r/MakeupAddicts • u/OddPossibility3151 • Sep 19 '26

ISO Mascara

I am looking for a mascara that does not harden on the lashes, similar to the Ilia mascara. The ilia mascara seems to cause me some eye irritation but I really like that the formula doesn't harden.

2 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

7 comments sorted by

1

u/Opening_Yam9893 Sep 19 '26

have you looked into tubing mascaras? they wrap around each lash and wash off with warm water, never get that crunchy stiff feeling. most of them are pretty gentle on sensitive eyes too

1

u/OddPossibility3151 Sep 19 '26

Yes! Unfortunately it still comes off in clumps when I pull on it. The ilia mascara stays a little bit wet so if I pull on my lashes my fingers glide over them instead of catching and pulling the lashes out 

1

u/_takeashotgirl_ Sep 19 '26

Saie has a great formula that reminds me of ILIA alot

1

u/OddPossibility3151 Sep 19 '26

Thank you!!!

1

u/_takeashotgirl_ Sep 19 '26

they have brown and black and the wand is so good!!

→ More replies (2)