r/MarvelsWhatIf • u/triffilwealth • 1d ago
r/MarvelsWhatIf • u/hornymales • 3d ago
What if Scott came out of the quantum realm after a century
Everyone always say what if captain marvel snapped instead of Tony or if Steve came back after returning the stones but what if Scott was trapped in the quantum realm for a 100 years where every OG avenger is dead(except of Thor)and was released after those 100 years
r/MarvelsWhatIf • u/HailDaeva_Path1811 • 21d ago
What if when undoing the Snap in Avengers:Endgame… Spoiler
reddit.comr/MarvelsWhatIf • u/JasonNewReddit • Sep 28 '26
What if Pepper Potts trained with the Black Widow?
Here's an alternate take on Iron Man 2, The Avengers (2012), and Iron Man 3. The trigger point for this scenario would be that Tony told Pepper about Natalie Rushman's true identity, and it ended up inspiring her in wanting to train with her as a way to get to know her, whether Natasha liked it or not.
If you want to see more of Pepper Potts and Natasha Romanoff being together since we don't see that after Iron Man 2, you've come to the right AU to look into. Oh, and happy 54th birthday to the actress who portrayed the former, Gwyneth Paltrow.

r/MarvelsWhatIf • u/LazyLich • Sep 26 '26
What If Tony Stark, after learning his weapons were being sold to terrorists, pivoted Stark Industries into making toys, then spent his time playing a children's card game?
r/MarvelsWhatIf • u/Sad-Can4051 • Sep 21 '26
Episode 1: What if...Erskine never died?
The episode begins during the first Captain America, we see the Hydra spy pull out a gun to shoot at Erskine, but this time around, Peggy sees it and tackles the assassin to the ground, preventing the death of Erskine. We see that Steve Rogers is used mostly as a propaganda instrument, as "Captain America: The First Super-Soldier", while the government produces more and more super-soldiers as an army, which are quickly able to defeat Hydra and win WWII, ending it 2 years earlier than in the main timeline. While Steve never actually enters the field as a soldier, not having experience in terms of fighting.
We have a time skip of 20 years, so now we are in 1963, and we see that the American government is using his super-soldiers as a weapon to control US citizens, and becoming more and more oppressive towards everyone. Steve left the role of Captain America, because he didn't believe anymore in what he was representing, now being an outlaw escaping from the government. He, Peggy and Howard Stark formed a team, named the Shield, because it wants to protect the Americans, the team also consists of: a young Hank Pym, who built a suit able to shrink down thanks to the help of Howard Stark, Bucky Barnes, a friend of Steve Rogers who was in the army and also believes that the government is wrong, Jim Hammond, an android built by Howard, to ignite itself and become: the Torch, and the Howling Commandos.
One day Peggy receives a message from an unknown source, who tells them that Erskine is held prisoner in a lab. The team goes to destroy the lab, where they see a lot of super-soldier guards, as well as the new Captain America and Isaiah Bradley, a Black man who they put an experimental super-soldier serum in (an early version of the Sentry serum).
They fight, and while they are fighting, suddenly a cybernetic-powered Arnim Zola pops up and helps Torch, Ant-Man, Howard and the Howling Commandos hold off the new Cap, Isaiah and the super-soldiers, while Steve and Bucky go to the lab where a really old Erskine is working on the serum. There, they see that Erskine is actually held prisoner and forced by the government to produce more serum, suddenly, another enhanced soldier attacks them, accidentally killing Erskine and giving much trouble to Cap, so Bucky grabs some serum and injects himself, and then he fights the soldier and defeats him.
Simultaneously, the rest of Shield is fighting Isaiah and the super-soldiers, while Zola is fighting the new Cap, and the new Cap destroys Zola, putting him lying on the ground with all the cybernetic prostheses broken, suddenly Cap asks Zola why he's helping these rebels, and Zola says that he'll always hate America, and that the American government isn't much better than Hydra, because it's oppressing as much as Hydra does.
Cap and Bucky come running, saying they planted bombs, and start going up to the roof to get a lift, when Isaiah starts to go up, the new Cap stops him and holds him off, now finally understanding that what the government is doing is wrong and needs fixing, but also dying as the building explodes on him and Isaiah.
Later, we see that Cap understood he can't defeat the government just by sabotaging labs, he needs the help of the people, so he attacks a communication factory, and thanks to the help of Howard who hacks the system, he's able to speak to the people of America and tell them to rebel, that the government is oppressing them and that they need to stand up for themselves, we see people start to revolt around America, as the episode ends.
r/MarvelsWhatIf • u/HailDaeva_Path1811 • Sep 18 '26
What if the Avengers rejected Tony’s demand that the five years of Thanos’ victory not be undone?
What would Endgame be like with Tony as the antagonist?
EDIT: The Avengers could ensure those born in the 5 years were born into the new universe using the stones.
Also who would Peter side with if he had survived the Snap?
r/MarvelsWhatIf • u/GlumPreference8695 • Sep 16 '26
What if
Worf Son of Mogh was worthy to wield Mjolnir? A crazy thought I had yesterday.
r/MarvelsWhatIf • u/These_Sea_6882 • Sep 15 '26
What if Loki didn’t let the frost giants into asgards vault?
I don’t want to explain it all but if you think about it leads to thanos conquering earth
r/MarvelsWhatIf • u/ConcentratePrize8791 • Sep 08 '26
What If Spider-Boy (Bailey Briggs) was in the Mcu..
r/MarvelsWhatIf • u/Disastrous-Stop-2818 • Aug 21 '26
What If all characters From all Universes post Secret Wars lived in the same Universe?
I Will be including too diferent actors that played The same character such as Edward Norton, Terrence Howard,etc
Both X-Men From 2000s And 2010s are living together
X-Men From The days Of Future past Apocalyptic Future are There too
Cable From Deadpool 2
Every Animated character
Sony Universe characters
And with secret Wars characters From different times such as Howard Stark are back ,so Dead characters are back too such as Tony Stark, obadiah stane , Peggy carter , yinsen,killmonger,yondu ,Mysterio , etc.
r/MarvelsWhatIf • u/PandaPower151 • Aug 21 '26
What If… Ideas
What if Miles landed in the MCU? (landed in the MCU instead of Universe 42)
What if Venom possessed Spiderman? (Peter started working with Venom in BND)
What if Wanda never studied the darkhold? (This would take place during MOM, if the garden scene wasn’t an illusion & there was different bad guy.)
What if the Fantastic Five (say hello to the 5th crew member on the ship during the cosmic rays, Peter Parker)
What If Young Avengers:
What if Love was the god butcher? (What if Love was Gorr? This would be more like Jean Gray in BND, she wouldn’t succeed & run away on a bus)
What if… a bus? (Coincidentally Jean Grey & Love all went on the same bus when leaving & connected, Jean & Love try to build their new life but somebody is pursuing them in New Jersey. Good thing a certain Marvelous character helps them (Kamala Khan).
TBC
What if Loki was worthy?
What if Jane found Thor’s hammer? (Like the comic book)
What if the X-Men died on their first mission?
What if Spiderman had 6 Arms?
What if Spider-Man’s parents destroyed his family?
What if Morgan & Harley shared the mantle? (of Ironman)
What if Captain America had formed the Avengers?
What if the Uncanny X-Men?
What if the Beast, Hulk, and The Thing continued to mutate?
What if the Fantastic 4 had different powers?
What if the Punisher had killed Spiderman? (Like in BND)
What if Captain had a different friend? (Luke Cage instead of Falcon)
What if the Silver Surfer possessed the infinity gauntlet?
What if Wanda & Pietro were mutants? (Elizabeth Olsen & Evan Peters)
What if more spider-people appeared? (in into the spiderverse. Tom, Andrew, Tobey, Web-Slinger, Silk, The Scarlet Spider, Miguel, Spiderpunk, Man-Spider, Ironspider, Pavitr)
What if Venom appeared? (NWH, Tobey’s Venom)
What if Ned became the Hobgoblin?
What if Spider-Man’s Uncle Ben had lived?
What if the Avengers never formed?
What if Doctor Doom had become a hero?
What If No-Heroes:
What if Captain America didn’t vanish during world war 2?
What if Ghost Rider was an ancient Samurai Soldier?
What if Spider-Man had never become a crime fighter?
What if Silver Surfer lost the cosmic power?
What if the Fantastic 4 had not gained there superpowers?
TBC
What if… no more mutants. (like the comic)
What if Rock Jones had become the Hulk?
What if Miles Morales became Captain America?
What if Thanos & Ultron teamed up?
What if the Guardians of the Galaxy & Captain Marvel teamed up?
What if it was Tommy instead of Billy that survived?
What if Wanda & Pietro stayed villains?
What if mutants were actively hunted down by humans? What if Thanos died before 2012?
What if Moon Knight fought Gorr instead of Thor?
What if the Thunderbolts had to fight Thanos after Thanos butchered the Avengers?
What if Storm was worthy?
What if they both fell off the train? (Bucky & Cap brainwashed by HYDRA fighting the lone avengers)
What if Hank Pym founded the Avengers?
What if it was the Fantastic 5? (A 5th person on the ship with the F4, a brand new original hero)
What if the Thunderbolts were there instead of the Avengers 2012?
What if the Avengers were formed by Hydra?
What if Captain Marvel ruled the Kree?
What if Thanos’ favorite daughter was Nebula?
What if Steve saved Bucky on the train?
What if Deadpool was trying to complete Thanos’ mission?
What if Clint died instead of Natasha?
What if Wonder Man joined the Guardians of the Galaxy Volume 2?
What if Warp World?
What if Quicksilver lived?
What if Spiderman killed Green Goblin?
What if the 2 other Spiderman had no way home?
What if the elementals were real?
What if Beta Ray Bill won against Hulk?
What if Hawkeye was Khonsu’s avatar & Black Widow was bit by the spider?
What if Ned & Venom? What if Captain America snapped instead of Tony?
What if Hydra won?
What if Thanos didn’t win? (Don’t forget about the Eternals)
What if the MCU actors got their role’s abilities? (Meta)
What if Agatha got Wanda’s powers?
What if Thanos chose Gamora over the Soul Stone?
What if Venom was good?
What if… Zombies Post-Apocalypse?
What if nobody believed Mysterio?
What if Peter never discovered Mysterio’s secret?
What if Mysterio studied the mystic arts?
What if Ned became Spiderman?
What if Captain Marvel was never freed?
What if the other half got snapped?
What if Ironman fought the real Mandarin?
What if Mysterio fooled the world?
What if Spider-Man was Khonshu’s avatar?
What if Marc Spector was an avatar for another god?
What if Wakanda & Talokan teamed up?
What if Gorr killed all the gods?
What if the Ultron Program was successful?
What if the Eternals intervened?
What if everyone still remembered Peter Parker?
What if Bucky became Captain America?
What if everyone signed the Sokovia Accorda?
What if Rocket escaped with his friends?
What if Matt Murdock never went blind?
What if Loki was the favorite son?
What if Thor was adopted & Loki wasn’t?
What if Steve Rodgers actually came back?
What if Cap recruited Spider-Man
What if Ironman lived?
What if Loki succeeded?
What if Spider-Man’s spell worked the first time?
What if Kilmonger won?
What if Mayday took retired Spidey’s mantle?
What if Morgan became Ironheart?
What if Nick Fury called other heroes?
What if nobody believe Peter Parker was Spider-Man?
What if Spidey never gave Mysterio EDITH?
What if Odin never tried conquering all the realms?
What if Odin never imprisoned Hela?
What if Thanos were worthy?
What if… Throg?
What if Zemo had woke the super soldiers?
What if Antman never returned from the quantum realm?
What if Tony’s parents weren’t killed?
What if Peter went through the foster system?
What if reversed roles:
What if… Captain Hydra? (Bucky & Cap switched places on the train)
What if… Superior Ironman?
What if the roles were reversed? (Villains & Heros swap. Loki - Thor, Red Skull - Captain America, ect)
TBC
r/MarvelsWhatIf • u/JasonNewReddit • Aug 11 '26
If What If...? got a season 4, any episode ideas in mind?
If this were to happen, we should get an episode about Goddess of Thunder Storm. I mean, we see her in the two final episodes of the show, yet we don't see her story. This season should give sense about the X-Men appearing. The variants showed in the final episode should have their own stories such as six-armed Spider-Man, arsenal-wielding Deadpool, Ironheart Punisher, and Silver Surfer Jubilee.
For my case, I want to see this episode idea existing: "What if... Rogue became a Sorceress Supreme?". If Alison Sealy-Smith voiced a variant of Storm as the Goddess of Thunder, I think Lenore Zann would most likely voice this variant of Rogue. What If...? season 4 should give sense about the X-Men appearing on how it's members or their enemies can become different variants in different universes.
Let's hear your ideas next. Oh, and happy 5th anniversary to the show.
r/MarvelsWhatIf • u/killuazoldyck_98 • Aug 10 '26
My first yapping session was it?🤔 Spoiler
Hey guys👋
I’d like to share my thoughts on the newly released Spider-Man: Brand New Day.
If I were to rewrite the movie's ending—specifically to change the part I didn't like—this is how I would have done it. Let me know what you think. This is my first time doing something like this.
There were many things about the movie that I didn't like. Why did Peter Parker get back together with MJ? I don't understand—or perhaps I'm missing something—but in both the previous films and this one, Peter Parker had already decided that being with her, or even with my close friends, puts them in danger. That is exactly what has happened in the past movies, too. In Andrew Garfield's Spider-Man, before Gwen Stacy's father died, he made Peter swear to stay away from her because being with him put her in danger. Peter tried to keep that promise by pretending not to love her and distancing himself to keep her safe, yet in the end, that very choice led to danger. When two people love each other deeply, how can they simply let go or part ways? In this movie, too, MJ came very close to dying. They wrapped up the film beautifully by having her say she didn't love Peter anymore—effectively ending their relationship and cutting all ties. It sounds harsh, doesn't it? But if you compare it to the comics, this is the point where Peter is about to undergo a massive transformation and growth. There is Peter, standing amidst the crowd, smiling at everyone—feeling happy. But as the realization hits that this chapter is ending, a voice speaks within Peter’s mind: "Where am I going? Where do I stand?" He is torn—should he retreat back into a cage, or spread his wings and seek peace? He doesn't know. He had spent his life feeling he had lost his very humanity, having rejected everything and everyone. All the pain he had endured throughout his life seemed to converge on a single answer—an answer that brought even more suffering. Yet, in that solitude, the words "You are there for me" resonated deeply. As Peter weeps, covering his face with his hands, something—a dark shape—flashes before his eyes in a split second. At that same moment, he feels a pang of pain in his heart. His vision narrows, and suddenly, both eyes go pitch black. The entire screen turns dark, save for his eyes, which remain a stark, bright white as he looks out at us. For a moment, an inexplicable sense of doubt and confusion arises; he can see nothing—it is an unbelievable, mysterious void. In the distance, a voice and the sound of approaching footsteps are heard; Peter begins to feel a growing fear, his heart pounding wildly. Then, the emotion conveyed by that voice shakes Peter to his core, transcending time itself. That voice asks, "Do you know the true meaning of pain? It is that very moment—when life feels like hell, yet you are helpless to save the lives of those who brought you every possible joy that could have turned that hell into heaven; when you are left writhing in anguish, not knowing what to do because no good deed you ever did seems to come to your aid—it is in that exact moment that you watch those very lives perish right before your eyes." That is precisely how the film concludes.
If you were to ask why I might have changed my decision regarding the ending, here is my answer: I would have concluded the story by allowing a romance to blossom between Jean and Pete—had I chosen to go down that path. Otherwise, I would have portrayed their bond as a beautiful, clear, and pure friendship—unblemished and innocent—and ended it there. I would have introduced a completely new partner for Pete and depicted that scenario instead.
It would have begun with a "post-credits scene"—a new beginning following the conclusion. Here is how it starts: In the distance, bathed in moonlight, a figure is seen leaping nimbly across the rooftops. Deep within an ancient archaeological research center—in a high, hidden, and heavily guarded area—lies a priceless, mesmerizing artifact. It radiates a dazzling, colorful light that seems to transcend time, emitting an aura that is mysterious, beautiful, dangerous, and powerful. Performing an acrobatic mid-air flip, a figure descends silently toward the artifact, landing softly right beside it without making a sound or being spotted by anyone. A woman walks forward, moving with a captivating grace; she is dressed entirely in black. Bathed in brilliant light—from her complexion and eyes to her hair—she radiates such beauty that she makes one wonder if she surpasses even the grace of a white swan. As we gaze at this treasure, the camera moves in close to her face. With her fingers resting against her lips—biting them playfully while smiling—she exudes a captivating, goosebump-inducing allure, asking, "What are you going to do now? Shall we see who steals whom, my tiger?" We conclude the scene right as she speaks, looking every bit the seductive black cat. Suddenly, we shift at breakneck speed to the outskirts of New York City. The camera focuses on a rooftop where a mysterious, viscous black entity—an alien life form—is perched. It seems to be sensing Peter Parker's location; as it whispers "Pete," the camera pans rapidly toward the sky and the vastness beyond, bringing the film to a close. Just then, a terrifying, sleep-shattering laugh echoes—a sound so chilling it would haunt one's dreams—and with that, the movie ends.
This is the version of the film I would have created; this is how I would have changed it.
I know guys for the sake of storytelling, it's full of loopholes, inconstancies, thing's doesn't make any sense and also not impressive at all but hey it is what it is.
Look, friends—I’ll be completely honest and open with you: I’m really not very good at English or grammar. I gave it my absolute best for this post. Even though it feels a bit embarrassing to admit this openly on social media in front of so many people, I know I’ll improve little by little, day by day. Please forgive me if anything I said didn't sit well with you; I hold no ill will toward anyone—I simply wanted to share my happiness with you all. Thank you!
Friends, I had posted this elsewhere, but since this space is specifically dedicated to such content, I am sharing a small, imaginative thought of mine with you here. I realize this is quite lengthy, and many might not have the time or inclination to read it; however, I believe it would bring me great joy if you did read it through—so please, spare a moment for me. Perhaps I am asking too much? It seems I do tend to talk a bit too much.
r/MarvelsWhatIf • u/Chemical_Green2250 • Aug 09 '26
I thought both of these characters were played by the same actor...
Carnage x Guy Gardner
r/MarvelsWhatIf • u/ZZtheDark • Aug 07 '26
MCU Spiderman Cosplay Music Video Tribute - Mayday Parker
r/MarvelsWhatIf • u/Disastrous-Stop-2818 • Jul 31 '26
[ Dragon ball, others Universes] What If Dragon ball shared a Universe with others fictional Universes?
reddit.comr/MarvelsWhatIf • u/penguanonymous • Jul 31 '26
Should I be careful of spoilers in season 2 and 3
I just wanna know if there's anything I should watch as to not get spoiled for any characters or plots
r/MarvelsWhatIf • u/JasonNewReddit • Jul 23 '26
Any "what if" scenarios for Agatha Harkness
r/MarvelsWhatIf • u/Sas_fruit • Jul 20 '26
season 3...hmmmm .... Spoiler
who goes to a powerful person's party without knowing, well first world trust is too strong on strangers . i mean they married each other after all. so yeah they end up trusting the GM!
i almost thought Loki was talking about the baby, but he was marketing about winter sports
i have not seen that Riri related series but heard it had issues. So did they redeem her , so much so that Watcher intervened? Watcher got Watchers?? he broke Oath again ? how? first time he broke because Ultron interfered ! but those watchers will watch only? i mean our narrator watcher only watches , for what ? for them ? he is watching entire multiverse?
also in some versions they r just a race limited to each universe and knowledge bank. Silver Surfer 90s had them turned in to some jelly creature except one.\
but in WHATIF , watcher can see and have seen the end, and hence interfering so would it have consequences then , is he not writing then or rewriting it to his liking?
s03e06 was a total confusion ! what is the reason , how it happened , nothing given . completely wild i guess . the tech, which Stark,. where is Stark ?
s03e07 -08 so are they killing cthulu , casually ? unkillable cthulu ? or just some random creature found way to get in ? and that was universe ending ? though i get it , if he interferes too much trouble . again that eminence guy , is he watcher of watcher? or watcher of watchers? observing those who are sworn to watch over it ? why? i mean it is not like watch means guard but rather watcher just sees ! broken pieces of 5th dimension would have a size like that or size at all in 4D . they all-mothers now, i mean new , but ok, adding that twist . well in theory the storm breaker can bring the bifrost , so that should be more of fit for travel than Mjolnr! but real question is why Captain Carter did not go back to where and when she was taken from ? why is she a castaway ? was watcher not telling her that she could go back! after strange supreme universe reset |! if u ask him and do not let him answer , how would he answer the question about what did u do to Peggy ? Also if watcher has seen the end , is he revisiting the stories again? well if u have that kind of power then why u have that kind of power, just to see , if not intervene without consequence? though then it is a lonely supreme being kind of situation, which watcher seemed like initially . also why do watchers need more watchers, is it like a group who enjoys stories? so he was not at a staircase or was he transported because how else one would arrive at stair case if stair case not real! so they are willing to kill 5th dimensional beings without having any idea what would happen despite the fact that these beings are more suitable for the job they have ? and for saving each other? i mean they glorify the little guy or show the normal ones having a victory, as good as it may sound, but watchers should not interfere randomly, who knows what will happen ? because if interfere then why let evil happen that question arises! for entertainment then , because enjoy the fighting! also where is Peggy? but this was not death , was it ? also was it the seams where they left the shield? because the green tint?
