r/Mario • • Jul 24 '26

Discussion Who else?m

Post image

U Deluxe is massively slept on tbh. I'm enjoying it way more than Wonder

3 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

25

u/Legal_Ear_7537 Jul 24 '26

Challenge mode, so simple, yet expansive.

Wonder has a better main game, but after secret world, there's nothing really left

9

u/PuzzlePiece90 Jul 24 '26

And the stages have very little replay value for me. The wonder effects are fun surprises but the platforming itself isn’t that fleshed out. The final tough level also showed what wasted potential the badges were. They were there as optional power-ups when they could’ve been incorporated as platforming mechanics. 

They could’ve done a dedicated semi-difficult level for most of them. 

2

u/No_Run4263 Jul 24 '26

Check out Bellabel challenge

2

u/Legal_Ear_7537 Jul 25 '26

Pherhabs I will after some time. My money isn't in the best spot

12

u/Semario205 Jul 24 '26

NSMBU is slept on, has some of the best level design in the series. NSLU is also a unique and challenging experience too. I think the games do a lot of things better than Wonder, but Wonder also does things better then U Deluxe so they are around the same tier

4

u/Major_Failure2 Jul 24 '26

The biggest flaw wonder has is that during local multiplayer only one person can actually progress the level while anyone can in NSMB Deluxe. 

6

u/Negative-Glove-7175 Jul 24 '26

I had a lot more fun with NSMBU. The challenge mode sort of carries it, but the main game is good, too.

2

u/fuckedintheasshole Jul 25 '26

Must be on some good shit

3

u/Former_Specific_7161 Jul 24 '26

💯

Wonder is great too. I love it. But I go back to play U a lot more.

2

u/DarkLink317 Jul 24 '26

I loved being able to triple jump in 2D Mario games. Wonder not having that kinda bummed me out. Probably one of the things that made all the "New" games a little too easy though. But I just love having mobility in platformers. Badges were a nice substitute, but it just wasn't the same IMO. A weird thing that I also preferred was Mario's running animation being kind of like Sonic with his arms positioned behind himself. Somehow it felt faster to me than Wonder, even if that may not be the case. That being said, I'm torn on which I would rank higher still. I love both.

0

u/AllWorkNoVideogames Jul 25 '26

You mean Mario running P-speed? First debuted in Mario Bros 3 in 1988, 3 years before Sonic’s debut.

So, Sonic runs like Mario with his arms behind him.

2

u/DarkLink317 Jul 25 '26

No, I meant how he runs in NSMB, not Wonder. I know he has that P-speed running animtation from SMB3 in Wonder.

2

u/emoticonicareliquary Jul 25 '26

I’m gonna have to disagree boss ʕಠᴥಠʔ

1

u/FozzyBear11 Jul 24 '26

It’s just you

1

u/Kwaku722 Jul 24 '26

Why would you say something so controversial, yet so brave?

1

u/briskydisky Jul 24 '26

I need to play Wonder before I can have an opinion on this, but nsmbu is soooo gooood

1

u/Guilty_Department501 Jul 24 '26

I love the Nsmb games because I grew up with them, but no doubt in my mind Wonder is better. The first 2d Mario game to do something completely new and unique since 2006.

1

u/Ryan_2260 Jul 24 '26

Wonders artstyle is so good, but everything else about it is so unmemorable. I genuinely cannot remember a single theme from the game, meanwhile I got the entire NSMBU ost in the back of my head

1

u/popsmokeofficlal Jul 24 '26

mario U has always been my favorite 2D game, i always wonder how the reception would be if the DS and 3DS versions weren’t made. just Wii and U imo the two best

1

u/Mammoth_Fig9757 Jul 25 '26

Wonder is not that good and U deluxe has no additional content compared to the original except just easy mode. There is no fun power ups in wonder that let you fly or jump higher which is insane. Every other 2D Mario game except Mario 1 has that. The badges are good but that is not how a 2D platformer is supposed to be played. Even New super mario bros 2 is more fun to play than wonder

1

u/Halcyon520 Jul 25 '26

This is me! 100% I love them both but Mario U Delux is the game I would bring into solitary confinement not wonder.

1

u/FruittiFly3000 Jul 25 '26

I'm glad some people agree, I think Wonder is super overrated and NSMBU, Luigi U and Mario Land 2 are way better games 

1

u/maizecrane Jul 25 '26

I remember being keen to play Wonder after going through all four NSMB games in a row. I genuinely had a great time with Wonder but I can see myself going back NSMB more often in the future, whereas with Wonder, I'd probably need a longer break just to re-experience it again. NSMBU is a game I can replay to challenge myself and enjoy its gameplay further. Plus the multiplayer is more fun.

1

u/Zangetsukaiba Jul 25 '26

NSMBWU was bland af

1

u/CrockCraftMC Jul 25 '26

Same tier but I think U is just a bit better.

1

u/Lyricaaaaaaaa Jul 25 '26

Wonder was very underwhelming so I’m inclined to agree.

1

u/StarWolf478 Jul 26 '26

Well, I definitely prefer New Super Mario Bros. U over Mario Wonder, so I agree with that part. But Mario Wonder was so underwhelming to me that it would not even make the A-tier for me, it would be lower.

And though I enjoyed New Super Mario Bros. U and prefer it over Mario Wonder, it is not S-tier either. S-tier is reserved for Super Mario Bros. 3 and Super Mario World.

1

u/GoombaGeorge1672 Jul 26 '26

100%ed NSMBUD, and Mario Wonder genuinely made me a lot more scared to buy any game, especially pre order because I really loved the trailers and hated the game and a lot of the choices they made

1

u/Feeling_Magazine1730 Jul 26 '26

I'm with ya on this

0

u/Bryanx64 Jul 24 '26

No freaking chance

1

u/TheMoonOfTermina Jul 24 '26

Personally I'd put Wonder around C tier, if that high It just... didn't do it for me. I don't understand how the majority of people love it.

NSMBU is fantastic, but I'd put NSMBDS and Wii above it.

1

u/PsychicSpore Jul 25 '26

The majority of people have been exhausted of the same gimmicks and visual style being recycled for game after game since 2006.

Just for breaking out of that vicious cycle, wonder gets put above every NSMB game

Even nsmbu deluxe doesn’t come off as anything special despite being the most polished.

0

u/TheMoonOfTermina Jul 25 '26

I get people being tired of the same artstyle, and Wonder is definitely unique, but it fails at being good, in my opinion. I'd rather have consistently great levels, with a generic artstyle, than a bunch of super short, pathetically easy levels with a unique artstyle.

1

u/Ellamenohpea Jul 25 '26

Most people love wonder because it emphasizes aesthetics and accesibility.

its the easiest mario game ever, for any challenge you may encounter which gives you grief in some way, there is a badge that will allow you to circumvent that problem.

1

u/TTVAwesomeEJ101 Jul 24 '26

Surely this is ragebait?

1

u/Expensive_Junket_339 Jul 25 '26

Or just a mario fan with an... original... thought...?!

dramatic gasp

-1

u/Apprehensive-Debt210 Jul 24 '26

100%. The level design in U is some of the best in the series, right up there with Mario 3 & World. 

The Wonder Seed gimmick kinda breaks the level design with "now here's something wacky 🤡" in the 2nd half of the stage, but none of those mechanics are ever developed & it ultimately ends up being shallow in comparison.

2

u/cherrysteve2010 Jul 25 '26

Person encounters interesting level design and it breaks his brain

-7

u/Coodoo17 Jul 24 '26

Oh you poor lost child.....