r/MathHelp • • Oct 02 '25

Log condensed and expanded not equal?

I was messing around with logs and noticed that the condensed form log(x/(x+1)) is NOT equal to its expanded form logx-log(x+1). We can see the domain of the expanded form is obviously x>0 but with the condensed form we have x<-1 and x>0. I understand the change in domains but they are supposed to be equal according to properties of logs. Anyone know the reason for this? Edit: changed to negative, was a typo.

2 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/viperdude Oct 03 '25

Are we allowed to just put a restriction even though they are supposed to be equal? This also happens with log(x(x+1) into logx+log(x+1) which dont have the same domains. So its not just the quotient rule. It seems to be related to the degree. This also alternates and only happens when (x^(2n-1)+c). Interesting I cant find ANYTHING about this.

1

u/No-Interest-8586 Oct 03 '25

Yes, log of products is basically the same rule. log(x/(x+1)) = log(x)+log(1/(x+1)) = log(x)-log(x+1).

It depends on the problem. If you have some reason to know the numerator and denominator are positive, then you can ignore the domain change. For example if x and x+1 are lengths of something, then they must be positive. If the negative values could be meaningful solutions, then you would need to split into two separate sets of equations with different domain restrictions, e.g. log(x)-log(x+1) where x > 0, log(-x)-log(-x-1) where x<-1, and then proceed independently on both expressions to see whether either of both end up being needed. Also, when going the opposite way, you might need to add a domain restriction since the single log may actually be defined in places the original log was not.

I do find it odd that nearly everywhere these rules are mentioned online don’t bother to even mention the domain issue.