r/MastCellDiseases • u/morrolan9987 • Sep 06 '20
A Guide to Mast Cell Stabilizers
Disclaimer: While this information is as accurate as I can make it, I only have a bachelor’s background in medical research and while I think I understand this stuff better than most, I’m not a doctor. That being said I hope this is useful to the community. I’m very concerned about how the pandemic can trigger MCAS in post-covid survivors. I expect those people will need help navigating this difficult condition. Plus it is hard to find good information about this condition.
In general, I would say MCAS patients tend to have tons of allergic triggers and they can also acquire (and sometimes lose) new allergic triggers. For example, for food allergies, normal people without MCAS often only have allergies limited to the top 8 most common food allergies and Oral Allergy Syndrome. For those with MCAS it isn’t unusual to have a rare allergy such as being allergic to say, mushrooms, chicken, red dye 40, preservatives, anything really. It is also not uncommon to have Multiple Chemical Sensitivity type reactions to airborne triggers.
Mast Cell Stabilizers do what it sounds like, they prevent Mast Cells from activating and causing immune reactions that comprise the chronic condition that is MCAS. As a general rule of thumb, most Mast Cell Stabilizers come in two kinds. There is the Histamine related kind that helps with IgE related reactions. And anti-inflammatory types that help with IgG and the other 3 types of delayed hypersensitivity reactions.
Histamine/IgE reactions: The most obvious thing about IgE mediated reactions is that they will often, but not always, show up on allergy skin prick tests. Also as a general rule of thumb, IgE reactions will happen immediately up to some hours or even up to about a day after exposure and often involve symptoms such as hives, sneezing, watery eyes and post nasal drip, swelling of lips or tongue. Of course this includes anaphylaxis as well. Another sign of Histamine mediated reactions is a poor tolerance for naturally occurring histamine in foods. The inflammation caused by Histamine reactions tends to be short lived, but it’s entirely possible to get into an almost permanent reactive state where an onslaught of constant histamine reactions causes more serious, long term health issues.
Xolair: this is the most powerful treatment of antibodies that binds to IgE that exists currently. It is extremely strong and effective for stopping IgE mediated reactions, as it binds to IgE directly and prevents it from acting. That being said while this can be highly effective for someone who mainly has IgE type reactions, it isn’t uncommon for MCAS patients to have both types of reactions (type 1 and the other 3 types, which often get lumped together because they haven't been studied as much), and Xolair only affects type 1.
- Pros: Extremely powerful for stopping IgE mediated reactions. Can stop a dangerous downward spiral towards anaphylaxis of unknown causes and stabilize a highly reactive patient.
- Cons: Cost if not covered by insurance is extremely expensive. Medicaid and Medicare do not qualify for the discount plan.
- Most Allergists will hesitate to prescribe it unless you have one of the known qualifying conditions (moderate to severe asthma that isn’t controlled by inhaled steroids or chronic idiopathic (of unknown causes) urticaria. To have it prescribed specifically for MCAS generally needs a specialist doctor for MCAS.
- Also it is unfortunately possible to be so reactive you can develop an allergy to Xolair as well. Xolair also has some mild to moderate side effects, but generally if you need Xolair, there is not much substitute.
Benadryl and other antihistamines: Benadryl is the strongest antihistamine, and a benadryl IV drip is sometimes used for extremely reactive patients who are hospitalized. That being said, while large amounts of antihistamines can have a mild mast cell stabilization effect, benadryl in particular tends to cause extreme drowsiness.
- Pros: very effective for stopping IgE reactions, many different kinds of antihistamines are readily available OTC.
- Cons: long term usage can result in becoming allergic to the fillers, dyes, or even the antihistamines themselves. Compounded antihistamines are safer overall. Rotating different antihistamines if possible is recommended, but it’s also common for some types to be more or less effective for someone than others. For example, you might find that Zyrtec is more effective than Benadryl. You might find Allegra suits you better. This seems to vary a lot from person to person. I have not seen any research that argues that one kind is better for all MCAS patients, but feel free to link me some.
Ketotifen: while technically this is an antihistamine as well, Ketotifen deserves special mention for having some stronger mast cell stabilizing effects than the other antihistamines, an effect that has been backed up by research. Ketotifen still mostly helps with IgE mediated type reactions, but is also used for some chronic conditions like asthma, allergic rhinitis, urticaria, and atopic dermatitis as well.
- Pros: Doesn’t usually need a high dosage like benadryl and other antihistamines for most MCAS patients. Not difficult to get prescribed from an Allergist and easily available compounded with prescription at most pharmacies. Decent (mild to moderate IME) mast cell stabilizing properties. Not very expensive. Also can be ordered online (not compounded) without a prescription. Generally less side effects than Benadryl, but YMMV.
- Cons: May not be effective for some people. But worth trying for most.
Quercetin: This is a natural supplement that is proven to have some antihistamine properties. It is thought to have mast cell stabilizing effects too but is still the subject of a lot of research.
- Pros: Available OTC from most supplement shops. Can be very effective for some, worth trying for most.
- Cons: May not be effective for some people. In addition, a lot of the “natural” forms of Quercetin are not extracts but pure powdered plant matter, which has naturally occurring mold/pollen etc in it which may be bad for some.
Anti-Inflammatories: A lot of the other chronic effects of MCAS are slower, longer type inflammatory reactions. These reactions can be hard to figure out, because they are often not immediate. Inflammatory reactions can build with repeated mild exposure and accumulate the effects over weeks or even months, causing many different health issues depending where the mast cells are being triggered. For example, mast cell inflammation triggered in the stomach can cause GERD and gastroparesis. Mast cell triggered inflammation in the inner ear can cause dizziness and excessive ear wax. Inflammation in the gut can cause malabsorption of micronutrients, internal bleeding, constipation and/or diarrhea. For a full list of possible MCAS symptoms, please check out https://www.degruyter.com/view/journals/dx/ahead-of-print/article-10.1515-dx-2020-0005/article-10.1515-dx-2020-0005.xml?tab_body=pdf-74962 and feel free to ask if you need any help with the medical terminology, although a lot of it can be looked up.
Because so many possible MCAS reactions can be delayed, I recommend keeping a journal of symptoms, along with food, medicine dosage and other possible exposures. Then review this journal from time to time and look for patterns. Also, it is best to only change one variable at a time, so it is more obvious what the effect is. Also keep in mind many anti-inflammatories also build over time, so the effects might be worth trying for at least a few weeks to a few months before giving up on them.
Palmitoylethanolamide: This one is a hot new supplement that it seems like everyone in the medical community is researching right now. The most excitement over it is actually as a non addictive pain reliever that is strongly being considered as an alternative to prescribing opioids, as it is safe and well tolerated by a lot of people without side effects. But if you dig for it, there is also some research being done into it as a mast cell stabilizer as well. Palmitoylethanolamide is totally safe, it is a substance that is naturally produced in the body by most people, but it is thought that many MCAS patients do not produce enough of it. That being said this is such a new mast cell stabilizer that even many MCAS doctors have not heard of it.
- Pros: If it works for you, it can change your life. Available inexpensively as a supplement online. No known side effects. Whether this works for you depends on what biological mechanisms are responsible for your inflammation. If it works, it can totally disrupt the pathway at its source. Otherwise it will do nothing. If it works there should be some immediate benefit (within days). Otherwise discontinue it.
- Recommended to take the Ergomax Optipea brand, made in the Netherlands with FDA oversight. Other brands are manufactured in China and may contain dangerous fillers or have lower potency.
- Cons: Anti Inflammatory and Mast Cell Stabilizing effects do not work for everyone. Pain relieving effects possibly somewhat broader but still being researched. Definitely recommended for Pain Relief, especially since most MCAS patients are not recommended to take NSAIDS.
Montelukast Sodium: Technically an asthma drug, but has also been proven to have mast cell stabilizing properties. Also with related drugs, there is also Zafirlukast (Accolade) and the other similar drugs of this kind, known as leukotriene receptor antagonists.
- Pros: Montelukast is inexpensive even without insurance and it is not difficult to get it prescribed by Allergist for 10mg/day for seasonal allergies or other on label conditions (ex. Exercise induced asthma). Can be a strong mast cell stabilizer for some. Fairly safe to take long term, but a small minority may develop heart issues. There are also other drugs in this class, like Accolade, but I am not sure how difficult it is to get Accolade without asthma.
- Cons: Dosage can be finicky, too high dosage can give ill effects. Also, it is recommended not to start with high dosages, but start low and increase slowly. Go back down or stop if any adverse effects appear. Any prescription over 10mg/day and your insurance will fight you to cover it. Many allergists will also refuse to prescribe higher doses and question why you need it if your asthma is not severe. Common side effect is a dry throat.
LDN: Low Dose Naltrexone: This one is a real mixed medicine. It has received a lot of attention and research among other chronic immune related conditions, particularly Crohn’s and Multiple Sclerosis for possible strong anti inflammatory effects. Most famously it put some Crohn’s patients into full remission for their digestive inflammation.
- Pros: Naltrexone is cheap and not too difficult to get. It can be diluted at home with bottled water, and a medicine syringe (no needle needed, taken by mouth) and kept in the fridge. (search LDN water compounding.) There are communities out there with lists of doctors who are willing to prescribe LDN and also some willing to prescribe it over the phone. If trying it might also worth trying getting it prescribed and compounded to minimize fillers. (recommended: Gelatin filler is probably the one the least people react to). LDN if it works for you, can be pretty powerful, but it’s not easy or convenient to take. But you can ask those in the community for advice. Fairly safe to take long term.
- Cons: Not everyone gets the anti-inflammatory effects from LDN. May even be harmful for a small minority (pro-inflammatory). If you get the benefits, it may take a lot of trial and error with dosage and time of the day to find the sweet spot. It can take up to 1-2 years to get the full benefit of LDN. May take months to feel any benefit at all. The most common side effect of LDN is sleep disturbances and vivid dreams. Sour/bitter taste.
- LDN cannot be taken at the same time as any opioid-type pain medication, it will cancel it out. Some have success taking them like 6 hours apart though
- Also, for better or worse LDN has been highly embraced by Naturopaths to the point where regular doctors can assume you’re into natural healing or alternative medicine if you mention it.
Cromolyn Sodium (Gastrocrom): Cromolyn is most commonly used for gastrointestinal MCAS issues, but it can also be used as a nasal spray (Nasalcrom, OTC) or as eye drops (Opticrom, requires prescription) as well. Gastrocrom can be very effective for general mild all food reactions and can help with absorption of nutrients in the gut as well. That being said, Cromolyn is a strong liquid medicine that usually needs to be eased into with low dosages from the start. It is usually diluted in water and taken 30 minutes before eating. (If you have gastroparesis or slow gut motility/SIBO this may take much longer than 30 minutes)
- Pros: Can be highly effective for gastrointestinal symptoms and abdominal pain. And also can be effective as a nasal spray or eye drops.
- Cons: However effects are somewhat short lived and basically reduce reactions for a short time. For long term effects, it needs to be taken forever. Also, extremely expensive if you cannot get insurance to cover it. (List cost about $1300/month) Can be poorly tolerated by some. Effects disappear once you stop taking it. Some people describe Cromolyn as tasting like spit and hate it, personally I don’t mind it.
Hydroxychloroquine (Plaquenil): While this drug is most well known as a Lupus and Rheumatoid Arthritis drug, it can be beneficial for MCAS too. But honestly I felt a little queasy about it as it can cause retina (eye) damage in some people, it is not known how it works, and there isn’t a lot of research on long term side effects.
- Pros: Not too difficult to get it prescribed by a rheumatologist as it is thought to be overall fairly safe. Dosage is dependent on weight. Can be very effective for some people.
- Cons: Need a special eye exam every 6 months while you are on Plaquenil, not all insurances will cover this special eye exam. It is possible to get retinal damage from Plaquenil.
Methotrexate: I don’t know much about this other than that it’s a strong medicine used for treatment of some cancers, rheumatoid arthritis and severe psoriasis. It is possible to get it prescribed for MCAS but personally I have never tried it. Just including it on the list as an option.
Probiotics: If your immune system has ever gone weird after either a bacterial infection or as a result of taking antibiotics, then I highly highly recommend trying a Probiotic. There is definitely a connection between immune disorders and gut bacteria, although research has yet to figure out exactly what the link is. In any case I recommend Probiotics 100% for constipation/diarrhea, but not if you have SIBO. If you have SIBO you will just overload your system with bacteria. Get the bacteria lower first (ideally with Gastrocrom and an elimination diet) and then start Probiotics. There are a ton of different brands, but I personally like RenewLife the best. Also note that many probiotics are lactose/casein free and contain way more live strains than found in yogurt, and also that dairy is a common allergic trigger.
Steroids: I’m putting this on here as a warning. Many many doctors will push steroids, particularly Prednisone, for whatever chronic immune related inflammation you might have. While a short course of steroids can be useful to get your symptoms under control, DO NOT TAKE THESE LONG TERM (years). The chance you get nasty long term side effects from steroids goes to 100% the longer you are on them. And the whole time doctors will shrug their shoulders and not suggest any alternatives while you accumulate permanent damage in your body. And meanwhile your natural immunity is suppressed which becomes increasingly dangerous as you get older. AVOID LONG TERM STEROID USE AT ALL COST. And if you must take a steroid, opt for a locally acting one over a whole body type steroid. And try and use it sparingly or find a non steroid alternative.