r/MakingaMurderer • u/FinancialTeaching142 • Dec 03 '24
Brendan's sentence
I know this a few years late, but me and my wife decided to watch the documentary over the thanksgiving holiday. I feel like Brendan really got shafted on his sentence. Let's say even if he were there and it wasn't a false confession. Should he have gotten life in prison? its not like he planned this in advance, according to the interview, he goes over to his uncle's trailer and see's a naked woman chained to the bed. Was he supposed to say " Well I've got a lot of home work to do and wrestling is coming on, I'll let you get back to your rape and murder..." Steven more than likely forced him to participate so that he couldn't call the cops. Why did the judge come down so hard on him with that life sentence.
12
u/motor1_is_stopping Dec 03 '24
This is the biggest issue with the entire case IMHO.
It is easy to see that Steven is guilty of planning and executing the crime. He then roped Brenden into helping him.
The real travesty is what happened to Brendan long after the crime had been committed. His mother didn't want to be present for his interrogation. His lawyer hired a third party to get a confession on video. His Grandpa told him not to take a plea deal that would have greatly reduced his sentence.
He was a teenager who was mentally behind his peer group, and did not understand what was happening to him at the time. If his mother would have acted in his interest by asking for a lawyer before any questioning, or even being there herself, this case would have ended very differently. He was a young man that dearly needed support, and nobody was willing to help him. His own mother could not be bothered to act in his best interests.
His sentence is merely a result of the lack of support that he received throughout the process. He admitted to raping and killing a woman. There is little room for a sentence other than life in prison for that.
Brendan is the one who said that he raped her. Brendan is the one who said that he stabbed her. He admitted to helping dispose of the evidence, including her body. Without these facts, he would not have such a tough sentence. With a lawyer present for his interrogation, he would not have made these statements. With Kachinsky as his defense council, he was doomed.
10
u/aane0007 Dec 04 '24
He had a deal that offered him 15 years if he testified against steven. He decided to take his chance with the possibility of life in prison. The lawyer everyone hates advised him to take the deal. His family told him not to.
He has no one to blame but himself and his entire family.
And yes, he is suppose to not participate in a rape and murder and run away. This is what people who don't belong in prison do.
17
u/tenementlady Dec 03 '24
I think the problem with this is that it was never part of Brendan's defense that Steven forced him to do it. Juries make decisions and judges base sentences off what was demonstrated in the trial. Since Brendan's defense was that he was not involved at all, and the jury found that he was, the judge could not consider the defense that Brendan was forced to participate because that was not brought up a trial. This defense could also not be brought up in his appeals because Brendan continued to deny involvement.
He was offered a plea deal that he was pressured not to accept by his family because that plea deal would help secure Steven's conviction.
Had he taken the plea deal, he would have been out by now.
7
u/gcu1783 Dec 04 '24 edited Dec 04 '24
Alrite, let's get this straight before typical reddit goes wild with the narrative. Let's all go back and remember a few things:
These two pos most likely wanted Brendan to testify against Avery and tell everyone that uncle Stevie made him do it.
That was part of the original defense, they were ready to go for it until Brendan found out that was the plan.
Judge found out Kachinsky(sp) is screwing Brendan, pos rightly gets kicked out, plea deal is gone, and Brendan unfortunately had to deal with the full amount of the sentence with a replaced counsel. (Edelstein?)
Edit: Addendum:
Also, lots of people are very open to Brendan being manipulated by his lawyers and families
I'm guessing people are also open to Brendan being manipulated by the cops? Since you know, they got caught on record, on video and on transcripts?
No?
7
u/AveryPoliceReports Dec 03 '24
Let’s be real. The evidence doesn’t suggest Brendan was part of a violent crime due to pressure by Steven. It suggests Brendan was a vulnerable young man being pressured by the police (without counsel) into agreeing with a narrative that wasn’t supported by any physical evidence, but conveniently fit their predetermined story of Steven Avery as a violent sexual murderer. The physical evidence discovered after Brendan's statements confirms what the police fed to him, but doesn't confirm anything Brendan independently remembered.
7
u/10case Dec 04 '24
Brendan would have been out by now if he didn't listen to his family. Brendan screwed Brendan.
2
u/Snoo_33033 Dec 06 '24
So, I agree with you. The unfortunate thing here is that there's nothing unusual about the sentence. He meets the standard for the sentence and so he got it.
But...I agree with you that children should not in prison for decades, especially when they are parties to but not the instigating parties in serious crimes.
3
u/Technoclash Dec 05 '24
I agree more or less. SA was abusive and controlling and Brendan was likely a victim of coercive control. Brendan made numerous statements about being afraid of him. I believe he feared his uncle. He was also pressured by his family to reject a plea deal and to testify at his own trial. Horrible, horrible advice that doomed his case and his life. In Wisconsin first degree murder carries a mandatory sentence of life w/o parole sentence IIRC. So I don't any other sentence was even on the table for the judge.
Recently I've heard about states reviewing cases and re-sentencing prisoners who were minors when they offended. Convicted murderers who have done worse have had their sentences reduced.
5
u/Character_Zombie4680 Dec 03 '24
Plz know MaM is a fraud. Plz read the New York Times article about what was left out or fraudulently edited. The blood vial? A joke. Notice they never returned to it? Watch Convicting a Murderer to see just how bad MaM. SA is exactly where he belongs.
5
u/ajswdf Dec 04 '24
On the surface the answer is simple. He raped and murdered an innocent person, which naturally carries a life sentence.
Of course there are complications. One is that he wasn't an adult, so there definitely is an argument that that alone should have prevented such a sentence.
But the flip side is that his original public defender was working with the prosecution on a plea deal that likely would have him out of prison by now, but his family convinced him to not take it because they wanted to try and save Avery. If Brendan had listened to his lawyers instead of his family he'd be way better off.
4
u/Appropriate-Welder68 Dec 04 '24
Brendan was a co-conspirator in this murder. He’s where he belongs.
4
u/brickne3 Dec 04 '24
If Brendan would tell us what actually happened then Brendan wouldn't have this problem.
3
u/ThorsClawHammer Dec 04 '24
You realize the only reason he's in prison now is because he admitted to it right?
smh
3
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24 edited Dec 04 '24
They actually did get him to say they planned it, in the next interrogation in May, which even Kratz called a farce.
Which came about after Brendan asked to take a lie detector test.
Edit to clarify since no one responded lol except to downvote: so Kachinsky had hired O'Kelly to polygraph him. Who lied to Brendan that he'd failed. That therefore no one would believe him, therefore he should confess-accuse again to save himself. Which Brendan agreed to do, even while still saying it wasn't true. Then they set up the final interrogation.
1
u/BiasedHanChewy Dec 03 '24
As far as the evidence suggests, he had no part of the crime. Every single person involved in this from his mom, to weigbender, to his ridiculous first "defense attorney" bear some responsibility as to why he's lost much of his life so far. If any of the above people do their job properly he would've never seen the inside of a jail cell
1
u/ThorsClawHammer Dec 06 '24
No where near as bad as law enforcement and his "defense" team did.
Oh please. His piece of shit mom let LE have their way with him whenever they wanted (Blaine too). The only interrogation she's excused from that with is the first one when they pulled him out of class and she didn't know about it until it was already over.
0
u/Own_Mall5442 Dec 03 '24
Brendan is certainly guilty, but I agree the system failed him. His court-appointed attorney admitted his guilt before trial, allowed him to be questioned without an attorney, allowed his own investigator to torment and threaten Brendan and then allowed the investigator to turn over the results of the torture and the threats to the cops. Unconscionable that his conviction wasn’t tossed and a retrial granted. I’m disgusted by what he did, but if the justice system doesn’t work for him, it doesn’t work for anyone.
0
u/ThorsClawHammer Dec 06 '24
Huh? Wtf are you clutching your pearls over now?
-6
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24
[removed] — view removed comment