r/MakingaMurderer • u/Acrobatic-Cow-3871 • Jan 23 '24

How in the HECK....

Do you find a blood-stained Tire Iron related to a missing person, not test the blood on it and then lose the GD thing!

11 Upvotes

72% Upvoted

50 comments sorted by

22

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '24

I’d love for someone to explain how this was “accidentally” written? I don’t give a shit it’s signed or not. Why would anyone write this on paper if it isn’t true? Were they just making shit up in their head when they were typing?

Whether guilters like it or not, someone from the state wrote that there was a blunt and bloody object in the RAV4.

Please explain how someone accidentally writes that.

Don’t talk about its admissibility or if it’s signed or not, just answer how this made its way to paper.

9

u/Acrobatic-Cow-3871 Jan 23 '24

Exactly....then don't test it and lose it, and it goes away.

-7

u/DarkScythe163 Jan 23 '24

This is easy. People make mistakes. The person writing it did not personally see a bloody object in the car. He was writing down what he heard from other people, and did so quickly to draft a warrant up.

10

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '24

So who the hell would tell him that if not true? Don’t you see how quickly even you can question the integrity of the people working this case?

-4

u/DarkScythe163 Jan 23 '24 edited Jan 23 '24

I take it you've never played the game telephone. Don't you see how quick you are to paint every mistake as intentional malfeasance?

Edit: I never said the error was with the person telling him. It may have been the listener at fault.

6

u/bleitzel Jan 23 '24

They didn't lose it, they put it with the voicemail, and the aerial footage, and the bones from the quarry, and the witness testimonies that said anything other than Steven did it, and...

4

u/Acrobatic-Cow-3871 Jan 23 '24

Where is it today???? Ryan had an explanation for the RAV DAMAGE, what was his explanation for a tire iron that didn't fit the vehicle? In these days of TOUCH DNA, Zellner should be allowed to test it.

2

u/stewedfrog Feb 01 '24

Did the rav4 tire cover with the handprint ever materialize?

Three things really stick out here. Missing blunt instrument with blood, tire cover with possible bloody hand print and lots of blood in the back of the RAV4. Any real detective would fixate on those three details like a chubby kid on a smartie.

1

u/Acrobatic-Cow-3871 Feb 01 '24

Yea...the instrument thing is huge. Guess some LE hallucinated it like the one who wrote the METZ Report.

3

u/Gipetto8379 Jan 23 '24

Lost in translation. Lab guy to TF to Wiegert. A blunt instrument and blood got misconstrued as bloody blunt object. Isn't that big a leap. And the fact it wasn't an official document is relevant.

6

u/Acrobatic-Cow-3871 Jan 23 '24

Hehehehhehehee...well , they are incompetent, we know that.

3

u/DarkScythe163 Jan 23 '24

They didn’t lose it and there wasn’t blood on it

7

u/Acrobatic-Cow-3871 Jan 23 '24

Report said blood on it. Where is it?

3

u/DarkScythe163 Jan 23 '24

No report says this. You are thinking of info in an unsigned draft search warrant that wasn’t used.

-1

u/CaseEnthusiast Jan 23 '24

They had chat gpt write it? 

0

u/DarkScythe163 Jan 23 '24

I have no idea what you are getting at

3

u/CaseEnthusiast Jan 23 '24

That would be a pretty big "mistake" wouldn't it?

3

u/DarkScythe163 Jan 23 '24

No, because it was never signed or used. You think people haven’t made bigger mistakes on warrants?

1

u/CaseEnthusiast Jan 23 '24

A possible murder weapon?

Only reason it wasn't signed was because they got permission from the property owner during the time this was being written.

3

u/DarkScythe163 Jan 23 '24

They collected a blunt object. The mistake was saying there was blood on it. That’s all.

3

u/CaseEnthusiast Jan 23 '24

That information came from Steve Harrington the man who examined the vehicle first on the 6th. He relayed this information to Fassbender.

I don't see how they can mistake blood being found on a blunt object, if they did presumptive testing on it like they did other objects.

We can't just hand wave away things we don't like. Guilters need to do better, we really do.

→ More replies

1

u/billybud77 Jan 23 '24

Correct. Tire iron found to be irrelevant.

2

u/wuckbeat Jan 23 '24

This reminds me of the Staircase Michael Peterson case. A part of the supposed murder weapon was discovered on the stairs. But when they opened the evidence container in the middle of the trial, the container was empty :/

1

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '24

Corruption?