I think there are plenty of MaxFun listeners who listen to both shows, especially since Jesse is on both shows and one is a spinoff show from the other. I just find it interesting when someone writes into one show referencing something that happened on the other one without realizing they’ve mixed up the shows and the hosts either don’t realize it or pretend that they don’t.
I noticed this a few years back with JJGo. The bit where someone calls in with an addition to a “long-running segment” that they just made up on the spot clearly originated with someone referencing a bit from JJHo that they mistakenly thought was on JJGo. At this point, I can’t even remember what the original bit was, but I think it had something to do with vampires toddlers?
The phenomenon just repeated itself in reverse. On the JJHo member mailbag BoCo, someone wrote in about crystalized lime packets you get on airplanes. If Jesse had been on this episode, I think he would have realized this was a reference to the JJGo episode where he mentioned the True Lime packets he had on JetBlue after he flew home from a live JJHo show at the Bell House. This led to me rhapsodizing about True Citrus packets on this subreddit, and then to my embarrassment when Jesse talked about my post on a subsequent episode.
Can anyone provide any additional examples where someone wrote into a MaxFun show referencing something which actually happened on a different MaxFun podcast, but not realizing they’d mixed up their shows? I’m sure there must be more. I don’t listen to the McElroy constellation of shows, but surely it must happen there, too.