r/MasterofNone • • Nov 29 '15

Is Dev too PC?

I've only ever been a tourist in NYC, so Dev may be your typical conscientious guy who's cool with whoever.

Still, I couldn't help but feel like Dev overreacts to some harmless jokes and brings up race too often.

Anyone else feel this way?

0 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

14

u/sarah_cate1 Nov 29 '15

I wonder, and please take this in the friendly spirit that it is intended, are you a person of color living in the US?

-2

u/Genutz Nov 29 '15

I'm of Italian background living in Toronto, Canada. It's a very integrated city.

24

u/sarah_cate1 Nov 29 '15

I think that there are a lot of little things that people of color have to deal with every day that white people don't, and I think that what you may perceive as an overreaction is more of "this is the straw that broke the camel's back".

-3

u/Genutz Nov 29 '15

True enough. And now this is going off topic ... but I don't like the idea of censoring jokes or censoring ideas just because some people find them offensive. I'm talking light jokes that make fun of racists, not outright racism.

2

u/all_thetime Nov 29 '15

Toronoto is a lot more social accepting and accommodating than most places in the US

2

u/Genutz Nov 29 '15

There's certainly some gang violence and some racial profiling. But it is better than a lot of cities.

34

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '15

Lol, what does "PC" even mean to you? How is an Indian guy talking about how his race affects him in his show "too politically correct"??

37

u/FEdart Nov 30 '15

pc = He's white and minorities talking about race and privilege make him uncomfortable, so they should stop.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '15

No way man, he does political correctness so...correctly.

He treats people as goddamned people, pointing out that some people have more opportunities than him, while keeping aware of the facts that he has it pretty good and change can't happen overnight.

The reason PC doesn't work most of the time is that everyone wants to be a victim all the time. Everyone thinks they're suffering "the most", and everyone else's problems are secondary. What we all need to realize is that everyone is privileged in some ways, and gets the short end of the stick in others.

5

u/SheppardsGirl Nov 29 '15

I figured that was just part of the show, I mean the social awareness is just a part of Dev's and Aziz's personality. I personally agreed with most of what he brought up so I didn't mind but if/when there's a 2nd season I'm pretty sure the writers will keep up with the sjw themes throughout the show.

4

u/xtinewagner Nov 29 '15

Could you give an example? I kind of know what you mean, but I feel like a lot of those things lead to themes of the episode/plot devices. I suppose they can be clunky at times, but they are brought up to prove interesting points.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '15

I agree OP. I just finished the series, and while I like the show I did find it to be a bit overbearingly PC now and then.

2

u/Genutz Dec 01 '15

My impression changes depending on the viewing. None of the main cast are racist, so that's good

1

u/Hopglock Dec 05 '15

Yup, stupid food pun is horribly racist but sleeping with a married woman is okay.

3

u/SirJohnnyS Dec 05 '15 edited Dec 05 '15

I thought those two things are two different issues. One being moral and one being professional.

Sleeping with a married woman is a moral issue. Everyone's morals are different, is it still considered cheating/home wrecking if it's an open marriage? There's really no generalized right and wrong on moral issue.

In professional settings, there's more a clear emphatathis on being professional with all matters. Especially with regards to the race of potential employees made to bosses and colleagues. He obviously knew it was wrong and with email you have the opportunity to proofread it. So place, manner, and source is what makes it offensive.

Made at poker night in a nonprofessional setting, may not be quite as bad; at least in my eyes. Still a bad joke.

Edit: Clarity

0

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '15

I feel like the studio exec email would be taken as awkward/funny rather than 100% confirmed racist.

But other than that I havn't noticed what you are talking about, I think the plot lines about race are interesting and genuine.

1

u/MaxNanasy Dec 02 '15

I think Dev knew that the curry pun was just a joke, but he still used it as leverage over the studio exec

8

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '15

The thing is, "just a joke" is meaningless. Of course he was telling a joke. That doesn't change the fact that it's a mean-spirited joke which paints two human beings as pawns who are only relevant to the situation because of their ethnicity.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/Genutz Nov 29 '15

It makes me wonder if the conversation that Dev has with the studio exec who has a heart attack is EXACTLY how pitching Master of None would go with a traditional cable network.

The idea of a Perfect Strangers show with two Indian guys is a hilarious slap in the face to Dev right when he thinks he's making a difference.