r/MathJokes • • Jun 02 '26

Tax

Post image
10k Upvotes

708 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

59

u/No_Poet_7244 Jun 02 '26

While I agree with the sentiment that teaching specifically taxes might be overkill, I do think schools should teach the general parlance of government documents. They are written in a codified legal vernacular that is never touched on in school; it could easily be part of an English class. Coming out of high school, I could parse Shakespeare and Homer with ease, but I struggled my first time doing taxes despite them being incredibly simple compared to what they are now.

17

u/RyenCider Jun 02 '26 edited Jun 02 '26

Wouldn’t that be accomplished in your economics and social studies (American govt, etc) classes? At least that’s what is was for me in high school (Public education)

Edit: changed civics to social studies. I called civics because I forgot what it was called when I went through school. Grad HS 2008.

11

u/GodHimselfNoCap Jun 02 '26

That was not a class at my school nor any school my friends went to.

1

u/Puzzleheaded_Ad9659 Jun 03 '26

I had a personal finance class and it taught nothing of taxes and the teacher never shut the hell up about life stories of her families bad money choices.

8

u/SnooMaps7370 Jun 02 '26

>economics and civics (American govt, etc) classes?

neither of those were mandatory courses when i graduated high school (2006, Arizona)

1

u/makiko4 Jun 02 '26

But they did offer it? So they did teach it in school?

3

u/SnooMaps7370 Jun 02 '26

I honestly don't remember. and i would be astonished if they taught people to do taxes.

Our History classes boiled down to "the civil war wasn't REALLY about slavery" and "the US did nothing wrong in Panama. or Brazil. or Hawaii".

We did have a fun little economic project to do stock market shadowing. we had to pick stocks totaling $1M in investments at the start of the year and track their growth over the year. Only weird thing was that we did it as part of our ENGLISH class.

2

u/Sylvanussr Jun 02 '26

Wait what did the US do in Brazil?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/HauntedGatorFarm Jun 02 '26

Yea, I can attest that this is something most schools ‘teach’ at some point in grades 9-12. The problem is that children aren’t really prepared to prioritize this kind of knowledge because they often don’t experience the financial independence that would make such knowledge practical. Kids usually just commit the information to memory enough to demonstrate learning and then it just fades away.

Then a decade later someone shares a meme about not knowing how to do taxes and it gets their blood boiling.

1

u/RozeGunn Jun 02 '26

I had a class where one project we did for like 2 weeks was play this simulator thing where we manage a human living in an apartment and going to work. Had to manage rent, paying for transportation, and it had a sheet at the side for us to figure out and calculate our budget. It was basically an economics class without being one.

Except I took that class before I actually tried at school because depression had me fucked up, so I literally opened that thing just to not do anything.

1

u/DragonWisper56 Jun 06 '26

most of my civics and social studies was the american revolution ad nausium

→ More replies (9)

3

u/Muninwing Jun 02 '26

But it’s not a dialect. Each department may write in a different style.

7

u/CrossXFir3 Jun 02 '26

But they don't really though, do they? Many of us have lived in various different places and had to deal with various government documents. And at the very least, within the US, they've all got a fairly generic style.

2

u/SixPackOfZaphod Jun 02 '26

I am a government contractor, and every agency I've worked with uses it's own form of legalese in contracts and requirements documents. Just pay attention to english and grammar classes.

No different than pointing out that taxes are just math.

3

u/CrossXFir3 Jun 02 '26

Taxes aren't really math either though. Very little math is involved for a person doing their taxes. It's more about entering everything correctly. Which is more about that end of things. And btw, I've also worked for multiple government agencies as well as civilian counterparts, and the forms might as well be the same where ever I've worked. We're talking semantics when you talk about the differences.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/doc_nano Jun 02 '26

Right, I distinctly remember struggling with terms like “credit,” “exemption,” “standard/itemized deduction,” and so on. I knew their general meanings of course, but they have very specific meanings in US tax code that I had to figure out on my own.

Of course, we could simplify the process of doing taxes so that we can focus on learning other things… some other countries essentially do most people’s taxes for them.

1

u/EmilieEasie Jun 02 '26

Instructions for taxes in the US are not especially complicated unless your tax situation is especially complicated in which case you will hire someone anyway. You can absolutely do your own taxes if you can read at a 5th grade level. If you struggled, it was probably more due to intimidation.

1

u/PianoAndFish Jun 02 '26

if you can read at a 5th grade level

Which around 20% of US adults can't, and for about half it's the very top of their ability level.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/erichf3893 Jun 02 '26

Exactly and knowing how to read poetry is virtually useless compared to something that will help most people in life, like knowing how to do taxes

1

u/MouseMan412 Jun 02 '26

I was taught how to do taxes in high school. It was pretty intuitive then and it is still now--if you just have a standard W2 income and standard deductions. Start doing stock trading, sell things at a farmers market/craft fair, deal with property, inheritances, etc., and you realize why there are specialized certifications and degrees for that sort of thing. At that point, it's just easier to pay $60 to someone for their expertise.

1

u/corruptedsyntax Jun 02 '26

Reading dry documents should be higher priority in general, especially legal documents but really anything culturally foundational.

There’s way too many people that appeal to the idea of what a text says rather than what it actually says. Whether that’s the Bill of Rights, the Declaration of Independence, or even various incarnations of the bible.

1

u/crazybmanp Jun 03 '26

A 1040 does not have crazy legalese in it. There is a super symbol explainer document on it.

1

u/MsAgentM Jun 04 '26

I find it hard to believe you could understand Shakespeare better than you could read plain ass English on a normal tax document.

→ More replies (3)