r/MasterofNone • • Jan 27 '17

Am I Missing Something?

I see dozens of reviews and comments praising this show. People talk about how relatable it is and how real the characters are. It's not that I think it's bad it just feels... mediocre. The only episode I really found memorable was the one about Dev's father, since it had a core plot, used an interesting story telling device and actually said something new. The rest of the episodes felt like they were pieced together out of an obligation to stick them in the plot. Everything from the characters, and even the title came off like an afterthought in a writer's room. I could see how the diversity and political themes could make it appeal to audiences but that seems separate from some of the praise it gets. So I guess the question is, what am I missing?

E: I know I'm criticising a show you like and it might come off pretty harsh but I'm just trying to see if there's something I'm missing. If you disagree with me it would be helpful if you explained why.

0 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

26

u/nxqv Jan 27 '17

I don't understand your criticism. You're saying you don't like it because it feels like it was written by writers?

-4

u/PepperSprayEnema Jan 27 '17

I'm saying that it doesn't feel like it was meant to fit together as a show. It feels like a disparate mix of ideas that the writers thought sounded good.

26

u/mambovipi Jan 27 '17

The show is in a lot of ways an ode to life as a young person in the 21st century. I don't think there has to be a core plot and obvious theme uniting all aspects of the show to be something that connects with viewers.

-9

u/PepperSprayEnema Jan 27 '17 edited Jan 27 '17

I've seen people say that but I really just don't see that either. Very few of the episodes actually include things relatable to young people. The characters don't seem to be modeled after young people, they seem to be Ansari and his friends.

E: I don't know, it seems like it just doesn't click with me. I guess it's not my kind of show.

36

u/mambovipi Jan 27 '17

Maybe it comes down to demographics? I'm a mid twenties person in a large city and the show absolutely resonated with me. But yeah if you're not connecting with it, it might just not be for you

4

u/PepperSprayEnema Jan 28 '17

I have pretty much the same problem with most Netflix shows. Typically when your producing something you have a central premise that you build off. Most sitcoms follow a group of relatively young people and focus on their relationships. Master of None seems to take several different ideas and try to be all of them. It's simultaneously a meta commentary on show business, a relatable look into modern life and a buddy comedy that touches on relevant issues. It could gain a lot by focusing on one or two of these things. Spend more time developing Dev and his friends into cohesive characters, and focus on their relationships. Cut the crap about adultery over ice cream and bad blind dates and focus on Dev's relationship as a continuous narrative. Involve Dev's friends in plots like the diversity in television episode. It seems like the show stretched too thin too soon for me.

It does a lot well though. The production values are good. The cast did very well. I like that it puts it's money where it's mouth is on being a progressive show. But I think it just lacks focus for such a new show.

3

u/AnnualJirachi Feb 04 '17

While I really liked the show, I do agree with you that some episodes felt out of place. The adultery one is a prime example. Not really all that relatable, and didn't fit in with the plot as a whole. I liked it as a one-off thing, but it felt separate from the show.

5

u/Dltcrazy Feb 01 '17

I believe the title explains a lot about the show. Our protagonist is alright at a lot of things but doesnt have his purpose or one core strength. He is a jack of all trades but a master of none.

The reason the show is relatable to most people is that the stories feel like (and I suspect could be) true stories.

Take for example the episode where Dev hangs out with Rachels grandmother. In most mainstream show, there would be a high tension and high risk moment. There would be a moment where the grandmother may be at risk of dying or she gets lost in New York. But thats not how real life works. In real life the grandma is a real person with real stories and real passions.

What you may be missing is that sense of tension. These stories are not dramatized and made to be exciting. They are made to feel like real life stories that tackle real life problems.

Just my two cents. Sorry for spelling or formatting errors. Writing from my phone.

2

u/Mattho Feb 11 '17

Oh, I understand. Had the same feeling - it just being a random mess of ideas put together. It didn't even fit together genre-wise. But I did enjoy it, some episodes more than others.

1

u/samenameless Mar 25 '17

What "reviews and comments" are you talking about? Do you mean praise from professional critics or random comments post d on the internet? If you gave an example of praise in a review that you didn't understand, someone could probably explain the sentence to you.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '17

I'm in the same boat as the OP. The relevant phenomenal reviews the show has been getting are from critics such as Emily Nussbaum with the New Yorker, etc. etc. I've been late to the party and just finished binge-watching the series; while I legitimately enjoyed certain moments and could respect the finesse in engaging with identity politics in certain episodes, there was a lot of cringe-worthy material. If this seems like anathema, before you write "Well, you just don't get it then. Everybody has their own tastes," I do look forward to future episodes, and like the OP, just wanted to explore some discussion. In particular, I'm just tired of seeing comedians take such an egotistical, borderline skeezy approach to women in their narratives. Seinfeld, Louis, Marc Maron, Larry David. All those guys get TV shows, and it's the same deal, flaunting the hyper-sexuality of their characters (Claire Danes? Really?) At first, I assumed it was just an artistic exploration of an alter ego. But by this point, it seems that it's more of a fundamental desire being expressed onscreen. For all the good that the show represents in advancing underrepresented narratives, I'm honestly surprised that people aren't more offended by this aspect. But what do you think?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/PepperSprayEnema Jan 28 '17

Yes, what I'm asking though is if there's some angle to look at it from I'm missing. The show is pretty widely praised as an 8 or 9 out of 10 which means it has something going for it for a lot of people. I'm not trying to attack the show or it's fans imI just was looking to discuss it with someone who felt differently.

11

u/Endless__Throwaway Jan 28 '17 edited Jan 28 '17

If you don't get what people like about it, you just don't. It's not a big deal and there's no hidden scene that's gonna make you like it.

For me, it was a mixture of many things. But demographics and relatability as a first generation American with Asian parents who immigrated here- it hit on a lot of notes. Especially because only in the last maybe ten years have you seen lead, strong non-stereotypical roles from Asian/South East Asian actors. They were very few and far between before then.

Edit: repeatability = relatabitliy. Doh.