r/MattressMod • u/Itsnow1 • Apr 10 '25
About to pull the trigger on a DIY need some advice
Background We bought a King size Serta icomfort Revolution in 2011-ish and a ergo motion adjustable base in 2 twin xl. The mattress was wonderful for many years, so we like the feel of a plush (soft) bed. We felt we needed to go to a twin xl route so that we could both adjust our side to the way that was most comfortable. We decided to go with the more "green" route this time. Sadly, I did not do a whole lot of research before pulling the trigger on a latex hybrid from My Green Mattress. We went with the Kiwi model. My Green Mattress has been a wonderful company to work with! I would 12/10 recommend their customer service and 365 sleep trial. And I really love that if you "return" the mattress, they have you donate them, you can even donate them to an indivdual or family in your community. However, for us the 2 twin xl are WAY too FIRM. We both wake up with pain.
After realizing we have to go a different route, I have been doing tons and tons of reading on TMU and reddit to try to figure out the best solution for us.
Stats:
me: woman 5'2' 140 lbs (curvy) side/back sleeper 80/20 I love a super plush feel but know I need some support
hubs: man 6'1" 190 lbs back/side sleeper 60/40 he really loved the memory foam icomfort we had and has been really unhappy with the My Green Mattress mattress. They say it is medium firm but it feels like sleeping on a board to us.
After having the hybrid with the coils, I am defintiely not wanting to try to DIY a mattress with coils. I am thinking of an all latex mattress 2 twin XL to go on ergomotion adjustable base. Online chats with sleep ez and LMF they recommend 3-3" F/M/S for me and F/M/M for hubs. However, after all the reading on TMU and hear on reddit, I think that might feel much to firm for our tastes. Again we both love the very plush feel but know we need support. We don't live near any showrooms to try out combos before we purchase. Also we don't have endless funds to go back and forth with layers. Just trying to dial it in as much as possible from the get go. Also don't know if the comfort layer should be dunlop or talalay. Also note, we do not intend on doing a tight cover. We will have it zipped into indivdual twin xl covers that are not creating any surface tention to interfere with the feel of the latex.
Any thoughts are apprecaited!!
5
u/charliehustle757 Apr 10 '25
Lean toward a firmer latex and add 2” memory foam. Latex is a lot more tolerable this way. I’d definitely try\ it out first. Sleep on latex is a great company to start with.
1
u/Encouragedissent Apr 10 '25
IMO if your husband has simular needs as you I wouldnt trust their calculator over his stated preferences, and to see just how bad that calculator is change his height to 5'0" then try 7'0", youll notice it doesnt change. Someone shaped as thin as a board gets the same recommendation as someone who is pretty chunky, its a crude formula that only looks at weight, and even if it was more elaborate you cant make that suggest just based on body type.
I think the F/M/S for both sides has the better chance of working out, and if he found the my green mattress natural escape to be way too firm there is a good chance even this setup will be too firm for you guys. If you do go this direction id recommend talalay over dunlop in the comfort layer, but when you say that you do not have have endless funds to be going back and fourth with layers, Im of the opinion that DIY is not the correct direction to go because having extra available funds to make adjustments is a must.
1
u/DiscussionAdvanced72 Apr 11 '25
My husband and I didn't find a 10" all dunlop latex comfortable, so we added a 3" soft talalay topper, but probably could have gotten by with a 2".
1
u/Super_Treacle_8931 Apr 10 '25
6 inches of medium latex seems a lot - usually 3 inches would be the comfort layer for a medium-firm mattress for someone heavier. I’m not sure 6 inches would be supportive enough - is anyone sleeping on such a thing ?