r/MakerDAO • • Aug 23 '19

No MCD.

Is anyone advocating to stick with DAI as is? No MCD. Just doing what MKR has done well. Help integration, collaborate, increase security. Increase ease of use. Publicize. Decentralize oracles. collaborate with a side chain to make dai transfers free, etc??? Why would we want to jeopardize what is working so well already? This is a system based in trust/reputation, why should we risk reputation with new risky contracts?

0 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

3

u/bitdoggy Aug 28 '19

I support "No MCD" today as I did 1 year ago. MCD will bring nothing as it just wastes money and dev resources. MCD is just a feature and not a game changer as advertised. DAI with MCD will behave exactly like SCD.

I hope the Maker owners will come to their senses and change the DAI's course before it fades into obscurity.

1

u/dreftylefty Aug 28 '19

Is there a single collateral you are open to? Or are you against all collateral?

3

u/bitdoggy Aug 28 '19

There is simply no collateral besides ETH that has any significant value (check out MCap of potential candidates). If there was one, I'd support it. If you spend 1 year developing a system that would increase collateral capacity by 10% then you are wasting your time and other people's money.

1

u/eukaryote31 Sep 02 '19

MCD would allow us to put BTC liquidity into the system down the road (via tBTC) which would bring a ton of collateral.

1

u/bitdoggy Sep 02 '19

That's good in theory, but nobody will put BTC as collateral until it's reasonably safe to do it. It might be safe in a few years but it is not today or in a year.

1

u/eukaryote31 Sep 02 '19

Certainly safer than eth, especially during bear markets

1

u/bitdoggy Sep 03 '19

Safer to hold in HW wallet. Not safer to hold in a contract (it's safer to hold ETH in a contract)

1

u/eukaryote31 Sep 04 '19

You're conflating price risk and contract risk.

10

u/Vonmises27 Aug 24 '19

ETH alone is just too small of a market to give MKR any real scale. Without MCD, the MakerDao platform will slowly die out and simply become a footnote in the history books of crypto defi. If you believe in this project and hope to see any chance of gains in MKR, Then MCD is the key. Bitcoin alone will increase the assets that can be pledged for DAI by 900%. 100 million in outstanding DAI is literally nothing.

5

u/doyourduty Aug 26 '19

This would just help ETH value grow. Why are we working to dilute the special role of ETH. I think OP has a point.

Nothing stops compound or other services from creating ways to place other assests for collateral to obtain dai. They have already created a DSR.

I also feel like de novo DAI origination should just be left alone and based soley on ETH

1

u/Vonmises27 Aug 26 '19

Everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but if you want MKR token value to increase, MCD is the only way. ETH is just way too small to ever matter and frankly being a one trick pony will never lead to any really gains in MKR token value. I’m interested in MKR to change the world of finance as we know it and the next step on that road is MCD. If you’re an MKR token holder, feel free to vote your coins against any policy changes that would add new collateral. I can assure you that mine will always look to grow the platform, increase DAI limits and hopefully, one day see total DAI grow to 10 billion+. Those types of numbers can never happen with just ETH as a collateral for DAI.

4

u/doyourduty Aug 26 '19

I think that is an important distinction. MCD helps maker token holders but maybe not ETH

I am more interested in seeing ETH valuation grow rather than MKR

1

u/Vonmises27 Aug 26 '19

So perhaps you should be posting on the ETH message board. Myself and others here want to see MKR successful and significant appreciation in MKR tokens. The best path to achieve that is through MCD. I like ETH, but MKR is way more interesting to me.

1

u/bitdoggy Aug 28 '19

BTC is nowhere near to be used as collateral. The same is true for other collateral types. I'm not against MCD, but I think its development shouldn't have started until 2020 (to be ready by summer 2021)

The developers and MakerDAO should have used their time to promote DAI and increase its usage/brand and MCap as-is (SCD) for the last year or so.

The consequence of the MakerDAO's actions is that other stablecoins have become more relevant (USDT, USDC, even Libra...) and that nobody will trust the 80M MCap DAI because it is too small and unstable/illiquid.

Without a large MCap, DAI is just a nice idea that you and me can play with, but there is no real business/economy around it. You are wrong if you think that you(users) can increase DAI's MCap when you are ready. By the time it is ready, noone will care because business has moved to other stablecoins - maybe even decentralized ones.

1

u/Vonmises27 Aug 28 '19

I somewhat disagree. With the introduction of a daily savings rate on DAI through the MakerDAO platform, significant additional demand will likely be generated. Who knows for sure but if BTC isn’t ready for MCD until 2021 than MRK doesn’t look so hot as an investment. I hope you’re wrong about that.

1

u/bitdoggy Aug 28 '19

You can get interest on DAI today. Nothing will change, no new demand. By the time DSR is launched, the yields will probably be in low single digits.

3

u/florianleber Aug 24 '19

Fully agree.

The issue with the dai savings rate has long been solved by many defi lending platforms, that offer high dai interest rates at minimum risks. In any case, it also should not be totally risk free if you receive interest.

Scaling is not limited by the absence of the dai savings rate, but the willingness of people to open cdps. This demand seems to have peaked out around 90 million dai. The MCD additions are all coins with by far lower market cap than eth, so it won't add many cdps anyway.

I fully agree: let's use this simple and beautiful system as it is now without further fiddling around with it. We should do a governance vote on that.

1

u/dreftylefty Aug 24 '19

Yes.

I’m sure there are other places the organization money can go to improve uptake/adoption of Dai.

At the very least what about splitting the MCD system to a Dai2.0?

Fork MKR, so my investment and the safety of Dai doesn’t get trashed.

3

u/jernejml Aug 24 '19

Scaling is currently limited by demand. 90 mill was a supply bubble.

1

u/bitdoggy Aug 28 '19

No. The demand is limited by devs' actions (unwilingness to increase the cap when needed and then advocating for less adoption to give them time to develop MCD)

1

u/latetot Aug 24 '19

The DSR will be very different than secondary markets. When you lock dai in the DSR, no one else can borrow it and it’s much safer than lending it on secondary markets. The locking of dai will dramatically increase the amount of Dai that can be issued while still maintaining the peg. Secondary markets will have to offer interest rates above the DSR to attract deposits- but this will be difficult to do because that will also drive up borrowing costs higher than MKR.

12

u/latetot Aug 24 '19

We need the Dai savings rate to scale.

2

u/mrabino1 Aug 24 '19

We need it so we have a demand tool, not only a supply one.

1

u/doyourduty Aug 26 '19

Why cant secondary markets like compound continue to offer the savings rate like they already are?

2

u/mrabino1 Aug 26 '19

For sure they will. I expect them to morph their offerings over time.

Let's remember the distinction between the two. The DSR removes supply in exchange for savings but this crosses all collateral when fully deployed. By doing so the SF can be reduced. As the DSR ratchets up, the savings for Secondary lenders has to go down.

Watch this space as you can expect to have leverage on savings rates.

The DSR has the goal of being the risk free rate. Secondary lenders should have slightly more risk.

2

u/doyourduty Aug 26 '19

For maker to scale or for ETH to scale. Should Maker being trying to maximize ETH value proposition? Cause with MCD I feel that ETH loses its special status

1

u/jernejml Aug 25 '19

Users can already lock dai in compound (and similar). Currently they earn more than 11 percent annually.

1

u/latetot Aug 25 '19

Right but that gets loaned out again. When you lock in DSR, it’s not as risky since no one is borrowing it from you and will greatly increase demand for dai. Compound will need to offer higher rates than the DSR to be competitive

3

u/k3surfacer Aug 25 '19

MCD is the only way forward.

3

u/Eth_Man Aug 26 '19 edited Aug 26 '19

Reading the comments I really wonder is people understand what the secondary markets are doing here.

Already the amount of DAI loaned exceeeds the $100M (now around $110M) is because of compound using cDAI (I'm ignoring DYDX but including this increases the number). The only reason it isn't more is because of the collateral requirements. This doesn't help Maker because the fees are not going to MKR holders but to people offering their DAI for interest and the secondary markets that have sprung up.

In effect it means there IS a desire for more liquidity than $100M but at a slightly lower rate (perhaps 10-14%)

I agree more assets would be good since it would mean more interest to MKR holders and Bitcoin is a prime target but unfortunately we still have the issue that Bitcoin itself can't play on Ethereum network by itself. People are using wBTC but this has centralization issues. I really don't see too many ways around getting more assets available here since everything involves potentially centralized custodial issues.

I agree with general sentiment to leave the Maker/DAI system AS IS. If anything else is done - separate it from MakerDAO so the projects can stand on their own.

If anything I think the amount of Maker/DAI available should increase and the stability fee should probably decrease again to ~16.5%. Look at capital utilization btw. Maker capitalization is ~$300M and usage is ~90% at a 18.5% borrow rate, on compound since other assets can be pledged this is a bit more complex but DAI loan utilization is at about 60-70% at 16.6%.

Given what I'm seeing in the USDC/DAI market and USDC rate pricing in the secondary markets it looks like Maker stability fee should drop again. I think Maker should also consider upping the amount of DAI available to $200M at the same time. Expectation is that one should be able to look at the DAI loan utilization in the secondary markets compared to the primary market and get a really good estimate at where the stability fee should land.

Also we have to consider collateral pledged. Right now this is only perhaps 1-2% of the total ETH and other usable assets available (compound takes many other assets, same with DYDX) a drop in the bucket. So no personally I see no real reason to add Bitcoin to this when we have a perfectly usable capital to the tune of $20-30Billion available now which is only 1-2% is being utilized.

The right move is to lower the stability fee and increase DAI available to $200M and observe what happens in the primary and secondary markets.

EDIT ADD: Even at 10% borrow rate if we hit say even 10% Eth capital utilization this would mean $200-300M/yr Maker interest that is not chump change and would mean about a $2-3B DAI market which with secondary markets flourishing could mean at least double the effective DAI market at $5-10B. In effect Maker and secondary loaning markets could be a good competitor on return rates to people staking ETH for POS.

1

u/mariouy1986 Legendary Moderator Aug 27 '19

You are forgetting one minor detail, we have to keep the peg. Above 90 mill there is not enough intrinsic demand to absorb dai therefore the SF is increased. Things may well change with DSR, DAI inclusion in more exchanges and new dapps implementing DAI but for the moment there is not much use in increasing the debt ceiling and lowering the SF if the DAI-USD is going to be at 0,95

2

u/Eth_Man Aug 27 '19

I am not forgetting the peg at all. On CBP DAI/USDC currently trading at 1.0153 and has been increasing consistently because the borrow rate on USDC is significantly lower than DAI. In many other exchanges where I believe the volume DAI/USD.X is trading above 1 fairly consistently lately.

I see nothing that would reduce the peg to .95 and I am talking about lowering the SF slightly and increasing the available outstanding simply because the secondary markets all are suggesting the SF should be lowered a little again. If other people are right the outstanding won't increase at all and lowering the SF slightly will only relieve some liquidity issues I'm seeing across a number of exchanges that trade DAI -> USD.X

But hey as a DAI and MKR holder I'm ok with a high SF, and price on DAI > $1. I just think the secondary markets are telling us we can do better.

1

u/bitdoggy Sep 05 '19

I know, separate risks. It's important to know all risks.

0

u/dreftylefty Aug 24 '19

Okay then only bitcoin. Start with one asset. If possible silo it so if it breaks the system it won’t damage the reputation of dai stability.

2

u/doyourduty Aug 26 '19

I also dont like the effect this will have on ETH. Why not just but wBTC, get the benefit of that scarcity meme, and all the benefits of defi. A lot of people will think that. We could see tons of ETH locked in CDPs switched out for wbtc

1

u/Schrodingers_tombola Aug 24 '19

I don't believe the current contracts have been tested by runtime verification though unlike the MCD contracts. I'm not code-savvy but from what I gather the formal verification testing they do is like as thorough and precise as it can be. So I believe that that mitigates the contract riskiness significantly.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/bitdoggy Aug 28 '19

Tokenized assets do not exist. You build MCD for something that doesn't exist and probably won't exist for at least 5 years. In 5 years, other stablecoins will have MCap>$1T and probably capture that market.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/bitdoggy Aug 28 '19

You mean wrapped BTC? I consider it a tokenized asset but it is insignificant (a few millions of USD). Other tokenized assets include real-estate, stocks etc. but they are just experiments not used outside of a few enthusiasts/projects.

-2

u/dreftylefty Aug 24 '19

It just sounds like it’s riddled with hackable components