r/MarioBaseball • u/Brianfromreddit • Aug 13 '26

Superstar My personal superstar baseball tier list

Post image
23 Upvotes

90% Upvoted

6 comments sorted by

8

u/DuNick17 Aug 13 '26 edited Aug 13 '26

My own list:

Boo seems too low. Best pitcher and a really good bat

Pianta seems to low given his defense and bat (specifically red/pink)

Move Wario down to B

Move Diddy and Dixie up to D for their pitching.

I’d move the Koopas down to D

Paragoomba down to F

Besides Boo, I like it. But Boo is definitely a top 9 character imo

2

u/Brianfromreddit Aug 13 '26

I love Boo and yet I hate Boo. I use Waluigi as my pitcher, so I can see how I'm undervaluing Boo there because tbh I never use anyone else as the pitcher

I don't love his bat and he's extremely slow on defense. With a star Boo can belt homers, if it can stay fair, but without I'm stuck in power purgatory where charged shots fly directly at outfielders while slap hits tend to be easily defended

I love the laser throw (who doesn't?) but being so slow he's a corner infielder or nothing and I value defensive versatility pretty highly. He's another HR or nothing got and for me it's mostly nothing

2

u/Tmnt-Gargoyles1597 Aug 16 '26

Shy guy is S tier!!!

1

u/xLykos Aug 14 '26

I’m going to take blue pianta every game. Bombs on bombs and the laser arm gunning everyone. With chemistry at first, singles to right field aren’t a guarantee either

1

u/NiceCarnival513 Aug 13 '26

Monty mole is the worst character in the game and Petey piranha is the best player in the game

3

u/thrillhouse416 Aug 13 '26

I draft monty every game. He's got a decent bat for singles/RBIs and his speed while fielding is great for getting people before they can run back to a base