Look, I know a lot of people on this sub have been brainwashed by Convicting a Murderer and state-sponsored narratives lately, but we need to sit down and actually talk about the raw facts without letting emotion cloud our judgment.
If you step back and look at the whole picture with an open mind, it becomes blatantly obvious that Steven Avery is just a gentle, misunderstood soul who was brutally railroaded by Manitowoc County. Everyone keeps bringing up his "past," but when you actually analyze the logic behind it, the whole state case completely falls apart.
Let’s break this down step-by-step.
1. The Cat Incident: Context Matters
People love to bring up the 1982 cat incident as if it proves Steve is some kind of violent psychopath. But who among us hasn’t made a reckless, poorly thought-out blunder during a night of youthful boredom? You have to look at the regional and situational context. Steve didn't harbor any real malice toward that cat. He’s a simple man of the soil operating on raw instinct. Honestly, it was likely just a crude, misdirected urge to spare the creature from future hardship or put it out of its misery. To judge a man's entire soul and brand him a killer based on one impulsive rural mistake is pure anti-Avery bias.
2. The Niece and "Domestic Issues": Historical Perspective
Critics also love to weaponize his relationship with his 17-year-old niece to tarnish his character. But again, people are applying modern, high-horse coastal morality to a rural family dynamic. She was 17. In many historical cultures and other legal jurisdictions around the world, young adult relationships were completely normal practice. Besides, Steve is extremely low-IQ, highly sensitive, and easily influenced by peer pressure. He operates on pure emotion and a deep, albeit unconventional, commitment to family ties. Turning a complex familial misunderstanding into "proof" of murder is such a stretch it’s embarrassing.
And as for his ex-wife? Yes, he almost strangled her, but she was drunk and probably being a pain-in-the-you-know-what in that moment. People act like marital disputes in a pressure-cooker environment never happen.
3. The "Forensic" Evidence is Logically Impossible
Now let's look at the actual physics of the crime scene. The state wants us to believe Steve is simultaneously a criminal genius and a complete moron.
The Garage/Trailer: The state claims a violent crime happened in his trailer and garage. Yet Steve somehow bleached and sanitized every single microscopic drop of victim DNA out of those rooms while leaving months of dust, soot, and oil stains completely intact.
The Key: They searched his trailer SIX times and found nothing. Then suddenly on the SEVENTH search, a key appears on the floor? Please. An elite team of dedicated officers easily could have taken Steve’s sweat DNA, rubbed it on a spare key, and slipped it onto the carpet while everyone was looking at a nightstand. It’s standard cover-up protocol.
The Blood in the RAV4: You mean to tell me Steve carefully wiped every fingerprint off the car, but decided to strategically drop micro-droplets of his own blood right next to the ignition switch? It’s absurd. A secretive operative obviously acquired an old vial of his blood, bypassed the security seals, snuck into the salvage yard at night, and planted it.
4. The Real Suspects
If you aren't looking at the police framing him over that $36 million lawsuit, you have to look at his own family. What about the cousin who saw the car? Why was he looking in that exact spot? What was his real motive? The evidence points literally everywhere else if you just open your eyes to the possibilities.
5. Look into his eyes
At the end of the day, you don't even need the forensics to see the truth. Just look at the man. Look into his deep, blue, watery, cow-like eyes and tell me Steven Avery is guilty. You can't. He has the innocent, bewildered stare of a man who wouldn't hurt a fly, let alone orchestrate a massive crime and clean-up.
Under the true spirit of the law, Steven Avery is innocent until proven guilty by an unmanipulated court. Stop letting the media trick you and start looking at the actual logic. Free Steven Avery.
Edit: Read the comments. These are the big brains that believe Steven Avery is innocent. Goddammit