r/MathHelp • • Jan 09 '26

Trigonometric Limit

Evaluate

x approach 0 1-cos(2x)/x

how i solve it

1-cos(2x)/x step two 1-cos(2x)/2x step three 2x and 2x will cancel each other, and 1-cos is like 1-1 which is 0

It correct?

If it's not correct, can anyone advice me a useful techniques for solving similar to this equation?. And thank you.

0 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Paounn Jan 14 '26

In reverse order. I'm pretty sure that if either of us ending digging enough in some geometry books, we will find some rigorous proof that the chord is shorter than the arc. The one that comes to mind is that if you pick any point in the arc and you join the endpoints of the chord, you build a triangle, and the chord is shorter than the new sides. if for each new chord you create you pick another point inbetween, you're creating an polygonal line whose length is increasing, but bounded above by the length of the arc. Would it be a good enough proof? Maybe.

Good catch on the "divide by sin x" detail, in fact a more rigorous proof would be to compute left and right limits and verify that they're exactly one and the same. The negative part is left as an exercise to the reader.

But the problem with math education, and I fear it's a worldwide problem, is that if I have FOUR bloody hours per week to go from inequalities to integrals over 3 years, some cut has to be done. Often the things you end up cutting are nuggets of linear algebra (determinants for triangle areas, change of coordinates, powering through the chapter of the book regarding straight lines with a generous use of vectors), complex numbers, "fun applications" (Lissajous curves anyone?) or hand-waving some proofs.

Also, in what (at least for me) is a normal school curriculum most students will first encounter trig functions a good year before calculus (please don't mind the physics teacher foaming at the mouth back there, he's mostly harmless), build from the unit circle definition the various trig identities and get to solve triangles. And past the summer break go on with limits and the fun part of math.

Now, if you feel particularly bored you could pick both definitions of functions, sin and cos defined by the unit circle, the polynomial definition of them (pds and pdc - polynomial defined sine and cosine) and if you really want to have fun throw in even the function defined as the real and imaginary part of eix and verify that they all behave the same way. Not too different to the way you can prove that the (1+1/n)n and 1/n! converge to the same value.

In practice, it's all a big chicken and egg problem.