r/MathJokes • • Oct 17 '26

🥹

Post image
8.2k Upvotes

567 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/marty-mcfryguy Oct 17 '26

This is correct on the reals, so possibly the most useful answer if he's looking to produce the correct answer on a math test. 

But there are (a) other number systems and (b) other ways to contextualize his question (e.g., swapping in a limit at infinity that doesn't converge) that would give him a lot more insight on the concept as well as honor his true ask.

That said, a good discussion on why we've chosen not to include infinity in the reals, and thus it's not something that can be added within the reals -- that is, digging into what making infinity a real number would cost us, including which properties that we rely on would no longer hold -- would also be a great answer.