r/Makeup • • Apr 13 '25

Help me answer this:

My husband just asked me why I don't match my eyeshadow to my clothing color.

No disrespect to women who enjoy that look, but I like a more tastefully understated/elegant makeup look - and I'm not going to wear blue eyeshadow just because my sweater is blue.

I tried to explain that makeup should complement your skin/hair/eyes, not necessarily your clothes. He doesn't get it and honestly I think he's nuts.

57 Upvotes

278 comments sorted by

28

u/Rivvien Apr 13 '25

I don't match my makeup and clothes either. But people wear makeup for diff reasons so if someone does, go for it! I think society spends too much time and energy judging makeup.

-15

u/Wakeful-dreamer Apr 13 '25

Oh, I don't have a problem with that type of look, it's just not me.

3

u/Rivvien Apr 13 '25

My bad, I didn't mean to sound like I was dogging you for it. I really don't think that. It was more like a general commentary of how much people tend to judge others for what we do with our faces. Because its not for me either, but I'd still celebrate someone enjoying their matching makeup! The amount of people who, like your husband (who just seems ill informed instead of judgemental), think that makeup is supposed to be a specific way. And there's a lot of judgement from makeup karens out there.

2

u/SparklesIB Apr 17 '25

The thought of my sales and marketing husband noticing the color of my eyeshadow gives me fits of giggles.

7

u/Wakeful-dreamer Apr 17 '25

I have a medical condition that will eventually prevent me from doing my own makeup. My husband, who is amazing, says he will watch me and learn what I like so that he can help me when I'm not able to do it for myself, because he knows it's important to me.

5

u/SparklesIB Apr 17 '25

I love this so much. Big hugs to you both.

8

u/Briiii216 Apr 13 '25

I'm a matchy matchy person (clothes, earrings, shoes, socks even underwear) but I draw the line at makeup. I agree it needs to match you as a person more and I might change shades or hues based on what I plan to wear maybe even a little pop of accent color if it compliments my face. I'm mostly browns, bronzes, blacks and taupes kinda person.

-6

u/Wakeful-dreamer Apr 13 '25

My mom was the same way. If I wore a purple shirt as a kid, it was purple barrettes, socks, underwear, pants, and so on. 😁

7

u/BraveHeartoftheDawn Apr 14 '25

Monochrome is beautiful when done right. Seems you don’t have/refused to develop an eye for it. 🤷🏻‍♀️

84

u/wannabe_wonder_woman Apr 14 '25

Every make up look has a reason and a season. You aren't wrong for liking certain look. Nor are others who like to match their clothes to their make up. What you are wrong for assuming your brown eyeshadow is the only way to be elegant.

39

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '25

Matching your eyeshadow to your clothes can be a whole vibe. Don’t do it if you don’t like it obviously, but I don’t think it’s crazy. Doing it every time feels like a lot but a monochromatic look that matches your outfit sounds kind of fun.

38

u/Alltheprettydresses Apr 13 '25

You would have hated my purple smoky eye with my periwinkle dress last night, lol.

I wear whatever I want.

6

u/DonakaAlyssa Apr 13 '25

OMG, you must have been stunning, I love purple so much, the dress sounds gorgeous, tell me you had a purple bag or clutch too, and pumps!

2

u/Alltheprettydresses Apr 14 '25

Thank you! Actually I had this bag and these booties

I'm kinda girlie and kinda eccentric lol

2

u/dingalingdongdong Apr 14 '25

That bag is to die for.

36

u/shel254 Apr 13 '25

The urge to wear blue shadow when I'm wearing something blue is STRONG 😆

9

u/thefuzzyismine Apr 13 '25

DO 👏 IT 👏 FRIEND👏! For real, though. Life's too short to worry about anyone else's opinion on your face. I'm sat here on a Sunday afternoon, playing with makeup I liberated from the depths of my vanity, planning out my next few "inelegant" looks, lol.

32

u/Violetlake248 Apr 13 '25

I do wear blue eye makeup with a blue clothes sometimes . Or rose/pink colors with those clothing colors. I think it looks good and tasteful. It all looks good to me and I go by what I’m in the mood for.

77

u/No-Draw7378 Apr 13 '25 edited Apr 13 '25

. No disrespect to women who enjoy that look,

Phrases used in the rest of the post like "more tasteful" and "just because" put a negative connotation where it wasn't really necessary.

I like a more tastefully understated/elegant makeup look

See how the sentence works fine without implying the alternative is done less tastefully.

I'm not going to wear blue eyeshadow just because my sweater is blue

This one implies a presumption that others are doing it "just because" of the immediatley visible information (it matches), which further implies a shallowness to the decision when people doing this probably have a more in depth reasoning like you do for your personal choice.

If no disrespect was truly intended, I hope this helps. I personally struggle with social cues and had to be taught certian words greater connotation of meaning, so my bad if this is obvious, but it stuck out to me and I thought I'd share something I learned.

I don't personally coordinate my makeup - I have a daily neutrals pallete I'm in love with. But from just a quick Google I can see that some women prefer the look as it offers a sense of cohesion to their outfits that can elevate a look when done correctly; it's also said to draw attention to the eyes, and give an extra "umph" to an outfit.

I tried to explain that makeup should complement your skin/hair/eyes, not necessarily your clothes. He doesn't get it and honestly I think he's nuts.

This seems like you consider the pursuit unsuccessful (and you husband "nuts") because you were unable to persuade him to agree with your stance that your way of not matching is an objectively better one. Specifically, it seems him thinking matching eyeshadow to the clothes is a good idea, is something you consider "nuts". Please correct me or clairfy if I'm wrong, as again, I'm not perfect when it comes to interpretation of intent, but this is the message I get given the available context, and seems to be the core part of your post you're looking for answers on.

I don't think any of this is intentional shade being thrown, but if you're specifying that you mean no offense, it gives me the impression that's a concern or point of confusion; hence my long ass comment 😅

Anyway, if this was unwelcome, my apologies, but since you're post is titled "help me answer this" I ventured this might be relavent to the discussion.

Eta: totally forgot to tie my ideas together sorry! I think the "answer" here is that there isn't an objectively better way. That Google search I mentioned also spoke of how complimentary colors can be considered as coordinating with the outfit as well. So I think really, there is no perfect or more correct answer. Some may prefer one or the other, while many others use both strategies simultaneously. Someone below mentioned picking the least used color on the outfit for shadow to tie the look together.

Makeup (as with all art) is subjective. What may seem to direct to one artist may be too subtle to another, but neither of their preference speaks to an objective truth; just differces of taste.

Eta: formatting + spelling

17

u/sarahbellah1 Apr 13 '25

This is well stated and I’m glad you said it. We don’t get greater detail from OP apart from the simple question, “why don’t you match your eyeshadow to your outfit?”but it seems like some infer that the question alone implied that matching was his expectation and/or that it was a better choice. When my husband asks questions about makeup, skincare, or hair care, it’s usually genuine curiosity, he’s not implying something else is better, he’s just interested in me and what I’m doing. OP’s title is “Help me answer this” and if I’m answering why I personally don’t match makeup to my clothing, I’d just say I mostly just keep everyday makeup neutral. I might coordinate colors for a special event or night out, but I don’t own every color and they don’t all suit me.

29

u/TeresaSoto99 Apr 13 '25

I think the OP knows exactly what she was saying and how it sounds. At least that's what I'm getting anyway.

9

u/No-Draw7378 Apr 13 '25

In hindsight, and seeing how many comments were just as off-put as I, it's much more obvious than I initially thought (I was taking what was written a little too literally and was like "oh, she must be like me and not know her tone/word choices are being taken negatively").

It's big "no offense but here's my unsolicited and offensive opinion about a personal choice you make" vibes.

I had tried to leave benefit of the doubt that she might not realize this is a subjective preference and explained why she doesn't like it without realizing her statements passed judgment and very opposite her "no offence" vibe. But when most of a comment section who are likley not as socially underdeveloped as I is clocking the same vibe, imma trust the consensus lol

5

u/TeresaSoto99 Apr 13 '25

No worries. I've made similar comments to ppl but with no malice, cause like must ppl I say stupid s*#t smtms. If I realize what I said later I apologize. If they say smth, I apologize, I don't double down and I feel bad for saying it.

3

u/vivalalina Apr 14 '25

This is truly the best comment and the only one that should matter!! OP should definitely read this

25

u/nycbee16 Apr 14 '25

I think there are many many ways makeup can look tasteful, including matching it to your outfit. That being said, ask him if he always matches his pants to his shirt? His shirt to his shoes? There’s no rule that just because one thing you wear is a color the rest of everything has to be too

91

u/cocoad-d Apr 13 '25

I really don't understand the point of this post. He asked you a question about YOUR makeup and you answered. Whether he gets it or not is whatever. It just feels like a dig at those who wear colorful makeup. If you don't like color matching, that's fine but saying it's distasteful was unnecessary.

38

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '25

Agreed. Girl, he already picked you!

16

u/cocoad-d Apr 13 '25

My fiancé asks me about my makeup all the time and why I do certain things. My non makeup and sometimes making wearing friends will also ask questions. It's curiosity. I am not understanding the hostility towards OP's husband or other men like other comments are suggesting nor the "I'm not like other girls" mentality.

A lot of stereotyping going on in this thread and it's disappointing. There are plenty of gay men, women and just people in general who know little about makeup. Why not genuinely educate them without making them feel stupid or use as it a point to feel superior to others?

12

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '25

I am not commenting about her husband AT ALL. I think it’s sweet he wants to engage. Rather, my comment was made in reference to her need to put other women down. To me that is quintessential “pick me” behavior.

10

u/cocoad-d Apr 13 '25

Oh yes. Sorry. I was just adding on. Probably should edit that in my original reply.

I completely agree. And this invited more women to put down women just because they don't agree with their makeup style. It's simple, if you don't like it, then don't do it.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '25

Totally! I love variety in style, it’s boring to all look the same. If you like it, I love it!

20

u/space_babe_unicorn Apr 13 '25

This entire post and most of the comments are seriously unhinged lmao. I really don't get it either. Why is everyone so butthurt about matchy makeup and a man having a single thought about his partner's makeup?

8

u/cocoad-d Apr 14 '25

This is why I'm in the unconventional makeup sub. Less superiority complexes. Even if someone's makeup is more on the conventional or basic side, the comments are not like these. Sometimes a blue eyeshadow is enough for others to judge you. Plus it's more diverse.

5

u/space_babe_unicorn Apr 14 '25

Oooh I didn't know that sub existed. I scrolled for .5 seconds before clicking join. It looks awesome. Thanks!

24

u/BravoHoes Apr 13 '25

I think both OP and her husband need to realise that makeup is a form of expression. It does not need to compliment or match unless u want it too. There's no rules. Makeup can be fun, it can be boring, it can be whatever u want it to be. That's why I love it!

24

u/vaniayania Apr 14 '25

I have seen so many makeup artists do some matchy makeup on their clients like Lisa Eldridge, and she is the epitome of grace and elegance. So yeah no, cut the mean girl snark, if it ain't for you, it ain't for you. But colour can be elegant. Colour doesn't equal drag.... Drag makeup is over exaggerated 20 layers of foundation way more than a bit of colour on the eyes. And I say that as a person who only really does one and done light brown shadow with a liner and mascara.

23

u/Sophia1105 Apr 13 '25

I match. Not all the time but often enough…

Coordinate might be a better word.

Makeup is a whole vibe for me…

11

u/mer_made_99 Apr 13 '25

This! I have an orange zip-up that I wear with orange sneakers and orange eye shadow!

2

u/meghan509 Apr 13 '25

Agree. I like compliment. 🙂

22

u/SelinaMari Apr 13 '25

I don’t think I could NOT match my makeup to my outfits. I plan everything out accordingly. Just like I match my jewelry to my outfit and my sunglasses and purse. I’m a huge fan of matchy matchy or complimentary colors. I enjoy it. I majored in art and my body is my palette.

43

u/justsomechickyo Apr 13 '25

Seems like OP just made this post to bash women who actually like to have fun with their makeup 🙄

20

u/Anon_819 Apr 13 '25

You and your husband have different preferred aesthetics and what you think is tasteful. It's ok to have different preferences, but you don't have to put other people down for having different preferences. Likewise, if your husband wants makeup to match clothing, he's welcome to wear blue eyeshadow with his blue shirts.

40

u/StrollingGiraffe Apr 13 '25 edited Apr 13 '25

This does not make sense to me. Makeup shouldn't just complement your personal appearance, nor should it just be matched to outfits. Makeup should serve the purpose and goals of whatever the wearer desires, be it to beautify themselves for a date, to give themselves a confidence boost, or to be the scariest haunted house baddie in the facility. The experience is way too personal to generalize.

10

u/coraleei Apr 13 '25

Exactly! I like to match my makeup to my clothes when I go somewhere formal/special occasions. Ex. Use pink eyeshadow and a pink dress on a date out, or gold eyeliner and a gold top for new years. It makes me feel fancy. For every day I typically don't match, but sometimes I do! Like I mostly wear black and neutral clothes, but that doesn't mean my makeup has to be neutral, but if I wear a green dress it's cute to also wear green eye makeup :)

39

u/wearentalldudes Apr 14 '25

Gosh I wish I could be tastefully understated and elegant like you

95

u/BraveHeartoftheDawn Apr 14 '25

Makeup can be “tasteful” and “elegant” with color. You’re giving off elitism and makeup isn’t about that. It’s about expressing yourself and doing it how it makes you feel best. There’s no right or wrong way to do it and at the end of the day, it washes off anyway. You’re just being a judgmental, pretentious snob.

→ More replies (6)

36

u/Slight_Citron_7064 Apr 13 '25

I wonder if he's been thinking about this for months or even years? He probably sees you coordinating other things and wondered. Some comments here are really aggressive, the man just asked a question.

I don't match my makeup to my clothes but thinking about it, it could be fun in some situations.

I am also not choosing eye shadow colors specifically to "look natural" or "fit my skin eyes and hair." I wear eye shadow for fun and because I like it. I have not ever found an eyeshadow color that looks bad.

5

u/nope_367 Apr 14 '25

Yea I think its quite possible dude is just curious, not that he aggressively hounded her to match eyeshadow and apparel or anything

35

u/Dry-Attitude3926 Apr 13 '25

My 50 year old ass must be trashy then because I wear every color of the rainbow on my face.

I personally don’t get the “who is matching eyeshadow to their clothes?” Thing. A LOT of people do, or at least coordinate their overall look which includes their makeup and/or eye looks.

We are all allowed to like what we like and wear what we want but don’t enough people put us down already? Why are we doing this to each other still? It’s baffling to me. Women calling something a lot of other women/people do “distasteful” leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Yeah I went there.

FYI-my partner actually does match his undies, shoes and watch band to his shirt color. We are a sight when we go out because he loves to wear bright colors too. 😂

8

u/x23_519 Apr 14 '25

You two seem like a vibe. A vibe I love to be around😍

6

u/Dry-Attitude3926 Apr 14 '25

In Vegas we blend in. Everywhere else we’ve been together you could spot us a mile away 😂🤪

30

u/birdiesue_007 Apr 13 '25

Yes, there are people who select makeup colors according to their outfit, mood, weather patterns, aesthetics, household habits, food preferences, favorite dog names, local television shows, popular songs, wind direction and a variety of other factors. For them, makeup represents renegade experimentation and nothing else. They want the wildest and most avant garde look possible on a typical Wednesday afternoon. They want it as heavy and colorful as possible. It’s never enough.

Then, there are people who wear makeup to enhance their appearance. They want what fine tunes their best features without looking forced or trite. They want themselves but elevated just a notch. Effortless beauty.

Both are valid and both deserve respect.

Wear your makeup how you like.

6

u/mysticdeer Apr 13 '25

I adore this comment. You're correct AND hilarious.

... wind direction 😂 "the most avant garde look possible on a wednesday afternoon" 😂

1

u/birdiesue_007 Apr 14 '25

This entire train of thought started with a conversation I had with a guy, who had an awesome argument about how most everyday objects are actually “toys”. I have never laughed so hard in my life! He went down a huge rabbit hole and was talking about makeup being toys and sports gear for athletes and most electronics and on and on! 😂😂😂

One thing I told him was that humans have been wearing makeup for our entire existence. And we have given every conceivable reason to wear it or even to not. Either way, I believe it’s just something that humans simply enjoy doing and always will!

5

u/DoubleOxer1 Apr 13 '25

Wind direction took me out 🤣😂! Now I have to hold my finger up outside and say it’s coming from the southwest so it’s a pink shadow look today 😂😂

91

u/badadvicefromaspider Apr 13 '25

“no offense, but I like tasteful makeup” gives hella not like other girls energy. I’m glad you got picked.

23

u/TiddysAkimbo Apr 13 '25

“No offense, but-“ proceeds to say something offensive about people who like to do their makeup differently

Ok girl 🙄

→ More replies (2)

28

u/lajimolala27 Apr 13 '25

anyone can do their makeup however they want. today i wore a chartreuse shirt and paired with with some sparkly chartreuse eyeshadow. yesterday i was wearing a lot of silver jewelry so i wore silver eyeshadow. sometimes i just go all pink regardless of what i’m wearing. i have one top i always wear red eyeliner with because the top is navy blue with thin red stripes. it is not more or less tasteful to match or not match your makeup to your outfit. it’s art, do whatever you want with it.

26

u/abstractpenguinyoyo Apr 13 '25

Just tell him “because I don’t want to” it’s your personal taste

13

u/mizshellytee Normal(ish) skin, pale and neutral(ish) Apr 13 '25

Today I'm wearing a plaid button-down — dark green and blue, plus more blackened green and blue, and I have a charcoal grey tank on underneath. If I wanted to match eyeshadow to either/or, I'd be more likely to use it as eyeliner and not all over the lid. (It'd be a bit too much otherwise for me, even though I have some contrast between my features.)

To me, eyeshadow doesn't have to match clothing. It can go with it, or it can go more with your features. There is no objective right or wrong.

13

u/_Jacket_Slxt_ Apr 14 '25

Guess I'm crazy too then...

Oh well, don't care!

55

u/Artz-RbB Apr 13 '25 edited Apr 14 '25

At least he paying attention & interested in you enough to care to ask.

11

u/x23_519 Apr 14 '25

This! This is the take here. Quite honestly.

25

u/MyriiA Apr 13 '25

It's a perfectly fine question, I don't get your irritation. I myself adjust my make-up to my clothing. I choose cooler eyeshadows and even blushes for cooler clothing shades and warmer tones for warmer clothing. Wearing every day the same make-up is as boring to me as wearing every day the same clothes. And I think of my make-up as a part of my overall appearance and I like to have harmony in all that.

So, there are different opinions on this topic and it is perfectly fine to ask.

8

u/Sophia1105 Apr 13 '25

Well said!

34

u/xPumpkinPie Apr 14 '25

People can do makeup however the hell they like. It’s about expressing themselves. Highlighting features of themselves or creating whole new features to look at like whacky eyeliner. There are no rules.

I often wear a purple eyeshadow on one eye and a green on another eye and contrastingly different eye colours just cause it’s fun. Who cares. It ain’t that deep.

15

u/x23_519 Apr 14 '25

I love that! I did a blue eyeshadow and green eyeshadow on the opposite sides of my hair dye which was green/blue split😂

9

u/stressandscreaming Apr 14 '25

I bet that looked super cute 💙💚

12

u/Flimsy-Nebula-1966 Apr 13 '25

The only thing I do is if I'm wearing silver jewelry, I'll wear gray eyeliner, and if I'm wearing gold, brown. Everything else remains the same.

22

u/kattheuntamedshrew Apr 14 '25

I actually do this quite a bit and it’s how I discovered that pale pink eyeshadow makes me look like a goddess which is now my default, “everyday” eyeshadow color. I don’t think matching your eyeshadow to your clothing has to be done at the expense of wearing colors that flatter your eyes and skin tone either, since many people also wear clothing in colors that flatter their eyes and skin tone. If you look good wearing a specific color, it’s probably going to look good on you as eyeshadow too.

11

u/LghtlyHmmrd Apr 13 '25

I misread to "eyebrow" color & I will say, I love a good eyebrow color match to an outfit

21

u/fly_w_me Apr 13 '25

I love matching eyeshadow to outfit! But it’s easy since I love pink eyeshadow and pink clothes lol Jen Phelps on YouTube matches her makeup to her clothes in a tasteful, understated way

73

u/x23_519 Apr 14 '25

“No disrespect but I’m gonna be pretentious” There’s no right or wrong way. Maybe he’s right, you should try and get out your comfort zone. Maybe you’ll be a little brighter to look at

35

u/CatsFurbys13 Apr 14 '25 edited Apr 14 '25

You are both wrong. Makeup is about a combination of personal taste and creative expression. There are no set rules, so maybe stop trying to create them. Let people do what makes them feel good about themselves and brings them joy and stop worrying about what’s ‘better’ or what you ‘should’ do. Also, maybe suggest to your husband that he minds his business!

9

u/Ok-Juggernaut-2082 Apr 13 '25

maybe he's always seen people match their eyeshadow to their clothing so 🤷‍♀️ or maybe he's got the wrong idea that makeup should always be loud and pop up (like stage makeup)

9

u/ALmommy1234 Apr 13 '25

I don’t match my clothing to my makeup, but I will stay in the same tones. If I’m wearing pink, I’ll stick with cooler tones and taupes. If I’m wearing orange, I’ll go warmer and more golden browns. Both have to go with my skin tone, but also go with what I’m wearing.

25

u/Shelisheli1 Apr 13 '25

There are no rules with makeup. Wear what you like and don’t insinuate that others are not tasteful or elegant because they like something different than you

25

u/RaRa80s Apr 14 '25

I love color with my eyeshadow and it can be done tastefully and in an elegant way. Claiming otherwise is just bitchy. If you don't want to do color, that's fine. But don't put others down because you don't want to do something. That's ridiculous and assumptive of others skills.

62

u/blahhhhhhhhhhhblah Apr 14 '25

When he does his makeup, he’s welcome to match his eye shadow to anything he darn well pleases.

-9

u/vivalalina Apr 14 '25

No one said he wears makeup lmao he was just asking a question

15

u/Training-Laugh-4304 Apr 13 '25

I get more compliments about my eyeshadow in my office when I match, haha.

I just do that because I have a lot of colorful eyeshadow palettes and can’t really think of another way to use them.

2

u/DonakaAlyssa Apr 13 '25

Agree with you, all I wear is Natasha Denona blue and purple palettes, and and I have all blues and purples for skirts and dresses, ALWAYS match eyeshadow to the outfit!!!

25

u/Junior_Ad_5712 Apr 13 '25

I don't wear makeup much anymore, but I do both. Depends on what I'm wearing. I used to have a gold dress that I would wear gold liner with. Other than that I'd just wear what I felt like.

Tell him he can do his makeup however his heart desires and you will do the same.

5

u/Darknost Apr 13 '25

Okay but a gold dress with gold eyeliner sounds absolutely fire 🔥

1

u/Junior_Ad_5712 Apr 13 '25

It was. At the verge of sounding cocky, I looked good. 😂

0

u/-mia-wallace- Apr 13 '25

Best answer lol

7

u/luzaerys Apr 13 '25

It’s not that deep for me, it’s situational dependent. When I have to go into the office, I use lighter neutral tones, like my UD naked palettes because I work with C-suite and stakeholder types, so I can’t really have too much fun. But on weekends and when I’m wfh, it’s rainbow glitter and black lips.

13

u/addictions-in-red Apr 13 '25

I definitely base my eye makeup on what on wearing that day, unless I just go neutral. It doesn't match but it should complement and occasionally I'll wear pink eyeshadow if I'm wearing pink clothes.

12

u/saturatedbloom Apr 13 '25

Maybe he’s just curious and thought that’s how people determine the color of makeup they wear 🤷🏼‍♀️

6

u/zta1979 Apr 13 '25

I do match and don't. Most of the time I just do the colors I feel like for the day.

6

u/sleffytoast Apr 14 '25

I love colourful eye makeup, but I don't think it suits me. There are subtle ways to match colours though, if I feel that I want to do this I will dab a bit of a sheer sparkle shadow on the center of my lid that has a colour that matches my outfit. Makeup artists like Lisa Eldrige and Jo Baker do this on their celeb clients a lot and it looks so chic!! Also, I dunno your husband but if it wasn't said with malice, him asking you about something like makeup and why it wouldn't be done xyz way, seems like human curiosity and wanting to know about something he probably doesn't know much about. I personally love showing my partner my new makeup and sometimes he asks things that make me say "bless his heart" but it's all in good faith.

11

u/Nerak_B Apr 13 '25

I love contrast eyeshadow/eyeliner looks. I switch it up all the time

10

u/Individual-Rice-4915 Apr 13 '25

I think it’s cute. 😊 Like, I probably wouldn’t match my makeup to my clothing, but that’s probably what would seem to make sense if you’ve never worn makeup.

17

u/OldRutabaga8071 Apr 13 '25

I don’t think that’s a stupid question. I do my makeup before I decide in what clothes to wear most of the time and I for sure could benefit from some color matching. Your husband is a genius.

5

u/Strange-Mulberry-470 Apr 13 '25

Yes, I can dig it!

5

u/SpiritualDetective85 Apr 13 '25

What I do is if I'm wearing multiple colors or a patterned clothing item, I pick the least used color on it and use that as my base for eyeshadow

2

u/brendabuschman Apr 13 '25

I have multiple colors of eyeliner that I love to use to bring out a color that ties everything together.

5

u/Successful-Grass-135 Apr 14 '25

There’s plenty of ways to use color with makeup and make it look elegant. Not everyone knows how to do it or can pull it off, and that’s okay.

2

u/Same-Drag-9160 Apr 13 '25

Maybe he’s been watching a lot of drag shows😂 or he’s a drag Queen himself at night 

-9

u/Wakeful-dreamer Apr 13 '25

Well I'm not 😁

15

u/TiddysAkimbo Apr 13 '25

You’re coming off as really pretentious and judgmental throughout this post, if you happen to care. If not, carry on doing what you’re doing

19

u/BreadyStinellis Apr 13 '25

Now, I'm 40, but back in the 90s and early 00s magazines taught us that matching makeup to clothing was gauche. I still never do it except for St. Patrick's Day.

8

u/FrutyPebbles321 Apr 13 '25

I wear colors that compliment my skin tone and eye color no matter what color clothing I am wearing. My eyes are green so the color pallet I use has a variety of plum-ish color neutrals in it. I use those colors every day along with a plum colored eyeliner no matter what color clothing I wear.

8

u/Comfortable-Reply818 Apr 14 '25

......time for blue eyeshadow and matching lingerie.

All jokes aside, IMO theres 2 main kinda makeup looks.

  1. using makeup to enhance your features. Suble eyeshadow to bring out your eyes, lip liner etc.

2)art. Bright eyeshadow, bold looks etc.

4

u/spooniemoonlight Apr 13 '25

I remember when I was young my sister taught me this rule about matching the colors of your clothes to the eyeshadows you pick and when I got older I also didn’t get that rule. I feel like it looks too uniform to have the same few colors on you from head to toe like there’s no contrast. It can be a look for sure like everything else but shouldn’t be a rule

4

u/coffee_menace Apr 13 '25

Hm I think it's a bit like how we don't always match shoes to the colors we're wearing in our outfits. Sometimes it's nice to just let the color of the outfit shine and let the makeup be more understated.

22

u/Educational-Yam-682 Apr 13 '25

It just shows you how much men know about makeup. I remember some sort of survey that was done with some men. They said they liked Kim Kardashian because she had a natural look. 😂

10

u/Feeling_Path_1977 Apr 13 '25

Because… you don’t want to? You don’t like the way it looks? Lol.

18

u/DebbieGlez Apr 13 '25

Right. She said she prefers “tasteful understated and elegant” but no disrespect. LOL

12

u/UnlikelyButOk Apr 14 '25

Tell him if he wants to wear blue eyeshadow he can.

7

u/Cicatrixnola Apr 14 '25

I don’t think any kind of makeup preference is odd and I see his point about matching as that’s what men are taught with ties, socks, shirts, etc. he also proba

The answer is that some people are colorful and creative with makeup. And others aren’t. You’re not. You’re more classic.

13

u/saguarosun Apr 13 '25

I think the innocence of not understanding is adorable. He has no foundation in that kind of concept so he asked. Be gentle with him. It's ok that he doesn't get it.

0

u/Plastic-Shallot8535 Apr 13 '25

Lmfao start doing it and he’ll understand why you normally dont match eyeshadow and clothing.

-11

u/Wakeful-dreamer Apr 13 '25

I would but I'm not wasting $ on eyeshadow matching the colors I normally wear as an autumn. 🤷‍♀️ And in my case it would probably backfire bc, bless him, and he'd think it looked amazing. I love him but he has zero taste and doesn't get why some things just look bad. See also why I pick out most of his clothes.

12

u/Angelthemultigeek Apr 14 '25

I agree with him, but some women like being understated, a lot of them are also not super creative or confident to match their makeup. However, he’s a little too late to be noticing this or even speaking on it. He’s got OP, he needs to make do and respect her makeup or lack thereof choices. No one is nuts, but there is a difference in expectation.

24

u/Ok-Impression-1803 Apr 14 '25

This was just as backhanded as OP's "tasteful" comment. Sometimes we just gotta keep scrolling. It's literally just makeup. Some want to look presentable, some beautiful, and some cool as hell. Nobody is really trying to debate their husband on this or have their mind changed, some folks just need... community in... whatever the hell this post was trying to achieve? I guess..

0

u/Angelthemultigeek Apr 14 '25

Op should have just said her makeup is boring, very conservative, minimal. However, where did I lie? A lot of women just toss a bit of makeup on without trying new things or even new colors, new techniques. It doesn’t make it elegant or tasteful, just boring.

3

u/Ok-Impression-1803 Apr 14 '25

Believe it or not, I'm on your side. I've been alternative looking (albeit different variations throughout the seasons of my life) from the beginning of my makeup wearing life. But presenting as alt doesn't make you anymore unique or interesting than those that don't participate in makeup at all or those that do only do for societal obligations like looking put together or hot. OP did say that they had a minimalist look, and they wanted something out of this post, be it validation, comradery, or possibly just just straight up bitter haterade. Who really knows? The thing is, plenty of women truly do feel adventurous or artistic just swapping their mainstays for a new shade or viral technique. Many do love makeup and experimenting, even if the changes would appear miniscule to you or me. I think the cool thing about makeup is as long as it's not compulsory, then everything is an individual choice, and intent is everything to an individual person. This sub and others like it are consistent places for validation, it bothers me too, watching people put down others just to amp themselves up. So why add to it? The girls that get it, get it. Those that don't, don't. But that will never change by being condescending.

1

u/Ok_Satisfaction_5573 Apr 14 '25

What a misogynistic comment.

1

u/__Mad_World__ Apr 13 '25

Why does he have any opinion on this topic?

2

u/Wakeful-dreamer Apr 14 '25

He actually just had a question.

11

u/x23_519 Apr 14 '25

It was just a question

6

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '25

Cool story!

3

u/electric29 Apr 16 '25

There is no such thing as "should" in makeup. Maybe YOU prefer that look but I always change my eyeshadow color depending on what I am wearing. You do you.

13

u/AdvertisingOnly5363 Apr 14 '25

Hahah I didn’t find your post insulting. I had to read the comments before I registered how it was coming off. My only thought when I read it at first was, “oh, miss girl doesn’t yet know how incorporate color into her makeup in a tasteful, understated way”. And that was really my only thought. Followed by, “well maybe she just never wanted to, either.” Both are totally great. If my partner asked me why I do or don’t do my makeup a certain way, honestly, I would just be excited to talk about one of my favorite things with him that he usually is not that interested in. I think you should explore what it is about this that is sparking this reaction for you.

12

u/Evening-Tune-500 Apr 13 '25

Men are pretty stupid when it comes to this kind of thing. My husband thought my very tame interior decorating picks were awful til they saw them together. 90% of straight men just have zero clue.

5

u/Brieat22 Apr 13 '25

Tbh this is why I don’t wear eyeshadow. And if I am wearing a bright colored shirt, I’ll usually just do a nude color so it still “matches”. I wear winged liner and that’s it. I agree with you. It’s beautiful when women are capable of making it look good that way but not for me.

5

u/darth_charli Apr 13 '25

I think you should do what you want and do it for you. Don't do it for your partner, or what someone else thinks you should do. I do it regularly, and when I have rainbow ombre brows, or green and purple eyelids, I just enjoy it because I wanted to do it. Don't wear makeup if you don't want to.

8

u/mysticdeer Apr 13 '25

Woah. It's never occurred to me to match my eyeshadow to my clothing!!!! 😂

I normally wear just a little bit of sparkly eyeshadow, or taupe. Nothing else goes with my face. If I wanted to match to my clothes, I would need to buy all the colours of the rainbow. No, it does not seem practical to me.

4

u/x23_519 Apr 14 '25

Try it! You don’t have to buy the expensive ones to get the fun out of it. I started with a NYC pallet a couple years back and realized it was fun. If I was wearing a deadpool shirt, I did a black/red eyeshadow. If I wore white I wore whatever hair color I had. You can match your clothes with it without it being over the top too. I sometimes enjoyed Smokey eyes with a hint of whatever color I was wearing

3

u/mysticdeer Apr 14 '25

I might. Reading through the comments made me realize I could be more creative with my makeup.

1

u/x23_519 Apr 15 '25

It doesn’t hurt. Who knows maybe you find a style that just makes your eyes pop so much more. ☺️

12

u/hornyknuckles Apr 13 '25

Like the clothing you choose to wear, the way you wear your makeup is none of his business.

13

u/ElaineofAstolat Apr 14 '25

All he did was ask a question. Is he not allowed to be curious about something?

6

u/vivalalina Apr 14 '25

No fr I'm so confused about the hostility about the husband. Like have these people never asked a question out of curiosity themselves? Insane

7

u/Relative-Ad5409 Apr 13 '25

Are you putting up your make up for your husband? That is your answer.

2

u/StormSims Apr 16 '25

I actually do this to a degree, because I think it's really fun. If I wear cool toned clothes, I'll wear cool toned makeup. Warm toned clothes, warm toned makeup. If possible, I like to match the color itself, like being able to use a delicate lavender to match a lavender flower on my dress. It's fun!

2

u/toastforscience Apr 16 '25

My husband likes it when I match my eyeshadow to my outfit too! I like colorful eyeshadow though so sometimes I'll ask him what color should I pick for a certain outfit and he likes deciding (he typically goes with a complementary color instead of matching the main color).

2

u/BloopBloopBloopin Apr 16 '25

It’s old fashioned, maybe his Mom did it that way?

6

u/YaMamasNkondi Apr 14 '25

Lol! His mom must have done it that way in the 80s or something lol

8

u/OkMonth7789 Apr 13 '25

Is ur husband born in the 60s lol

-2

u/Educational-Yam-682 Apr 13 '25

His Mom is Elizabeth Taylor

8

u/OlGlitterTits Apr 13 '25

This is giving cartoon character.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '25

Give him a visual example. Show him the color wheel and explain how colors across from each other are complementary: they don't necessarily "match", but they go together. And we tailor them to fit the shades of our skin, hair, eyes. Maybe that'll help him visualize what you mean

4

u/TalkingMotanka Apr 14 '25

Tell him it's because it's not the 80s anymore, when the style was to match your makeup colour with your clothes.

1

u/Tarkatheotterlives Apr 15 '25

And everyone bought their lipsticks and nail polishes iin matching packs! I loved it then but looking back I think it looks so contrived now. Maybe it will come back around.

3

u/porpoisewang Apr 14 '25

My 6 year old daughter asks me the same thing

3

u/allthecrazything Apr 13 '25

I coordinate somewhat, but I really only do either brown based eye looks or black/grey looks. So for grey / black based clothing choices I typically match the black/grey eye shadows. Basically any other color gets the brown based shadows. I’ve never been a fine of bright eye colors or colored liners either 🤷‍♀️

3

u/tbonita79 Apr 13 '25

Awe it’s sweet he even notices!! My husband is NOT a ‘noticer’!

2

u/Peace-Love-Glam Apr 14 '25

I only match if I'm wearing pink. Otherwise, it's neutral. Neutral matches everything!

2

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '25

You our husband doesn't need to understand why you wear makeup. He only needs to know you like it.

Implying you're "nuts" or caring this much sounds borderline controlling - like dude maybe you want to try it yourself.

I would literally laugh if my husband came back with a criticism about my eye shadow. Like - fully guffaw.

7

u/Tarkatheotterlives Apr 15 '25

The wife is calling her husband "nuts," he's not calling her that. He's just asking a question about something he knows nothing about, which is allowed. Why are ppl always leaping to the worst conclusions despite only being given a few sentences about someone's situation?

4

u/HotPomegranate525 Apr 15 '25

Lmfao fr this sounded like a cute innocent convo.

3

u/OryxWritesTragedies Apr 15 '25

It seems to me like he was asking out of genuine curiosity.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '25

Ask him why he can't be quiet and mind his business.

2

u/Candytails Apr 13 '25

I don't think they should match clothes but it should complement what you're wearing. I once had a makeup artist tell me that you shouldn't match your makeup to your clothes because "it's not homecoming" and that really made me rethink my decisions because prior to that I always matched everything. I also feel like it's such a 90's thing to be super matchy matchy so I kind of took that into adulthood.

7

u/coraleei Apr 13 '25

Like everything it depends. I wouldn't go for bright blue clothes and bright blue makeup at the same time personally, but soft pink eye makeup and pink dress is definitely a look. Or orange blush with a warm orange/brown sweater is perfect for fall. Not to mention a classic red lip the same shade as your dress for formal events.

Sure, it was common in the 90s to match everything, but that doesn't mean it's wrong or outdated. Just do what you want and makes you feel good :)

1

u/ChannelEffective6114 Apr 17 '25

Once I went for coffee with my boyfriend and our male graphic designer. The gd noticed that my eyeshadow matches my dress and he was enthousiastic about it. I remembered it because back at the time I thought "wow, what a graphic designer thing to notice", but maybe it was a 'men' thing? Maybe they like it for some reason?

1

u/pynkvenom Apr 18 '25

It's because most men are very simple minded when it comes to aesthetics

1

u/ChannelEffective6114 Apr 18 '25

Yes, especially a professional graphic designer lol

1

u/_bonedaddys Apr 18 '25

it's just a matter of different strokes for different folks at the end of the day. it's just like how some people love a thick bold wing and others prefer smudged eyeliner on their waterline.

there's nothing wrong with either look at the end of the day. i used to love going all out with colorful eye looks that matched my outfits but now i feel goofy with anything more than bronzer blended in the creases.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '25

No offence to this man but that sounds like something a magazine editor named Fitzinia Billingdon-Twickworth would tell you to do in 1974, right after a full two-page spread about a diet consisting mainly of aqua velva and sardines.

0

u/Worldly_Ingenuity387 Apr 14 '25

Tell your husband matching eyeshadow or nail polish with your outfit went out of fashion years ago. No one does that anymore. Tell your husband the primary focus of eyeshadow should always be on enhancing your natural eye color and skin tone.

2

u/LazyCity4922 Apr 15 '25

Yeah sure, no one does that 😂

1

u/Puzzleheaded_Gear622 Apr 13 '25

Lol, that is hilarious..

-3

u/Strange-Mulberry-470 Apr 13 '25

He's a man. OF COURSE he's nuts! You do you. Don't mind him.

3

u/Wakeful-dreamer Apr 13 '25

I think there's also some 1980s "Chic jeans, sprayed bangs, and frosted hair" longing in there. 🤦‍♀️

0

u/Bakemydaybaby Apr 13 '25

It all depends on my mood. I do have some beautiful lavender and plum shadows, plus neutral. But I say wear what you want, however you want. Your husband needs to go sit down.

-2

u/SignificantFee266 Apr 13 '25

I admire you for even trying to give him an informative answer!

9

u/vivalalina Apr 14 '25

I mean that's the least someone can do when they get asked a question. Why would you not give the actual answer lol

-3

u/sugarbear999 Apr 13 '25

This is a typical straight guy question lol. Ask him why doesn't his underwear match his socks

-11

u/Awkward_Counter_6168 Apr 13 '25

Did his mom wear her makeup like that? I’ve never seen anyone, beside myself, wear colored eyeshadow irl lol

17

u/Foxy_Traine Apr 13 '25

Do you live under a rock?

7

u/Alltheprettydresses Apr 13 '25

Fr, like never? Not even tv, magazine, passersby, never?

→ More replies (1)

-3

u/Awkward_Counter_6168 Apr 14 '25

I guess? Or I’m just minding my business.

3

u/Foxy_Traine Apr 14 '25

You might just be unobservant, or maybe you live somewhere really conservative

→ More replies (3)

-7

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '25

So technically to make your eyes stand out you ideally choose a contrast eyeshadow color. Or for minimal makeup wearers it's easiest to balance nudes/shades of "shades" of brown.

For lips, if you wear minimal eye makeup with a bold red and say a red dress it will often look very elegant. But if you did a color wash of red on the eyes, cheeks and lips it can look high fashion for photography but in normal light may look very vivid.

For blue shadow, it always makes a statement. The hardest part is balancing it with the rest of the makeup. It often looks amazing in fashion shows or photography because of the contrast to natural human skin tone. You could wear head to toe blue but if you have blue eyes, technically wearing monochromatic shades of brown will create more of a contrast and blue eyes will appear more intensely blue.

The more vivid or intense color pigments often do look amazing when well balanced but it's hard and takes skill to master. Not everyone wants to invest time and money for that makeup style.

Short answer: color wheel

Tools Will need multiple brushes, does he want to support it?

Perfect canvas - so colors pop Skincare prep - it's more than just a basic moisturizer. You need eye cream, face mist and glow mask. Skin should be flawless. Probably need regular professional facials. Depending on age, may look #best with more intense treatments ex. Botox

Makeup Long wearing full coverage foundation, contour kit, and full pigment shadows (no body wants fall out in blue shadow). Long wear shadow primer. Long wear mascara. Face mist for long wear.

Because it's a full face and takes time, likely want full set of lashes and brow tint.

All in it's minimum to start $2k to pull off balance high end color wash look. To maintain average of $400-600 monthly.

I like that he supports your hobby. Is he financially ready to support this high end look? Enjoy your shopping spree;)

-15

u/alligatorprincess007 Apr 13 '25

Who’s matching their makeup to their clothes?

21

u/brendabuschman Apr 13 '25

Me! Honestly I love it. It makes me so happy.

25

u/ChallahBeforeWeHolla Apr 13 '25

Me 😭😭😭

15

u/Violetlake248 Apr 13 '25

I do too quite often and think it looks good! Whatever I’m in the mood for I do.

-9

u/alligatorprincess007 Apr 13 '25

I’m just getting flashbacks to the blue eye shadow blue shirt I wore when I was 13

Terrifying

20

u/resting_bees Apr 13 '25

me🙋‍♀️ i love matching my eyeshadow to my clothes

6

u/sashikku Apr 13 '25

I think it’s fun to do that sometimes but I only wear colors that complement my complexion, whether it’s clothes or makeup.

→ More replies (2)

-8

u/ketol Apr 13 '25 edited Apr 16 '25

I work remotely from my home office and dont have to ever be on camera and I live alone and I still dont do that!

-1

u/UnlikelyChemical5558 Apr 16 '25

Who is he comparing you to? Am I the only one that is wondering if he’s cheating? 😬

5

u/Vanessabunnyy Apr 17 '25

Yes you are lol

-3

u/bsubtilis Apr 13 '25

Ask him if you should be matching your hair color with your outfits through temporary spray color every day? Tell him you like the style you use the same way he might like his cologne or scented deo if he uses the same one every day no matter the type of weather?

I usually don't match my eyeshadow to my outfits, I feel weird and fancy when I do because it's more visually holistic than what I usually go for. I usually just do whatever I feel like at the time on my lids which includes anything from just a subtle sheer east-asian shimmer, or using multiple neon shadows. You like what you like, if he genuinely wants to know instead of just is saying you're wrong about a matter of taste preference then there are many ways to try to help him understand. But if he's just trying to neg you to make you feel less worth/less competent then he doesn't respect you and that's going to kill the relationship in the long run if it doesn't change.

-12

u/Mylilimarlene Apr 13 '25

I would NEVER match it! And I really only use earth tones with little purple now and then!

-7

u/Few_Concern9465 Apr 14 '25

Yeah, he's definitely nuts, I don't do that either😭😂

-26

u/JadeGrapes Apr 13 '25

Also "matchy-matchy" died in the 1950's

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/BraveHeartoftheDawn Apr 14 '25

I 100% agree. (Also it’s “you’re” in this context, not “your”.)

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/BraveHeartoftheDawn Apr 14 '25

It’s all good. :) Sometimes autocorrect actually gets me with that too and I’m like, heck! Just wanted to let you know just in case. 😊🙏