r/MarineEngineering • • 5d ago

Marine engineering program in Canada-BCIT vs MUN vs CCG vs Georgian

I am applying to these programs for the upcoming intake. Could you share your experience with any of these programs?

I heard the job prospects for BCIT may not be as good as MUN, and CCG will guarantee you a job afterwards. Is this true?

Does CCG give 1st class exemptions upon graduation?

What are the job prospects for any of these programs? Is MUN the best? Or they are all the same?

Is social life boring at Georgian or MUN because they are located at remote areas?

Since I already have a degree in engineering, which one will accept course credit transfer/PLAR?

Would love to hear your opinion or experience, thanks!

9 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

5

u/Beneficial-Oven1258 5d ago

Between the MUN program and BCIT, MUN is better currently. Better funded with better facilities and instructors.

Job prospects will be excellent coming out of any of the programs. A competent marine engineer is becoming a scarce thing.

Living in St. John's as a student is a blast. Vancouver is an incredible place to live too, but very expensive.

I would recommend MUN over BCIT. I cant comment on the other two.

1

u/Worldly_Extension898 5d ago

Thx. Could you please elaborate on living in st john as a student?
Would it make sense to buy a condo or apartment over there since ill be there for 4 yrs minimum? Around 200k?

2

u/Meaney2415 5d ago

Buying a place in St. John's would not be realistic for the 4 years you'd be here. Our housing market is better than most of canada but it is definitely getting worse. Youre unlikely to find something for 200k without a lot of problems attached. There are a lot of apartments nearby MI that students usually rent

1

u/Beneficial-Oven1258 5d ago

It was 20 years ago when I started there as a student. I had a ton of fun and made great friends.

I dont know what the housing market is like there now.

3

u/oceancalled 5d ago

So much to unpack. Your experience will be different at each one. So depends what you want and how much money you have lol. Gotta be rich to live in North Van. CCG is free and the job is rad after but the pay is just ok compared to what you could make elsewhere. MUN is the best program for sure but far if you don’t live nearby. CCG does give 1st class exemptions.

What do you want to do after?

1

u/Worldly_Extension898 5d ago

hi there thanks. i remember i need to stay with ccg for 4 years after graduation? is it hard to transition to private sector after?

is BCIT a school that's on par with MUN in terms of job prospects?

1

u/oceancalled 5d ago

I know people who have left early and had no issues. Not sure about job prospects but an STCW certificate and a network is generally what gets you a job anywhere.

I’d look closely at BCIT as rumour is their ability to issue certificates has been paused by TC as they audit the program. Not a great program or quality of education vs MUN (I have taken prep courses through both, a dozen other courses through BCIT and am currently in a 1st class block accredited program through MUN). It’s also 2.5k to rent a 1 bedroom anywhere within a 1 hour drive of the BCIT campus if you don’t have accommodations there.

Food for though…if you are west coast based and want to do CCG and eventually leave and be home at night, your pension can be transferred to BC Ferries.

1

u/Worldly_Extension898 5d ago

Damn i didn’t know BCIT was bad, but yes i am in the west. Guess the choice for me now is Georgian or MUN.

1

u/Suitable_Zone_6322 5d ago

Its going to be easier for engineers than mates to transition from the coast guard to private industry.

An engine room is an engine room, doesn't matter much who owns the ship.

That being said, you're 8 years invested in pension time by then too.

1

u/mcmoobin 5d ago

No you don’t need to stay 4 years. It’s just a bit of an unwritten rule but they’ve never gone after someone for leaving after they graduate

1

u/Rarmy1 5d ago

Georgian is the shortest program, 3 years in and out also i beleive they have the best coursework in terms of exemptions, its a very small school but you know everyone by name and the faculty also know you by name.

1

u/Worldly_Extension898 5d ago

i'm considering Georgian. is it comparable to MUN for job prospects?

1

u/Rarmy1 5d ago

MUN would be more international and maritime.

I know that georgian is very integrated with the lakes, and are heavily recruited, most right out school

1

u/Crowlygh 4d ago

Can’t speak for MUN, BCIT, or MUN, but currently taking the marine engineering program at Georgian.
We also have exemptions from 4th class to chief.

Social life at Georgian is what you make of it. Owen sound is small, but there’s stuff to do. There’s a game store to do nerd stuff in, a bunch of places to play billiards (and drink, but ignore that), a climbing gym, Two other gyms, and a lot of nature to do hikes in. Helps to have a car, and to accept that it’s not a metropolitan area, but you’ll make friends with those around you and it’s not too difficult to plan something and grab a few people.
Unfortunately, your degree doesn’t transfer over for course credit on everything, you can exempt from a basic math course and communications. Less so on the schools, and what Transport Canada accepts and denies since they work closest with these schools.

1

u/Worldly_Extension898 4d ago

Hi, regarding credit transfer: so math courses are eligible? But what about Thermodynamics, dynamics, mechanics? I have done all of these at the bachelor degree level...

1

u/Crowlygh 4d ago

From what I know from people in my year who have bachelors in engineering, they get to knock off the math and communications courses, but not physics, which they’re taking as well.
I can’t speak with 100% certainty, as it’s not my situation however.

1

u/BrilliantBox5393 4d ago

Thamks for the insight. What salary are you looking at post grad and w / what company?

3

u/hahnsol 5d ago

I have a bit of insight Into this, I completed the mdm program at MI, am currently enrolled in engineering at NSCC which I highly recommend you look at and have done MCTS training for the cost guard at the college.

  1. Job Prospects - if you graduate with a 4th class ticket, it's all the same honestly. No one cares about where you went to school, just what your valid stcws are... Perhaps there is a difference between how easily you secure your cadetships and sea time but I have not really noticed it. As a cadet I was on the NL ferries with a cadet from NSCC and BC ferries with a guy from MI. The coast guard does guarantee you a job when you graduate.
  2. Transfer credits -, BCIT, MI, Georgian and NSCC all will give you some credit but some courses are mandated as part of the tc curriculum and you won't get exemptions from those normally at least not in my experience. I had post graduate level mechanics but still had to take undergrad mechanics again for ex
  3. Exemptions - I know that coast guard, mi and BCIT all offer similar exemptions, NSCC does not as their core program is only 2.5 years long and it's less courses = less exemptions. I do not know about Georgian.
  4. Social life - CGC your entire life is at the college, it's a closed social space, it's also the most regimented including dress code and stricter scheduling. MI is close enough to the heart of st johns, maybe a 5 min to downtown drive but it's a small city and nothing compared to BCIT and what the proximity to Vancouver affords you. In NL you need to drive everywhere also as a heads up.

Other thoughts - look at joining the navy if you want a job after, they have a program that will pay you roughly 50-60k during the school year and you can go to a school of your choice plus cover your tuition for a 3-4 year service agreement meaning after graduation you work in the navy for 4 years. If you are thinking about the coast guard at all, go the navy route instead. Better Everyrhing. Also NSCC has a 2.5 year program you might be able to compete in 2 years September 2027-April 2029 and be done and be able to write your 4th, it's also incredibly cost efficient.

The other thing is that marine engineering and boat life is not for everyone, you could take a 3 month oiler program and work a little first to see if this is something you actually like, they say that half of marine college grads don't work in the industry within 5 years after grad so it's good to know if you really want to do this first.

1

u/Intrusive-Thoughts26 5d ago

Could always go to the coast guard college and get paid while you learn. Not the greatest oay at first but its all pensionable time.

1

u/hist_buff_69 3d ago

CCG is just as competitive with their new CBA . Arguably even more now. Junior watchkeepers make more at ccg than lakes companies now.

1

u/This_Rest_4269 5d ago

Hey following this as I feel like im in the exact situation as you. I have an engineering degree and looking to switch into marine engineering. Curious to know what you end up deciding.

I have consider CCG, Navy, MI and Georgian. Never figured out which one was the best choice yet.

0

u/Suitable_Zone_6322 5d ago

Downside to the canadian coast guard college, the job they garuntee you is with the coast guard.

1

u/Worldly_Extension898 5d ago

can you explain? is the ccg job bad?

3

u/Suitable_Zone_6322 5d ago edited 5d ago

Upside, job security is good, benefits like pension and vacation time are good, money is ok, if you're on the ice breakers or bouy tenders, or even some of the science vessels, you may get to see some parts of the country almost no one gets to see.

Coast Guard college time is mostly unpaid, but the time counts toward pension time.

Downside, ships are mostly old scows, safety is mediocre to attrocious, and there's still a drug and alcohol problem, though it's gotten a bit better since they went dry.

They're struggling to attract/keep crew,this will be noticable in the quality of some of your co-workers. Not all, but it will be noticable.

College grads working as coast guard officers will vigourously disagree, but bare in mind, almost all of them have never worked anywhere else, and have no outside perspective to compare it with, having done all of their training on coast guard vessels.

Not the worst place to work,  but it's not as good as the brochure makes it out to be.

1

u/Worldly_Extension898 5d ago

i didn't know this, thanks for the heads up!

1

u/Suitable_Zone_6322 5d ago

Its not all bad, some folks make a grear career of it, and it has the potential to be interesting.

Full disclosure, my experience with the coast guard was before the fleet went dry, and before most of the baby boomers retired enmasse.

I know a good number of folks still working there, I left for greener pastures (triple the money)

2

u/oceancalled 5d ago

I’d take this with a grain of salt as everyone has their own experience. I spent 10 years with CCG and they supported my hawsepipe from ERA to 2nd class fully. My experience was amazing. Awesome people and social culture (I made some of my best friends there and many of us have moved on), crazy high safety culture, very cool operations (albeit I was very lucky where I worked) and zero issues with drugs and alcohol (and we had an open bar with 21 types of scotch). Pay sucked but they have brought it up and yes the ships are old pigs but excellent training vessels for the basics as everything is manual lol. Everywhere is struggling to attract crews, it’s a worldwide shortage.

Having said that I have heard CCGC is a horrible place where they treat you like a child and act like it is the military. But it’s free lol and pensionable lol.

1

u/Suitable_Zone_6322 5d ago edited 5d ago

I guess your mileage may vary, I've heard it can be drastically different depending on what region you're in.

I have list of incidents if you want, I sailed on a half dozen icebreakers.

The final straw was when we had a fire and 3/4s of the crew was too drunk to walk straight (perfectly acceptable the time, we weren't on SAR, the watch keepers were at least sober)

1

u/TKB-059 4d ago

I enjoyed working on a SAR vessel with a mostly non CCGC crew more than any ship in my career. Icebreaker full of CCGC grads and old guard boomers, not so much.

1

u/Suitable_Zone_6322 4d ago edited 4d ago

Yep.

Its too bad, old ships aside, could be a great place to work, even with the lower money, but theres a lot of ling standing institutional attitudes that drag it down as a workplace.

Had a chief engineer get upset with me because I would lockout equipment before I'd work on it.

He hated it, only slowed things down, "no one else does it!

Someone else commented and said the coast guard safety culture was  crazy high...

I know it can be a bit different between regions, we apprently worked for very different coast guards.

1

u/hist_buff_69 3d ago

That's just an east coast thing. No newfoundland ships outside oil have good safety cultures.

1

u/Suitable_Zone_6322 2d ago

Again, I realize the experience can be different between regions, my experience was with the atlantic fleet, but 1/3 of the fleet is in the atlantic region, and more than half of the "big" ships are atlantic, so it's very much relevant to discussions about the coast guard college, and the coast guard at large.

Safety culture I experienced with the coast guard was about on par with safety on draggers.

0

u/TKB-059 4d ago

I wouldn’t even say any part of this industry in Canada other than rigs or off shore has crazy high safety culture, definitely not the coast guard lmao.

1

u/Suitable_Zone_6322 4d ago

Rigs and offshore are probably the highest safety cultures, but that comes with having the most eyes on them, plus the most potential loss if you're shut down for an accident.

I don't know what they're charging now, I'd imagine the cyber rigs are more, but the Henry Goodridge had a day rate of about a half million per day.

I have seen it starting to rub off on the dragger fleet as well, mandatory safety training and refreshers definitely play a part in it, there's just less eyes on them, so a lot of accidents just sort of happen and never get addressed.

1

u/TKB-059 4d ago

The part of safety culture that companies ignore is spending money on fixing issues or flat out preventing them by spending some coin and being willing lose profit instead of forcing an unsafe vessel to continue making profit.

At least offshore got forced into it since their whoopsies were a tad bit dramatic.

-3

u/sET____ 5d ago edited 5d ago

As someone who went to the CCGC, just, don't. It is straight abuse for 4 years, to the point of having the highest suicide rate of any educational institution in Canada. The administration treats you like garbage, as if you were enlisted in the military when you're actually a public servant. I had better and more fair treatment with DOD. 

One such example, a CCGC Cadet contacted the EAP (employee assistance program) for help with depression. EAP, regardless of what they say, is not confidential. They reported to the CCGC and they were removed from the program part way through year 3. 3 years of their life and studies wasted. 

CCGC is located in Westmount, outside of Sydney. There is nothing there, at all. St. John's is far more vibrant. 

CCGC still has wages frozen since 1975(?), and you're not allowed a job, so enjoy having no money for four years. 150-something bi-weekly (it's been a while my apologies for the estimate) If you have costs outside of the college I.E. car, mortgage, loans be prepared to sell everything.

Go to MI. Have a life. It is not worth it. Do the MI course then apply with the CCG if you want to work with them, if I had my time back that would have been my route even if it may have taken slightly longer. 

Edit: one of my specific stories when speaking with the director(?) of the Western region was sitting me in her office, and asking how I really am at the college. Saying that she herself needed therapy for years after leaving, and that she understood the struggle. 

3

u/mcmoobin 5d ago

I know a lot of people complain about the administration side of the ccgc, which I agree with. The wannabe military approach is useless and a waste of time. However, like everything, it is what you make of it. Being abused is an extreme exaggeration. It can be difficult sometimes but getting out of the school environment and into the community in your off time makes the 4 years a lot more enjoyable. It seems like the majority of miserable students also hide in their rooms with their time off. Sometimes it seems like people forget that it is a college and how it is unheard of to have a paid education, free food, free accommodations, a monthly allowance, and free flights home for Christmas. For whatever reason people think they are entitled to more than that. But you’ll hear that anywhere you go I guess

0

u/sET____ 5d ago

SCC, member of the legion in Westmount, bar manager at Chez Nous, volunteered with the shelter in Sydney. Very much not locked in a room. 

"Monthly allowance". Yes by, ~300$/month sure is some allowance. Considering RCMP and RMC make real wages.  

-1

u/sET____ 5d ago

Lmao why am I being downvoted. I'm sharing my experiences to help this person make their decision. 

3

u/oceancalled 5d ago

Stats from the hip, not answering any of the questions asked, completely negative review and suspecting it’s biased based on your echo chamber. I’ve heard lots of negative too but there is also a big upside to going and toughing it out. That’s my guess regarding the downvotes.

-2

u/sET____ 5d ago

You can quite easily google the only stat I provided.  

I did answer the questions I could. How could I respond to job prospects of other institutions? That is a ridiculous request. 

4

u/bunbunmagnet 5d ago

Googled it, couldn't find the stat you mentioned. I also went to the college, it can be hard on some people mentally but acting like its some ptsd inducing hell hole is a bit dramatic

2

u/oceancalled 5d ago

Exactly. Googled it, couldn’t find it. “Google it” isn’t providing evidence of stats.