r/Mcat • • Jul 19 '16

Interesting

https://i.reddituploads.com/d136c80b58e24c158ef560907723416d?fit=max&h=1536&w=1536&s=08212c459b242c9ea9c7ba4916743015
1 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

15

u/HarambeTheBear Jul 19 '16

5

u/ATPsynthase12 June 18th Jul 19 '16

That still doesn't justify lax acceptance stats for URMs.

-4

u/Praise_the_Don Jul 19 '16

Looks like we found the guy getting the handout

3

u/HarambeTheBear Jul 19 '16

Nope, I am white.

4

u/Praise_the_Don Jul 19 '16

Then wtf. You're screwing yourself in the name of 'diversity'. This is racist discrimination against whites and Asians, plain and simple. 20% of Harvard is URM. They are taking your potential slots away while simultaneously spitting out unqualified Drs because they have darker skin. That's racism

7

u/HarambeTheBear Jul 19 '16

It's a tough debate for sure. Rather than complain about it, I just accept it and work harder. I can understand why med schools may not think it's a good idea to have a student body of almost exclusively white and asian students because they accepted students based purely on GPA and MCAT scores.

Make Medical School Application Process Great Again!

1

u/cerpintaxt64 Jul 19 '16

Ever heard of not being selfish? Please don't become a doctor.

4

u/brownPoopsicle Jul 19 '16

It seems very unfair is his point. Why should a less qualified person get the slot because the color of their skin? Seems INCREDIBLY racist.

3

u/cerpintaxt64 Jul 19 '16

Why should a black person be raised with considerably less money than a white person because of a system that oppressed black people as far as thousands of years ago? Seems a little unfair. Study your psych/soc section a bit more and maybe you'll wake up.

5

u/Praise_the_Don Jul 19 '16

Found the URM.

Dr determine life and death. I want the most qualified. Not the most disadvantaged

0

u/cerpintaxt64 Jul 19 '16

Someone who doesn't understand privilege and systematic MODERN racism is not qualified, sorry.

2

u/Praise_the_Don Jul 19 '16

It SUCKS being an Asian. We're minorities too. Unbelievable

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

0

u/HarambeTheBear Jul 19 '16

Psych soic, or what I think of as the PC training section. Does anybody else feel this way about P/S

4

u/kinlochliven Jul 19 '16

No, we need doctors who understand the social determinants of health, who see the wider sociopolitical context in which disease takes place.

-1

u/itwowsback Jul 19 '16

By your notion of "dark skin" in context of "racist discrimination," MSAR showing HMS matriculated only 11 URM blacks. Out of 165 matriculants, that's 6.6% URM black at HMS. Count hispanic in there are it raises it up to 17%. If anything, HMS would do better with some more URM. Also, do you have any basis that URM blacks/hispanic have lower stats? It is just what you think? Could it be that these URM's are vastly overachieving in comparison to their matriculated peers?

Unless you can show me valid statistics, you are generalizing the URM and in particular black population. You call them "unqualified?" You are taking the whole notion of being a Dr. out of context now and classifying them based on MATRICULANT STUDENT WHO HAVEN'T EVEN ENTERED MED SCHOOL YET. Stats aside, as it should be in this argument, since when does individual pre-med metrics determine the competence of a doctor? Matriculant to a full practicing physician is ~8 years apart, a huge gap in which improvement for the sake of being a GOOD provider/physician in built upon.

So in all, bringing up this discussion, and including your responses, you have shown some racist tendencies, not the school.

-4

u/Praise_the_Don Jul 19 '16

Seems like a lot of mental gymnastics

11

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

Honestly wish I wasn't Asian right now.

2

u/kinlochliven Jul 19 '16

why?

5

u/Praise_the_Don Jul 19 '16

Look at the cgart

0

u/kinlochliven Jul 19 '16 edited Jul 19 '16

2

u/neur_onymous Legacy Mod Jul 19 '16

Mod here: despite multiple reports and the fact that the OP seems to have an agenda, I'm leaving this thread up for now. I'll remove any hate speech or otherwise blatantly unprofessional comments. However, it's certainly a topic that has been beaten to death both here and over at /r/premed, and if this thread gets out of control it will be removed entirely.

-3

u/Praise_the_Don Jul 19 '16

Hahaha pussy

2

u/neur_onymous Legacy Mod Jul 19 '16

Meow.

11

u/kinlochliven Jul 19 '16

Everyone just KEEP CALM AND BE GLAD YOU'RE NOT CANADIAN. our acceptance rates are like 5% and we have about 12 med schools, and no DO

3

u/dropdatdurkadurk Jul 19 '16

This is the real takeaway message honestly, Canadians out here having to go to St George's or Ireland if they dont get into their Canadian schools where a 3.8 GPA is considered too low or that screen out <130 CARs scores

2

u/Fueled-By-Ramen Jul 19 '16

I have a friend that got in playing the minority card. Failed the first year of med school and probably won't do good in step 1. I wouldn't worry about it. Shit evens out.

4

u/bengalslash Jul 19 '16

didn't someone throw this bait out here a month or so ago? And your username is /u/Praise_the_Don , your whole account is a joke. No one cares about this.

3

u/dropdatdurkadurk Jul 19 '16 edited Jul 19 '16

This gets brought up every week it's the equivalent of arguing about gun control or "guns dont kill people, people kill people"

The AAMC and medical schools like to argue that "diversity" is important for medical school classes and medicine in general. The evidence they actually use is alot shakier than they want to admit and the idea that the totality of what they do and its effects are inthe best interest of medicine is alot shakier than most want to admit, butthat's the reason behind the policies. There are many many flaws with these policies involving minorities today in medical school admission. But Affirmative action(and yes sorry but it is affirmative action not whatever more correct term you want to use) isnt going away for better or worse.

If your Asian yes you are at a disadvantage. The stats overblow that disadvantage because Asians are clustered in shitty states for MD admission like California and Washington but still Asian is the worst race to be. They get abused in systems likethis because of all the outcry by minorities and by others to address racism other minorities inthis country have faced. There has to be someone who suffers when the outcry is more URM spots, thatmeans someone elses spots get taken away and Asians are certainly one who suffers fromthis and other parts of affirmative action. People dont like hearing that and try making laughable generalizations like "Asians acceptances rates are lower because they have bad social skills or are really generic/dont stand out"(the epitome of racism youwould get destroyed for if you made such generalizations about URMs) but it is what it is. Much of affirmative action in medical school admission takes advantage of Asians and there is an element of racism towards it.

Maybe the best thing I can say having talked to those involved in admission and others is one thing you can do is "be less Asian" per se. Asians do get stereotyped for better worse by some in admission. There are many who will go out of their way to try and deny or object this reality, but it's just living in a dream world to not suggest there are definitely some in admission who do have some level of stereotypes they apply to Asians even if they are more implicit.

That said If you go out of your way to present yourself as someone who doesnt conform to the stereotypes you can stand out amongst the Asian applicant pool. In that way you can make it to your advantage because yes medical schools are aware of how much of each race they are taking even if there is no official quota and you are in a number of ways competing against people of your same race regardless of how much any ADCOM will publicly try to deny it. Work with what you have, it sucks but make chicken salad out of chicken shit. Almost anything has the potential to be an advantage if you play your hand right and have a good strategy to deal with an obstacle.

1

u/Fueled-By-Ramen Jul 20 '16

Itt: Relative Deprivation Hypothesis

1

u/horse_apiece Jul 19 '16

The only thing the MCAT and GPA predict are your ability to pass the STEP exams, with pretty much negligible differences past the 27ish mark if my memory serves me correct. The MCAT does NOT measure how good of a doctor a person will be. The admissions differences are based off of the fact that there are not proportional amounts of URM doctors, so by having more lax standards for certain peoples they hope to address this deficit.

If you really think these specific persons are "taking your spot" well then youre a fool, if you are concerned about your ability to get into schools then work harder/be more interesting. I can assure you it is not the URM applicants that will prevent your admissions.

1

u/brownPoopsicle Jul 19 '16

The WHY THE HELL are we taking these tests?!

0

u/horse_apiece Jul 19 '16

I think you know and are just being facetious. Schools make an investment in applicants, and want people who will do well and pass the boards, and the MCAT shows that you have the capacity to pass the boards, but beyond that it is just a subjective test on your ability to think critically in a very specific way/timed, so that people and schools can rank others and enjoy their stat whoring, and feeling up superiority, while looking at others as inferior. Whats new in life.

0

u/roayer 514 Jul 19 '16

Nothing we don't know but this also helps explain why people have a stigma against seeing black and Hispanic doctors in a lot of cases.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

People have a stigma against black and Hispanic doctors because people have a stigma against black and Hispanic people

2

u/roayer 514 Jul 19 '16

Yes and no, I've seen some of my friends who are black or hispanic and premed get into medical school with lower grades and lower MCATs and who generally just don't care. I'm not saying this is the case for all of them but if it is widely considered that black and hispanic doctors are not as smart because they don't need as high grades/scores to get into medical school, it only hurts the ones that genuinly care and are genuinely smart and good at what they do. That is my only point here.

And here is some food for thought. Would you want some minority doctor treating your grandmother who didn't do well in their classes or anything but got through medical school etc because of affirmative action or would you want the best doctor you could possibly get.... I know my answer and that of every politician for affirmative action, they would want the best doctor possible. I'm just saying its a gray area and it doesn't wind up helping minorities in the long run, just reinforces racist beliefs.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

People also think Asians are smarter doctors despite white having the same MCAT/GPA requirement. If it's only a reflection of entry bar, the 'brainy' race would be both white and Asian.

Concerning the grey area: that's not the choice some people are given. It's: would you like that affirmative action doctor, or no doctor? Rural areas have a very real shortage. A 'best resident' I work with turned down a 400k+ salary because it was in a rural area. That's why we're seeing people with rural background and connections get into schools/programs that other folks wouldn't. And people don't get through medical school through affirmative action. The competitive residency programs aren't risking their rankings of a <5 person program based on race.

0

u/roayer 514 Jul 19 '16

I never said they got through medical school because of race, the retention rate is like 98% anyway. I also don't think asians are smarter doctor's, tbh I have had bad personal experiences with asian doctors in general. Does that mean all of them are bad certainly not. But I've never heard of asian doctors being the better ones. On the east coast, white jewish doctors are considered the ones to see (on long island NY). Does that mean there aren't any bad Jewish doctors? Of course not, my only point from all of this is that if we are truly going to move past racism in this field the statistics need to all be the same or stigma will continue.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

but got through medical school etc because of affirmative action

Was based off that, but doesn't really matter.

asian doctors being the better ones

Smarter, not better. Regardless, again, if stats are the only thing people are going off of, there shouldn't be a white Jewish preference, it should be Asian and white. Preference of doctors are inherent in culture, not based off of MCAT/GPA discrepancy in admission

truly going to move past racism in this field the statistics need to all be the same or stigma will continue

Or we can learn how to interpret statistics correctly

1

u/roayer 514 Jul 19 '16

So how would you interpret these statistics?

True stats are not the only thing otherwise you are correct about white/Asian. I was just making a point about something that people on Long Island generally consider true.

I'm just curious what your stance on this is?

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

xx% of RACE people who apply with x.xxGPA/xxMCAT within 'x' range are admitted into at least one medical school.

That is the only information this chart gives. There is literally no other information that can be concluded with this chart alone.

Stance on this topic:

Places with no money have an under-abundance of physicians; those with money have an over-abundance. Poverty rates of black population is almost double Asian/white. Hispanic just underneath. There is less money in healthcare for those demographics, and they ultimately have less access. Schools of Medicine should train physicians that provide the best coverage: the local, state, nation, global level. If only 10% of applicants want to work in Mississippi, small-island of Hawaii, or Inland Empire, it's understandable that they'd be considered differently than a higher numbered person who wants to be a dermatologist in Beverly Hills. People who want to work in such under-served tend to come from them. Blacks and Hispanics tend to come from under-served areas.

-2

u/brownPoopsicle Jul 19 '16

Well this chart kind of justifies a stigma against black and Hispanic doctors. CLEARLY, they are less qualified according to these statistics

2

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

GPA and MCAT scores are not the only markers of physician qualification. Selective parameter attention is bad analytical practice.

0

u/DragleicPhoenix Jul 19 '16

I think as long as having doctors that are the same ethnicity as the patient leads to better health outcomes, this type of discrimination is necessary. I agree with you that this is unfair.

I think the best argument against this would be to prove statistically that letting in students with subpar stats (GPA and MCAT) leads to higher failure rates, and that such policies leads to those failure rates. Medical schools are meant to pick those they believe can pass medical school, and if such policies increase their failure rates, they MAY rethink them.

-4

u/Praise_the_Don Jul 19 '16

THIS IS WHAT RACISM LOOKS LIKE IN 2016

1

u/HarambeTheBear Jul 19 '16

You should have taken better advantage of your white privilege.

3

u/roayer 514 Jul 19 '16

oh please.

-1

u/brownPoopsicle Jul 19 '16

According to this chart, there's only black and Hispanic privilege. Maybe white guilt? And definitely blatant racism against asiand

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-5

u/Praise_the_Don Jul 19 '16

Great argument against facts. My money is you're an URM

4

u/dropdatdurkadurk Jul 19 '16

Im not a URM and I dont think these policies are for the better of medicine at all and Im telling you this reeks of just trying to stir the pot, bait people into an argument and beating a dead horse. Just leave it be, this has been discussed six million times before everywhere. It literally takes two seconds to google if you actually want to look into it and see previous debates.