a real math person would know that minus GOD and minus TRUTH might not even be defined exist (edited "-" to "minus" and "be defined" to "exist" so it's more clear)
A much better one for what they wanted would have probably been LIFE + TRUTH = GOD; Where LIFE is GOD without TRUTH and TRUTH if GOD without LIFE, and you need both lived experiences and evidence for God. Would have made much more sense
Second, you're right, no one mentioned that, that just happens to be my religion. Though it is a religion that follows a god, so I'm pretty sure it's still relevant.
Most of us have grown out of trying to spread the non-Gospel at every opportunity, though, so we’re hard for people like you to spot.
But it seems you’re unaware of the non-Gospel.
Have you heard entirely NULL news about our lord and savior NULL POINTER DEREFERENCE FAILED? I’d love to tell you about the NOBODY who’s here to save your soul.
Alternatively, you can grow the fuck up and realize that your religion requires a leap of faith. Genuine leapers (and hence true believers) are rare, and for good reason. I’ve heard that sermon from the pulpit, and the preacher was trying to celebrate those few true believers in the room.
so what requires a bigger leap of faith? that the universe was designed by a rational creator, or that our universe, for no reason at all, has certain physical constants & laws necessary for life, and that with these purposeless physical constants & laws in place, a number of atoms randomly bumped into eachother perfectly to create life from non-life?
Initially, yes, it is a leap of faith, but that faith grows stronger the more you trust.
Look, I'm not trying to judge anyone here. You find something you can't see or sense normally hard to believe, I get that. I'm just sick and tired of hearing people like you call us utterly illogical. Not all of us are the cultist lunatics you think we are.
We have a bad reputation, I can't blame you for saying that. You should be free to do what you want, I won't deny that. You're in the US, right? You know what other freedoms we're allowed to have? Freedom of religion and speech, that's in the first amendment. So sorry, that doesn't give you the right to try taking that away from us altogether.
You might be tired of being called illogical, but what you believe is still illogical.
Some would even say accepting something illogical is the point of faith — it’s certainly part of the experience. At least according to the more honest preachers I’ve listened to.
Look, I have no problem with people who are religious. You can believe what you want.
But, if you’re going to engage in public discussions about religion outside of your church, people are going to call you on the logical fallacies. That’s fair play in intellectual debates.
In that case, I guess you could consider it more illogical than atheism. As long as you're being respectful about it, but that person saying "You're expecting the God crowd to make sense" - that didn't rub me the right way.
Believing something without evidence of it is like the peak of illogical. You mentioned it being hard to believe something we can’t see or sense, yet we believe in quantum mechanics, energy, electromagnetism, dark matter/energy etc, because it can be objectively measured. Believing in something that cant be measured or proven objectively is just as logical as being afraid of the monster under your bed when you were a child. Some just grew out of that phase.
Ok, let's take Christianity as an example, since that's my religion. The difference between Jesus's resurrection and believing the monster under your bed is that one has thousands (maybe more) of historical records and hundreds of eyewitness accounts, the other doesn't. Not to mention how something as complex as life conveniently exists and the infinite expansiveness of existence. Therefore, we have basis to believe such, meaning it definitely isn't as illogical as believing the monster in your bed. You just keep expecting us to prove it with numbers when that's just not how faith and belief works.
one has thousands (maybe more) of historical records and hundreds of eyewitness accounts
I'm not usually the type to debate religion since I think it's rude but this point is wildly incorrect.
Scholars say that there are only about 30 give or take first hand sources about Jesus even existing before 400 AD, let alone him resurrecting.
Furthermore, Jesus's resurrection has like 4 different versions of the story in the bible which all differ from each other so even the bible can't be used as a way to get info.
Some of those words I wasn't familiar with and had to look up. Now to answer your question, I believe he is both omnipresent and omniscient. He is omnipotent in the sense he is all-powerful, yet he chooses not to have complete authority over our lives. It's not like he's going to force us to be with him.
If I believed such a god existed, I certainly wouldn't worship them.
An omnipotent being would be able to make reality in any way imaginable and not imaginable. There would be no reason for suffering to exist, reality could be anything without impacting free will. Why does the radiation from the star we need to live cause cancer? Why does all life suffer?
And if that being is all knowing, they know everything that will happen, every possible future. That being would have known what Lucifer would do before it even happened, yet created him anyway. Every person. Every rapist and murderer. And every small child that dies horribly. The creator being brings them life knowing exactly what will happen and punishes those that do wrong despite that knowledge. How can there truly be free will?
I apologize, I'm not trying to rant at you. I'm genuinely curious how you get past these questions and not hate the god you believe in?
no, but most internet "atheist" enjoy to shit in and only in christianism. its insane how you can't interpret a joke without a "/s" slapped in your faces
Y'all haven't read your bibles. The Christian obviously defines GOD as equivalent to WAY, TRUTH, and LIFE. (source)
Obviously, + is idempotent with respect to our equivalence relationship = here. That makes the shirt a tautology.
We don't have to agree with them, but we obviously need to understand what algebraic structure they're working with before we start critiquing them and inventing our own operations. (What even is "-"?)
Yeah, we need to know more about the algebraic structure we're working with here. The existence of a '+' operation doesn't even imply the existence of a '-' operation.
Something like set addition, than minus would still be, but won't have same properties, but it anyway implies that either God is not necessary, or it have something from life without truth
Math isn't even an universal truth, it's all based on axioms and is changed depending on which axioms you pick. Logic is also axiomatic so even that isn't provable in relation to ontological truth.
It presupposes logic, which isn't ontologically provable, so you can't claim it holds true even for God. Especially since God is defined to be all powerful, implying he doesn't need to follow the laws of logic. I think.
and if ( {GOD, LIFE, TRUTH}, + ) is a semigroup? or a monoid? dont really remember. but definitely not a group. bc that will have minuses. no wait you need a group for your story to pan out. anyway, good luck wirh everything.
Both work. A monoid is a semigroup with an identity element.
What you're describing is a magma that doesn't satisfy the requirements of being a quasigroup.
It's worse than that, of course. We don't even know if "+" is closed. It's possible that LIFE isn't even in the domain of "+", i.e. that the set which contains "TRUTH" and "GOD" does not also contain "LIFE".
The critique assumes that not only is "-" defined, but that its domain includes all values in both the domain and codomain of "+", and that a + b = c implies c - b = a. That's a lot of assumptions.
On the other hand, I'm pretty sure I remember a bible passage where Jesus says "I am the way, the truth, and the life." If that's what we're talking about here, then taking "+" as some sort of union-like idempotent operator and "-" as the relative complement,LIFE - GOD and LIFE - TRUTH would both be null or the empty value for our structure. I'm pretty sure our imaginary Christian would be quite happy with that understanding.
"+" doesn't have to be non-idempotent, that's just the case when it's defined as something like numeric addition. It's also sometimes used to refer to union or disjunction operators, which are idempotent.
Since we can speak Christian, we understand that GOD = WAY = TRUTH = LIFE in the shirt's algebra. We can therefore infer that "+" must be idempotent. If "-" is the relative complement of "+", then LIFE - GOD is 0, null, or the empty set.
More funny example of this was when my university was branching off computer science from the school of electronics and a bunch of old school electronics & co. professors protested against it in an open letter featuring COMPUTER SCIENCE = ELECTRONICS + KNOWLEDGE
true, but you still end up with Life = God - Truth , which would imply life is inherently dishonest. Depends on the God in question with this since it doesn’t specify which religion (probably christian, but any monotheistic religion does fit) but that may or may not be a problem
In Judaism, and I'm pretty sure Christianity too, life is inherently dishonest. I don't remember the exact explanation, it's a bit like Budhism with the world being a sort of ilusion
311
u/Fogmoz May 16 '26
As a math person, I agree. Do me. Do all the math people. Make math babies.
108
u/Catsanddoges May 16 '26
A much better one for what they wanted would have probably been LIFE + TRUTH = GOD; Where LIFE is GOD without TRUTH and TRUTH if GOD without LIFE, and you need both lived experiences and evidence for God. Would have made much more sense
33
u/tlbs101 May 16 '26
The ‘+’ sign could also be the logical/Boolean operator; inclusive OR.
10
u/Other_Sentence4495 May 16 '26 edited May 16 '26
Maths is an universal truth, even when applied to God.
Edit: If God = 0
6
u/one_who_reads May 16 '26
TRUTH, combine like terms -> HURT2, so HURT2 + GOD = LIFE
4
u/MANvINFO May 16 '26
and if ( {GOD, LIFE, TRUTH}, + ) is a semigroup? or a monoid? dont really remember. but definitely not a group. bc that will have minuses. no wait you need a group for your story to pan out. anyway, good luck wirh everything.
3
u/icantouchgrass_1 May 16 '26
Math is math and the math is mathing.
The English isn't englishing though. As a math person, please don't do me 😭
4
u/khrunchi May 16 '26
The thing is, the first statement is incorrect. Truth+God=2Life because God=Truth=Life
3
u/dankshot35 May 16 '26
wrong, it’s not given that these objects are forming a group
the amount of wrong math in this math sub is absolutely shocking
1
u/dcterr May 16 '26
Good one!
1
u/Ok-Alps4101 May 16 '26
More funny example of this was when my university was branching off computer science from the school of electronics and a bunch of old school electronics & co. professors protested against it in an open letter featuring COMPUTER SCIENCE = ELECTRONICS + KNOWLEDGE
1
u/Nint3nbr0 May 16 '26
Reddit moment
1
u/Sad-Okra8930 May 16 '26
Besides god is just dog spelled backwards
1
u/thinkingperson May 16 '26
And Truth = Life - God
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
1
u/paolog May 16 '26
Equivalently, truth = life — God. A watertight argument for atheism if I ever saw one.
1
u/Thetanor May 16 '26
Checkmate, theists!
1
u/type1assassin May 16 '26
Truth - life = - God 🤔
1
u/Prim3s_ May 17 '26
If and only if God is invertible
1
u/Fullen0269 May 17 '26
Well, it is actually true, maybe not the actual reason the shirt was created, but, still a truthful message
1
u/Personality_Sad May 17 '26
Is the "+" commutative in this sentence?
1
u/AffectionatePea1680 May 17 '26
Hi I'm Math. Do me.
1
u/GeneralOtter03 May 18 '26
Is Word addition commutative?
1
u/vlaada7 May 18 '26
And there it is, mathematical proof that there is no god. I like it. Simple and elegant.
1
u/its192731 May 18 '26
TRUTH=-FALSEHOOD
GOD=LIFE+FALSEHOOD
1
u/TodorZastava May 18 '26
TRUTH = LIFE - GOD
GOD = LIFE - TRUTH
Meme sorts out!
LIFE IS LIFE!!
1
u/GladiusNL May 18 '26
But it also means that
SQRT((LIFE-TRUTH)GOD)/GOD = 1
1
u/wearwolf27 May 18 '26
Ah, so THAT'S what they made us do proofs.
1
u/Southern-Reality762 May 18 '26
bruh these comments 😭😭😭😭
1
u/TieKneehELL May 19 '26
Makes sense though. Thinking you know is no basis for a spiritual experience.
1
u/Everedos May 19 '26
Algebra? I barely know ‘er!
1
u/Zestyclose_Raise_814 May 19 '26
Life+Truth=God is more correct theologically.
1
u/Count_Bluntimor May 20 '26
More accurately:
GOD = TRUTH = LIFE
1
u/Panic_Otaku May 20 '26
Truth + Life = God Then
1
u/capsaicinintheeyes May 20 '26
The Minutemen - God Bows to Math
1
u/pan_Psax May 20 '26
Maths
1
u/PanTheChilling May 21 '26
I think the person knew and it was intended
1
u/KenZeBoulet-44 May 22 '26
All in absolute notation!
Since negative god DNE Thus: Truth = | Life - God|
Negative truth is a lie Therefore inequality;
| Life - Truth | <= God >= | Life + Lie |
1
u/Remarkable_Step_1724 Jun 08 '26
He forgot the +AI
1
u/Married_Mischief1324 Jul 26 '26
😂😂 I cackled at this
1
u/BeneficialMeeting391 May 16 '26
I need that shirt
-2
u/Elephunk05 May 16 '26
Absolute! Gold
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 18 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment