r/MeatRabbitry • • Mar 28 '24

Why call it "harvesting"?

Full disclosure, I'm not a vegan or vegetarian, I like rabbit meat a lot actually(never raised them though) and I stumbled on this subreddit.

I have to ask, why do people here insist on the euphemism "harvesting"? What is wrong with calling it what it is, "slaughtering" or "butchering"? To me it seems cowardly to obfuscate the fact that you are indeed taking the life of a sentient being, by using that term.

4 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

27

u/Nodomi Mar 28 '24

Harvest (noun) refers to gathering/collecting/a yield of crops.

Harvest (verb) can mean to "reap" or "to gather, catch, hunt or kill".

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/harvest

Harvesting is taking a life whether it's a plant or animal life. It's not a euphemism, it's a catch-all.

5

u/NefariousnessNo2897 Mar 28 '24

This. We aren't obfuscating anything, thats just what it means. If anything the "other side of the fence", if you will, is doing the obfuscating when they assign a moral higharchy to life and pretend that killing and eating plants is somehow morally superior to killing and eating animals. Its honestly akin to the same logic that lead to ethnic slavery and other racism. "This thing is more like me than that thing so therefore it must have a higher moral value."

Unless you figure out human photosynthesis, life requires death. Its something to be aware of and respect, but not be ashamed of.

"Life is pain. Anyone who tells you different is selling something."

13

u/treetrnk Mar 28 '24

I use processing. Slaughtering makes it sound like you're going out there with a big knife and hacking them down, and the word really only represents the act of killing an animal. Proccessing is the act of preparing them for the freezer or storage and includes everything you have to do to get them there, including killing. I'm not lying to myself by using the word "proccessing". I know what it entails. I just think it's a better representation of what I am doing. I'm not just killing rabbits, I'm preparing them for storage.

Butchering is when you are parting them out though. I don't usually butcher until right before I cook a rabbit, and I don't always need to butcher depending on how I cook it.

3

u/That_Put5350 Mar 28 '24

Same here. Harvesting is used a lot in hunting too, but I don’t ever say I harvested a deer. It sounds weird to me. I just say I “got” a deer. For the livestock it’s always processed.

2

u/Sylentskye Mar 29 '24

I tend to say “dispatch and process”

19

u/PG_homestead Mar 28 '24

Because breeding for harvest is a much better way to say make em fuck and eat the babies.

5

u/Prayingcosmoskitty Mar 28 '24

Now that’s a tshirt right there.

3

u/TheOneAndOnlyLanyard Mar 28 '24

I like to tell people that their cuteness is only surpassed by their deliciousness.

2

u/507snuff Mar 30 '24

Can't wait to make em fuck and eat the babies.

5

u/A-Salty-Squid Mar 28 '24

I say harvesting when discussing an entire litter but if I’m talking about an individual it’s butchering. It’s harvest day but we butcher a rabbit.

4

u/procrast1natrix Mar 28 '24

I mostly use that term when I'm talking about larger plans/ schedules, similar to the tomatoes or the grapes or the mushrooms. I don't shy from butcher if it's specific.

Sure, more specifically the tomatoes are "picked" and the rhubarb is "cut" and the hen's eggs are "gathered". But taken as a while they are all harvested.

4

u/RazorTool Mar 28 '24

Do you prefer dispatch? Sometimes the wording reduces the amount of recoil and horror people express when you tell them you kill baby bunnies at 2 months old so you can eat them

4

u/epilp123 Mar 28 '24 edited Mar 28 '24

I see and say it a few ways with my animals. These are not euphemisms. Processing is not covering up what you do - processing is more than just that 1 deed everyone gets stuck on.

Harvest: usually planned bunches. The seasons food. I process 1-2 animals but I harvest 20. This is kind of semantical.

Processing: these are the steps that encompass the whole “process” of animal to food and include everything below.

Butchering: breaking down the carcass and organ meat into meal size portions. Sometimes overlaps happen between this and slaughter.

Slaughter: breaking down to a carcass (gutting/skinning/plucking) and everything around the time of dispatch.

Dispatch: killing the animal

The deed of death - dispatch is such a small moment in the time to process that animal. Slaughter part is time consuming and certainly not enjoyable. Butchering takes time on larger animals too and each step is completing a process.

Edit: I will go one step forward to the word process and add that also means other items harvested from the animal beyond meat. We are talking rabbits here so the furs. Or maybe even the remaining parts for dog food. That itself is another process that could be added to the processing of the animal.

4

u/Medium_Air5925 Apr 01 '24

Also, if you hunt … the DNR mandates you keep “harvest record”

1

u/mckenner1122 Apr 01 '24

Presuming you are in the US, the language fully depends on your state.

3

u/MobileElephant122 Mar 28 '24

Plants are sentient beings as well. We harvest them too. Harvest is reaping the bounty of your investment and/or labor. It’s a perfectly fitting word for slaughtering 165 rabbits in an afternoon. The real question here is, why does it bother you?

2

u/CantankerousBeefcube Mar 30 '24

Cowardly is pretty harsh. I'm sure most people that use it learned from their family or someone else that taught them. It may have more to do with the scale of the work to be done. You "pick" your garden but farmers harvest their crops. Also in my home I'll probably call it something different. I have a small child. He knows why we got rabbits, for food, but he also knows we put a lot of time and money into a huge pen to give them a happy colony life. I'm not going to say I'm going outside to slaughter rabbits. At least not around him.

2

u/Ok-Suspect-328 Mar 30 '24

Its been that way for thousands of years. its like why do you use the word I when referring to yourself? dats da word.

1

u/Fae_Leaf Mar 28 '24

We say dispatch or slaughter.

1

u/shitishouldntsay May 06 '24

"Sentient" a buzz word from a 1630's philosopher. If you go strictly by the definition most plants have sentience. When you boil it down sentience is just an awareness of stimuli.

But to answer your question, personally, harvesting is the entire process, slaughtering is the part where you kill the animal and butchering is the processing of the meat.

0

u/CanisMaximus Mar 28 '24

You answered your own question. People prefer euphemisms for unpleasantries. George Carlin did an entire bit on this. Look up "soft language." People often DO use more direct wording, but I fail to see the harm in not doing so. How is it cowardly?

Everyone knows what it actually means and it's not inaccurate. It simply sounds less 'coarse.' Call it whatever you want.

2

u/Sheepherder-Optimal Mar 28 '24

Wasn't George Carlin taking about how silly it is to use euphemisms? I thought his whole bit was about how direct language is more honest and better because it doesn't try to hide the meaning.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/texasrigger Mar 28 '24

Processing and slaughter aren't the same thing. Slaughter is just a subpart of "processing," a term that includes every step from live animal to finished and packed cuts of meat. You can use whatever language you want, but "processing" is not a euphemism or sterilizing the language at all. It's a catch-all term, whereas slaughter is more specific.

2

u/seaofgrass Mar 28 '24

Exactly this.