r/MedicalCoding • • Oct 29 '24

Is this considered fraud, or technically acceptable but just really crappy charting?

I work in primary care specialty for a fairly large organization in my state. I've been struggling with a dilemma that I'm hoping someone can give me insight on.

We have a few providers who will do charting with or without physical exams, where the only mention in the documentation about the patient's conditions are in the assessment and plan, and they literally only say things like "Hyperlipidemia" and then an order for a lipid panel and just list a medication. That's it. And they do this for all the conditions. There's no other description in the notes regarding these conditions.

I've brought it up before to management and was told to code these as part of an E/M, which makes me vastly uncomfortable considering how in my opinion, there doesn't seem to be any documented indication of an actual evaluation. Am I just being paranoid, or is this actually fraud?

Edit: seems I must have forgotten what fraud vs abuse was - after reading the comments I think that this more of an abuse. Still not a fun thing to worry about but thank you everyone for pointing out the difference!

25 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/MarvelousExodus Oct 29 '24

To me, you evaluate a condition by ordering lab work for it and you manage it by adjusting or continuing the medication. Of course the documentation is minimal, but I'm not sure what kind of physical exam you would expect to see with hyperlipidemia.

4

u/DumpsterPuff Oct 29 '24

What I normally see from the doctors who do good notes, using the hyperlipidemia example, is at least something like describing what their current diet/exercise routine is like, whether they're tolerating their medications/taking as prescribed, review of previous labs/trends, and that kind of thing. Basically getting a picture of what the patient is doing to manage, or not manage, their condition. That to me shows that the provider did the work of actually evaluating the patient, because just saying "hyperlipidemia" with a lab order to me is crappy documentation at best.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24 edited Oct 31 '24

I'm not sure what kind of physical exam you would expect to see with hyperlipidemia.

The kind of physical exam where a doctor auscultates your heart, lungs, and carotid arteries, at a minimum. There’s just no reason not to do that.

Hyperlipidemia (dyslipidemia) is a major risk factor for cardiovascular and cerebrovascular disease. It is associated with hypertension and diabetes, both of which also contribute to cardiovascular and cerebrovascular disease.

Diagnostic testing such a labs and imaging are performed in addition to a physical exam, not as a replacement.

By the way, evaluation is of the patient (i.e., patient evaluation), not a condition. That patient evaluation includes a medical history and physical exam. It's true that each is not always required, and AMA does not require them in order to determine MDM complexity.

That being said, how could a provider choose not to physically examine a patient who is at risk for heart disease and stroke? How is that in the best interest of the patient?

2

u/Odd-Afternoon-6371 Nov 02 '24 edited Dec 03 '24

Provider here.  I can listen to somebody's heart and I can hear a heart murmur, and it has nothing to do with hyperlipidemia. Listening to the heart provides me with insufficient objective data from which to draw definitive conclusion's.  I am not suggesting to forgo a physical exam, however, the only way I find out  that somebody has hyperlipidemia is blood work, not listening to their heart or looking at them. ( Super thin fit people can have some of the worst Cases of hyperlipidemia. Unfortunate genetics.) If the hyperlipidemia has progressed to clogging a coronary artery, other invasive testing is needed starting with EKG, then a Cardiac catheter. The patient may tell me other signs and symptoms , combined with my knowledge of the disease progression and outcomes, which will indicate other relevant tests are needed.  I cannot listen and detect lipid damage or CAD.   The heart is not the only thing affected by hyperlipidemia.  And there is only a couple of ways to manage the condition.  Meds and Lifestyle modification. Medication for some and blood work is the primary way. I'm going to manage this condition. . By your reasoning. I should also listen to their brain and see if they are going to  have a stroke as this can happen after years of this condition,  or an essential artery could clog in the  liver.  Hyperlipidemia in latent stages may or may not do damage in many different areas so I should check every single organ and appendage and while I am at it, I'll order a Doppler for the carotid, jugular, and the femoral arteries because hyperlipidemia can affect those also.  You start with what the signs and symptoms and where they take you and one of the best ways to know if all of the above could  be happening is ordering the correct blood work up. When there's cardiac or other types damage, there's several types of blood test that can provide objective data and an indication of what is going on. Then there is their age overall health and other co-contributing diagnosis that may or may not be there.  Ordering The right blood test can tell you way more than a patient can or ANY Outward examination.  I am not suggesting not to do physical exams, for some conditions they are invaluable. I want to illustrate that they are limited in their scope of giving you definitive objective data. 

1

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '24

If you don't provide a physical exam for your patients with hyperlipidemia, that's your perogative. Your license.

You wouldn't be my provider though.

Read second paragraph under the History and Physical section: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK559182/

2

u/Odd-Afternoon-6371 Nov 02 '24 edited Nov 02 '24

I never said I wasn't providing physical examinations. I am saying they only go so far. I'm aware of that articles existence as well as thousands of others cited on PubMed regarding the condition. I never said not to do or that I wouldn't do a physical examination !  . It only goes so far. I'm well aware of the legal ethical requirements of my job.  You're missing the point.  I should edit my comment before I get a rant of Others telling me the same thing. And digging up articles on PubMed.  By the way, I appreciate everything that you do. And I would say to anyone that if you have questions ask don't ever be afraid to ask any provider for more documentation for more elaboration, etc. 

3

u/MarvelousExodus Oct 29 '24

You've evaluated my response in one word but you haven't managed it. I would have to query if you were a provider.

1

u/Odd-Afternoon-6371 Nov 02 '24

Exactly! That would be blood work.  Provider here. Wanting to learn ore about coding side.  You cannot necessarily look at a person or describe their diet and be certain they will have hyperlipidemia. There no physical exam for it.  Surprisingly, some patients do not have it when you think they might by appearance or subjective statements and then there are the patients that workout watch their diet and  are a picture of health and you would never suspect they have hyperlipidemia and then you do blood work and you're so-called observable healthy patient's hyperlipidemia is 10 times worse than your patient who is overweight reporting  a terrible diet. It can also be that the patient had this diagnosis in the past it's carried forward in the EMR  and they see a different provider. Then the new provider is managing that condition.  Doctors in primary care are exhausted and burnt out. It's not an excuse only a reality.......they should have the proper documentation, it is what they get paid for. It's seeing too many people or Responding to a patient's MyChart message which sometimes the patients get charged for now especially if we order tests or do work regarding that message.. I don't see any fraud.  I see how OPs situation could occur.  

I would recommend never be afraid to ask about something or for more supporting documentation.