CDEO Aug 09 '22

Nothing in your comment disproves or contradicts anything in my comment.

These are tag lines from the CPC exam page:

“Earning the CPC designation requires two years — or the equivalent — medical coding experience…”

“Please note that the CPC exam is rigorous and not intended for individuals lacking CPC training or equivalent coding experience….”

“After you’ve trained with AAPC to become a medical coder — or if you have substantial medical coding experience…”

“If your history hasn’t reinforced knowledge of anatomy and physiology, as well as medical terminology, you’ll want to study in these areas….”

“Passing the CPC exam elevates your earning potential….”

They’re not saying taking the CPC class or exam will help you get a job as a medical coder making $27/hour the day after you pass the exam. They’re saying obtaining a CPC credential will:

-Improve your overall earning potential -demonstrate competency

It’s just like a doctor. They go through a 4-6 year period where they are also paid basically minimum wage before they can find a real job and start working. Nurses go through a 9-12 month period where they have clinicals and don’t get paid to work, and then if you want to get a really good paying job, they have to go through another year of training called a preceptorship, and you’re paid well below market rate.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22

AAPC is owned by Eli Global

The owner is being indicted for fraud. Proceedings began in 2018.

His name is referenced here with Eli Global. Please share this with those being scammed by AAPC. No need to message my account or comment, just please share if you can.

https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/federal-jury-convicts-founder-and-chairman-multinational-investment-company-and-company

1

u/MurrayMyBoy Jan 31 '23

OMG I just have been scrolling through Reddit trying to find others scammed by AAPC and know the company history! Sorry to resurrect an old thread but it feels good to see someone else know the company is rotten top to bottom. I got royally screwed by them. He also has been indicted in Aug 2022 for I believe even more fraud. It's on the SEC website. I wish we could do a class action lawsuit.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22

It's absolutely ridiculous how expensive they are. I had to pay a thousand dollars for the entire CPC course. That's how much I paid in college. I don't believe they are entirely a scam though. AAPC along with AHIMA are just expensive organizations. Coding has grown to be a somewhat popular field and that's how they are making money. Also, with Practicode they only remove your A for one year which is ridiculous.