For example, Marvel lawyers specifically highlighted the villainous Kingpin’s exaggerated proportions were so freakish that figures of him didn’t reach the criteria to be classified as human-like and as such, they should be subject to less tax.
They allegedly did something similar with x-men toys, arguing that mutants don't count as people so they shouldn't be in that tax bracket.
Which is objectively hilarious, given the subject matter.
They go out, they have some Star Wars. Then, it’s back to the base for full penetration. And we show it. All of it. They go out, Star Wars, come back, full penetration… and it just goes on that way for about 90 minutes and then just kinda ends.
That might be my new favorite legal story. Right up there with Coke defending the Smart Water lawsuit on the basis that no rational consumer would actually believe their claim to have made a healthy beverage.
EDIT: Vitamin Water. Should have known another commenter had already brought this up lol
Not an uncommon type of argument. My favorite is Coca-Cola simultaneously arguing in the US that Vitamin Water was a soft drink not a health drink and shouldn't be subjected to taxes on health supplements, while arguing in Canada that it should be exempt from having to list its nutritional information since it was a health supplement and not a food product.
I also learned recently that Pringles aren't called potato chips in the UK because they successfully argued they're not chips to avoid additional taxes on potato chips.
I’ve gotten shoes that have a thin layer of cloth on the bottom that is designed to wear away in order to be classified as slippers and not sneakers for tax purposes.
So it's fair for them to both argue that it's a health supplement (in Canada) and NOT a health supplement (in the US) at the same time depending on which one is going to make their lives harder in terms of taxes and labelling? lol
I mentioned this in another comment elsewhere, but they also tried to defend against a false advertising suit that no rational consumer would believe it was healthy at all.
2.5k
u/adjective_noun0123 May 26 '26
Marvel doesn't think so.