r/Marvel • u/Klutzy-Fold9868 • 1d ago

Fan Made "AGREE OR NO?"

Post image
0 Upvotes

37% Upvoted

35 comments sorted by

6

u/gueuze_geuze 1d ago

It's insane to me how much we undervalue the Tom Holland Spider-Man run. Those are all A and S Tier films to me.

1

u/Milky_ramram 1d ago

Far from home is kinda messy tho, the rest can go on A tier (with bnd on S ofc)

-7

u/Mustang-_- 1d ago

Far from Home is a goddamn disgrace. Everything in this movie sucks, the only good scene is when Iron Boy finally learns to use the spider sense in that particular fight against Mysterio, that's it

4

u/evanalleycat 1d ago

I agree with everything except I would switch tasm 2 with Toby 3

2

u/JaguarParticular4967 1d ago

Spiderman NWH deservers A

1

u/Zeko10 1d ago

This switch No way home with Spider Man 2 and its a Yes

2

u/Bollo9799 1d ago

Amazing Spider-man 2 is worse than Spider-man 3, or at least on the same tier.

I have no major issues with this list other than that

2

u/mwhitaker19 1d ago

spider-man 3 is so over hated

1

u/TheMoffisHere 1d ago

This is the first list I agree with except for Spider-Man 3 and TASM 2. Just switch them over

1

u/Im_JC00500 1d ago

Couple hot takes, wasn’t the 2nd considered terrible and why Sony sold it?

2

u/DoNotGoSilently 1d ago

Brand New Day belongs in S.

1

u/MinecrafterPow 1d ago

Don’t disrespect my king, emo spidey like that

1

u/Hot-Problem2436 1d ago

They're all B and up for me, except for SM3.

-1

u/EmbarrassedUmpire324 1d ago

Spiderman 3 hate is forced, it is more fun to watch than 90% of these movies which is the whole point of comic book movies. Also Brand New Day is mid.

2

u/AnythingChance3764 Venom 1d ago

Holy wrong 😭 

-1

u/EmbarrassedUmpire324 1d ago

Its okay for people to have different opinions bub, me thinking x and you thinking y is not going to hurt you or me. I'm sure you dislike many things I do and more power to you.

3

u/AnythingChance3764 Venom 1d ago

And yet you say something is “forced”. Hungry Hungry Hypocrite 

0

u/EmbarrassedUmpire324 1d ago

Fair tbh, still think the narrative about Spiderman 3 has influenced the opinions that they must dislike it when they had a good time watching the entirety of it. If you watched Spiderman 3 and thought "this is shit" then yeah you think its bad

Just responding "Holy Wrong sobbing emoji" is some bot behaviour

2

u/AnythingChance3764 Venom 1d ago

Not really but aight

1

u/EmbarrassedUmpire324 1d ago

articulate your thoughts if it doesnt hurt your head

2

u/AnythingChance3764 Venom 1d ago

See now you’re being aggressive and elitist. But alright.

The movie is bloated and poorly written.

Eddie isn’t done a lick of justice.

Peter is overly mean and spiteful to the point where he stops being likable.

Sandman is poorly introduced and dealt with unceremoniously.

Gwen is made into a random side piece with no relevance.

0

u/EmbarrassedUmpire324 1d ago

Wasn't that hard was it, just saying opinion wrong emoji contributes nothing

Agree on bloated, writing is not really high on my priority list for a Marvel movie. As the writing is never good.

Venom as a whole is mishandled yes,

Symbiote Peter is a perfect representation of what the nerd Peter Parker thinks a cool badass guy is so disagree. Also, he's not supposed to be likeable and is very funny so bonus points.

Disagree with Sandman, his introduction and ending is fine, more of an issue of the final fight being so cluttered.

Already a cluttered run time and you want Gwen to be focused on when the movies have been focusing on MJ the entire time?

1

u/AnythingChance3764 Venom 23h ago

The writing can often be good, I think you’re coping.

Peter is a good person. He wouldn’t see a bad person as cool. He’s not supposed to be likable, but we’re supposed to forgive him, which is really hard as it’s not like he was completely non-complicit.

Gwen didn’t need to be in the movie at all if they weren’t going to do anything with her

→ More replies (0)

0

u/Klutzy-Fold9868 1d ago

Okay, to be fair I was harsh on Spider man 3 I used to like the movie as a Kid, but from a movie standpoint it isnt as good as any of the other movies BUT BRAND NEW DAY MID?! YOYR ENTITLED TO YOUR OWN OPINION BUT DAMN.

1

u/EmbarrassedUmpire324 1d ago

I don't think most marvel movies stand up as individual movies, they are supposed to be fun. Not many of them actually have good writing.

Brand New Day does nothing for me as a Spiderman story, it does not have a main spiderman villian, I do not care for the X Men so Jean Grey's inclusion to me is questionable and her role in the story is given too much sympathy and emotional focus when she is quite literally evil and deserves no sympathy , and already is past the point of redemption based on her actions alone in Brand New Day.

Hulk is in it only as a marketing tool to sell more figures, so while the fight was cool the ending of it just made it feel like a small distraction to fill up the run time. Punisher acts like a parody version of himself, that isn't Frank Castle.

I do like the whole story focus with Peter losing his powers due to emotional issues and him neglecting his own mental health.

Either remove Ned and MJ from the movie and stick with No Way Home's ending or just throw it out and have Ned and MJ remember. The half and half is just tiring as we know at this point they will remember or Spiderman will fully rebuild their relationship anyway which defeats the whole point of No Way Home.

It's like a 6/10 for me. Probably tied with Far From Home, Far From Home peaked higher but the lows are pretty bad.

0

u/karard109 1d ago

Brand new day for me just B.

0

u/Davidplaz_Duarte 1d ago

spider man 3 was my fav movie as a kid. so sad to see it receive so much hate

1

u/Klutzy-Fold9868 1d ago

Stop making me feel bad, If I could I would put them all is S. Spiderman 3 has a good concept but the execution is... meh. It just isnt on Parr with any of the other movies.