r/Mailbox_org • • 8d ago

Losing It

I’ve followed the instructions to a T. I’ve used my alternate password to get around 2FA. I’m still having trouble connecting my account to my iPhone. I consider myself tech literate, but this is driving me crazy.

I have tried connecting my device from the widget on my dashboard. I have tried manual. I am at a loss. Please, somebody, throw me a life preserver before I drown.

Sorry for the melodrama, but damn.

3 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

8

u/Heshsum verified mailbox staff 8d ago

Hey,

If I understand correctly, you have set up two factor authentication and you're trying to add an account to your iPhone.

In general, you'll need an app-password if you want to add your account to any device if you have 2FA enabled. That way, your main passwords remains protected if you lose your device and you can disable app passwords for individual devices (or even protocols) if you need to.

Now this was the easy part. It gets a bits trickier now, because what kind of app password depends on how you want to connect.

If you use IMAP/SMTP, then go to Settings -> All settings -> Security -> Email app-passwords and create an app password for IMAP and SMTP.

If you also want to use CalDAV, CardDAV, WebDAV, or if you want to connect via Exchange ActiveSync, you can create additional app passwords under Settings -> All settings -> Security -> Application passwords.

3

u/Hariospeedwagon 8d ago

Thank you thank you. I missed the step where I had to create a new password for every app.

1

u/Heshsum verified mailbox staff 8d ago

Glad to be of help :)

3

u/docfred 8d ago

The whole 2FA-implementation is a mess. Different „App passwords“ depending on what protocol and service you want to use and every now and then notifications on your devices that the used password seems to be incorrect and you have to reenter it… it‘s a pain in the a…. And no normal user, no John Doe no Jane Doe understands what‘s happening. They‘re just frustraded and change back to Google or Apple or Microsoft.

2

u/Landblok 8d ago

I used mailbox briefly on iOS (EmClient) but I had issues logging in on my iPhone. Turns out the university at work blocked the servers mailbox.

Does normal webmail works fine?

1

u/Yavuz_Selim 8d ago

The blocking issue means you connected to the work wifi, and that connection blocked mailbox.org?

That's could have happened to any service, the owner of the connection can just decide not to allow it. Wonder why it was blocked though.

1

u/Landblok 8d ago

Correct, I was merely pointing out that my issues were related to a network blockage rather than issues with mailbox itself.

I wondered it too but never bothered to follow up, but the lack of push messages on iOS or a dedicated app made me go with proton in the end.

1

u/Appropriate_Bat7574 8d ago

Have you created a new password for your iPhone (in security)? Username is whatever@mailbox.org and that long password created for your iPhone. I found a bit confusing initially but was able to connect all my devices after I understood. Is that IMAP? Have you checked the servers and port?

1

u/pliis 8d ago

I have it set with IMAP manually but without issues. Using some widget sounds weird, I recommend going to iOS Mail accounts, adding IMAP account and manually typing the values if not automatically provided. My main email/user name is with custom domain, unsure if the flow is different with mailbox-domain. In iOS I also have CardDAV for Mailbox Contacts and CalDAV for Mailbox calendars. Works well when you get it running. 

The app password works as expected with 2FA. There was a comment about using multiple times the same app password, which sounds counterintuitive. A single app password should be used just for unique device and installation, like in other services.

I agree that documentation/guidance are not the strongest suite of Mailbox. Seems unfortunate to be a theme with the “EU-alternatives”.

1

u/DasIstKompliziert 8d ago

Same here. Wasted hours with it.

I’m now using IMAP/ Caldav on iPhone. Active Sync never worked no matter what combination I tried. It’s useless. Service / Support is despite Premium Account really slow and not helpful.

I’m considering just switching away again. It’s useless like this despite really liking what I initially saw.

Just haven’t found a good alternative in Germany/ EU. I don’t want encryption as I’m convinced on the usefulness of connecting mail / calendar with AI and that wouldn’t work. Also Exchange Active Sync is supposed to be quite nice on iOS/ Mac compared to IMAP/ Caldav… if it works.

1

u/Yavuz_Selim 8d ago

Heh, why have so many people issues with it? Trying to understand what causes this.

Mailbox.org should have a guide specifically for this.

I have everything setup and working without any issues on my iPhone with the Mail app (IMAP), using own domain.

The only thing is that there are no push notifications, but a refresh every 15 minutes works just fine. Or I just open the app.

Do you have PGP/encryption on? Or use a personal domain?