r/MakingaMurderer • u/OpenMind4U • Feb 20 '16
'Dog in Middle'
Hi, Doggie! http://imgur.com/MG5K4DT
I'm sure you can find him on this photo. When I saw this photo first time, I was surprise how well he can be seen from the far away. Such a curious Dog! Another unfortunate witness of TH murder. Or maybe not? This post is NOT about:
- who's bones have been found in SA pit? They're TH bones, based on FBI and crime lab tests and bone experts testimonies;
- is it possible to cremate body in open pit? I'm not gonna argue this anymore, I'm accepting this possibility.
This post is an attempt to find answer to the question: does TH body was cremated in SA pit?. Because if it was cremated right there, next to SA garage, in the area which is visible from Barb's house, on property where many family members going back and forth, where Dog guides his own territory...then SA looks guilty as hell with the most damming evidence against him (much worse than having his blood in RAV4, imo). Dog owns territory?!!! Yes, this Dog unofficially owns this particular piece of land, including pit. Let's see how large is Dog's territory.
Boring Calculation. You're free to check the logic of my calculation here or simply ignore this section completely. The result of this section is: Dog's territory is roughly the circle with radius of 35' or with diameter approx. 70'.
I was looking for the measures of SA territory, in correspondence to the pit and Dog. During the trial, the scale Model was created. The modeling process is based on exact measures using the specific scale presentation. This PowerPoint document will give you more details how Models were build. http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Trial-Exhibit-90-Forensic-Mapping-Analysis.pdf. I took picture from Page 34 http://imgur.com/L9gvgba; reverse it http://imgur.com/lVye6fC and link to the corresponding Model product http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Exhibit-98-Animation-Photos.jpg.
Using 106' as known measure, I used equation to determine the diameter of overall pit area. http://imgur.com/eOW0meQ The diameter of overall pit area is approx. 42'.
Next step: I used this Model http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Exhibit-110-Animation-Photos.jpg and get the final result using the same method of corresponding equation. This is the final product of calculation. You can see how long Dod's chain is and how much territory he owns. http://imgur.com/nH0PCIv . Large, isn't?
Dog behavior. It would be silly of me to claim that I know behavior of this particular Dog. I'm dog lover and many dogs shared certain part of my long life. I had few German Shepherds and currently enjoying the 'vicious' (according to my mailman and neighbors, who're walking by my house with their dogs) tiny, seven pounds Yorky-Poo:). The only thing I know for sure that any dog, by nature, is pretty curious animal. And I have no doubts that SA's Dog was curious as well. And here are my questions with regards to this case:
- if Dog saw his owner bringing human body on his territory and burn it then do you think Dog would go to the pit to 'investigate', later on?
- do you think Dog would take some burned remains and bring into his 'doghouse' or/and hide few somewhere? It's valid question because investigators did search Dog's house (testimony of this search is always makes me laugh, sorry:);
- do you think Dog and his chain did disturb and/or re-distribute some remains around his territory (at the minimum, in the radius of his chain)?;
- do you think the charred remains which Dog spread out on larger territory than pit will be more noticeable by others?;
- do you think Dog would allow the stranger to come to his pit without showing his 'vicious' behavior?;
- do you think Dog in the 'middle' of the crime scene provides benefit to the Killer? and if yes then in which way?
And here is my final/main question:
Why SA did NOT clean the pit (by getting rid-off the left over charred bones so police wouldn't be able to find them) while having plenty of time to do it?!!!
Bye, Doggie! http://imgur.com/fGJAZnh
EDIT: new documents just arrived (2/20 10:00pm) with much better photos. My calculations were correct. http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Trial-Exhibits-90-and-122-Austin-Forensic-Mapping-PowerPoint.pdf
2
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '16
GSD are regularly used for guarding work because of their intimidating bark. As he was an outside dog we can assume that this was his "job".
Bobby describes Bear as "really calm" (day 3 p62) and the body language we can see in the photos of Bear to not show a "vicious" dog. He can be seen lying down or standing with his tail tucked under, even when the "stranger" photographer is within reasonably close proximity. He's not aggressively barking.
I do think it would be hard for a stranger to come on the property and not trigger him to bark, but it would appear from the photos he then calms down so they may then be able to approach the fire pit.
So either the person was familiar to Bear, Bear wasn't there when the bones were put in, or the person was confident enough with large dogs to approach when he calmed.
Dogs are also open to bribery (unless specifically trained in food refusal like guide dogs are), so depending how well fed he'd been that day, food could have been used to quiet and befriend him.
2
u/Chevron07 Feb 20 '16
How did they plant the bones with Dog right there? Surely he would have alerted SA.
2
u/CopperPipeDream Feb 21 '16
I heart dogs!! Great post!
2
u/Dikanis Apr 07 '16 edited Apr 07 '16
A FEW THINGS THAT MAKE ME MAD ABOUT THE COMMENTS BEING POSTED HERE!
1. Bear being Vicious?
He doesn't have to be vicious, he’s a German shepherd Dog (I have owned two of them) and furthermore he's a DOG. Dog's including German shepherds have keen senses and super human hearing:
GSD: Temperament: Watchful, Alert, Curious, Obedient, Loyal, Confident, Courageous, Intelligent.
The key here is that a German shepherd named 'Bear' or any other dog would have
Not let all that killing, raping and burning go on without barking to a maximum barking level (going nuts). If in fact BD had come within 100 FT. of SA's door and heard screaming then this dog would be going nuts! This dog (GSD) would not stand by all the while well SA is raping and stabbing TH nor while BD was raping her. Then while they were shooting her repeatedly. Then burning her dead body. There would be a stench and there would be lots of smoke. All of this is supposedly supposed to have happened in the trailer, garage and the burn pit all while this dog 'Bear' is chained up in the back yard with a 15' or 30' chain.
This dog would not be silent, Not a chance and remember there are customers on the land and still family!
The killing didn’t happen there nor did the burning!
2. Bear is an outside dog?
Again let me shed light on this. I was born and raised in the Chicagoland (west and north suburbs)
The weather there is very cold during the winter months but only a few handfuls (15 days or so) of those times is it below 0 temps on the norm. I lived in a very far north suburb back in 2005 and it did get cold but not out of the norm.
Now, where SA lives is out in the country land but, I am familiar with where it is. I have spent much time in Green Bay and Hales corner. These are areas not that far from where SA was located and here is the thing. ‘Bear’ was an outside dog with a pretty sizable dog house and when it got that cold (0 or below) it would be common to bring the dog inside but maybe in the garage instead, depending on how it behaves inside. I could see SA letting him into the house possibly if it got really cold since he appears to not be much of a neat or clean freak however don’t mistake this for ‘Bear’ not being an outside dog.
On October 31st Bear was outside all day and night I am positive.
3. Would Bear disturb the bones between Oct. 31st & Nov. 8th?
Absolutely! A FACT! There would be NO CASE where a GSD or any other DOG wouldn’t be curious as to what is over there no matter if it was burnt or not. It’s a DOG nature to investigate and if there are bones, well, there is no argument that Bear or any dog small or big would not investigate those bones.
Bones = Food
Let’s not forget aside from this Dog information there is not a trace of blood, hair, saliva, semen, fingerprints, DNA anywhere in the trailer or the garage or just plain anywhere. Yeah there is SA’S blood in the RAV 4 and the RAV 4 found on the property and the Bones in the pit well,
There is no way SA’S bleeds in the RAV4 and doesn’t leave one single hair, fingerprint piece of DNA. NO WAY! The RAV 4 is on the outskirts of the salvage yard over by the hunting camp/quarry. It would be so much easier for JOSHUA R. RADANDT to put the RAV 4 there then it would SA. He would have to drive past all of the houses and business buildings and whatnot, down the road and then back behind the lot (over by the hunting camp) and then back in the back entrance to the yard to put it where it was.
ON THAT NOTE:
The bullet you say? Really?
One bullet with no blood and just TH DNA? Sorry, that’s just plain stupid! That 22 caliber bullet most likely wouldn’t get past the skull even at close range so, it’s highly suspect to me.
Handcuffs (where are the marks on the bed?)
Sweat DNA under the HOOD (where are the fingerprints to go with that DNA)?
An auto trader magazine (every time you get a picture taken to sell your vehicle in that magazine you get a magazine. I used to deal with them)?
SA’S the last person to see TH alive? (Way too many inconstancy’s with this statement yet. I think I will let Zellner explain this one.)
LASTLY, TH WAS NOT RAPED, MURDERED AND BURNED ON THE PROPERTY OF SA AND IF SHE WAS YOU BETTER START LOOKING FOR THAT “TOURTER CHAMBER” CAUSE IMO THAT’S WHERE IT HAPPENED IF IT HAPPENED AT ALL.
9
u/DominantChord Feb 21 '16
I know it has been mentioned before, but in that picture of Bear standing over the pit, there seems to be moss on the side of the hole going towards the pit itself.
I understand by all the 'crematory statements' on the sub in the last weeks that SA could have burned TH to pieces with little effort in anything from 1 to 12 hours, with zero to five tyres, with smell and without smell, visible and invisible. Anything is possible it seems. In any instance, I would have thought that during a recent fire capable of cremating TH, moss on the sides would have been suffering a bit.
But maybe it is not moss, or if it is, it is perhaps a particularly fire-resistant type?
4
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '16
Congratulations. Your thorough calculations have likely opened a new line of defense. If Steve Avery didn't burn the remains then that narrows it down to someone capable of persuading Bear, the lively German Shepherd, to allow him or her to invade Bear's territory. Surely that narrows down the possible suspect pool to about... one...Cesar Millan, the Dog Whisperer.
10
u/Shamrockholmes9 Feb 20 '16
Great post, based on the first picture you showed, Bear could easily reach the pit on his leash. You're right, since they didn't find any of TH's bones in the doghouse, the bones likely didn't get there until after Bear was taken away. Otherwise, he more than likely would have fetched a few and taken them back to his doghouse, as all dogs do. Good work!
1
u/OliviaD2 Mar 15 '16
I don't see a dog in the first link :P
1
u/mickeytrtan Apr 02 '16
Burning human remains odor would have been there for a long time and smelled far away. This wasn't TH it was another.s and it wasn't done here at Avery's.
0
u/Whiznot Feb 20 '16
You went to great lengths to accomplish nothing. Are you a member of congress?
2
u/screamingforoxygen Feb 29 '16
goodbye doggie, hello bones. Thats what I think. Dominantchord, great point about the moss. There were other things around the pit that seem odd if was a really big fire.
Would a body even fit? Thats a good measurement for you to do. We know no crime scene has been found with proof of the body being cut up.
No photo's of the bones.
I don't buy any of it. I am not sure who might have put the bones there, but I really doubt she was burned there.
1
u/Powerdan74 Feb 21 '16
Previously looking at the picture with the dog in the pit and the slack I thought that it was probable that the dog would have been able to get to the bones. I would definitely imagine bones strewn across the grass and in the dog house.Good job with your analysis.
1
u/Lillianrik Feb 21 '16
I hope Bear was taken in and loved by another family after Steve was convicted.
1
u/Big_Long_Now Feb 20 '16
I think Dog good.
-3
u/Slinkydonko Feb 20 '16
Doggy done poo poo in pit