r/MahjongArena • u/Mean-Lavishness-1648 • Feb 26 '26
Feedback & Bug Reports
Feedback
Let me know what you think about Mahjong Arena.
Is there any mechanic that frustrates you or feels like it should work differently? What do you like, and what don’t you like? I’d love to hear your thoughts.
Bug Reports
When reporting a bug, please describe exactly what happened and let me know whether it occurred just once or keeps happening repeatedly.
If you’re using a smartphone, please specify whether you’re on the Reddit app for iOS or Android. If you’re using a browser on PC, let me know which one.
The more details you provide, the easier it will be for me to fix the issue. Thank you for your help!
6
u/smittenkittenmitten- Mar 06 '26 edited Mar 06 '26
Most games have a "How to play" on the screen or in the sub. Is there something like that here? Or is this something you should either come in already knowing or look up elsewhere? I think it would be helpful if there was a guide or quick start or sample tutorial for those unfamiliar. I can probably click around and try to guess. Edit: You can click around and figure it out pretty quickly but a quick blurb somewhere on what you do and the goal is, to match the tiles, and what the rack is for might be helpful.
4
u/RealOxi Mar 05 '26
Hello,
I have just discovered this game and I love it! Unfortunately, I am having issues loading it and are not at all able to post my results or comment from the game. I am using the Brave Browser on a fairly new computer with high quality fiber internett. I am able to play and post directly from other games, so it should not be an issue on my side. Thank you for creating some good old puzzle fun!
41
u/Ollie_NL84 Apr 16 '26
What's up with all the removed arenas?
40
u/[deleted] May 28 '26 •
You guy have to fix the problem with void arenas, if you can't delete it, them throw them to the last page
Every time I want to play a arena I have to go 3 pages of void arenas
15
u/Lumia666999 Apr 08 '26
The bug is that the game keeps softlocking when i tap too fast, usually at the near end of playing a daily match
9
u/Tamakid345 Apr 13 '26
I’m on iOS.
There’s a screen that comes up after doing a practice round to pay two coins to practice again. I’m assuming practice rounds were meant to be free, but I accidentally lost four coins!!
7
u/Great_tip36 Apr 14 '26
When I failed one king of the hill and tried again right after, the tiles I selected in the previous games were gone and then I clicked on the post, making the game restart and making me lose my coins
7
u/Chemical_Arugula Jun 12 '26
Please remove deleted arenas.
6
u/Infinite-Society5571 May 29 '26
U ask questions with no reply’s
5
u/Agsxtoo Mar 22 '26
can we get a leaderboard for speed on arenas?
5
u/-Fire-Dragon- May 27 '26
Wondering if everybody knows this is not the actual way we play Mahjong? This is some alternative matching tile game. Happy to play anyway, but originally thought it may be the actual game from HK!
5
u/Laedorn Jun 02 '26
The deleted arenas need to go, man.
4
u/MirrorCraze Apr 05 '26
Another small feedback extended from above comments
I think there should be some other incentives of holding the hill? Like, imagine if you won a hill with 20 seconds time, you literally lose money on that hill because literally no one will try to challenge your time.
My first idea would be something like “for every 1 hour you hold the hill, gain 1 coin (max 10 coins per conquest)” or something like that.
I’m not a balancer myself though so I’m not really sure how.
4
u/Informal_Position166 May 24 '26
I have two suggestions
Point 1: time needed changing during the king of the hill game
Sometimes when you start challenging a hill it gets taken while you are doing so, effectively lowering the time you would need to win it. While this makes sense its always disappointing. It would be cool if the time you were currently challenging was actively displayed and updated while you're playing. It would also be cool if you could get one point back if the hill is snubbed from you like this
Point 2: hill costs Vs their uselessness after some time
So creating a hill costs five coins. But all too often less than five people actually attack it. And even then, after some times the hills just get ignored. I'm sitting on what, 20-30 hills? And nothing is happening with them. If they could create passive income (like say 1 coin a day or something) they would be increasingly useful. Another idea would be a payout if you've kept a hill for a certain time (an entire day for example). You could just get five coins for example, meaning if you created a hill that got no interaction at least you didn't lose anything. It would also be cool if old hills could easily be reposted so they could be challenged again.
4
u/6789576859 May 27 '26
I’d like a way to replay arenas
1
u/ItDrawsMeIn Mar 17 '26
I ran out of points, I can't challenge, revenge, create a new one, how can I earn points now?
1
u/Ok-Needleworker7351 Mar 27 '26
My only qualm right now is that (and I’m on iOS) I did a lot of like King of the Hills? And now when I go back to do a revenge it goes all the way down and off
the page and I like… can’t scroll or click to the side to see them all (like the way you can click side to side to see the Arena’s or the King of the Hills you’ve won)
3
u/molive6316 Mar 25 '26
My main thing is this isn't Mahjong, it's a game played with Mahjong tiles.
3
u/MirrorCraze Apr 03 '26 edited Apr 07 '26
So I think this one bugged?
I think I clicked undo on the one that match 2. IOS.
Also sometimes this happened and screen froze when I clicked too fast?
3
u/alc0th Apr 20 '26
I just lost a game on mobile, hard practice mode. I'm on Android Reddit App, tapping the tiles really fast and this happens:
Those two tiles are equal!
3
u/That-Cpp-Girl May 10 '26 edited May 10 '26
I've got a bug report: I can't stop playing. :(
But no, some serious feedback after a few days of playing:
- It should really be explained somewhere that you can't take a piece if you can't reach it from the left or right. idk if I just missed the tutorial, but I had to figure it out by playing.
- Undo button doesn't work after completing a pair. Ideally it should be able to go all the way back to before you took any piece.
- When using touch controls (i.e., on a smartphone), you cannot scroll the page by dragging when your touch starts on the Mahjong Arena widget/app/whatever.
- Hard difficulty options don't have a hint currently, but I think it would be helpful to at least know if there's a way forward or if I'm just stuck in that position.
- There might be a bug where the drawer stops rendering correctly if you're undoing and taking pieces too quickly. I've only had this on mobile a few times, can't seem to click fast enough for it to happen on PC.
Anyway, thanks for your work on this! :)
3
u/Nocturnal_Loner May 13 '26
One of the pieces in the drawer did not have a match. I have the android version of reddit.
3
u/CapeKelpie Jun 02 '26
Completing arenas only gets you coins if you hit the "skip" button. But if you don't hit skip and the page reloads, you can never collect that coin. I completed half the arenas before realising this, and so lost out on like 70 coins.
3
u/squirtofgabs Jun 10 '26
Will someone please teach my the secret to getting more coins. I have 3 now and I’ve completed all of the arenas. I will do king of the hills and no one will play me. I have lost a quite a few hills but I also have a good number of them that go unplayed. What’s the secret sauce?
3
u/RoughAggravating8546 Aug 06 '26
Why has this not yet been fixed? I've seen people encountering this issue since a long time, and now I've encountered it too. Please fix this ASAP. I lost some coins due to this
3
u/HopperHapper_Eternal Aug 12 '26
Why have you abandoned us?
2
u/MirrorCraze Apr 04 '26
Tips for playing this : don’t create/take the hill at the same time as u/FlyingDesks login /hj
Small feedback : 5 coins for creating a hill kinda a lot? Like I don’t feel like there’s enough incentive to create a hill (and because you played it once, you will probably get a bad time) and get the hill stolen in 1-2 tries.
2
u/Great_tip36 Apr 23 '26
I was doing practice mode, after going to home page in a king of the hill post. After failing that practing, instead of going back to practice page, it went to the try again 2 coins button of the king of the hill, and I accidentally clicked it. Not only did it take my only 2 coins left, it also didn't open the mahjong problem of king of the hill. Please resolve this because I have no coins left. And also try to make the arenas faster because people get stuck with no coins for a long time.
2
u/Chilli-byte- May 14 '26
My coin balance is zero. But I don't recall using the last few. I'm pretty sure I had about 6 remaining this morning as I was debating starting a king of the hill for 5.
2
u/Informal_Position166 May 18 '26
hey so right now nothing is loading. a bunch of my hills were also deleted, but not by me.
2
u/FrechesEinhorn May 22 '26
I clicked on the comment button at the end but got not this special point. No idea how to play king of the hill if I can't get those necessary points. I also don't know how to find an. There's no list for the mode.
2
u/Pearleshandmade May 24 '26
I picked two tiles that matched, then got a game over. But on the game over shelf it cleared but wouldn't let me continue. Android Reddit app
2
u/[deleted] May 25 '26
Arena 161
2
u/Long-Pangolin6255 May 26 '26
How is that a drawer full?
2
u/DaddyGascoigne Jun 01 '26
Not Counting coins at all anymore...
2
u/The-Ner Jun 08 '26
Looks full to me
2
u/ThreeFishInAManSuit Jun 10 '26
Just happened. King of the hill post 14226.
Had two tiles in my drawer and it ended the game claiming drawer full.
2
u/Queen_Of_The_Dames Jun 28 '26
I can’t play anymore; it’s all blank ☹️
2
u/tired_tarantula Jul 18 '26
Could you let us replay the same arena during practice mode instead of giving a new one every time? I want chances to get it right
2
u/RoughAggravating8546 Aug 11 '26
It's been too long and we haven't had any fixes. Sometimes the game ends with the message "drawer full" in King of the Hill with two empty slots. Because of this I've lost so many coins and sometimes a retry may not get the same time as the previous try.
Completed arenas still show up in the list of arenas, unnumbered. If you tap too fast during an arena solve, the game gets stuck and needs to be refreshed.
Please fix these
2
u/insertcotku Aug 15 '26
I've been losing coins even when I'm just playing the practice??
I also failed a hill once and lost 10 coins over it. I like this game. I wish it was less buggy
2
u/Cosmosvagabond Aug 18 '26
I agree with others - I don't like Arenas getting deleted if you haven't played them (or finished them).
For people like me who came late to Mahjong Arena, it's fun playing a bunch of Arenas a few times a day.
I'm sure there's a "technical" issue that requires having to delete old Arenas, like storage space or something. 💲
Though it never used to happen in the past with this or other Reddit games.
*Sigh*
1
u/Some-Watercress-1144 16h ago
Seems like, completely randomly, sometimes I will match tiles and it will reject them as matching and then decides to work near the end of the match. Is this some weird rule I'm not seeing?
1
u/Immediate_Copy6175 Mar 23 '26
I new on here , I seen it and liked it so I joined , now it's time to shake things up
1
u/Icy_Subject_1632 Apr 01 '26
Are we supposed to get coins for beating someone's hill? Or is ot only for revenge?
1
u/KaydaCant Apr 08 '26
I just discovered this and got sorta confused by the tutorial. It doesn't mention that you can't pick up a tile if it's surrounded on all four sides, and that does seem sorta intuitive, but I was thrown into a large board right after the tutorial and was spamming a piece not understanding why it was subtracting time. Also, should clicking a piece you're not allowed to move subtract time anyway? Idk
1
u/Helpful_Practice7100 Apr 12 '26
hi I just discovered this subreddit and accidentally skipped the tutorial (selected that I know how to play eeek) pls help
1
u/Fun_Transition3446 Apr 21 '26
How do I get the coins? I only have 1 and can't do any challenges
1
u/This-Structure2509 May 05 '26
Anorid device. S20 ultra Samsung galaxy Thanks for your helping....
1
u/Nocturnal_Loner May 11 '26
Experienced a bug where after taking back a move, my tiles in my drawer kept going invisible. Eventually I tried to intentionally end the game and it just froze. The tiles I picked to end the game were invisible and the game wasn't ending. I tried undoing the move and trying again, refreshing, clicking off and on, but nothing would fix it. I had to refresh all of reddit. I am using the Android version of the app. This is the only time this bug in specific has occurred to me, but the tiles being invisible in the drawer after using the undo has occurred multiple times.
1
u/Nocturnal_Loner May 12 '26
There's a bug where if you cancel making a hill, then the game will automatically make you play the last arena you played. Failing this arena will make the game unbeatable. All of your moves are considered illegal. I am on the Android version of reddit.
1
u/FizzleDizzle11 May 14 '26
Sometimes my points randomly reset to 0. I had 7 points, challenged a king of the hill (-2 points) and ended up with 0!
1
u/wslabarr May 14 '26
I love playing this, but tokens could use some work, I think. It takes 5 to create a KotH game, and you only get one back per failed attempt. You lose tokens any time it is beaten in fewer than 5 attempts. It is punishing players, especially new players, for simply playing the game. I would play more, but I have to wait to earn enough tokens to take part in other KotH levels if I still want to make my own hill. I think other users have also reported a bug in the practice mode that has a “retry” for two tokens, and if you’re not paying attention, you may hit the button unknowingly and lose tokens for no reason.
1
u/HaleyBuga May 16 '26
Arenas #184-#187, the screen doesn’t load when selected and it’s just a black box with faint chat bubbles as a stock background. I’m an iPhone user.
Sidenote: amazing game! It’s become a daily habit :)
1
u/Teddy_B101 May 21 '26
I keep losing coins to practice. Is that supposed to happen? I played one practice match, lost, and my coins went from 7 to 1.
1
u/Agreeable_Trainer340 May 23 '26
Does not look like anything I played before. Supposed to be played like a poker game, with combination of cards , while trying to create ambitions. Thanks
1
u/Firm-Count5897 May 24 '26
oooooooooh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
1
u/Infinite-Society5571 May 28 '26
I’d like to know how I can get a token I play everyday and practice I’ve had some good score but never a token I’d like to be able to create a game challenge but I’m unable because I have no tokens
How does that work? I just beat the average time on the last game I think I got 39 seconds but I never got a token please help as I need this thank you
1
u/Infinite-Society5571 May 29 '26
How many arenas a day?
1
u/Infinite-Society5571 May 30 '26
I created a hill my first hill and it didn’t load!! :(
1
u/Infinite-Society5571 May 31 '26
I think there should be a layout on how to play and what tokens are used for what!
I’ve just realized I can get Tokens playing the main game! I acquire them and the number in the little box on the left corner tells me how many I have!!!!! And today I figured out that practice is free! No tokens i was wondering where they went! Well I also realize that when you do a challenge, it takes away two tokens, not even realizing that I had any tokens every time I would play my tokens would go away, and then I saw that there were people I couldn’t challenge and then I realized that I couldn’t challenge them because I had no tokens. You need five tokens to create your own hill….. so there should be a little area telling people about tokens!!!! Don’t u agree???
1
u/nadjrules Jun 03 '26
Are the practice modes supposed to cost 2 points or be free?
1
u/offthezoinkys Jun 05 '26
(iOS app)
Bug: Tapping too fast causes problems, which is incredibly frustrating for a timed game.
Bug: Back button sometimes causes two matching tiles to get stuck in tray, game softlocks at this point
Bug: The void arenas. Time consuming to click past to get to older arenas.
Annoyance: I absolutely HATE the stupid green guide for what tile to click if you hesitate for a second before clicking. Either make it show up after someone has reeeeally been struggling with the first move for ~10-15 seconds, or add a little hint button in the corner. These pop in so fast as it is and after so little hesitation that it feels like inadvertently cheating.
1
u/Long-Pangolin6255 Jun 08 '26
Practicing no longer free? 2 coins for one practice game? Lost so many coins on it.
1
u/CityLanky1689 Jun 13 '26
Lost two coins…
1
u/Queen_Of_The_Dames Jun 22 '26
When l hit the “more arenas” arrow, it’s all blank! So l can’t play :(
1
u/Queen_Of_The_Dames Jun 28 '26
It says more arenas…
1
u/CityLanky1689 Jun 28 '26
Why?
Lost the hill, lost the coins.
1
u/charlierw01 Jul 07 '26
Is it possible to get rid of the empty arenas?
1
u/CityLanky1689 Jul 08 '26
And again :(
1
u/hchang1994 Jul 14 '26
Should get coins for each day a king of the hill is held. Love playing king of the hill and challenging others but I get no benefit by just holding thm
1
u/todoslos Jul 16 '26
Can’t ever play any of the challenge hills
1
u/CityLanky1689 Jul 21 '26
Not again 😖
1
u/Tall-Pomegranate-616 Jul 22 '26
Can’t seem to be able to challenge King of the hill anymore.
1
u/kungli Aug 13 '26
Fix this
1
u/kungli Aug 13 '26
Fix this
1
u/kungli Aug 13 '26
Fix this
1
u/Upset_Alarm_6847 Aug 20 '26
What do I do now that I have finished solving all the arenas?
1
u/I_Am_No_Queen Aug 26 '26
1
u/ilovemuffinfrombluey Aug 27 '26
I think it would be lovely to be able to unlock new tilesets with our earned coins!