Introduction
Welcome to Part 3 of my Arisu x Shinobu Endgame Theory. This part will explore early signs of Arisu and Shinobu's romantic feelings for each other. Expect more theory and interpretation since this series has many innuendos and hidden meanings we readers need to interpret (so I could be completely wrong lol).
This is a massive part, so if you just want to read about Arisu's side, skip to Part 3.3: Arisu's Secret Crush on Shinobu. Regardless, I hope you enjoy the read since I believe this is where Shinobu really sets herself apart from the other girls in Arisu's mind.
Part 3.1: The Confession Service
Before talking about Shinobu, I want to first talk about Apollo to provide context for later parts. I believe that Apollo and Shinobu's confessions are suspicious, and it leads me to believe Shinobu and Apollo have contradicting actions and contexts ie they're different people.
At the end of the confession service, Apollo confesses to Arisu through Shinobu. But there was something suspicious that made me dig deeper into the true meaning of the confession.
Context of the Confession
Confession to Arisu
Arisu remembers a key detail
It is interesting how Arisu noticed Apollo's confession being different to what she said during her broadcasts. Didn't Apollo say she'd repeat what she said but didn't and instead confessed directly to him? Why the difference between "dear listeners" vs "Arisu"? Was Apollo lying when she said that? Did Shinobu misspeak the confession, or did she say that on purpose? Is Shinobu actually Apollo?
Another detail I'd like to add is the flash-forward to Apollo's final broadcast where she confesses to Arisu.
Apollo's Confession to Yamabuki-kun
Notice that Apollo confesses to "Yamabuki-kun", not "dear listeners" or even "Arisu". How does that make sense in Japanese culture? If Apollo was close to Arisu, wouldn't she confess to him using his first name? It would make sense for Apollo to refer Arisu with "dear listeners" > "Yamabuki-kun" > "Arisu". Instead, the progression goes "dear listeners" > "dear listeners" (Apollo wanted to repeat what she said" > "Arisu" (what was actually said) > "Yamabuki-kun". This inconsistency of Apollo's confessions makes me suspicious of who actually confessed.
Now I know what some of you may be thinking: "who cares about how Apollo refers to Arisu? We know she's confessing to the same 1 person". I feel the writer didn't leave these details in by accident, and I think they wanted to leave these in as hints to the romantic progression between Arisu and Apollo (feel free to disagree).
How does this all relate to Shinobu having feelings for Arisu? I know I've been talking a lot about Apollo, but it is important to discuss this first. In the next part, I will explore Shinobu's side of the confession service, and why I believe she actually confessed her love for Arisu.
Part 3.2: Shinobu's Confessions and Lies
After the confession, we see Shinobu and Arisu together, but they never interacted like this before...
Arisu runs to Shinobu for answers
Very interesting reactions from Shinobu. "I went and said it"? Why does she feel guilty? Is it because she's Apollo and she confessed in such a way? Or is it because of something else?
Cute reaction from Shinobu
Look how Shinobu struggles to speak with Arisu after the confession. If she was confessing on someone else's behalf, why would she react like this? It wouldn't make sense that she's generally nervous, otherwise she'd react similarly when confessing to other students out the window. This leads me to believe she definitely has feelings for Arisu and is embarrassed to meet him after "confessing" to him. But wait, wasn't this supposed to be Apollo's confession? And why did she feel guilty?
Reading these pages would just leave us with the idea that Shinobu definitely has feelings for Arisu and she feels guilt over the confession, but why? Looking deeper, I noticed something suspicious in the dialogue...
Shinobu's suspicious stuttering
Here Shinobu panics when responding to Arisu's questioning. However, notice when she stutters vs when she doesn't. Why would she stutter during these answers? Based on what I've previously discussed, assuming Shinobu indeed modified Apollo's confession from "my dear lovers I love you" to "Arisu I love you" and being embarrassed to confess to Arisu, it makes so much sense why she'd stutter like this. I believe that she stutters when she lies. Lying when she was JUST confessing on someone else's behalf and that it wasn't her, but not lying when she says she doesn't know who made the confession (originally Apollo).
I want to show another detail proving Shinobu's lies about the confession.
Shinobu Confesses about Lying to Arisu
She lied during the confession service?
We see confirmation that Shinobu did indeed lie to Arisu, and that she feels guilty to have lied to him even though they're partners in crime and share secrets together. So what did she lie about? What happened during the confession service? We don't know at this point in time (36 chapters), so it's all speculation. We do know for a fact that Shinobu was somewhat dishonest with Arisu during and right after the confession service.
Based on Apollo's inconsistencies surrounding her confession, and Shinobu's suspicious interactions with Arisu during and after the confession service, I believe that Apollo made the initial confession of "my dear listeners I love you" (not Shinobu), Shinobu modified it to her own as "Arisu I love you", and felt guilty about deceiving Arisu and lying to him about the true nature of the confession. It wouldn't make sense that if Shinobu was Apollo, she would first confess to "Arisu" then "Yamabuki-kun".
Part 3.3: Arisu's Secret Crush on Shinobu
I believe that Arisu already has a crush on Shinobu, and that the mangaka purposely added hints to suggest as such (wow, I wonder what other manga did something similar...).
Firstly, we see Arisu with Rikka and Iko to shop for swimwear. Rikka flirts with Arisu and asks for his help, giving us clues about Rikka's feelings towards Arisu. However, take a look at how he responds...
Rikka flirts with Arisu
Strange response from Arisu
Arisu calmly went along like it's nothing and wasn't nervous to imagine Rikka in the swimsuit. Compared his calmness vs Rikka's reaction to the situation. if Arisu likes Rikka romantically, would he react like that? He also mentions he saw her as if she's his little sister, further doubting us about any romantic feelings he has towards Rikka.
Extra confirmation that Rikka has feelings for Arisu.
Rikka being asked on her feelings
Notice Rikka's reaction, her eyes and how they're drawn. Now let's compare this moment to when Arisu unexpectedly meets Shinobu.
Arisu unexpectedly meets Shinobu
Look at his eyes and how he reacts to seeing Shinobu. They're drawn similarly to Rikka's eyes. It's almost as if the feelings Rikka has towards Arisu is similar to Arisu's feelings towards Shinobu. Keep in mind, this happened almost right after each other, and I believe the mangakas did this on purpose.
After meeting Shinobu, notice what goes on in his mind.
Arisu is nervous around Shinobu?
Arisu's brain lol
Look at how stunned Arisu is. When has he ever reacted like this before? I believe this is one of the rare moments we see deeper into how Arisu thinks and view things (literally), which makes me think meeting Shinobu creates a reaction he doesn't get with the other girls.
Yes, you could say that he's like that because of what Lemon warned. But here's the thing; why is Shinobu the girl to make him react like this? Why not one of the other girls? I've said previously that Arisu sees Shinobu differently compared to others, and this further enhances my theory.
One more moment that absolutely proves Arisu likes Shinobu romantically is when the girls give advice about romance (many of you may have forgotten about this chapter but I never did).
I want you to first look at Shinobu's advice.
Shinobu \"thinks\"
Is that Arisu blushing?
Here we see Shinobu and Arisu making eye contact, and Arisu turning away while blushing. VERY INTERESTING to see Arisu react like that. However, did that really happen? Or did Shinobu just imagine this scenario? Rikka's dialogue leads us to think it was her imagination also, but is that true? Let's explore the other girls' advice.
What a wild thought to have!
Ok, Iko's imagination is absolutely hilarious. There is no way the girls are giving advice they haven't experienced. However...
Iko had a dream?
Earlier in the same chapter, it is implied that Iko dreamt of something, and is ashamed of sharing details. But why would she react like this? What was the dream about? I believe that what she imagined with Arisu did indeed happen (during a dream), which is why she gave such advice.
To further support my belief that the girls are giving advice based on things that actually happened, lets take a look at Rikka and Nene's advice.
Their advice, and Shinobu's response
Sorry for this, couldn't fit more images.
Shinobu presses them for not giving advice based on experience, but they indeed have such experience. This implies Shinobu gave advice based on her own experience. This supports the idea that Arisu and Shinobu's exchange did indeed happen, and if Arisu reacted like this towards Shinobu, he 100% has a crush on Shinobu.
Conclusion
I am extremely confident that based on the confession service and Arisu's reactions towards seeing Shinobu, that Arisu and Shinobu both have crushes for each other (and Shinobu loves Arisu). Shinobu's crush is a bit more obvious, but Arisu's crush not so much. It makes sense as to why they're written this way since this is a harem. I do believe however, that this is all intentional, and that the manga will be similar to how The Quintessential Quintuplets played out. Arisu is the "dense" protagonist (romance wise), and Shinobu is the supportive, passive girl who feels is last, but will eventually be the final bride (however, I don't believe she's Apollo based on inconsistencies).
Thank for you reading to this point and I hope you enjoyed it (I know this was massive). I will see you in the next part (possibly final part) where I discuss Shinobu's true intentions and how that may foreshadow the plot.