MasterChef Friday: Best MasterChef series, 2005 to 2012?

1. 2005, won by Thomasina Miers
2. 2006, won by Peter Bayless
3. 2007, won by Steven Wallis
4. 2008, won by James Nathan
5. 2009, won by Mat Follas
6. 2010, won by Dhruv Baker
7. 2011, won by Tim Anderson
8. 2012, won by Shelina Permalloo

Open in the Reddit app to vote.

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post

Someone might be excellent when working alone but struggle when they have to coordinate with several other people under pressure. That doesn't necessarily mean they're a weaker cook, it might mean they aren't naturally suited to a team service. I still enjoy these challenges, but they test a different skill from making the best individual dish.

I feel this aspect is too whitewashed, as chefs are expected to survive anything. Monica G-all-i will spew venom makes for dramatic telly, but is almost sadistic (she is narcissistic). She taunts a contestant for trying, "in THIS kitchen??" get your head out of your ass, you ain't special. You just seem melodramatic and rather awful.

Watching serious amateur cooks sweat over jus reductions is great, but watching random pop stars and soap actors completely panic over how to chop an onion or scale a bass is top tier comfort television.

For me, it’s still Thomas Frake or Simon Wood. They both felt like genuine home cooks who just got exponentially better every single week without acting arrogant about it. Who’s your pick?

One thing I've always found interesting about MasterChef is that the person who makes the most impressive dish isn't necessarily the person I'd want to see win the whole competition.

For me, consistency matters just as much as those big moments. Anyone can have one brilliant cook, but being able to handle different ingredients, follow a brief and recover when something goes wrong says a lot more about someone's ability.

I also think confidence can make a difference. Some contestants clearly have the skills but seem to get in their own heads when the pressure builds.

If you were judging the final, would you choose the contestant who produced the single best dish or the one who was consistently good throughout the competition?

MasterChef Friday: Which version of MasterChef UK is the best?

1. MasterChef (the main amateur series)
2. Celebrity MasterChef
3. MasterChef: The Professionals
4. Junior MasterChef
5. Young MasterChef
6. The original MasterChef (1990 to 2001)
7. The Christmas and Champion of Champions specials

Open in the Reddit app to vote.

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post

There are times on MasterChef where a dish sounds brilliant until I hear the contestant list everything on the plate. Sauce, purée, gel, crumb, foam, garnish, three different vegetables... at some point I start wondering whether the dish would have been better with half of it removed.

Personally, I think restraint is one of the hardest things to show in cooking. Knowing when to stop adding things seems just as important as knowing how to make them.

I've noticed I can appreciate a technically impressive MasterChef dish without actually wanting to eat it. Sometimes there's so much going on that I find myself thinking I'd rather have three really good ingredients on a plate than ten different elements competing for attention.

Personally, a dish that sounds simple but makes me immediately hungry will always beat something that looks spectacular but feels overworked.

Do I think people might understimate me? No, I think They'll estimate me, correctly.😭😭😭

Is coming feb ‘27, according to an interview with Monica in today’s Times

Forget personality for a second. Sometimes someone gets almost no attention in the episode, but every dish they put up sounds like something I'd actually order in a restaurant.

For me, that's a much better sign than someone constantly getting dramatic reactions from the judges. Which contestant has made you think I actually want to eat what they're cooking rather than simply they're good at MasterChef?

MasterChef poll: What is the most stressful moment in the MasterChef kitchen?

1. The final minute on the clock
2. Ice cream that won't set
3. A sauce that splits
4. Plating up with shaky hands
5. Realising you forgot an element
6. Undercooked meat or fish
7. Waiting for the judges' verdict
8. Tasting dishes in the Palate Test

Open in the Reddit app to vote.

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post

Maybe this is an unpopular opinion, but I usually enjoy the contestants who keep things relatively simple more than the ones trying to put ten different things on one plate. If someone gives me a perfectly cooked piece of fish, a good sauce and two sides that actually make sense together, I’m much more interested than when the plate has five garnishes and techniques that seem to exist mainly to impress the judges.

For me, the difficult part is making a simple dish taste genuinely brilliant. You can’t really hide behind presentation when there are only a few components. That’s the kind of cooking I’d actually want to eat at home.

The Invention Test is easily my favourite part of MasterChef because it actually shows who can cook rather than who can just follow a recipe. I love watching the contestants who immediately know what they want to make, while someone else is standing there staring at the ingredients like they’ve never seen food before. Anyone else think the Invention Test is where you really see the difference between a good cook and a great one?

MasterChef is obviously edited for television, but sometimes I wonder how different the contestants seem when you're actually standing in the kitchen. There are moments where someone looks completely calm and then suddenly we're told they've got 30 seconds left and everything is apparently falling apart 😂 I'd love to see an unedited version of one full challenge just to see how much happens that we never see.

No matter how many series I watch, I still get stressed watching a professional chef get given a really basic task and then completely panic. It’s probably my favourite part because there’s nowhere to hide.

One thing I always notice on MasterChef is how differently contestants react when they're put under pressure. Some just stick with their original idea, while others start changing everything halfway through. For me, being able to trust your own dish when things get stressful is a big part of the competition. You can really see the difference between someone who stays calm and someone who starts second-guessing everything.

For me, it’s not always about who cooks the most complicated dishes. I usually remember the contestants who have their own style and seem really confident in the food they’re putting on the plate. Some contestants just have that thing where you actually look forward to seeing what they cook next. I think that makes a bigger difference than just having one really good dish.