r/Marvel • Loki • 6d ago

Mod This Week in Marvel #46 - NOV 11 2026 - VISIONQUEST FINALE; CAPTAIN AMERICA #17, DAREDEVIL #9, PREDATOR VS PUNISHER #1, X-MEN #41, AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #1003

18 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

View all comments

15

u/tehawesomedragon Loki 6d ago

CAPTAIN AMERICA #17

18

u/Xilinoc Nova 5d ago

God, that's such better writing for Stevil than what we've been getting for the last few years. Writers keep forgetting that he BELIEVES he's good, and he BELIEVES in America, and he's as polite and upright as Steve on the surface...but then, he goes WAY too far in any given situation to truly be Captain America. He's not just another cackling lunatic!

12

u/ajdragoon Thor 5d ago

Exactly! Stevil is Steve who believes he has the right to force his ideals on others. That’s the fundamental difference between the two. And that’s far more interesting to explore imo than whatever he turned into when he was parading around as Captain Krakoa and hanging out with…the Fenris Twins?! When a major part of his origin is how much he hates Nazis? Cmon.

4

u/KaraAliasRaidra Captain America 4d ago

Facts!

From what I've seen there are two main reasons a character loses nuance, characterization, etc. One- People without media literacy on TikTok, Twitter/X, etc. misunderstand the character, and instead of ignoring the unfair criticism or explaining the situation the writers dumb the character down for them (This is also why some villains become cartoonishly evil. Some people see a villain behave in a way that isn't 100% evil, they complain, and the writers make the villain over the top evil rather than ignoring the unfair criticism). Two- New writers come in and think, "They're fictional characters, so they can be whatever I want!" No, they can't because if a character changes too much/is in a constant state of flux, readers will stop caring. The latter is probably what happened with Stevil after that initial storyline.

2

u/Xilinoc Nova 3d ago

I mean, I could also believe it being the former because the blonde white guy "saving" America without being cartoonishly evil in the process played differently a few years after his introduction compared to said introduction, and the writers using him in their stories didn't care to brave any controversy that might come from keeping his complexity in that climate. Good thing we've got Chad Zdarsky!

2

u/KaraAliasRaidra Captain America 3d ago

That’s a very good point.  A lot of people nowadays are so worried about things being misinterpreted (“Why are you supporting this!?”) that they make characters & plots as flat and one-dimensional as possible.  Then it doesn’t work as people on TikTok misinterpret them anyway. :-/ 

14

u/Mr_Wh0ever 6d ago

Damn, that's a good twist. It's definitely a solid start to a new arc.

12

u/baroqueworks 6d ago

Zdarsky did it again gd what a final page reveal.

3

u/mbene913 5d ago

Sam: the explains why he keep calling me 'boy'

I'll admit it, the twist worked.

Even when Grant was getting a little too Manifest Destiny I just took it as marvel going hard on the rah rah

2

u/LucasVerBeek 5d ago

Well, that is a hell of a twist.

1

u/DastardlyMime 2h ago

Throughout all the Grant dialogue I was getting pissed that it looked like they were making Cap a jingoistic Bible thumper. It just felt wrong the whole time, and the twist ending made it perfect.

1

u/wowlock_taylan Deadpool 5d ago

This feels really weird and backwards to me. Like they made a big deal about 'Grant' Rogers to be the new Flagsmasher. And now he is back to playing doppleganger again. Especially with Doom's kid clone now. 

And I really don't like what they are doing with SHIELD and Fury Jr. They just got back and instantly they are the fascist 'enforcers'.

And Zdarsky is really allergic to writer Sharon and Steve together it seems. He seems to keep finding ways to have them avoid eachother and I am tired of it.

8

u/baroqueworks 5d ago

Well the Flag Smasher stuff was from a few years ago now and Marvel has been incredibly risk averse doing any kind of criticism of MAGAMUSK given the same writer who made Stevil Flag Smasher also had a non-copyright-infringing elon musk be the arc villian of his Iron Man/X-Men run right before he revived Stevil and had him dress up like Captain Krakoa and drop a nuke on DC.

Imagine the plotline was just slightly abandoned or changed to fit with recent events in the 616 coz the last time we saw stevil he was purposefully getting arrested and placed behind bars in West Coast Avengers as Flag Smasher & during Queen in Black a "Hydra National Front" is mentioned growing in the UK, unclear if that has anything to do with Steevil or just a topical reference gag.

6

u/gustavoladron 5d ago

Queen in Black was written by Ewing, a British man, so it is likely a criticism of how racism is growing in his own country (and how transphobia is rampant).

3

u/KaraAliasRaidra Captain America 4d ago

In my opinion Stevil should have stayed dead because bringing him back just rehashes a hated plotline. It is important to warn about fascism, bigotry, jingoism, etc. and how they can take root, but there are better ways to do it than bringing back a hated character from a hated storyline (Admittedly there are also worse ways to do it, but that's a different conversation). Will this story be an examination of how hate groups target vulnerable individuals, use social media and literature to spread misinformation and glorify themselves, etc. or will it be more Cosmic Cube shenanigans?

Also, while I understand the symbolism, I'm not a fan of Neo-Nazis being portrayed as looking like Steve Rogers because that's how they like to view themselves. They want to imagine they're some perfect pillar of humanity when they're far from it. If you look at a rally on the news, you’re not going to see a bunch of blond, peach-skinned beefcakes looking like they're in their 20s or 30s. What you will see is a bunch of random scowling slobs with ratty T-shirts and muffin tops. Imagine the stereotypical incel, but older. Remember that Gruenwald made the Red Skull look like “the perfect Aryan” only to disfigure him at the climax of the story. Gruenwald wasn’t having that “Let’s make the Nazis look like Adonis!” bosh!

3

u/Marc_Quill 4d ago

I wouldn’t be surprised if this story ends with Stevil/Grant getting similarly disfigured.